'Not allowed': NSW caught in rule breach drama over State of Origin selection
NRL fans are calling for change to the farcical rules around the 18th man in State of Origin, after it was revealed on Thursday night that Tom Trbojevic knocked back the chance to be NSW's emergency player in Game 1 so he could play for Manly. And it raises questions about whether the rules were breached by allowing him to do so.
Bulldogs fans are fuming that Matt Burton is once again 18th man for the Blues in Game 2, given it means he can't play club footy this weekend. Because the 18th man has become such a vital player on game-day and could be called into action if a player is ruled out through an act of foul play, they need to be training with their respective Origin teams all week. The other members of the extended squads are released back to their clubs for the weekend's games, but the 18th man has to stay in camp and remain fully-fit to play.
It means Burton will miss a fifth game for the Bulldogs while serving a role for NSW that means he's every chance to sit on the sideline all game. The situation was made even worse for Burton and Bulldogs fans on Thursday when Jarome Luai was parachuted into the starting team to replace the injured Mitchell Moses at five-eighth, despite not being named in the initial squad.
Burton was named 18th man earlier this week, and many feel he's been hard done by to not be replacing Moses. Nathan Hindmarsh said on Triple M radio on Thursday: "I've got to feel a little bit disappointed for Burton. He's been carried as 18th man before, just give him a run. I think his combination with Nathan Cleary would have worked alright."
RELATED:
Laurie Daley's concerning admission about NSW player under cloud
Selwyn Cobbo tipped for sad Broncos exit after 'secret meeting'
If Burton and the Bulldogs weren't already annoyed enough, a new revelation about Trbojevic will add to the frustration. Michael Chammas of revealed on Thursday night that Turbo was picked as 18th man for Origin 1, but withdrew so he could play for Manly that weekend.
It remains to be seen whether the Bulldogs knew that was an option for Burton as well. Trbojevic has been plagued by injury over the last few years and reportedly felt obliged to knock back a spot in the Blues' squad so he could be available for the Sea Eagles against Parramatta.
But it seemingly breaks NRL rules around representative games, with players not allowed to withdraw from rep footy unless they're injured or have a compelling reason. The rule reared its head last year when Kalyn Ponga was forced to backflip and make himself available for Kangaroos selection, even though he eventually wasn't picked anyway.
"The 18th man shouldn't be selected until the Sunday night before an Origin," Chammas wrote. "Allow the states to pick extended squads as they do now, but send players 18, 19 and 20 back to their clubs. And at the end of the round, having determined everyone's fitness, then decide who [the 18th man] should be."
NRL fans made the same argument on social media on Thursday, particularly after Burton was overlooked in favour of Luai to replace Moses. Many described it as a "joke" that Burton can't play for the Bulldogs this weekend, and the revelation about Trbojevic only adds to the controversy.
Many pointed out that the 18th man should simply be picked from a team on the bye to avoid any drama, as was the case with Campbell Graham in Game 1 (after Turbo withdrew).
So let me get this straight:👉 Burton, 18th man, and is unavailable for Bulldogs.👉Moses gets ruled outObvious thing to do? Request an exemption from the NRL and leave Burton 18th man 💀These rules, and Laurie Daley, are a joke 🤡 DISRESPECTED #stateoforigin pic.twitter.com/qczacebg5S
— Larry Taylor (@thelarrytaylor) June 12, 2025
Geez Burton must feel awesome.
— T Hampshire (@trenthampshire) June 12, 2025
Absolute joke release Burton now!!! 18th man WTAF!!!
— Craig Brian Peter Coyle (@cbpcoyle) June 12, 2025
Let them pick THREE after the round and they can use any of the three depending on who is injured. All sides - club and state - get a better a deal.
— cowsandguns (@sc_cowsandguns) June 12, 2025
Understand with 19th and 20th But 18th should be fresh. As we've seen with Moses going down. But controversly they have not used the 18th
— Rob Cotterill (@robbiecotterill) June 12, 2025
Burton is too valuable at 18th Man. It just makes sense to bring in Luai in this situation. I mean, he's only won 4 Premierships with the 1,7&13
— Mike Scolz (@skulzy87) June 12, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC Sports
41 minutes ago
- NBC Sports
Putt free and try hard: Why Sam Burns, the world's best on the greens, is rolling at Oakmont
OAKMONT, Pa. – Sam Burns has a simple answer to why he's, statistically, the world's best putter. 'I practice it a lot,' he says. Louisiana Tech head coach Matt Terry can confirm. The Bulldogs share a home club with Burns, Squire Creek Country Club in Choudrant, Louisiana, and when Burns isn't on the road, he can often be found on Squire's practice green perfecting his stroke – template work, chalk lines, speed drills, you name it. These days, Burns will sometimes plop his 1-year-old son, Bear, down on the grass, hand him a wedge and get in a few extra putts while the toddler sits there, gnawing on the grip. 'That stuff is why he's so good; it's just constant,' Terry said. 'I tell my guys all the time to just go watch him putt and mirror what he does. 'The dude's the best I've ever seen on the greens.' The USGA usually gets creative with a handful of its U.S. Open groupings. For example, this week's trio of Burns, Denny McCarthy and Nico Echavarria combined the best three putters in the field, according to the PGA Tour's strokes-gained metric. Burns is unequivocally the best of the bunch. He's the only U.S. Open competitor, per Data Golf, who is gaining more than a shot per round on the greens in the past six months – and he's 0.2 strokes per round better than the next best player, Cameron Smith. 