Karen Read murder trial: Defense lawyers rest their case
The case, which prompted intense media coverage and allegations of law enforcement misconduct that led to the firing of the case's lead investigator, could be with the jury in Dedham, Massachusetts, by the end of the week.
Read's sensational first trial ended nearly one year ago with a jury unable to reach a unanimous verdict on charges of second-degree murder and other crimes in connection with the Jan. 29, 2022, death of John O'Keefe.
The defense did not call key figures central to the theory it laid out in those initial proceedings — that Read was the victim of a biased police investigation and a plot that sought to frame her for the killing — and opted instead for a series of experts whose testimony sought to dismantle the prosecution's evidence.
What to know about Karen Read's murder retrial in the death of her police officer boyfriend, John O'Keefe
Three things to know about the prosecution's case
Defense team goes after cellphone data and a key witness prosecutors are relying on
As retrial zeroed in on a possible murder weapon, an expert's credibility was challenged
Family of Read's boyfriend says she put them 'through hell' but they're ready for second trial
Messy investigation exposes problems with police work that public rarely sees, experts say
Read's defense in the first trial
How to watch the 'Dateline' episode 'The Night of the Nor'easter'
Among them were three crash reconstruction specialists and two pathologists. Also called to the witness stand was a snowplow driver who offered what was perhaps the defense's most direct challenge to the case Norfolk County special prosecutor Hank Brennan had presented.
Blizzardlike conditions descended on the Boston area on Jan. 29, and the driver, Brian Loughran, testified that before the snow grew heavy, he made multiple passes on the residential street in Canton where O'Keefe was found unresponsive.
O'Keefe was discovered near a flagpole in the front yard of a now-retired Boston police sergeant, Brian Albert, shortly after 6 a.m. — a little over three hours after, Loughran said, he first passed the home in his plow, nicknamed 'Frankentruck' for what he described as its mismatch of parts.
Loughran said he knew the Albert family — he used to deliver pizzas for Brian Albert's brother — and he testified that he could clearly see from his truck to Albert's front door.
'What was on the ground in the area of the flagpole?' defense attorney David Yanetti asked.
'Nothing,' Loughran responded.
'Did you see a 6-foot-1, 216-pound man lying on that lawn?' Yanetti asked.
'No,' Loughran said.
After a night of drinking, O'Keefe was supposed to have gone to a gathering at Albert's home early Jan. 29. Brennan has said he never made it inside. Although prosecutors presented no direct evidence of the collision that they said mortally wounded O'Keefe, vehicle data presented at trial showed Read suddenly reversing her Lexus at 12:32 a.m. at 24 mph in front of Albert's home.
An accident reconstruction expert called by Brennan testified that dozens of abrasions found on O'Keefe's right arm were consistent with injuries caused by the broken right taillight on Read's SUV.
Read has said she dropped O'Keefe off outside Albert's home and watched him enter. Her lawyers have said he was most likely beaten at the gathering — perhaps because she had recently flirted with, then ghosted, a federal agent who was also at the event — before O'Keefe was bitten by Albert's German shepherd, dragged outside and left in the snow. (Albert and the agent, Brian Higgins, have denied playing roles in O'Keefe's death.)
One of the defense witnesses, a former emergency room doctor and forensic pathologist who said she had seen hundreds of dog bites in her career, testified that the dozens of abrasions on O'Keefe's arm were not from a broken taillight but from a dog.
The defense's final witness, a biomedical engineer who examined whether O'Keefe's injuries were the result of a collision, testified Wednesday that they were not. Experiments conducted for the case using crash test dummies showed that at speeds of 24 mph, there most likely would have been more damage to Read's car and to O'Keefe's arm, said the engineer, Andrew Rentschler.
Absent from the witness stand were three people whose testimony played an outsized role in the first trial: Albert, Higgins and former Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor.
Proctor, who was fired after an internal investigation found that he sent derogatory texts about Read and shared confidential investigative details with non-law enforcement personnel, acknowledged during the first trial that he said 'unprofessional' things about Read. But he rejected the defense's claims that he led a biased investigation.
The defense mentioned Proctor repeatedly during Read's retrial, with defense attorney Alan Jackson at one point asking his supervisor whether his conduct tainted their examination of O'Keefe's death.
'The investigation was done with honor and integrity, and the evidence pointed in one direction,' State Police Sgt. Yuri Bukhenik responded.
