This is how many people complained about noise at the Blackweir Live gig series in Cardiff
The series of gigs was opposed by a number of residents and park-goers, but also enjoyed by tens of thousands
Blackweir Live sparked dozens of noise complaints
(Image: John Myers )
One hundred noise complaints were made after a controversial series of gigs took place at a popular Cardiff park recently. Four days of performances were held at Blackweir Live in Bute Park this year, starting with Noah Kahan on Friday, June 27, and ending with Stevie Wonder on Wednesday, July 9.
There were also performances by Alanis Morissette (Wednesday, July 2) and Slayer (Thursday, July 3).
Concerns were raised about noise when a new events licence was granted for Blackweir Fields to host Blackweir Live in April. Never miss a Cardiff story and sign up to our newsletter here.
Cardiff Council assured residents at the time there would be conditions in place to mitigate any potential noise nuisance.
When we asked the local authority for the number of noise complaints that had been made after the Alanis Morissette gig it said it had received 48 complaints.
It then provided us with an updated figure following the Stevie Wonder gig, which was 100 complaints in total across the series.
Article continues below
One local councillor said he could hear music from Blackweir Live two miles away with his windows closed.
Cardiff Council ward member for Penylan, Cllr Rodney Berman, said on X during the Slayer gig at 10.14pm: "The sound is booming as I sit in my study with my windows shut and I'm about two miles away.
"I hate to think how loud it must be for those living a lot nearer the site."
The following number of noise complaints were made for each concert:
Noah Kahan - 40 complaints
Alanis Morissette - 10 complaints
Slayer - 36 complaints
Stevie Wonder - 14 complaints
Local councillors for Cathays, Cllr Sarah Merry, Cllr Ali Ahmed, Cllr Norma Mackie, and Cllr Chris Weaver, raised concerns to the council about the Blackweir licence and its proposed operating hours before it was approved.
Under the licence that was approved for Blackweir Fields there can only be six main event days during the year.
It allows events to take place on any day during the week from 9am to 10.30pm.
Blackweir Live on the final night
(Image: John Myers )
The pollution control team at the council requested that a condition be added to the licence requiring a noise management plan to be submitted for approval by them at least 28 days prior to each event or at the start of a series of jointly-managed events.
It also requires the noise management plan to include the proposed sound levels for the event, the proposed methods of monitoring and managing the impact of noise disturbance, and a complaint management process.
A Cardiff Council spokesman said following the Alanis Morisette gig that noise complaints would all be reviewed in line with standard procedures.
The spokesperson added: "However, noise monitoring on site has confirmed that the events have complied with the terms of the premises licence.
'The council has already committed to carrying out a full review of the events once they are complete and feedback from the public will be considered as a part of this process."
The controversy around Blackweir Live started when ticket sales went live before a new licence for Blackweir Fields was approved.
There was a licence in place for the site but this was for events of up to 25,000 people. The licence that was applied for asked for permission to allow events of up to 35,000 people.
Cardiff Council argued that events like Blackweir Live, which was organised by Depot Live and Cuffe and Taylor, would bring tens of millions of pounds to the city's economy and generate revenue to maintain and improve Bute Park.
However campaigners, sports teams, and Friends of Bute Park were worried about the potential impact more events would have on the park.
Article continues below
At a public meeting held in June many residents said they were not opposed to live music.
