Ratepayers in Durban face hefty costs due to eThekwini Municipality's legal errors
Image: IOL / RON AI
Durban's ratepayers are being forced to absorb the financial consequences of officials who continue to make unlawful decisions without fear of accountability
Asad Gaffar, chairperson of the eThekwini Ratepayers Protest Movement (ERPM), remarked after the city incurred costs in a R30 million tender legal battle between the eThekwini Municipality and a service provider, Daily Double Trading, which culminated in a recent decision by the Constitutional Court.
The Constitutional Court dismissed the municipality's leave to appeal against the Supreme Court of Appeal judgment - the city wanted the upper courts to overturn the Durban High Court ruling in 2022, which ordered it to pay Daily Double Trading R30 million as a settlement to the R43 million claim the company had made for work done.
The municipality argued that it did not authorise an attorney to settle with the service provider; therefore, it could not be liable for the payment. However, it did not oppose the matter in court.
The municipality is now liable for an additional R20 million in expenditures, including substantial legal fees, as a result of the matter continuing since 2018 at an interest rate of 10% annually.
Reverend Thulasizwe Buthelezi, the MEC for the Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta), called on the municipality to recover the money from the officials involved in causing the wasteful expenditure.
Gaffar said the ERPM reiterates its longstanding concern over the widespread culture of impunity, maladministration, and legal recklessness within the municipality.
He said that ratepayers were being forced to absorb the financial consequences.
He applauded Buthelezi's decisive intervention and his demand for full disclosure of legal costs, as well as disciplinary action against those responsible.
'This is not merely an issue of legal error, but it is a systemic governance failure that has placed further strain on an already embattled municipality, struggling with service delivery backlogs, infrastructure decay, and financial instability,' Gaffar said.
The ERPM called for the full implementation of consequence management measures, including disciplinary processes, civil recovery of losses, and, where warranted, criminal referrals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
City Power tackles portion of Joburg CBD's 180 delinquent buildings
City Power state the entity is still owed R1.6 billion by Johannesburg customers. City Power have been scouring Johannesburg's streets in search of properties illicitly consuming electricity. The entity was in the CBD on Thursday, where it removed illegal connections from several buildings and businesses. The disconnection drive is part of a week-long operation focusing on areas in and around the CBD. Hijacked buildings City Power spokesperson Isaac Mangena said the illegally connected buildings posed a security risk not only to inhabitants, but also to the municipality's electricity grid. 'At the moment, there are 184 properties classified as problem buildings within the city, with 62 of them suspected to have been hijacked and 122 not abiding by the city's bylaws,' stated Mangena Mangena noted that the buildings were all in poor structural condition, featuring overcrowding and exposed wiring. 'Such settings are highly combustible and prone to devastating fires. The illegal connections also place excessive pressure on the network, destabilising the system,' he said. City Power states that customers still have an outstanding debt of R1.6 billion with the entity and that this week's operation could help in retrieving up to R30 million. 'City Power remains steadfast in its mission to address non-payment by defaulting customers,' concluded Mangena. Suspected stolen meters Highlights of Thursday's operation included the disconnection of three hijacked buildings and a shoe-repair store in Commissioner Street found to have a suspicious meter. 'It was found operating on a residential meter rather than a business meter, and the meter, suspected to have been stolen from a township, was removed. The property was disconnected on the spot,' confirmed Mangena. City Power states it will continue these operations until the illegal usage of municipal electricity infrastructure is halted. 'These unlawful connections disrupt businesses and factories, causing production losses that often result in job cuts. 'Ordinary paying customers are then left to endure frequent outages caused by the strain of these illegal activities,' Mangena concluded. Police made multiple arrests and confiscated piles of electrical wiring. NOW READ: Here's how much you could be fined if you refuse City Power's meter audits
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
12 companies close, 4 000 jobs lost as US tariffs and sales slump bite automotive industry
The automotive industry was in big trouble before with a slump in new vehicle sales and this has now intensified with the introduction of the US tariffs. The US tariffs and a slump in new vehicle sales caused 12 companies to close and 4 000 people lose their jobs over the past two years. The erosion of the industrial value of the automotive indsutry is emphasised by recent suspensions at Mercedes-Benz and other Original Equipment Manufacturers. Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition Parks Tau shared this grim news with people who attended the annual National Association of Automotive Component and Allied Manufacturers (NAACAM) show on Thursday. He pointed out that the automotive sector is the cornerstone of South Africa's manufacturing economy, contributing 5.2% to gross domestic product (GDP) and 22.6% of industrial output. 