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Predators trailer explores To Catch A Predator's complicated legacy
On the surface, To Catch A Predator may seem like it was a moral net-positive. The Dateline series helped apprehend multiple criminals before they could target more children. That, at least on paper, sounds like a good thing. Predators, a new documentary delving into the repercussions of the popular show, however, argues that its legacy is a lot more complicated than that. 'A cultural sensation from its inception in the early 2000s, Dateline NBC's candid-camera investigative series To Catch A Predator ensnared sex offenders and lured them to a film set, where they would be interviewed and arrested while cameras rolled. The show was a hit and transformed its host Chris Hansen into a moral crusader and TV star, while spawning a worldwide industry of imitators and vigilantes,' the documentary's logline reads. 'But why did we watch so voraciously — and why do we continue to devour its web-based, clickbait-driven offshoots?' 'Looking back on the show and the countless franchises it spawned, filmmaker David Osit turns his camera on journalists, actors, law enforcers, academics, and ultimately himself, to trace America's obsession with watching people at their lowest,' the film's synopsis continues, before promising to 'delve into the murk of human nature to observe hunter, predator, subject and spectator alike, all ensnared in a complicated web of entertainment as far as the eye can see.' A new trailer for the documentary includes a clip of a recorded call presumably from the show, before teasing an interview with Hansen himself. 'Some people watching this may feel like you have something to answer for. What do you say to that?' the filmmaker asks while Hansen looks uncomfortable. To Catch A Predator premiered in 2004 and was canceled in 2008, shortly after Bill Conradt, a Texas assistant district attorney, committed suicide after learning he was about to be a subject on the show. In a statement, Osit said the incident left him with a long-lasting distaste for the true crime genre. 'I certainly found the show fascinating… I remembered watching as a young adult and feeling a complex stew of discomfort and schadenfreude as child predators were lured into a house, interviewed and ultimately arrested with cameras rolling for our national entertainment,' he said, per People. 'But even knowing the sordid details of what happened in Texas towards the end of the show's run—a man who ultimately committed suicide rather than be filmed by Dateline NBC cameras during one of their child predator stings—I didn't imagine a story about this show could transcend what always bothered me most about the true crime genre.' You can revisit the phenomenon yourself (or decide whether Osit's documentary just advances To Catch A Predator's long shadow) when the film premieres September 19 in theaters. More from A.V. Club Society is remade then falls apart in Ron Howard's star-studded Eden Some publicists are turning to Grok, ChatGPT for metrics that streamers don't offer Shari Redstone worried what Trump would have done to CBS News if Paramount didn't settle Solve the daily Crossword
Boston Globe
3 days ago
- Boston Globe
Karen Read seeking dismissal of most counts pending against her in wrongful death lawsuit
Her attorneys stressed that Advertisement Lawyers for the O'Keefe family fired back in a filing opposing the dismissal motion, noting that discovery in the high-profile lawsuit Advertisement The family's emotional distress claims 'require a fact-intensive analysis which is not ripe for deciding at this early stage of the lawsuit and without adequate discovery,' the lawyers said. They added that 'traditional' emotional distress damages are 'expressly disallowed as a component of wrongful death damages,' hence the additional counts. The plaintiffs' attorneys said the O'Keefe family has 'suffered and continues to suffer immense emotional trauma from this wrongful death, which has been further intensified by the unyielding barrage of harassment and ridicule by Read and her supporters targeting the grieving family.' A Norfolk Superior Court jury Prosecutors had alleged that Read backed her Lexus SUV in a drunken rage into a Boston police officer, early on Jan. 29, 2022, after dropping him off outside a Canton home following a night of bar-hopping. Read's criminal attorneys said she was framed and that O'Keefe entered the property, owned at the time by a fellow Boston officer, where he was fatally beaten and possibly mauled by a German Shepherd before his body was planted on the front lawn. The allegations in the lawsuit track with the government's case in the criminal trial, and the O'Keefe family's attorneys said in court papers last week that Read, when she initially returned to O'Keefe's residence in the predawn hours of Jan. 29, 2022, woke up and traumatized his niece, then 14. Advertisement Read woke up O'Keefe's niece 'in a panic stating that something had happened to JJ and that [the niece's] surrogate father was dead,' the plaintiffs' lawyers wrote. In the niece's presence, Read chose not to call 911 but instead called " various acquaintances proclaiming, among other things, that JJ never came home and that he may have been hit by a snowplow,' the plaintiffs said. 'Thereafter, at or about 5 a.m., Read departed JJ's residence leaving [the niece]frightened, traumatized, and alone.' In the dismissal motion, Read's lawyers said the civil complaint includes no allegation that O'Keefe's niece 'directly observed' the alleged collision, nor did she 'observe the Decedent at any point thereafter.' The niece's 'alleged perception of death, as alleged, was based on conversations with the Defendant and there is no precedent for one to claim emotional distress as a bystander merely by learning via conversation that a loved one has been injured or passed away.' The parties are requesting a hearing in Plymouth Superior Court on the motion to dismiss the civil counts, records show. The next hearing currently scheduled in the case is a status conference on Sept. 22, according to court documents. Material from prior Globe stories was used in this report. Travis Andersen can be reached at
NBC News
12-08-2025
- NBC News
A Chattanooga mom of four vanished without a trace more than a year ago. Her family is determined not to let her case go cold.