However, they added that too much parkland was being made inaccessible during the summer months.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Stevie Wonder and Noah Kahan Cardiff gigs had no planning permission
A series of concerts held in a popular park in Cardiff went ahead without planning permission, a council report has performances on Blackweir Fields from Noah Kahan, Alanis Morissette, Slayer and Stevie Wonder saw tens of thousands of people Cardiff council report stated there was no application for planning permission in the run up to the shows, and that a certificate of lawfulness, which shows whether planning permission is required or not, had not been issued. The council said it had decided not to take formal planning enforcement action against the organisers. The series of gigs known as Blackweir Live had received complaints from residents, who set up a petition about large fences being erected around the council said the concerts would bring £35m to the city's economy, which would be used to improve parks and planning said there was no planning permission application before the events took place, and without a certificate of lawfulness, the organisers Depot Live and Cuffe and Taylor were "proceeding at risk".Planning laws prohibit a temporary change of the use of parks for more than 28 days each year without additional planning consent, but the report found that the area of Blackweir Fields was affected for a total of 37 days, nine days more than report highlighted a case in London earlier this year, when a resident successfully took her local authority to court, arguing Lambeth council did not have the correct planning permission to stage events in Brockwell Park. The report said: "There have been no other temporary events in Blackweir Fields during this calendar year, but the result remains that the number of days exceeds that permitted."Council officers considered whether enforcement action should have been taken, but recommended "it would not be expedient for the council to take any formal enforcement action against the event organiser", calling the breach "minor".The report concluded both Cardiff council and the organisers of any future events should apply for planning permission for any event exceeding the 28-day council said the decision against Lambeth council was made after the Blackweir Live gigs had been approved and also added an events licence had previously been granted for the said: "While the setup and breakdown of the site exceeded the 28-day limit for temporary events, the concerts themselves stayed within that timeframe, which was why planning permission was not sought for such a temporary event."The implications of the recent court judgement will now form part of a wider review of arrangements for future events in Cardiff."The organisers of the events, Depot Live and Cuffe and Taylor, have been asked to comment.
Spectator
3 days ago
- Spectator
Magnificent: Stevie Wonder at BST Hyde Park reviewed
The highs of Stevie Wonder's Hyde Park show were magnificently high. The vast band were fully clicked into that syncopated, swampy funk, horns stabbing through the synths, the backing singers adding gospel fervour. And Wonder – now 75 – sang like it was still the 1970s, his voice raspy one minute, angelic the next. Anyone who heard that phenomenal group play 'Living for the City' or 'Superstition' and didn't feel 'ants in my pants and I need to dance', as James Brown once put it, should resign from life: they do not deserve such joy. That said, there were oddities. We were blessed with visits from four of Wonder's nine children, two of whom were given whole songs to sing while the great man had a breather, as were three of the backing singers. Then there was the opening of the show: ten minutes of Wonder addressing the crowd, who maintained a respectful silence while being told over and over – in different formulations and intermittent lapses into faux cockney – that there was too much anger in the world and we all needed to love each other. He couldn't decided whether he wanted to be Dick Van Dyke or Martin Luther King. Needless to say, scientists have as yet ascertained no link between pop stars telling concert-goers that we need to love each other more and increased social cohesion. Actually, the latest studies suggest that the longer such lecturing goes on, the more irritation among those being lectured rises. It's a phenomenon some call the 'Imagine Syndrome', which Wonder exemplified by then playing 'Imagine', so we could hear its timeless message of triteness through fresh ears. But within four songs we were at 'Master Blaster', then 'Higher Ground' and one was willing to forgive everything – all the gloopy ballads, all the showbizzery, even the white jacket with diamanté portraits of John Lennon and Marvin Gaye. Even singing 'Happy Birthday' to his youngest daughter was fabulous because it was Stevie Wonder's 'Happy Birthday', not the song that launched a thousand cakes. There comes a point where you have to see these people before it's too late. I'm glad I got to see Stevie Wonder while he was still recognisably good