Demands for cops to investigate deaths of hundreds of babies across Scotland
Campaigners are concerned about the number of newborns dying in maternity units and have called for urgent action.
Police are facing demands to investigate the deaths of hundreds of babies across Scotland.
The Sunday Mail has learned campaigners reported concerns about the number of newborns dying in maternity units and have called for urgent action. But Police Scotland insists it has 'noted' the concerns, but has so far refused to open a formal investigation.
It comes as forces in England are currently probing the deaths of hundreds of babies at the Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust after a review found catastrophic failings. Scottish campaign group ASAP-NHS, led by former Crown prosecutor for the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) Roger Livermore, contacted Police Scotland in February over their concerns about baby death rates in Scotland.
Recent figures show about 500 babies have died since 2019, with health boards paying compensation in 131 cases of baby death or injury. The total compensation bill in the last five years is more than £74million with about a third of that being paid out by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.
Livermore said: 'We have been very concerned about the large number of babies dying unnecessarily and unlawfully all over Scotland. We have reported them to the police and Lord Advocate but no effective action has been taken.
'There are major problems in maternity services across all parts of the UK. Current scandals in England are being investigated by the police. Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain has held a very small number of fatal accident inquiries on the situation at individual health boards. This is not sufficient.
'Overarching law requires that deaths must be handled and investigated by a person and body independent of government – not a member of it. In the rest of the UK this is the HM Coroner system.'
Livermore said he was concerned that Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the NHS watchdog in Scotland, had never carried out maternity unit inspections before this year. He said that reviews into serious incidents which have resulted in death or harm to patients, known as serious adverse event reviews, are also not being routinely published.
He said: 'Frontline staff such as midwives are aware of the problems and have already raised concerns about the situation across the country. The internal reports, when they are forced out of NHS boards under Freedom of Information, show that the same problems are endlessly repeated. Lessons are not learnt. The public are totally kept in the dark.'
As previously reported by the Sunday Mail, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde was rapped by health watchdogs after it emerged hundreds of serious adverse event reviews had not been carried out, years after the incidents had happened.
The health board recorded more than 1000 'Category 1 significant adverse events' that may have contributed to or resulted in permanent harm or death of patients in the last five years. Police Scotland said that it had received the report but was not planning on taking any action.
The force said: 'There is no police investigation into baby deaths at Scottish maternity units.'
Between January and October last year, 262 incidents were recorded with just 14 reviews completed at all, and just one within the 90-day timescale. In 2017, NHS Ayrshire and Arran was criticised over the 'unnecessary' deaths of six babies at Crosshouse hospital, with staff shortages affecting patient care.
In 2018, Freya Murphy died at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital after medics failed to notice she was being starved of oxygen during delivery. An FAI found staffing levels were an issue.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Protesters gather to demand hospice reopens and question funding
Campaigners have returned to a hospice inpatient unit in Liverpool a year after it was shut to stage another protest to demand the facility reopen as soon as possible. The 26-bed unit at Marie Curie in Woolton, Liverpool, closed in July 2024 because of a shortage of specialised nursing decision sparked immediate concern and a campaign group, Save our Hospice, formed to demand a u-turn. A Marie Curie spokesman said it was in talks with the NHS Cheshire & Merseyside Integrated Care Board (ICB), which commissions end-of-life care in Liverpool, to agree a "sustainable long-term plan" for the unit's future. A large group of campaigners gathered outside the unit on Saturday afternoon and held placards criticising Marie Curie for not "taking up our offer" to fundraise for the unit. Some wore yellow t-shirts with the slogans "Save our Hospice" and "Save our Ward". Independent Liverpool councillor Lucy Williams, who attended a protest at the unit on Saturday, told the BBC: "It's been a year since they closed their doors to the inpatient unit and it's been a year that they've continued to receive funding from the ICB."So we're here today to ask where has that money gone and why haven't they delivered that service that they're getting commissioned to provide."Williams worked at the hospice as a palliative care nurse for two years, and said: "People's relatives and loved ones have died here and a lot of them have committed their time to fundraising for this hospice."We found out over this year that money doesn't come to this hospice, it goes into a national pot - so throughout the closure this fundraising has continued and people haven't been aware that the inpatient unit in Liverpool has been closed." 