Woman who crawled out of drain in the Philippines found, as a nation grapples with homelessness
Acting on instructions from Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr, a team from the Social Welfare Ministry managed to track down 'Rose' at a slum district, and took her to a 'processing centre' to 'undergo a thorough assessment and appropriate intervention'.
Photos of Rose crawling out of a narrow drain at a busy street corner late in the afternoon on May 26 in Makati city – her dress and denim shorts caked with grime, and her hair streaked with dirt and dried leaves – have gone viral.
These images provoked both shock and amusement, with many drawing comparisons to a Japanese horror movie about a ghostly killer clawing her way out of a deep well.
But they also triggered heated discussions about homeless people living in a subterranean world beneath gleaming financial districts like Makati, in a nation that has seen growth averaging at 5 per cent to 7 per cent annually.
Philippine Social Welfare Minister Rex Gatchalian presented Rose to reporters on May 29, and said the ministry was giving her 80,000 pesos (S$1,850) so she can start a sundry neighbourhood store.
The ministry will also help her partner, who has welding skills but is jobless and also a vagrant, find a job, said Mr Gatchalian.
That gesture, however, has been met with scepticism.
'But it's a whole community! Why choose a band-aid solution,' publisher and editor Chi Balmaceda Gutierrez said in a Facebook post.
Ms Rocky Galman, who lives in Brisbane, said in the same thread: 'It's good to help people in need but you need to teach them first, secure their home and food, then give them the ability to work or set up a business. If you give them money without proper education/training, it will just go to waste.'
Others even mocked the effort.
'Maybe I'll just go home to the Philippines, look for a sewage canal so I can get 80k to start a business,' said Ms Charise Penafiel, who is working in Hong Kong.
A street photographer took these photos of a woman crawling out of a storm drain in Manila's main financial district. -- PHOTOS: WILLIAM ROBERTS/INSTAGRAM
'Botanical Garden'
When she was presented by Mr Gatchalian to the media, Rose said she was not living inside the drain.
She said she crawled inside the hole because she dropped a 'cutter blade' into it.
But Makati police spokeswoman Captain Jenibeth Artista told GMA News vagrants like Rose were using the drain as an entry and exit point into sewage lines that act as subterranean passageways.
Makati police station chief Colonel Jean Dela Torre told reporters on May 28 that the police found several items in the storm drain where Rose emerged from, including pliers and shirts.
Mr William Roberts, the amateur street photographer who first took Rose's photos, said in an Instagram post that he found one end of this tunnel system along a creek that its users have dubbed the 'Botanical Garden'.
He said he talked to one man, Jerwin, whom he found emerging from a sewer pipe.
He said Jerwin told him: 'We don't live in the canals. We hide in them from the sun, from the police, sometimes to stash what little we have, sometimes to keep each other safe.'
Mr Roberts said the story of Rose and Jerwin 'is about the cracks we cover up with concrete, the faces we ignore when they crawl out of the canal'.
There are more than three million homeless people across Metro Manila – a sprawling metropolis of 16 cities with a combined population of some 14 million.
They live in shanties, makeshift pushcarts colloquially known as 'kariton', and wherever they can find shelter – by the side of the road, at cemeteries, and apparently in storm drains and sewage tunnels.
The Borgen Project – a US-based non-profit – said extreme poverty, domestic violence, human trafficking and natural disasters are the usual push factors behind homelessness in the Philippines. - The Straits Times/ANN
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Express
4 hours ago
- Daily Express
Kedah airport runway closed after ‘incident' with air force aircraft
Published on: Tuesday, August 19, 2025 Published on: Tue, Aug 19, 2025 By: FMT Reporters Text Size: In May, the Alor Setar airport's runway was also forced to close after an air force fighter jet skidded on its nose while landing. (KLIA2 pic) PETALING JAYA: The runway of Sultan Abdul Halim Airport in Kedah has been temporarily closed after an incident involving an air force aircraft at around 11.30am. Malaysia Airports Holdings Bhd said the runway was closed to help with the removal of the aircraft and for 'clearing works'. Advertisement 'A notice to airmen has been issued by the Civil Aviation Authority of Malaysia, and the closure is expected to remain in effect until 4pm today. 'Passengers are advised to check with their respective airlines for the latest flight updates,' it said in a Facebook post. It is not immediately clear what had occurred. In May, the Alor Setar airport's runway was also forced to close after an air force fighter jet skidded on its nose while landing. The pilot did not suffer any injuries in the incident. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
The Star
11 hours ago
- The Star
Plastic waste from Asia inundates Sea of Japan coastline
FILE PHOTO: A large sea bream object, made from colourful debris found drifting at sea, such as plastic tanks, toys and wires, and produced by Japanese art group Yodogawa Tecnique, is displayed at the Setouchi Triennale art event at the port of Uno, Okayama prefecture in western Japan on May 19, 2013. Japan is one of the world's largest generators of plastic waste and is being urged to take steps to keep oceans clean. - AFP/JIJI PRESS TOKYO: Marine waste that has drifted over from other Asian countries is causing problems in prefectures along the Sea of Japan. Intergovernmental negotiations held in Switzerland through Aug 15 sought to establish the world's first treaty on preventing pollution but ultimately failed to reach an agreement, prompting concerns over delays in taking action against serious plastic pollution. At the same time, Japan itself is one of the world's largest generators of plastic waste and is being urged to take steps to keep oceans clean. Plastic containers and bottles have covered the western coastline of Tsushima in Nagasaki Prefecture, about 50 kilometres from Busan. 