As Israel faces blame for the hunger crisis in Gaza, UN's own data shows most of its aid is looted
Despite this, condemnation of Israel over the hunger crisis in Gaza has been ramping up, prompting an increasing number of Western governments to declare intentions to recognize a Palestinian state as punishment, and leading some media outlets to totally tune out the role both international humanitarian organizations and Hamas, whose October 2023 mass terror attack in Israel started the nearly two-year-old war, have played in this catastrophe.
"Nobody is able to have nuance in this conflict or hold multiple truths and that's part of why everybody from journalists to NGOs to U.N. officials, the pro-Palestine people, activists and advocates, parrot the same talking points that there's no aid theft and that everything is Israel's fault," Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, told Fox News Digital.
Us Report Urges Un Agency's Shutdown Over Hamas Ties, Oct 7 Terror Links
Alkhatib, a Gaza-born American, said that while the U.N. and other NGOs were "playing politics" by ignoring their own failures so as not to jeopardize funding and because they are terrified of Hamas, Israeli leaders were also "exaggerating" claims about Hamas being the only ones to loot the aid. A close observer of events in Gaza, he described a chain of thievery and extreme price hikes perpetrated by civilians and merchants that have all contributed to the misery there.
He added that statements by some Israeli government ministers about cutting off aid to force Gazans out of the territory have not helped either.
Read On The Fox News App
"Their statements have become the story under which nothing else will fit… no amount of evidence, no amount of clarification, no amount of nuance is going to come anywhere near to grabbing that much attention," Alkhatib said.
Farhan Aziz Haq, a spokesman for U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres, confirmed to Fox News Digital that some aid had been stolen but said it was because so few supplies had entered Gaza in recent months that "people facing hunger have resorted to offloading supplies directly from our convoys," he said.
"We understand the frustration, but let's be clear: this isn't our system. It's what happens when aid is squeezed through too few routes after months of deprivation," he claimed, adding "only a steady, reliable flow of aid and commercial supplies can restore people's belief that aid will arrive and allow for safe, orderly distributions," he claimed.
Information posted on the website of UNOPS, the U.N. Office for Project Services, shows that around 87%, or 1,753 of the 2,013 aid trucks that entered Gaza since May 19 did not reach their final destinations, with the aid being stolen either "peacefully by hungry people or forcefully by armed actors."
Israel Announces Immediate Resumption Of Gaza Aid Airdrops Amid Growing Hunger Crsis
The data, which showed that a record 90 trucks carrying some 1,695 tons of aid were looted on May 31 alone, comes as shocking photos of emaciated Palestinian children – some of which were later proven to be children with pre-existing health conditions used as propaganda by Hamas – have gone viral.
The revelations about the U.N.'s faulty aid system also come amid worldwide condemnation of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a new U.S. and Israel-backed aid distribution mechanism, devised, in part, to prevent aid from falling into Hamas' hands. The U.N. has refused to cooperate with the GHF. The aid group announced on Sunday that it had delivered nearly 105 million meals to Gazans since it started operations in May.
It also comes in sharp contrast to reports by some media outlets who chose to ignore evidence of Hamas stealing and reselling aid in order to fund its ongoing war – seemingly as a way to suggest that Israel is using starvation as a tactic of war or committing "genocide." Israel has emphatically denied both claims.
A recent article in the New York Times even went as far as reporting that there was "no proof" that Hamas had stolen U.N. aid, despite countless documented accounts, including from freed Israeli hostages who reported seeing stockpiles of U.N.-branded products inside Hamas tunnels.
Kobi Michael, a senior researcher at the Institute for National Security Studies in Tel Aviv, said that not only did human rights organizations and many media outlets base their faulty reports on information published by Gaza's Ministry of Health, which is run by Hamas, they also did not "take the nature of Hamas seriously."
"Hamas is not the most reliable source in the world," he said, adding that "the international media and other sources do not consider the interests of Hamas, or its strategy, and they do not seem to acknowledge that Hamas wants a chaotic situation in the Gaza Strip. Hamas wants there to be many casualties among Palestinian civilians, because it serves their interests."
Gaza Humanitarian Foundation: What To Know About The Us-backed Aid Group
"Just to listen to what Hamas leaders have been saying since October 7," Michael continued. "They have promised to repeat October 7 again and again, they have called on the Arab world to join the armed resistance against Israel and on the Arab public to pressure their regimes.
"They have also said publicly, and loudly, that they have no problem sacrificing another 100,000 Palestinian civilians for the sake of the victory," he said.
