logo
Why did ScotGov support award of Scots ferry contracts to firms abroad

Why did ScotGov support award of Scots ferry contracts to firms abroad

MV Isle of Islay is expected to be taking passengers in Scotland nine months before MV Glen Rosa that is still being completed by state-owned shipyard firm Ferguson Marine.
It has been confirmed successful sea trials mean that MV Isle of Islay - one of the first of the four ferries being built in Turkey in the wake of Scotland's ferry fiasco - is on target to be delivered by September.
But there are now concerns that Scots companies have lost out in playing any part in making any contribution to the building of 11 new lifeline vessels to serve the nation's islands as part of a Scottish Government plan to help end the nation's ferry fiasco.
Why did CMAL award ferry contracts to shipyards in Turkey and Poland?
The Scottish Government-owned ferry and port owner CMAL awarded contracts to build ferries to Cemre Shipyard in Turkey and Remontowa Shipbuilding in Poland based on competitive procurement processes. These shipyards demonstrated the capability to deliver vessels that met technical specifications, timelines, and budgetary constraints.
The Cemre yard and (inset) one of the vessels it is delivering for Scotland (Image: .) Remontowa was awarded a £147.5m contract to build seven all-electric ferries, having received the highest score during the bidding process.
The Turkish shipyard Cemre Marin Endustri was contracted to construct four new roll-on/roll-off passenger and vehicle ferries for Scotland's west coast ferry network. These vessels are intended to enhance services on routes to the Isle of Islay and the Little Minch corridor, which includes Skye, Harris, and North Uist. The deals together were worth £206m.
Why was Ferguson Marine, the Scots state-owned shipyard firm not awarded these contracts?
The Inverclyde firm had faced several challenges that affected its competitiveness in the bidding process.
Firstly a lack of experience. The shipyard had not completed any ferries in the past five years, failing to meet the tender's requirement to show recent experience in building at least three similar ferries.
Read more:
Public inquiry demand over 'scandal' of hundreds of Scots jobs lost in ferry fiasco
'Laughable': Turkey-built ferry to be delivered seven years faster than fiasco ship
Cost to repair CalMac ferry now £2m more than to buy replacement
'Final nail in coffin'. Scots fiasco firm loses out on big ferry contract to Poland
'Material uncertainty' over Scots ferry operator future amidst £45m funding hike
'Mismanagement': Public cost of Scots ferry fiasco firm hits £750m amidst overspends
It had financial and operational issues. Ferguson Marine's previous projects, such as the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa, have been significantly delayed and over budget, raising concerns about the yard's financial stability and project management capabilities.
CMAL's procurement process emphasised technical and financial suitability. Ferguson Marine is understood to have not scored as highly as other bidders in these areas.
What were the issues with the Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa projects?
The issues with Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa has become known as Scotland's ferry fiasco.
Glen Rosa and Glen Sannox's arrival to serve islands was scheduled to be online in the first half of 2018. Glen Sannox finally went into service on January but islanders are still awaiting the arrival of Glen Rosa.
Glen Sannox (Image: Andrew Milligan/PA) Both vessels were significantly behind schedule and over budget. Glen Rosa's delivery has been delayed until spring 2026, with costs soaring.
Costs of the entire project are currently expected to have multiplied at least five-fold from the original £96m price.
The delays were down to design and construction flaws. Problems included inadequate planning, quality issues, and a lack of detailed construction plans with CMAL and Ferguson Marine blaming each other for failings.
The contract also lacked adequate financial safeguards, such as a builder's refund guarantee, which would have protected public funds in case of project failures.
What are the implications of awarding contracts to overseas shipyards?
Awarding contracts to overseas shipyards has both advantages and disadvantages.
Overseas shipyards like Cemre and Remontowa, it is felt, have demonstrated the ability to deliver vessels on time and within budget.
These shipyards have experience building similar vessels, ensuring adherence to technical specifications.
But the disadvantages are the economic impact on Scotland.
Excluding domestic shipyards like Ferguson Marine can have negative effects on local employment and the Scottish shipbuilding industry.
Ferguson Marine has previously indicated that losing ferry contracts had an effect on its ability to continue as a going concern.
Ferguson Marine (Image: Colin Mearns) The decisions on the contracts have sparked political criticism and debates over the government's commitment to supporting domestic industries.
What lessons have been learned from these experiences?
While the decision to award ferry contracts to overseas shipyards was based on factors like cost, efficiency, and technical capability, it has raised important questions about the future of domestic shipbuilding in Scotland and the need for improved procurement practices.
The challenges faced in ferry procurement have highlighted the need for robust procurement processes and that contracts should include builder's refund guarantees to protect public funds.
It has also shown the requirement to balance the need for cost-effective procurement with the importance of supporting local industries.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Everything you need to know about Donald Trump's four-day Scotland visit
Everything you need to know about Donald Trump's four-day Scotland visit