Tara Daniels has known her cousin, Valerie Elder Smiley, since the day she was born. 'She was just, like, my first child, and I've loved her from day one,' Tara said. 'She's a joy to be around.' But Tara hasn't seen her cousin since the 41-year-old disappeared from Chattanooga on Friday, June 28, 2024. 'It seems as if she's just vanished off the face of the earth,' Tara said. Tara told Dateline that the days leading up to Valerie's disappearance were typical. 'She was acting normal, you know, the whole week,' she said. But, she added that the family had been concerned for Valerie's health. 'She was having blood pressure problems, and then it went to memory loss problems, and then we found out it was from some medication that she had been taking.' According to Tara, the family, including Valerie's husband and four sons, were doing their best to make sure Valerie was doing all right. 'We were monitoring that,' Tara said. She thinks Valerie got confused and lost on the day she disappeared. Apparently, Valerie and her husband, Patrick, spoke on the phone that day and he asked her where she was. 'She said, 'Well, I'm on my way home,'' Tara said. 'And so he was at the house waiting for her to return, but she never returned. So he went on to the ballgame because the kids– her twins play ball, so they went on to the ball game.' Valerie was also supposed to go to the game, but she never made it. 'Normally, she would ride with them to the game,' Tara said. Eventually, they were able to track Valerie's phone from June 28th. 'The way that the phone showed us on the pings, you know, she was going in circles,' Tara said. 'She was trying to get back to her street, and she never made it back.' In June, for the first anniversary of Valerie's disappearance, Valerie's family came together on WRCB, the local NBC affiliate, to spread the word that Valerie was still missing. Patrick Smiley confirmed that he spoke to his wife on the phone the day she disappeared, and she told him she was on her way home. He also said he called the authorities to report Valerie missing after the ballgame. 'By the time I made it home, it was around 10:30 or 11 o'clock at night,' he told WRCB. 'We reported it to the police and waited for them to come out so we could do a missing person report.' The family immediately jumped into action. 'We started going out searching and looking all over the area, trying to find out: Where could she be?' Tara told Dateline. 'We were out until the wee hours of the morning trying to find her.' The Chattanooga Police Department posted about Valerie's case on July 1, 2024. The post stated that they were requesting assistance in locating Valerie Elder Smiley, who 'was last seen on June 28, 2024, leaving her home in Chattanooga.' The post noted that 'she was driving a red 2004 Ford Expedition with a Tennessee license plate of 079 BFQD.' Two weeks later, Chattanooga PD posted additional details that 'her phone was last pinged in Fayetteville, Georgia, on June 29th and Union City, Georgia, on June 30th.' There was no other information available. Dateline called the Chattanooga PD and left a voicemail requesting an interview. We also submitted a request on their website contact form, but have not yet heard back. When asked if Valerie had any connection to where her phones pinged in Georgia — which is more than two hours away from Chattanooga — Tara told Dateline the family had no knowledge of any reason Valerie would have been there. 'We don't know anybody in that area,' she said. Tara told Dateline the Chattanooga community really came through for the family. 'We had posters, we had pamphlets,' she said. 'The community came together.' They organized search parties, too. 'In different areas, all the way down to Georgia,' she said. 'Two search teams went to Georgia just to saturate that area.' They also searched in the neighboring counties and towards Nashville. 'We had people all around the state of Tennessee.' Valerie's car has also not been found. 'It has never surfaced, and it had a unique identifier on it,' Tara said. The red car had a sticker that said TSU MOM on it. Tara says Valerie's accounts have all been inactive. 'None of her money has been touched. None of her credit cards have been touched,' she said. Valerie's social media accounts have also been left untouched. More than a year later, Valerie's family is still in shock that she is missing. 'We really don't know what to think because there has not been any kind of lead,' Tara said. 'We're hopeful, believe me. We're hopeful that she is still alive; that's our prayer.' At this point, Tara feels like they need to spread the word farther about Valerie's disappearance. 'Because she could be somewhere totally different than what we think,' she said. 'We're just a close-knit family,' Tara said. 'We often have family functions, and it hasn't been the same, you know, with her being gone.' This year, Valerie's second-oldest son graduated from high school. 'It was tough because she was not there to witness it.' 'We're just trying to get some, you know, get some closure to: Where is she?' Tara said. She told Dateline it is important that Valerie's case doesn't go cold. 'It's that important to us as a family that we keep it alive and that we not let it go, you know, cold — and not be another statistic.' She asks that anyone with information come forward. According to the Chattanooga Police Department, Valerie is 5'5' tall and weighs about 210 lbs. She has black hair and brown eyes, and a tattoo of her name on her right calf. She would be 42 years old today. If you have any information on Valerie's disappearance, please call the Chattanooga Police Department at 423-698-2525.
