Labelling rules ease for genetically-modified food made without adding new DNA
GM food or GM-free: a consumer's choice?
Hoggard told RNZ last week there was some opposition to FSANZ's P1055 proposal during public consultation from those who 'don't believe in [genetic engineering]'.
'There was still some vocal opposition, so that was taken on board,' he said.
'Obviously, there was support from a lot of industry and scientific groups.'
Hoggard said that in removing the requirement, producers could still choose to disclose gene technologies used throughout production on the label.
'There's nothing stopping anyone who is producing food that doesn't have any new breeding technologies to label it as such.
'We're not outlawing that people don't have to put these labels on.'
He said it came down to the consumer's choice.
'So if the organic sector, for example, doesn't want to allow these new breeding techniques in their production, then people who also think they don't want to consume food that's had new breeding techniques used in them, then they can just buy organic and know that 'okay, that hasn't been used'.
'If this is something you're not worried about, then just go ahead shopping as normal.
'If it is something you are concerned about, producers who will be using the old methodologies will still be able to highlight on the packaging that, 'hey, we don't use the X, Y and Z' or 'we don't do this or that'. And you just need to go and look for that food.'
Food Safety Minister Andrew Hoggard says producers can still choose to disclose gene technologies and label items as such. Photo / RNZ, Angus Dreaver
Hoggard said to the best of his knowledge, no health issues had been raised from the consumption of GMO products, such as soya bean, for example.
Meanwhile, GE-Free New Zealand spokesman Jon Carapiet said the eased labelling requirements took informed choices away from the consumer.
'It's really fundamentally unethical to take away the ordinary consumer's choice in the supermarkets,' Carapiet said.
'It's all about trust, and to say 'we're not gonna even trust you to make your own decisions anymore'... is really wrong.'
He said the assertion that shoppers concerned about GM food would simply buy organic food instead was 'disingenuous'.
'The average consumer certainly can't afford to go and buy organics on an everyday basis. I wish they could, but they can't,' he said.
'So to say all the ordinary people of New Zealand don't deserve the right to choose, I think that's very wrong.'
Carapiet said supermarkets could ask their suppliers to disclose the use of gene technologies throughout production to ensure transparency and to inform shoppers about the product they were buying.
'I think that in the coming months, if this does go ahead, companies will have to go above and beyond the food authority standards.
'If the food authority FSANZ says 'no, you can have GM crops and GE foods unlabelled in the supermarket', then it's going to be for the supermarkets to voluntarily label it.'
Supermarkets commit to compliance
In a written statement, a Foodstuffs spokesperson said it took food safety 'very seriously' and complied fully with the Australia and New Zealand Food Standards Code, including all labelling requirements.
'Customers have the right to know what's in the food they're buying,' they said.
'As part of our supplier agreements, we require partners to disclose country of origin information, and any environmental or social claims must be accurate and substantiated.'
They said the same approach applied to food made using gene technologies, including GM ingredients.
'Any changes to regulation in this space will be carefully reviewed, and we'll continue to ensure our labelling provides customers with accurate and transparent information, so they can make informed choices.'
A Woolworths New Zealand spokesperson said it will make sure its retail items comply with labelling rules.
'If the labelling rules in New Zealand change, then we would ensure all products comply with labelling requirements,' they said.
– RNZ
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
24 minutes ago
- Scoop
Contractor Being Finalised For Ashburton's Second Bridge
The likely contractor to build Ashburton's second bridge should be announced by September. NZTA is in the process of applying for consents and permits for the project, including developing plans to find and relocate up to 140 skinks in the area. The Government announced in December it would fund the 360-metre bridge, with construction expected to start in mid-2026, pending approvals. NZTA project director Lonnie Dalzell said there will be an announcement on the appointment of the 'Early Contractor Involvement' in the next few weeks. The contractor chosen for that role enters into a negotiation for the design and construction contract for the project - but if an agreement isn't reached, NZTA can go back to the market to find another contractor. Dalzell said NZTA is continuing to work through property acquisition, approvals and procurement, including the process to bring a construction contractor on board before the detailed designs are completed. 'This will allow the contractor to be involved in refining the details of the design, look at improved construction methods, understand the local opportunities and address any potential issues. 'We expect to complete this process later this month and to award a design and construct contract at the end of the year. 'We will have more clarity on project costings once we work through the detailed design process.' Once the design and construction tender is settled, it will finalise the price of the project, for both the NZTA-funded bridge and the council-funded road to the bridge on the Tinwald side of the river. A number of consents have been lodged or are in the process of being lodged, and in some cases, NZTA and the council are applying for the same consents. Where overarching applications are being lodged, they are seeking separate consents for the portions of the project specific to either NZTA or council. "So, in other words, it is not two consents sought for the same piece of work,' Dalzell said. 'A process is underway for consent applications to the regional council, with those applications due to be lodged later this month. This relates to NZTA's bridge and embankment construction, and the council's work on the connecting road and associated infrastructure.' An 'outline plan of works' will also be lodged with council, detailing how aspects of the project will be constructed, he said. Both parties have been granted archaeological authority for the project, a legal permit that ensures the protection of cultural and heritage sites during construction and how they will manage any potential archaeological finds. 'Last month, we applied for the necessary wildlife permit and have developed a Lizard Management Plan for DOC approval, which includes how we intend to rehome the lizards, including monitoring and pest control.' A lizard survey found 11 southern grass skinks, considered 'At Risk – Declining' in New Zealand, within the project boundary he said. 'It is expected that there are more, and we are preparing plans for finding and relocating up to 140 of these skinks during construction.' NZTA has also been working with Environment Canterbury to provide enhanced habitat for bird nesting ahead of the breeding season, particularly for the threatened, black-billed gull (tarāpuka), away from the project area and ahead of construction starting. Three existing, raised gravel islands in the river around the SH1 bridge have been identified as suitable habitat for nesting birds, and NZTA has started clearing the islands of vegetation and debris downstream of the bridge. NZTA staff will provide an update on the Ashburton Second Urban Bridge project at the council meeting on August 20. A public update on the project will take place on September 11 from 3:30-6:30pm at the Event Space at Te Whare Whakatere, Ashburton Library and Civic Centre. NZTA will run the information session for the public to come and see the plans and ask questions.