Yet the GHF has faced scrutiny and blame for the humanitarian disaster unfolding in Gaza amid daily reports by Hamas-backed bodies of civilian deaths at or near their aid distribution points and following chaotic images of people fighting over the food packages or sheltering from gunfire. The new agency has hit back, saying that Hamas, the U.N. and other international aid agencies, are just hoping the initiative fails so they can control all aid operations in Gaza.
On Friday, U.S. Special Envoy Steve Witkoff, together with U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee, visited southern Gaza to inspect one of GHF's aid distribution sites.
"Went into Gaza today & observed humanitarian food program by U.S. launched GHF. Hamas hates GHF b/c it gets food to ppl w/o it being looted by Hamas. Over 100 MILLION meals served in 2 months," Huckabee wrote in a post on X.
David Makovsky, director of the Koret Project on Arab-Israel Relations at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, said blame for the crisis should not be placed on one party but that "by bringing the U.N.'s own records to bear we can level-set the conversation.
"There is a whole debate about GHF, which will not be settled today," he noted. "Yet, in a humanitarian emergency crisis, feeding people should take absolute top priority and I think it is incumbent for the U.N. and GHF to work together to feed people.
"I hope that by bringing in lots of food into Gaza you can help innocent suffering people and also dramatically bring down black market rates exploited by Hamas which they use to control their people," said Makovsky.Original article source: As Israel faces blame for the hunger crisis in Gaza, UN's own data shows most of its aid is looted
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
From Temple Mount, Ben-Gvir says 'entire Gaza Strip must be occupied'
After Ben-Gvir's visit, the Prime Minister's Office issued a statement saying that Israel's status quo on the Temple Mount "has not changed and will not change" National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir ascended the Temple Mount on Sunday to pray, where he called for Israeli sovereignty over Gaza, he announced in a social media post. 'The horror videos released by Hamas are meant to pressure Israel,' Ben Gvir said, referring to new footage released by Hamas on Saturday showing hostage Evyatar David in a tunnel being forced to dig his grave. 'I say this precisely from here - from the Temple Mount, where we've proven sovereignty is possible - that a clear message must be sent: The entire Gaza Strip must be occupied, sovereignty declared, Hamas uprooted, and voluntary emigration promoted. Only then will we return the hostages and win the war.' Ben-Gvir and hundreds of other Jews were visiting the Temple Mount to mark Tisha B'Av, the Jewish day of mourning for the destruction of the First and Second Temples in Jerusalem. The status quo on the Temple Mount, established after 1967, allows Israel to oversee security while the Jordanian-backed Islamic Waqf administers the site. Non-Muslims, including Jews, may visit during limited hours but are strictly prohibited from praying there. The status quo's aim was to maintain religious balance and prevent conflict, though it has often been tested by political and security tensions. Ben-Gvir's number two, Negev and Galilee Minister Yizhak Wasserlauf, also visited the site on Sunday and posted a video of himself praying along with dozens of other people. Ben-Gvir joined by Amit Halevi, Sharren Haskel MKs Amit Halevi (Likud) and Sharren Haskel (New Hope-United Right) also ascended the Temple Mount to mark Tisha B'Av. 'Minhelet Har Habayit' (The Temple Mount Directorate), an NGO that provides services to visitors to the site, said on Sunday that some 3,527 people had visited the site throughout the day. According to the NGO, this set a record for the number of visitors in one day. After Ben-Gvir's visit, the Prime Minister's Office issued a short statement saying that "Israel's policy of maintaining the status quo on the Temple Mount has not changed and will not change." The PMO had to put out nearly identical statements numerous times since the current government took office in late 2022, due to repeated statements by Ben-Gvir that the status quo had changed. "Israel's policy of maintaining the status quo on the Temple Mount has not changed and will not change." For the first time, more than three thousand Jews ascended to pray on the Temple Mount in one day, with 3,527 Jews ascending for Tisha B'Av prayers on the Temple Mount, according to the Temple Mount administration. MKs Amit Halevi (Likud) and Sharren Haskel (New Hope-United Right) also ascended the Temple Mount to mark Tisha B'Av. In March, the Shin Bet wrote in the conclusions of its internal investigations into the failure of the October 7 massacre, that repeated declarations about a change in the status quo on the Temple Mount contributed to Hamas's decision to launch the attack, which it called 'Al Aqsa Flood'. Jordan's Foreign Ministry strongly condemned what it called the "storming of the al-Aqsa Mosque," saying that it was "a flagrant violation of international law" and "an unacceptable provocation." The ministry then added that Israel has no sovereignty over the al-Aqsa Mosque. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Mahmoud Abbas considers unilaterally declaring Palestinian statehood at UNGA