Scotsman

time9 minutes ago

  • Scotsman

Everything you need to know about Donald Trump's four-day Scotland visit

Donald Trump will be meeting with Prime Minister Keir Starmer and First Minister John Swinney. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Preparations are underway as Donald Trump is set to arrive in Scotland later this week. This will be the first time the US president has returned to the country of his mother's birth since 2023. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Trump is set to visit his golf resorts at Turnberry on the Ayrshire coast and Menie in Aberdeenshire. He will return to the UK for an official state visit in September. Donald Trump will visit his golf resorts during his Scotland visit. | Bloomberg via Getty Images When is Trump visiting? White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters that the visit would take place between July 25 and July 29. She said: 'President Trump will travel to Scotland, where he will visit both Turnberry and Aberdeen from July 25 to July 29. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "During the visit, President Trump will meet again with Prime Minister Starmer to refine the great trade deal that was brokered between the United States and the United Kingdom." Make sure you keep up to date with news from across Scotland by signing up to our free newsletter here. His schedule has not been made public but he is expected to split his time between his two Scottish bases at Turnberry and Menie. What is he doing in Scotland? Mr Trump's press secretary confirmed that he will be meeting Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Aberdeen. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad First Minister John Swinney has also confirmed he will have a meeting with Mr Trump during the visit, although no details have been released. PA Mr Trump said: 'We're going to be meeting with the British Prime Minister, very respectful, and we are going to have a meeting with him, probably in Aberdeen, and we're going to do a lot of different things. 'We're going to also refine the trade deal that we've made. So we'll be meeting mostly […] at probably one of my properties, or maybe not, depending on what happens, but we'll be in Aberdeen, in Scotland, meeting with the Prime Minister.' He will also visit both of his golf courses in Scotland - Turnberry in Ayrshire and Menie in Aberdeenshire. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It is also expected Mr Trump will pay a visit to the 18-hole links New Course ahead of its expected opening in August. What will security be like? The chair of the Scottish Police Federation, David Threadgold, told Scotland on Sunday that all officers in Scotland could be affected for the duration of the trip, with some officers potentially being asked to work 12-hour shifts. He said: 'This is a huge policing event for Scotland and we will require mutual aid because of the huge demand on my colleagues. 'Very few if any cops will not be impacted by next week's visit and beyond.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He added that ensuring officers can eat, drink and rest will be a 'challenge'. Police Scotland have also made a request to the Police Service of Northern Ireland seeking officers to provide additional support during the visit. Flying restrictions over the Trump International Golf Links site in Aberdeenshire are already in force and will remain in place until August 10. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Will there be protests? Coordinated anti-Trump protests are being held in Edinburgh and Aberdeen this weekend, marking the arrival of the US President in Scotland. Since the dates of the President's visit have been confirmed, a group of campaigners from across the UK have joined forces under a banner called the 'Stop Trump Coalition'. It has organised two protests in Scotland on Saturday, at Union Terrace Gardens in Aberdeen and outside the US consulate in Edinburgh, which are expected to kick off at noon. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Protesters gathered in Edinburgh when Donald Trump visited Scotland in 2018. | PA Organisers said activists, made up of trade unionists, climate campaigners and pro-Palestine groups, will respond to the President's agenda and follow him 'wherever he goes' during his trip.

One of Scotland's biggest battery energy storage farms to be built two miles from busy riverside town
One of Scotland's biggest battery energy storage farms to be built two miles from busy riverside town

Scotsman

time9 minutes ago

  • Scotsman

One of Scotland's biggest battery energy storage farms to be built two miles from busy riverside town