NZ Herald
42 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Frank: Stories from the South, ep. 12 – The fastest growing district in New Zealand
'A lot of our population was born overseas, and that proportion is growing all the time,' says Broughton. Last month, the mayor attended a celebration of citizenship at the Dunsandel Community Centre. 'Over 100 people,' he tells Frank Film. 'All new people in Selwyn, and all new people to New Zealand and they're all becoming citizens.' The appeal of the district, according to Broughton, also lies in its booming agricultural, industrial, manufacturing and construction industries. He points to the new homes being built, the new library and the industrial park currently providing 1200 jobs, many for people commuting from Christchurch. 'This has turned into the place where New Zealanders want to be, where things are happening, where jobs are available,' he says. But population growth has its complications. In 2000, the number of dairy cows in the Selwyn district was 59,900. That number almost tripled in under 25 years, reaching more than 176,000 last year. Selwyn is undergoing rapid transformation and is described as "the place where things are happening". Photo / Frank Film 'I think that the intensification of land use has both positive and adverse effects,' says Broughton, acknowledging the impact of dairying on the district's waterways. Selwyn District Council is currently investing $5 million into finding low-nitrate water sources to supply the district. Selwyn is also home to some of the most productive soil in the country, land Broughton warns is irreplaceable. 'If we lose that to housing, then it's gone,' he says. But that decision no longer comes down to local government. 'We sort of had red lines drawn around our towns about where growth would and wouldn't happen', Broughton says. In July 2024, the Government's National Policy Statement on Urban Development changed the requirements for councils to free up land for housing. 'The Government changed the rules and basically said, 'If you've got land on the edge of an existing town and the infrastructure is there to provide capacity for urban growth, then that urban growth can occur',' he says. Selwyn Mayor Sam Broughton says there are job prospects and challenges arising from the district's growth. Photo / Frank Film Other aspects of Selwyn's growth are also in the hands of central Government. 'What's missing in that planning, and local council doesn't have control over it, is where schools go and where new hospitals and GPs are,' he says. Even today, with its burgeoning population, the district still does not have its own hospital. 'Sure, community needs new roads and it needs water supplies, but a great community has also got those other social services that are the central Government's responsibility.' He compares Rolleston to Timaru, which, despite having a smaller population, has four high schools. Rolleston has one. 'We need more classrooms here,' says Broughton. 'There's a second campus being built at the moment, but I think we also need a second school or provision for that.' The population of Selwyn is expected to almost double in 30 years. Photo / Frank Film When it opened seven years ago, Rolleston College had 225 kids. 'Now, we've got just under 1900,' says principal Rachel Skelton. Lincoln University is also growing quickly, receiving a record-breaking 5500 enrolments this year. Broughton was 35 when he was first elected mayor in 2016. Raised on a farm near Darfield, job opportunities then, he says, were 'always elsewhere'. Now, he recognises the university as playing a pivotal role in shaping Selwyn's increasingly diverse population. 'I've seen a massive change in the ethnic make-up of Selwyn. It's really exciting, and I think the centre of that was around Lincoln University, people being attracted internationally to come and study, and then found out how good Selwyn was and decided to stay.' One resident who immigrated from India says living in Selwyn has brought him 'peace of mind'. 'It's such a lovely place, and community, and relaxed environment,' says another resident from Chile. 'The only thing that I can say from my perspective as a foreigner is just that we have to look after what is provided to us, because sometimes we take things for granted here.'
Otago Daily Times
42 minutes ago
- Otago Daily Times
'Keen bean' students catch maths book errors
Education Minister Erica Stanford. Photo: RNZ The Education Minister has thanked "keen bean" students for picking up errors in Ministry of Education-funded maths resources. Eighteen errors were spotted and fixed in new maths resources, including incorrect sums, a wrong number labelled in te reo Māori, and incorrectly saying "triangles" instead of "rectangles" in an answer. In one case, an answer to a problem in a Year 4 workbook was listed as 1024, and had to be changed to the correct answer of 19,875. In another workbook, the number four in te reo Māori (whā) was incorrectly written as two (rua). Erica Stanford said she "wouldn't overblow it," as there was, on average, half a mistake per book. "Those little eagle-eyed, keen bean students around the country who are now doing an hour a day of mathematics, picked them up and we've fixed them," she said. Photo: Supplied via RNZ Stanford said it was not unusual to have errors in books, and they may have been there for a while as they were existing resources. "You find it quite often in books, and it's not just these maths books, you'll find the odd error here and there." The errors were immediately changed online, and would be fixed in re-prints for next year's release. Photo: Supplied via RNZ A Ministry of Education bulletin sent to school leaders said the ministry was aware of the errors. "Our resource providers regularly review their print and digital resources to correct any errors that have been reported, and to ensure accuracy," it said. The ministry asked schools to contact it if they found any errors, including typos.
