Hong Kong Court Strikes Down Law On Use Of Opposite-Sex Toilets
A trans man, known as "K", filed the lawsuit nearly six years ago in light of what he described as "embarrassing and upsetting" discrimination often faced by trans people when using public bathrooms.
K was encouraged by doctors to use men's bathrooms as part of his gender dysphoria treatment, but because his Hong Kong ID card identified him as female, he could be fined up to HK$2,000 ($255) for doing so.
He did not receive criminal penalties but recalled a situation where his entering a women's bathroom led to tension and misunderstanding.
"The way people looked at me and doubted me was very painful," he told AFP.
"When the rules are abolished, I believe it will reduce these embarrassing situations."
K argued that existing rules breached his rights to equality, privacy, and freedom from discrimination.
High Court judge Russell Coleman agreed on Wednesday, saying the laws "create a disproportionate and unnecessary intrusion into the privacy and equality rights".
"Many trans people choose not to use public conveniences at all, due to fear, the threat of harassment, and to avoid having their gender identity invalidated or undermined," Coleman said.
The judge gave the government a year to "consider whether it wishes to implement a way to deal with the contravention".
Hong Kong's government said it would study the ruling and consider follow-up actions.
Transgender activists have notched a handful of wins in Hong Kong's courts, which are separate from those in mainland China.
The city's top court decided in 2023 that it was unconstitutional for the government to require a person to complete full gender-affirming surgery before the "sex entry" on their ID card could be changed.
K said the ruling was "another forward step" for LGBTQ rights but noted that Hong Kong still does not have a gender recognition law.
Authorities should also create more gender-neutral facilities and dispel myths that women's toilets would become unsafe after Wednesday's ruling, he added.
K's lawyer Mark Daly said the government has a duty to "proactively review discriminatory laws and ensure that public spaces are safe, inclusive, and accessible to all, regardless of gender identity".
Quarks, an advocacy group for transgender youth, hailed the ruling as a "major step for human rights development in Hong Kong".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
'I will be your champion': Krissy Barrett makes history as first female AFP commissioner; background in terror and overseas missions
Australia federal police's chief Krissy Barrett standing alongside Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (Image credits: X @AlboMP) Australia federal police's (AFP) assistant commissioner Krissy Barrett will become the first woman to lead the force, earning her role as the nation's top cop, following the early retirement of former commissioner Reece Kershaw. Australian prime minister Anthony Albanese and home affairs minister Tony Burke announced the leadership change at a press conference in Canberra, standing alongside both Barrett and Kershaw. Barrett, currently serving as a deputy commissioner, brings significant experience in counter-terrorism and international operations. She has played key roles in deployments to the Solomon Islands and the investigation into the Bali bombings. She will become the ninth commissioner of the Australian Federal Police (AFP). 'As commissioner, I will ensure the AFP continues to keep Australians safe, protects the vulnerable, and identifies and disrupts an emerging cohort of criminals who have mixed motivations and threaten our national security,' Barrett said as quoted by Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 'I promise I will be your champion. I promise I will do this uniform proud for you. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Woman Wears Her Mothers Old Ring For 25 Years - Then Jeweller Tells Her This Marvelousa Undo And to every Australian, I will be devoted to protecting you and our way of life, and I commit to working as hard as I can every single day, like every AFP commissioner before me," she added. The AFP chief also acknowledged the support she received from Kershaw throughout her career, saying he had been a mentor to her and many others in the agency. Kershaw's contract had been extended in May last year to run until October 2026, but he recently signalled his intention to retire. He has led the AFP since his appointment by the Coalition in 2019. Home affairs minister Burke said Kershaw had expressed his decision to step down a few weeks ago. Prime Minister Albanese thanked Kershaw for his contribution, stating, 'Reece, you have achieved an enormous amount for our nation. And I hope you feel incredibly proud.' During his time as commissioner, Kershaw made child exploitation, organised crime, and drug trafficking key priorities for the AFP. His background as a child protection investigator informed much of this work. However, his tenure was also marked by controversy. He faced criticism over his handling of the Dural caravan saga, which was later exposed as a fake terror plot. In 2023, questions were raised about his relationship with a senior partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC), Mick Fuller, involving a government contract. Text messages later revealed Kershaw had more frequent interactions with Fuller than he initially disclosed to parliament. Despite these concerns, minister Burke said in July that Kershaw retained the government's 'full confidence.' This came even as accusations of racism were levelled against the Northern Territory Police, which Kershaw led prior to joining the AFP. Kershaw stepped down just weeks after the release of a coroner's report into the 2019 death of Kumanjayi Walker. Coroner Elisabeth Armitage described the NT Police as having 'hallmarks of institutional racism' and found 'clear evidence of entrenched, systemic and structural racism' within the force, reported the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
Hindustan Times
4 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
UK couple held in Iran moved to 'worst' prisons