'The project is in a carefully chosen strategic location that will directly support the UK's energy security strategy' – Andrew Philpott, Apatura Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... One of the largest battery storage facilities planned for Scotland has been given the go-ahead in the latest push for greener sources of energy. Renewable energy storage specialist Apatura said it had received planning consent to build a new grid-scale 560-megawatt battery energy storage system (BESS) near Clydebank in West Dunbartonshire. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The site is the 11th such development that the firm has secured planning permission for in the last two years. With the latest approval, Apatura has now secured permission to build a combined total of more than 2.1 gigawatts in electricity storage capacity at sites across central Scotland. Apatura has now secured permission to build a combined total of more than 2.1 gigawatts in electricity storage capacity at sites across central Scotland. Picture: Adobe Stock The latest planned development is located on land adjacent to Cochno Road, two miles from Clydebank and eight miles from the centre of Glasgow. Andrew Philpott, chief development officer at Apatura, said: 'The Whitehall project is in a carefully chosen strategic location that will directly support the UK's energy security strategy. Once commissioned, it will play a key role in providing the resilient infrastructure network needed for a net zero future. 'Projects like Whitehall will directly contribute to stabilising energy prices and reducing bills for households and businesses, and are also integral to the UK's goals of cutting emissions and boosting energy independence and security.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He added: 'Apatura is committed to opening up access to affordable clean energy for Scotland and the entire UK. Our BESS projects are an essential part of the wider nationwide effort to upgrade and future-proof the country's energy infrastructure to meet our expanding energy needs in a sustainable way.' In the decision letter granting consent, Scottish ministers said they 'regard the proposed development as essential infrastructure. Through the provision of energy storage, it adds flexibility and resilience necessary to maintain secure and reliable supplies of energy to all our homes and businesses as our energy transition takes place.' A battery energy storage system consists of several large batteries that store electrical power for use at a later time. They can be charged using excess electricity generated by wind or solar farms, for example, or by grid connection during periods of lower demand. However, many of these projects have attracted local criticism over their impact on the landscape and concerns regarding the risk of fire. Several large-scale BESS projects have been given the nod in recent years. Such facilities generally provide sufficient power for relatively short periods of a few hours before requiring recharging. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In March, a vast £130 million facility in West Lothian was granted consent, with the 200-megawatt site having the capacity to meet peak electricity demands for approximately 240,000 homes for two hours. Developed by onshore renewables firm OnPath Energy, the 'state-of-the-art' facility will be located on Pond Industrial Estate near Bathgate. The firm said Pond Flexible Energy Park would play a vital role in Scotland's journey towards its 2045 net zero goals.

Popular Waitrose ready meal urgently recalled over 'undeclared' ingredients
Popular Waitrose ready meal urgently recalled over 'undeclared' ingredients

Daily Record

time9 minutes ago

  • Daily Record

Popular Waitrose ready meal urgently recalled over 'undeclared' ingredients

The premium supermarket has urgently recalled the product due to a packaging error. UK shoppers have been issued with another food recall recently. This time it is for a popular ready meal that may be "unsafe to eat" for some consumers. ‌ Waitrose and Partners has issued a recall for its Waitrose Indian Takeaway for 2 due to a packaging error that has led some packs to contain spring rolls which are not mentioned on the label. ‌ Since the savoury snacks contain sesame and soya, both which have not been declared on the list of allergens, this means they pose a health risk to anyone with an allergy or intolerance to the said ingredients. ‌ An allergy alert posted to the Food Standards Agency (FSA) has advised that the supermarket's recall affects 1412g pack sizes with the best before date of July 25, 2025. Customers who have purchased the affected Indian takeaway meal have since been urged "do not eat", with the supermarket advising they should package it up and return it to their local Waitrose store to receive a full refund. ‌ Waitrose and Partners have been advised to contact the relevant allergy support organisations to let customers know about the recall. Meanwhile, the premium UK chain has since issued a recall notice that details all the information regarding why the ready meal has been recalled, alongside what to do if it has been bought. Shoppers looking for further information are being advised to contact the Waitrose Customer Care on 0800 188 884, option 4, for further information. ‌ Waitrose said in its recall notice: "We apologise it has been necessary to recall this product and for the inconvenience caused." Allergy alerts are generally posted by the FSA when foods have to 'withdrawn' or 'recalled' due to numerous factors that make it a risk for some consumers due to missing or incorrect allergy labelling, or other food risks. ‌ It comes after we reported that the food watchdog had to issue the same alert for multiple jars of jam sold by a Scottish firm after they were found to contain sulphites - an ingredient not mentioned on the label. Fife-based firm Sarah Gray's issued a recall for 13 strawberry and prosecco/champagne jams since they posed a possible health risk for anyone who is sensitive to sulphites and sulphur dioxide. The FSA doesn't just issue allergy alerts, as the food watchdog has also issued a recent 'food alert for action' after they found that one version of the viral Dubai chocolate bar contained peanuts, also not mentioned on the list of ingredients. ‌ Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. The firm has advised UK food businesses to immediately halt sales of the Noesis Schokolade Love of Dubai chocolate and to undertake product withdrawals, alongside issuing recalls for sales already made. We recently reported that the recall affects all numbers and best before dates of the 95g bars, with anyone suffering from a peanut allergy being urged not to eat the chocolate bar. It comes after the FSA previously had advised anyone with allergies to "exercise caution" when it came to consuming the TikTok-viral treat, after it was discovered that some of them may not have been intended for UK sale, therefore not meeting the high levels of food safety standards.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store