'Get the ward open' Williams said an "easy" resolution was to immediately re-open the ward. She said: "They're receiving the funding to have the ward open, surely they can have one or two beds? That's better than none at all. "So get the ward open and if Marie Curie aren't competent to provide the service then the ICB need to commission someone who is."The Marie Curie spokesperson said the charity hoped to reach an agreement with the NHS integrated care board "as soon as possible".While admissions to the inpatient unit "had been paused", the hospice had remained open and was providing palliative and end of life care to "thousands of people in Liverpool in different ways", they added. The spokesperson said the ICB was aware its funding was being used to provide these services. Listen to the best of BBC Radio Merseyside on Sounds and follow BBC Merseyside on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
Spectator
3 hours ago
- Spectator
The truth about palliative care
Watching MPs debate the Terminally Ill Adults Bill in recent weeks has left me and fellow clinicians wondering how many of them have been to a specialist palliative care unit. It has raised a concern about whether people understand what palliative care actually provides, and what we clinicians actually do. How many people have an idea about what hospices and palliative care teams can help with, and would knowing more about such services strengthen calls to make them core parts of NHS provision? Palliative care and assisted dying have seemed in opposition in recent weeks, with people picking sides as though they were rival football teams. I work in a sector that has had to rely heavily on charity and fundraising, which only goes so far. Last year was one of the worst in terms of fundraising for one of our local hospice charities. Palliative care is about living, joy, fun and thinking about your legacy Specialist palliative care in all settings is in a crisis of under-resourcing. We know that palliative care provision is patchy, and inequitable, with some geographies, settings and patient groups receiving completely unacceptable levels of care. Many don't have seven-day on-call cover, when the reality is that crises at the end of life can occur at any time of a given week. Palliative care is not all about inpatient hospices for those who are in the last days of life. We have (in some parts of England and Wales) community teams, outpatient clinics, support teams in general hospitals, day services and out-of-hours on-call provision. We often get involved from diagnosis onward, get to know some patients over several years, and even discharge them again if they feel better and their symptoms improve. And when it comes to dying, most deaths are uncomplicated. Many will not require much more involvement than good local district nursing teams and their usual GP care if systems are working locally. We in palliative care probably need to do far more to dispel some of the narratives that many recent bad death anecdotes have brought up in the assisted dying debate. Yes, bad deaths certainly happen, but many people die peacefully each week, and such 'ordinary dying' is, of course, not reported on. In England and Wales in 2023, over 500,000 deaths were registered. Even ten bad deaths amongst those would be newsworthy, of course, but it does not constitute a norm. It was different when I was a junior doctor in the early 2000's, when I saw some very bad deaths and there was zero palliative care provision in some of the English hospitals I worked in. Hospices being described as full of dying patients, their pain poorly controlled and their senses dulled with high-dose morphine drips, is not the reality. The '20 bad deaths a day' statistic that was highlighted by assisted dying pressure groups has been debunked as unreliable. And faecal vomiting, so vividly described by some MPs, is more talked and written about than it is actually seen on wards and in communities. When I worked at our local hospice, over half the inpatients would be discharged back home again after they had received help with their symptoms. This was often a surprise to them, because many appeared to assume that you never really leave a hospice alive. Some of the older images of hospices full of dying people seem to prevail in the collective memories, when in fact modern-day 'palliative care inpatient units' actually have a rather different role. The same goes for palliative care more generally: much of it happens in the community. I have seen many of my palliative clinic patients for years, and they live life alongside their terminal illness. Always knowing that time may be short, perhaps one pneumonia away from potentially dying, but equally living life to the full whilst they still can, jetting off on holiday, or going clubbing, hiking, cycling and working, and generally being part of their local communities. One of my younger patients recently told me in a video consultation that she just doesn't fit the 'image of a cancer/palliative patient' that people in her environment have come to expect. Many of my patients hold jobs and are on reasonable doses of morphine or oxycodone, without too much in the way of side effects, so they can actually get on with their lives. They drive their cars, perfectly legally. We also review whether they still require the meds, sometimes weaning them