enough to be Stevie Wonder because some legends are at the point where it's their catalogues rather than their voices that bring 65,000 people out. The day after Wonder, Hyde Park was meant to host the final show by Jeff Lynne's ELO, but a 'systemic infection' had forced him to cancel. I had seen Lynne a few times, and it was always tremendous fun. The week before, I had been at Villa Park, watching the final performance by Black Sabbath and Ozzy Osbourne, which was extraordinary and moving. What struck me was how under-celebrated the Birmingham music scene of the late 1960s has been. You can't move for the mythologising of Manchester and Liverpool pop, and though the city bigs up its links to metal, you rarely hear about the products of Brumbeat. But this was the generation that gave us Steve Winwood (and the Spencer Davis Group and Traffic), Lynne, Ozzy and Sabbath, Roy Wood (who was the pre-eminent genius of the lot at the time), the Moody Blues and half of Led Zeppelin. That's one of rock's greatest cities, not the butt of a joke. Finally to Heavenly, the most overqualified group in pop history (seriously, Google them). They are the unlikely heroes to a small but dedicated scene, known as indie-pop or twee-pop, in which emotional directness trumps technical virtuosity: Kurt Cobain loved them for being punk rock and entirely without machismo. Theirs is a political stance based on not compromising principles (the show was part of a DIY weekender they had organised themselves) and being avowedly feminist ('Hearts and Crosses' sets a story of rape against queasy fairground organ). That makes it sound strident and hectoring, but Heavenly are not that. The songs would not have troubled Steely Dan's session guys, but they are full of joy, vim, life. Best of all, there were plenty of twentysomethings in the crowd, filming and dancing and singing along. No need to be Stevie Wonder to be an inspiration to the generations to come; simply capture something truthful.
BBC News
6 days ago
- BBC News
Stevie Wonder: 'I'll keep playing as long as I breathe'
At the age of 75, Stevie Wonder is still going strong. His latest UK tour, which wrapped up earlier this month received rapturous reviews, with critics calling the star "fresh and on form" for "a riotously joyful celebration" of his while contemporaries like Billy Joel and The Eagles are reducing their musical commitments, Wonder says he will never consider retiring."For as long as you breathe, for as long as your heart beats, there's more for you to do," the Motown legend told the BBC's Sidetracked podcast. "I'm not gonna stop the gift that keeps pouring through my body. "I love doing what I'm doing. An artist never stops drawing. As long as you can imagine is as long as you are going to be creative."The star also confirmed he was still working on a new album, titled Through The Eyes Of Wonder, which he first discussed in project has previously been described as a performance piece that will reflect his experience as a blind would be his first studio album since 2005's A Time To Love; extending a recording career that started in 1962, when he was just 11 years old. Wonder spoke to Sidetracked presenter Annie Macmanus, the day before he headlined the BST festival in London's Hyde Park - playing a two-and-a-half hour set that encompassed his biggest hits, from Superstition and Isn't She Lovely to You Are The Sunshine Of My Life and I of the set was drawn from the 1970s purple patch when he won the Grammy Award for best album three times in a row, for Innervisions, Fulfillingness' First Finale and Songs In The Key Of told Macmanus that he never tired of revisiting those records."Songs are like children, they're with you forever," he said. "They are statement from the spirit within you. "And singing those songs is like me taking another breath." America 'going backwards' Earlier this month, during a concert in Cardiff, the musician addressed a long-standing conspiracy theory that he is not actually blind."You know there have been rumours about me seeing and all that?" he told the audience, "But seriously, you know the truth.""Truth is, shortly after my birth, I became blind," he told his disability a gift, Wonder continued: "Now, that was a blessing because it's allowed me to see the world in the vision of truth, of sight." In his Sidetracked interview, the singer talked about the importance of using music to spread positivity and speak truth to his life, he has been a vocal civil rights campaigner, and played a key role in the campaign to have the birthday of Martin Luther King Jr recognised as a national holiday in the who campaigned for Democrat Kamala Harris in last year's US presidential election, told Macmanus that America was currently beleaguered by "people trying to go backwards"."It's not gonna go down like that," he insisted. "I think that if you look back in history, there's always been a point when people wake up."And I think that, for those who think it is gonna go down like that, remember that God is watching you."You can listen to Stevie Wonder's full interview on the Sidetracked podcast on BBC Sounds.
