Rape gang survivors attack Labour minister after ‘dog whistle' comments
Grooming gang victims have accused Lucy Powell of 'totally dismissing' thousands of abuse survivors by calling the scandal a 'dog whistle' issue.
Sarah Wilson suffered years of sexual abuse from the age of 11 at the hands of paedophile gangs in Rotherham.
On Sunday, it was confirmed that Ms Powell will stay on as Leader of the Commons despite accusing a political commentator of blowing a 'little trumpet' as he brought up the scandal.
Ms Wilson, now a campaigner on the issue, was one of at least 1,400 children in Rotherham exploited by gangs of men, of predominantly Pakistani heritage between 1997 and 2013.
During Friday's episode of BBC Radio 4's Any Questions, Tim Montgomerie, a Reform backer, said: 'I don't know if you saw the documentary on Channel 4 about rape gangs.'
Ms Powell, the MP for Manchester Central, interrupted him and replied: 'Oh, we want to blow that little trumpet now, do we? Yeah, OK, let's get that dog whistle out.'
Sharing a clip of the Labour frontbencher's remarks, Ms Wilson wrote: 'This is what victims and survivors have been up against all these years. This is why we weren't listened to.
'They never cared and they never will. [They] totally dismissed survivors and our experiences of being groomed.'
Scarlett, a 20-year-old grooming survivor from Greater Manchester who appeared in the documentary, and Marlon, her father, also criticised Ms Powell.
He said: 'Scarlett and I, who shared our story in the documentary despite the emotional challenges, are outraged by Lucy Powell.
'We feel abused and disrespected once again, and we did not anticipate this kind of treatment from our government leaders.
'You have used us as a political tool for an excuse to be critical towards Conservatives rather than supporting a public inquiry. You should be ashamed.'
Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, said on Sunday that his Cabinet colleague will continue in her role and that she felt 'mortified' by her remarks.
Asked by Sky's Trevor Phillips whether Ms Powell's job was safe, Mr Streeting replied: 'Yes. I think she made a genuine mistake, she's owned up to it, she said sorry and we'll move on.'
Sir Keir Starmer has resisted Tory and Reform calls for a statutory inquiry into the historical sexual abuse of thousands of children by gangs of men, predominantly of Pakistani heritage.
Senior Labour figures, including Andy Burnham, the Mayor of Greater Manchester, and Dan Carden, who leads the socially conservative Blue Labour group of MPs, have also said there should be a national inquiry.
The issue returned to public prominence in January amid hundreds of posts on the subject by Elon Musk, the owner of X and a close ally of Donald Trump.
Channel 4 aired a documentary called Groomed: A National Scandal last week that exposed institutional failures to protect vulnerable girls, including those in care homes.
Challenged on whether he saw this abuse as a 'dog whistle', Mr Streeting replied: 'No, and I don't think that's what Lucy intended to imply in a heated debate on Radio 4 and that's why she's apologised for what she said.
'That's the right thing to do but, you know, I've known Lucy for a long time. I don't think for a moment she would have meant or wanted to imply that raising these issues talking about these issues is dog whistle.'
Mr Streeting went on to insist that the scandal was not a 'political thing' before appearing to accuse some Tory and Reform members of treating it as a 'party political knockabout'.
He said: 'I do think there's been a degree of playing politics with it and we would rather that didn't happen.
'I think that was actually what Lucy Powell was driving at on Radio 4 on Friday night and it came across in a way that she never, ever intended and that's why she apologised.'
In a later interview with the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Mr Streeting said Ms Powell was 'mortified' by the reaction to her remarks.
When it was put to him that Ms Powell is a member of the Cabinet, Mr Streeting said: 'She's also human. I've made mistakes in the past, I'm sure I'm going to make mistakes in the future.
'She's mortified. She does not want and would not want people who have campaigned on or been victims of these crimes to think she was in any way trying to undermine those experiences or those arguments.'
Ms Powell said in a statement on Saturday night that she had made the comments 'in the heat of a discussion' on Any Questions.
She said: 'I would like to clarify that I regard issues of child exploitation and grooming with the utmost seriousness.
'I'm sorry if this was unclear. I was challenging the political point scoring around it, not the issue itself. As a constituency MP, I've dealt with horrendous cases. This Government is acting to get to the truth and deliver justice.'
Labour has dropped previously announced plans for five local grooming gang inquiries in favour of a 'flexible approach', in which councils will be able to spend cash to tackle the issue as they wish.
This could mean full independent local inquiries, but could also take in 'more bespoke work' such as victims' panels or locally-led audits of past failings.