'No matter how many times we collect them, they keep washing ashore whenever there's heavy rain or a typhoon,' said tour guide Shoko Sakata, 45. According to city estimates, 30,000 to 40,000 cubic metres of drifting garbage reaches Tsushima annually. Over half is plastic products, with 54 per cent of the plastic bottles collected last year coming from China and Taiwan, and 38 per cent from South Korea. According to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, about 20 million tons of plastic waste ends up in the global environment each year. About 90 per cent of that comes from developing countries, with improper waste control cited as the main cause. Japan is planning to provide technical assistance to Asian countries and elsewhere to establish waste sorting and collection systems, and has set a target of training 10,000 personnel in charge of waste control. However, reducing drifting waste ultimately depends on the efforts of the countries that generate it. 'International rules are needed to restore clean beaches,' said Michinao Suenaga, 54, a board member of the Tsushima Coast and Aquatic Preservation Programme Association, which engages in beach clean-ups. In contrast, an Environment Ministry survey in fiscal 2023 found that most of the plastic bottles that washed ashore along the coasts of the Pacific Ocean and the Seto Inland Sea were domestic in origin. Ehime University Professor Hirofumi Hinata, who specialises in coastal physical oceanography, attributed this to ocean currents and wind. 'Some of the plastic waste flowing into the Pacific Ocean eventually reaches countries like the United States,' he said. Japan ranks second in the world, after the United States, in its generation of plastic packaging waste per capita — 32 kilograms per year as of 2015. The public and private sectors are working to reduce the amount of plastic waste. Kirin Holdings Co., for example, promotes label-free bottles and has vowed to 'contribute to the realisation of a circular economy' and the 'reduction of environmental impact'. The Plastic Resource Circulation Law, which came into effect in 2022, requires convenience stores, hotels, restaurants and other businesses to formulate plans to reduce the volume of plastic products they provide. However, penalties apply only to large businesses, resulting in limited efforts by small operations. A Tokyo restaurant owner who uses plastic straws said, 'Plastic is cheaper, and customers strongly prefer it, so we can't switch to paper.' Plastic exposed to ultraviolet rays and wind breaks down into tiny fragments called microplastics, which are less than five millimeters in size. Consuming fish that ingested microplastics is feared to pose health risks to humans. 'We will keep encouraging countries to participate in discussions toward the establishment of a treaty, while promoting effective initiatives both domestically and internationally,' a senior Environment Ministry official said. - The Japan News/ANN
Focus Malaysia
a day ago
- Focus Malaysia
Mutton or pork? Mystery meat at ‘Muslim-friendly' eatery causes confusion, alarm online
AS PREVIOUSLY pointed out, issue of a restaurant's halal status is of great importance to Muslim diners. This was again highlighted by a post by popular culinary influencer Amin Sukor a.k.a. Abang Ameen in a Facebook post where it was claimed that a restaurant popular with Muslim diners had 'mystery meats' stored in its cold room. The issue was originally highlighted by Rose_amalina (profile locked) which asked what meat was pictured next to the poultry carcasses in the freezer. The enquirer further cast aspersions on the manner the poultry that was slaughtered in the supposedly halal-certified restaurant. Aside from being stored next to the mystery meat which the restauranteur claimed was mutton, she asked if the slaughter was done in accordance to Islamic requirements. Editor's Note: A quick check on the Farmer Village restaurant's social media does not show the Bandar Teknologi Kajang eatery claiming to be halal-certified or even Muslim-friendly. But its menu seems to be porcine-free. In fact, mutton seems to be heavily featured in its various dishes. The 'mystery meat' was discovered by a staff member who has since reported the finding to the authorities. But it appears no action has been forthcoming leading Rose_amalina to wonder if the owner of the Farmer Village restaurant was 'protected'. The post sharing the uncomfortable discovery has since generated 3.2K likes, 875 comments and 1.6K shares, denoting that the issue has plenty of traction. One commenter claimed that the younger generation of Muslims were too keen to be 'hipsters', an insinuation that they were modern and casual to halal requirements. This was not what their parents taught them. She also lamented that any query on a restaurant's halal status was often met with rudeness even if it is a cashier who will retort as if they were the proprietor. It was further claimed that Chinese eateries cannot be trusted even if they possess the halal certification given the Chinese tend to just prepare food as they see fit. It did not matter if Muslim diners were deceived as long as there was profit to be made. One observer was stunned at how many Muslim customers would queue to dine at obviously non-Muslim establishments when he travelled through Ipoh. They seem very confident of the 'pork-free, no lard' claims by these restaurants, he opined. One commenter was at pains to highlight the differences between properly certified halal restaurants with one that merely denotes 'no pork or lard' is used to prepare the food. Another confirmed that the restaurant is NOT listed on JAKIM's website as a halal-certified establishment. For many, the fact that the restaurant is Chinese-owned is reason enough to NOT dine there regardless of whether it is halal-certified or displays 'pork- and lard-free' signage. Many Muslim diners would only be satisfied and feel at ease if the restaurant was Muslim-owned. This underlines their belief that no other Muslim would knowingly feed a fellow Muslim haram food. It boils down to an issue of trust. If in doubt, Muslim diners are free to patronise any number of halal-certified eateries. But as this issue rumbles on, it will be a matter of time before the more conservative elements demand that Muslims can only dine in halal-certified restaurants as mandated in PAS-ruled Kelantan. Such a decree will not only affect restaurants like Farmer Village but thousands of Muslim-owned businesses that do NOT possess such certification. Is this the route Malaysians want to take? – Aug 18, 2025 Main image credit: Amin Sukor/Facebook