The move, symbolic in nature, is predicated on a forthcoming constitutional declaration that would define a Palestinian state's borders and foundations. Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas is considering unilaterally announcing the transformation of the PA into a state during the upcoming UN General Assembly in New York in September, London-based outlet al-Araby al-Jadeed reported on Sunday. The reported declaration is a symbolic step, and was confirmed to the outlet by a Palestinian official. The move, according to the report, is predicated on a forthcoming constitutional declaration that would define the state's borders and foundations. A constitutional declaration would be announced by Abbas, and would confirm the state's "borders, nature, content, and constitutional foundations until the Palestinian constitution is approved," the report added. National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir denounced Abbas's reported decisions, stating that he will appeal to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu "with a request to bring immediate operative measures to the next cabinet meeting to dismantle the Palestinian Authority." "This must be the response to the terrorist Abu Mazen [Abbas]'s fantasies of a 'Palestinian state' - crushing the terror authority he heads," Ben-Gvir added in his post on X/Twitter on Sunday. Elections for a new Palestinian National Council will be held before the end of the year, Abbas announced in a meeting with the PLO's Executive Committee on July 20. Abbas's decision aims to 'bolster the international push to recognize the State of Palestine,' according to Palestinian officials, marking an important step toward a necessary shift in the development of the Palestinian Liberation Organization. The new council will comprise a total of 350 members: 200 representatives from the West Bank, Gaza, and Jerusalem, and 150 from outside Israel, in order to create a balanced council that accurately represents the population it is meant to govern. Participation in the election will require candidates to 'commit to the PLO's political platform, its international obligations, and UN resolutions,' stated the official Palestinian news agency WAFA. France, other nations begin recognizing Palestinian state In July, French President Emmanuel Macron wrote that he would formally recognize a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly in September in a post to X/Twitter. 'True to its historic commitment to a just and lasting peace in the Middle East, I have decided that France will recognize the State of Palestine,' wrote Macron. 'The urgency today is to end the war in Gaza and to provide aid to the civilian population. Peace is possible,' he added. Other nations, including Canada and the UK, while stating their intention to recognize a Palestinian state, added that recognition was stipulated on reforming the PA and reaching a ceasefire with Hamas in Gaza. This is a developing story. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Blinken: Palestinian state recognition 'a rebuke to Hamas,' but hostages, ending war take priority
Recognition of a Palestinian state is necessary, not only if Israel wishes to resume normalization with Saudi Arabia. But, Blinken pointed out, recognition must be based on predetermined conditions. Former US secretary of state Antony Blinken has said that the recognition of a Palestinian state is a rebuke to Hamas rather than a reward, but must come secondary to the matters of returning the hostages, preventing famine in Gaza, and ending the war, he wrote in a recent op-ed in The Wall Street Journal. 'Israel long ago achieved two of its three stated objectives in Gaza,' Blinken wrote in WSJ, referring to Israel's goals of destroying Hamas' military capabilities and killing those responsible for the October 7 massacre. Israel's goal to return the remaining hostages, he said, will not be accomplished by following Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's plan to occupy Gaza, with Netanyahu's plan simply lengthening the conflict and amplifying anguish on both sides. Blinken noted that key Arab states are willing to help Palestinians govern and rebuild Gaza while preventing Hamas from reemerging into power, but will 'only [do so] if there's a credible political path toward Palestinian self-determination.' Conditions of recognizing a Palestinian state Recognition of a Palestinian state is necessary, and not only if Israel wishes to resume normalization with Saudi Arabia. But, Blinken pointed out, recognition must be based on predetermined conditions. 'No one,' Blinken said, 'should expect Israel to accept a Palestinian state that is led by Hamas or other terrorists, that is militarized or has independent armed militias, that aligns with Iran or others that reject Israel's right to exist, that educates and preaches hatred of Jews or Israel.' He suggested a timeline of three years and deemed the United Nations Security Council as the most suitable candidate to judge whether or not Palestinians uphold the aforementioned conditions. 'America's veto would reassure Israelis,' he noted. Meanwhile, he pushed, Israel must address the growing humanitarian crisis in Gaza and implement a withdrawal plan. Israel must also stop allowing settlements to expand in the West Bank, demolishing Palestinian homes there and in east Jerusalem, and hold extremist violence on all sides accountable. Israel would also need to 'support the reform of the Palestinian Authority instead of trying to undermine it.' Until then, he stated, Israel cannot maintain the idea that Palestinians will tolerate being a 'non-people without national rights.' As well, Palestinians must understand that ideas of a state 'from the river to the sea' are unfeasible. 'No one is going anywhere, whatever the delusions of extremists on both sides.'