A British couple detained in Iran for seven months on espionage charges have been moved to separate prisons in and near Tehran, heightening fears for their welfare, their son told AFP on Monday. A undated handout picture released by the family of Craig and Lindsay Foreman through Britain's Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) in London on February 15, 2025, shows Craig and Lindsay Foreman posing for a selfie photograph at an unknown location.(AFP) Lindsay and Craig Foreman, both 52 and who previously split their time between southeast England and Spain, were seized in Kerman, in central Iran, in early January while on a round-the-world motorbike trip. Their family has known little about their whereabouts since then, but say they learned Sunday via the UK Foreign Office that Lindsay has been transferred to Qarchak women's prison near the capital. It has a dubious reputation, with human rights groups repeatedly criticising dire conditions reported there. "It's one of the worst prisons in the world," Lindsay's son Joe Bennett said in an interview Monday near his home in Folkestone, southeast England. Meanwhile, his stepdad Craig has been moved to Tehran's infamous central prison, also known as Fashafouyeh, which is about 30 kilometres (18 miles) south of the capital and has similar notoriety. Bennett, who has yet to talk to his parents since they were detained more than 200 days ago, called the developments "unbelievably tough". "Because of where they are, I'm worrying more than I was ever," he added, urging Iranian authorities to allow British officials fresh access to the couple and to let his parents call home. "You're just thinking, 'is she OK'," he said of the seven-month ordeal, adding "it's like you feel sick all the time". Fears "I do have confidence in their resilience, they are mentally strong," Bennett told AFP. But the 31-year-old sales manager, who used to speak to his mum nearly daily, fears overcrowding at their new prisons and that they may be abused, as well as a fallout from their enforced separation. "I believe they will be, together, as strong as possible, but now they've been separated... that lifeline has been taken." The couple, who were on a "once-in-a-lifetime" trip, entered Iran from Armenia and had only intended to stay four days before crossing into Pakistan. The UK government advises against all travel to Iran, after a string of British and UK-Iranian dual nationals have been detained over the last decade. Western governments have accused Tehran of using them as bargaining chips amid perpetually fraught relations between Iran and the West. Bennett noted the family -- which includes three other siblings -- were confident they "knew what they were doing" given they are "experienced travelers". He said the couple took "every means possible" to travel safely and compliantly through the country, including getting tourist visas, hiring tour guides, keeping to main roads and staying in hotels. Relatives first realised something was wrong when the couple stopped communicating but their messages on WhatsApp and other platforms showed as having been read. Iran then said in February that the Foremans were accused of entering Iran "posing as tourists" to gather information. It claimed to have established links between the couple and foreign intelligence services and that they were being held on "espionage charges". 'Crazy' Bennett dismissed the claim that his parents are spies as "crazy". "They're not spies or political players. They are just two people who are traveling around the world." He also renewed his criticism Monday of the UK government, saying it felt like ministers and officials were just going "through the motions" in their response. A Foreign Office spokeswoman said it was "deeply concerned" at Iran's espionage allegations and that it continues to raise the case "directly with the Iranian authorities". "We are providing them with consular assistance and remain in close contact with their family members," she added. But Bennett claimed the family's letters to Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Foreign Secretary David Lammy had gone unanswered, while meetings with junior ministers left them feeling underwhelmed. "If you're not taking accountability for two UK citizens abroad, and you're not acknowledging us as a family, we don't feel like we're getting supported in the right way," he said. Bennett said the family had been receiving support and advice from former British detainees in Iran and their relatives, including Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe, who was held there for several years, and her husband Richard Ratcliffe. Ratcliffe mounted a years-long campaign for his wife's release, which eventually occurred in 2022.
New Indian Express
4 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Russia urges caution in nuclear 'rhetoric' after Trump's comments
Russia urged caution on Monday after US President Donald Trump said he would deploy two nuclear submarines following an online row with former Russian president Dmitry Medvedev. Trump said he had ordered the deployment in response to what he alleged were highly provocative comments by Medvedev, saying the submarines would be positioned in "appropriate regions". Trump did not say whether he meant nuclear-powered or nuclear-armed submarines. He also did not elaborate on the locations, which are kept secret by the US military. "Russia is very attentive to the topic of nuclear non-proliferation. And we believe that everyone should be very, very cautious with nuclear rhetoric," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters, including from AFP, on Monday. The row between Medvedev and Trump erupted against the backdrop of the US leader's ultimatum for Russia to end its military offensive in Ukraine or face fresh economic sanctions, including on its remaining trading partners. Medvedev -- one of Russia's most prominent anti-Western hawks -- accused Trump of "playing the ultimatum game" and said that Trump "should remember" that Russia was a formidable force. "Each new ultimatum is a threat and a step towards war. Not between Russia and Ukraine, but with his own country," he said. Medvedev, who has not posted on social media since the spat, is currently the deputy chairman of Russia's Security Council. He served one term as president from 2008 to 2012, effectively acting as a placeholder for Putin, who was able to circumvent constitutional term limits and de facto remain in power. The chief of staff to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on Monday backed Trump's actions. "The concept of peace through strength works," Andriy Yermak wrote on social media. "The moment American nuclear submarines appeared, one Russian drunk -- who had just been threatening nuclear war on X -- suddenly went silent."