off opioids once a reversible pain crisis is over. All this makes predicting a diagnosis of less than six months with any form of accuracy quite hard. The recent debates have made many of us working in this area feel somewhat downhearted, partly because there are a lot of clichés about this area of work that will just never go away. But it has made us think about ordinary 'living with dying' in our society, and how we show that it can be done well. Some of us try our best to frame this world in a more positive light, and I know quite a few patients who are quite happy to help in this, which of course is a good start. A number of my patients have agreed to become part of information campaigns to talk far more positively about palliative care and living with dying, including good advance and future care planning for when their illnesses progress. We have produced videos together on why you may want to consider having a plan for when you become less able to communicate your views, or are getting closer to the end. Sound dreary? Not if you take my patient Keith's approach to it, who sold tickets to his own funeral party. A lot of palliative care clinicians, including Dr Kathryn Mannix with her books (including With the End in Mind) have sought to demystify this area of life and also to inject a bit of much-needed humour and warmth into 'ordinary dying'. It's poorly understood, and people like to brush it away. With assisted suicide, it now risks being medicalised even further and also brought forward quite considerably for some people. News and media narratives don't always help: 'All the medical care stopped and then the patient was for palliation only' or 'They were then just for palliative care'. If 'no longer for active care' means they are now for palliative care, I invite anyone to join our very active ward rounds with patients who receive blood transfusions, iv antibiotics, immunotherapy and scans, all within balance and reason and in close consultation with patients and families. We actively review and discharge some of our patients because, whilst they may have a disease that will likely be life-limiting and their risk of dying is that bit higher, they may still have years ahead of them. Amongst some of my patients and their families, this sometimes raises a chuckle. 'We thought: palliative care, that's it, just a few more days…' Not so. Recent heated debates may have left some with the impression that most deaths in the UK are bad, that palliative care cannot do anything and that hospices are ghoulish places that only give morphine infusions. Think opium den, just with doctors and nurses. This is completely wrong. Palliative care is evidence-based, follows guidelines and reduces strong opioids as much as it starts or increases them (careful titration according to evidence-based guidelines). Palliative care can bring cheer; it brings out the best in people, thinking outside multiple boxes and helping people focus on important achievements in life: getting rid of a nasty infection with intravenous antibiotics, getting a blood transfusion to improve anaemia, receiving immunotherapy from the oncologists, radiotherapy, being pain-free to go for a bracing walk in the Cotswolds, getting to a Millwall game, getting married in Vegas, getting to a Slipknot concert, just being yourself. Whether you've got six days, six weeks, six months or six years left to live (and who knows?). Wherever you stand on matters like assisted dying, good palliative and end-of-life care should never be under-prioritised. We need better funding and in parallel we need to convey very clearly that palliative care is about living, joy, fun, thinking about your legacy and working with a team to get on top of the big challenges. It's only a little bit about dying. Let's call it assisted living.
South Wales Argus
3 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Welsh Government unveils new funding to target waiting lists
The funding boost from the Welsh government will help tackle long waiting lists and reduce waiting times across the Welsh NHS. The Planned Care Recovery Plan includes ambitious targets to cut the overall waiting list by 200,000 and eliminate all two-year waits. It also aims to restore the diagnostic wait times to less than eight weeks by March 2026. The new funding will help provide more outpatient appointments, diagnostic tests, and treatments. This includes more than 20,000 cataract operations. Health Secretary Jeremy Miles said: "Tackling waiting times is our number one priority. 'We have seen long waiting times fall by two thirds over the last four months. We will build on this progress and go further. 'This additional funding will help deliver what people want – faster access to treatment.' As well as the funding, all health boards will be required to make changes to boost productivity and efficiency to reduce variation. These include reducing the number of follow-up appointments, which are automatically booked, and allowing people to arrange them only if they need to see a doctor. There will have to be a minimum of seven cataract procedures per list as standard by the coming September. They are also expected to streamline pathways, removing steps that do not add benefit value to a patient's healthcare journey. Mr Miles said: "I am determined to work with health boards to deliver a stronger and more sustainable NHS for the people of Wales. "These service improvements, together with the extra funding, will help to provide better access for patients to planned care."