The Government is also awaiting the findings of an audit by Baroness Casey into the nature and scale of grooming, as well as the profile of the gangs behind it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
an hour ago
- Bloomberg
Italians as Well Off as Brits Expose UK's Era of Stagnation
The UK economy has lost its edge over Italy and slipped further behind France over the past decade, according to per head gross domestic product figures that reveal a stark underperformance fueled by a population surge, high inflation and tepid growth. The findings will ring alarm bells in Keir Starmer's government, which is looking at how much the economy generates for each resident rather than aggregate output as a gauge of the living standards it has pledged to improve. GDP per capita was stagnant last year when Labour took office and fell in 2023.
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
From hotels, to wine and candy: Canada spent $170K to bring back women who joined Islamic State
The federal government spent more than $170,000 to bring Canadian women and their children back to the country after they went overseas to join the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, documents show. As first reported by Global News, the documents, which were released under access to information legislation, contain details of the costs incurred when eight women, along with their children, were brought home from Syria. They include costs for business class air travel and hotel bills in Montreal that include wine, candy and chocolates. A number of the women have since been charged with terrorism offences. On Friday, the Conservatives called for an investigation into the expenditures in a letter addressed to Jean-Yves Duclos, the chair of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security, Global News reported. 'With Canadians lining up in food banks in record numbers and struggling with housing costs, the Liberal government must answer for why they spent $170,000 on lavish costs to repatriate reported ISIS criminals,' the letter reportedly says. The Conservative party did not respond by press time to National Post's request for comment. The first round of repatriations, completed in October 2022, cost $10,863, according to the documents from Global Affairs Canada. Canadians Kimberly Polman and Oumaima Chouay were returned to the country in that operation. Polman is facing terrorism charges and Chouay pleaded guilty last month to one charge of participating in the activities of a terrorist group. The second operation, which occurred in April 2023, cost $132,746 in expenses for government staff and those returned to Canada. Not all the expenses are detailed in the documents, but the total cost includes $20,331 for 23 hotel rooms at the Marriott hotel at the Montreal Airport, including room-service bills and a catering tab of nearly $3,000. At the time, four Canadian women — three of whom were arrested upon arrival — and their 10 children were returned to Canada, The Canadian Press reported. Among that group was Edmontonian Aimee Lucia Vasconez, who was married to two different ISIS fighters, according to an affidavit filed in court by an RCMP officer. Another, Ammara Amjad, was also arrested and faces a terrorism charge. Individual bills show that one room cost nearly $1,100, driven up from the original room cost of $638 by purchases of $95 worth of wine, a $105 room-service meal and $87 worth of items from the hotel gift store, including chocolate, chips and drugs such as Benadryl and Reactine. That same room tipped $7 on an $8 coffee. Another room ordered $15 worth of children's ice cream, and a third ordered white, red and sparkling wine at $25 apiece. One room's food bill included two $24 smoked meat dishes. The third repatriation operation, done in early July 2023, cost more than $27,500 and saw a government of Canada employee purchase snacks, including goldfish and granola bars, from Costco, and Timbits from Tim Hortons, for the operation. Hotel rooms in Montreal cost a bit more than $2,300. Two Edmonton women, Dina Kalouti and Helena Carson, were among that group. Both have been sentenced to six-month peace bonds and they are required to continue counselling with the Edmonton-based Organization for the Prevention of Violence (OPV), which provides programming for people seeking to leave extremist groups. The documents redact a number of details, and 50 pages were not released, as they are under consultation. The documents do not appear to account for the costs of actually flying to Syria to get the women from detention camps; they include only the costs of transferring them within Canada. Global Affairs Canada did not respond to National Post's requests for comment by press time. A number of Canadian women travelled to the Middle East when the Islamic State seized territory in Iraq and Syria more than a decade ago. However, the terrorist group lost much of its territory, and Canadians who had been living and fighting with the Islamic State were held in detention camps. This led to a major push, particularly from the United States, to have nations repatriate their citizens who were held in Syria. In 2023 alone, the U.S. state department reported under then U.S. president Joe Biden, 14 countries — Canada among them — repatriated 3,500 citizens from where they were detained. Overall, the administration reported that nearly 7,000 family members of foreign fighters had been repatriated by 30 countries. The U.S. bureau of counterterrorism warned in December 2023 that more than half of those held in camps were under the age of 12 and if they remained, they would become vulnerable to ISIS recruitment, perhaps fuelling a resurgence of the terrorist group. — With addition reporting by the Edmonton Journal and The Canadian Press Quebec woman pleads guilty to joining ISIL, sentenced to one day in custody Ruling ordering Ottawa to bring Canadian ISIL suspects home sparks security debate Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here.
Washington Post
11 hours ago
- Washington Post
RFK Jr. rules out 2028 presidential bid, vows ‘loyalty' to Trump
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Friday addressed rumors he would seek higher office, pledging his singular focus is serving as U.S. health secretary in a public statement aimed at tamping down attacks from some conservatives who have questioned his devotion to the president.