'This industry faces intersecting challenges that demand urgent collaboration but within these challenges lie transformative opportunities to redefine and leverage our global competitiveness.' ALSO READ: Automotive Business Council concerned about Trump's tariffs Automotive industry faces stark reality The automotive industry employs 115 000 South Africans directly, with over 80 000 in component manufacturing alone. However, Tau says, we confront a stark reality that domestic sales of locally produced vehicles plummeted to 515 850 units in 2024, far below the South Africa Automotive Masterplan 2035 target of 784 509. He said it is also important to remember that 64% of vehicles sold in South Africa are imports, eroding local production scales. 'Compounding this, local content remains stagnant at 39%, well short of the 60% target, while US tariffs now significantly affect our R28.7 billion automotive exports. These pressures triggered 12 company closures and over 4 000 job losses in two years.' According to Tau, localisation is not merely policy compliance, but existential. 'A 5% increase in local content would unlock R30 billion in new procurement, dwarfing the R4.4 billion US export market. To achieve this, we must act collectively to address some of the bottlenecks to growth. 'Therefore, we are reviewing the Automotive Production Development Programme (APDP) as a comprehensive way of responding to the challenges the sector face, but also to ensure that we see regular growth in the sector to meet the goals of the Automotive Masterplan. 'Some of these reforms include the incentive structure and shifting duty credits to reward manufacturing instead of assembly credits. 'Our critical minerals and metals strategy will prioritise beneficiating platinum group metals (PGMs), copper and manganese for high-value new energy vehicles components such as fuel cells and batteries. Isondo Precious Metals' fuel cell plant in the OR Tambo SEZ proves this viability.' ALSO READ: South Africa faces 25% tariff on US car imports, Minister Parks Tau voices concern Is innovation the answer for automotive industry? Turning to innovation, Tau said global competitiveness hinges on embracing disruption. 'We have been on a path of developing a new industrial policy which focuses on decarbonisation, digitisation and diversification and we follow the example of players in the auto sector. 'In the area of digitisation, Eastern Cape pioneers like S4 and Jendamark demonstrate how AI and automation can future-proof operations.' In decarbonisation, Tau said Borbet SA's 20-year solar energy commitment and Malben Engineering's green steel pilot project align with global carbon rules reshaping trade. As NAACAM notes, carbon has become 'part of the cost of doing business – and increasingly, part of the value too'. Turning to diversification, Tau said catalytic converter exports, historically our lead sub-sector, are declining due to EV shifts and Chinese competition. 'We must scale new products, such as e-axles and thermal systems as well as markets, particularly under the Africa Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA).' ALSO READ: Devastating impact of US tariffs on SA automotive sector even before implementation Transformation in the automotive industry 'We walked a long journey with the automotive sector on transformation. Therefore, it goes without saying that inclusion drives growth. The South Africa Automotive Masterplan 2035's target of 130 new black-owned manufacturers is advancing, with 26 black-owned MSMEs exhibiting, supported by the Automotive Industry Transformation Fund and OEM partnerships such as Toyota-Isuzu's supplier development programme. 'As you would agree, the pace does need to be hastened. Therefore, we are hopeful that the industry will support the endeavour of the Transformation Fund that we are pursuing at the dtic with the view to enhance overall transformation through enterprise and supplier development (ESD) funds.' ALSO READ: US tariffs: SA sends new proposal but no changes to laws Tau emphasised that South Africa must accelerate skills development to ensure that we prepare our labour force for the dramatic changes that artificial intelligence will bring into the sector. 'It is therefore critical that we partner with institutions in the country to address this urgently. 'Entrenching supply chain equity through initiatives like linking equity investments to procurement from black-owned tier 2/3 suppliers will create symbiotic growth. As government, we are also working hard to eliminate compliance burdens and reduce red tape which inhibits investment in our country's automotive sector. 'Our policy response is accelerating and we plan on introducing an Omnibus (general laws amendment) Bill to fast-track high-impact investments and projects within 90 days. This is but one of the ambitious plans we have for the medium-term. ALSO READ: 'Open our eyes and ears' – Ramaphosa on how to tackle US tariff hike on SA cars ITAC to look into impact of exports on automotive industry 'We will also, through the International Trade Administration Commission (ITAC), look at the impact of imports into the country and the impact they have on local production. We want to grow the sector and therefore our first option must not be to wield a stick but rather offer a carrot to these companies to attract more investment into the country, increasing the value-add of particularly our component manufacturers.' Tau pointed out that the Eastern Cape produces 46% of South Africa's vehicles and 54% of its exports, epitomising our potential. Therefore, he said, everyone has the responsibility to reignite the collective ambition that drives NAACAM's advocacy. 'With South Africa chairing the G20, our automotive sector can model African industrial resilience rooted in localisation, powered by innovation and fortified by equity.'
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Motor manufacturers under threat: SA mulls incentive revisions, but are tariffs the answer?
File picture: Mercedes-Benz SA. Deindustrialisation remains a major threat to the South African vehicle manufacturing industry. Image: Supplied South Africa's automotive manufacturing industry is facing an existential crisis as affordable imports from India and China flood the market and export contracts come under threat. Although the imposition of US tariffs only affects Mercedes-Benz at present, this is expected to take a significant toll on that company, while elsewhere in the industry, a gradual deindustrialisation is eroding local output. While industry leaders such as Toyota SA CEO Andrew Kirby have previously sounded the warning bells about industrial decline, the Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau, added to the chorus this week when he stated that the abovementioned pressures have resulted in 12 component company closures and over 4,000 job losses in the last two years. Speaking at an industry showcase held by the National Association of Automotive Component and Allied Manufacturers (Naacam) on Wednesday, Tau stated that local vehicle production, at 515,850 units in 2024, was far below the Automotive Masterplan 2035 target of 784,509. Equally worrying is that local content for vehicle production remains stagnant at 39%, well below the 64% target. Imports remain a threat, as just 37% of the vehicles that South Africans purchase are locally produced, according to Lightstone, while 36% are sourced from India and 11% from China. Minister Parks Tau said his department was currently reviewing the APDP incentive programme. Image: Supplied Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading 'Localisation is not merely policy compliance - it is existential. A 5% increase in local content would unlock R30 billion in new procurement, dwarfing the R4.4 billion US export market. To achieve this, we must act collectively to address some of the bottlenecks to growth,' Tau said. He revealed that the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition (DTIC) was reviewing the current Automotive Production Development Programme (APDP) as a comprehensive way of responding to the sector's challenges. Among these reforms would be shifting the duty credit incentive structure to place a greater emphasis on rewarding full manufacture, rather than just assembly. The government is also planning to incentivise electric vehicle (EV) and battery manufacturing. As announced earlier this year, carmakers will be able to claim a 150% tax deduction on investments related to EV production. The government is also considering adding locally mined minerals to the list of Items that qualify as local content under the APDP. In addition, a comprehensive skills gap analysis has been completed, resulting in EV-specific curricula and certification programmes now being developed in conjunction with numerous universities. The Minister said the government was also working hard to eliminate compliance burdens and reduce the red tape currently inhibiting investment into the auto sector. This includes a General Laws Amendment Bill that aims to fast-track high-impact investments and projects within 90 days. A call for punitive tariffs However, when it comes to protecting the local manufacturing industry from a flood of affordable imports, it appears the DTIC is not in favour of punitive measures such as tariffs. This is in spite of widespread calls for this, including from manufacturers such as BMW SA and industry organisations. Speaking at a separate event held on Tuesday, in response to Trump's tariff imposition, Tau said: 'With regards to Chinese and Indian auto, it is a discussion that we're currently having with the intention of taking a less punitive approach, but rather taking a more proactive approach of getting some of those products manufactured in the country.' 'So we're not holding the stick as a starting point. We start with the carrot and then balance it with the stick," Tau added.