'If you look at putting,' Burns explains, 'the ball is rolling on the ground. There's a lot of imperfections on grass. There's a lot of different lines the ball can go in, depending on the speed, so if you try to be too perfect with putting, it can drive you crazy, so I just try to really read it, put a good roll on it, focus on the speed and hope for the best.' Added Burns' close friend, Scottie Scheffler: 'He's got good fundamentals, good instinct, and he putts very reactionary. That's really all there is to it.' The ninth green at Oakmont Country Club is a long way from Squire Creek, both literally and figuratively. Measuring at over 22,000 square feet, the putting surface, which sits in the shadows of Oakmont's farmhouse-style clubhouse, is the largest on property and doubles as the club's practice green. It features a wide variety of challenges, sloping back to front with a large swale through the middle and a mound on the right portion. Friday's hole location was tucked front right, just right of the swale and behind a deep bunker. At 5 under through 17 holes and on his way to easily the best round so far this week, Burns had no business saving par after tugging his drive into the left penalty area. But he took his medicine, dropped and hit his third shot pin high, 23 feet left of the flag to avoid any chance of dumping one in the sand. You see, the thing about putting is no one makes everything. Even Burns whiffed on a 5-footer last Sunday in Canada that would've won him his sixth PGA Tour title. He three-putted to lose, too. And on Thursday at Oakmont, he unusually finished in the negative in strokes gained putting, ranking just outside the top 100 of 156 players. But Burns bounced back with a vengeance on Friday, pouring in over 102 feet of putts, including that clutch par save on the par-4 ninth to solidify a second-round 65 and two-day total of 3-under 137, which left he and Viktor Hovland (1 under) as the only two players in their wave at even par or better. 'That putt was, I don't know, 6 feet of break,' Burns guessed of the putt, which gained him about a stroke on the field alone. 'Yeah, it was a nice one to make for sure.' Despite his elite skill with the flatstick – his trusty Odyssey Ai-One 7S – Burns finds himself in unfamiliar territory. This is his 21st career major start. Until his T-9 at last year's U.S. Open at Pinehurst, he'd never cracked the top 10 in a major. The physical explanation, at least in recent years, is Burns' iron play hasn't been good enough. He entered this week ranked No. 149 in strokes gained approach, so the fact that he missed just four greens Friday and ranks inside the top 10 in that category through two days probably explains his breakout performance. But Burns added that he learned something 12 months ago at Pinehurst. 'I just feel like I've tried to play too perfect and tried to force it a little bit at times … around major championship golf courses,' Burns explained, 'and I think especially around here, honestly it kind of forces you to take your medicine because a lot of times that's the only option you have. … You really just have to free it up. It's too hard to try to guide it around here. You're going to hit some in the rough, you're going to hit some in some bad spots, you might as well do it with authority.' Burns' patience was tested late Thursday afternoon when he quickly went from 3 under to 2 over with a bogey-double-bogey-bogey finish over his last four holes, Nos 15-18. 'It was unfortunate,' Burns said, 'but there was too much good to focus on the little bit of bad.' A day later, Burns was heading toward his television interview when he walked past Jon Rahm, who was speaking to reporters following a disappointing 75 that dropped him to 4 over. 'I'm too annoyed and too mad right now to think about any perspective,' Rahm said. 'Very frustrated. Very few rounds of golf I played in my life where I think I hit good putts and they didn't sniff the hole.' Rahm lost about three strokes with the putter on Friday, a performance that ranked him ahead of fewer than 10 players in this second round. Shortly after wrapping his thoughts, Rahm was off to the practice area to figure something out. As Burns knows, that's the simplest way to holing more putts.
USA Today
5 hours ago
- USA Today
5-star LB Tyler Atkinson taking Georgia official visit
5-star LB Tyler Atkinson taking Georgia official visit The Georgia Bulldogs are preparing for another significant official visit weekend and while the number of visitors might be lower, Athens is set to host several elite recruits. Among them is five-star linebacker Tyler Atkinson. Atkinson is a familiar face in Athens, having visited Georgia multiple times for camps and prior visits. The Bulldogs have been actively recruiting him for years, using these in-person opportunities to sway Atkinson to come play between the hedges. Georgia has been the well-known leader for Atkinson and many people look at him as a potential future Butkus Award winner for the Bulldogs if he joins the program. Georgia has made Atkinson a top priority throughout his time during high school and needs to land a top an in-state prospect like him. This official visit will go a long way in determining if the Bulldogs can land Atkinson and keep him home from the other contenders. The five-star class of 2026 prospect went on official visits to Oregon and Clemson already and both teams are making a strong push for Atkinson. The Bulldogs also are after five-star wide receiver Cederian Morgan. They already have a commitment from five-star quarterback Jared Curtis, who is the only five-star in Georgia's fifth-ranked recruiting class. Ranked as the nation's No. 8 overall recruit by the On3 Industry Rankings, Atkinson is one of the best players in the nation. The 6-foot-2, 205-pound linebacker had a dominant junior year. He led Grayson to a 14-1 record and a Georgia AAAAAA state championship, racking up 166 tackles, 32 tackles for loss, 13 sacks, an interception and a forced fumble. 247Sports projects that Atkinson will commit to Georgia football.
USA Today
9 hours ago
- USA Today
Another Georgia football commit shuts down his recruitment
Another Georgia football commit shuts down his recruitment The Georgia Bulldogs are getting closer to knowing who will sign with them in the class of 2026. Four-star safety Jordan Smith has announced he is shutting down his recruitment, according to Hayes Fawcett. Although Smith had originally planned to take official visits with Florida State and Tennessee, this news suggests he will more than likely sign with the Bulldogs during or after the early signing period. Smith has already committed to Georgia. Smith is a four-star safety from the class of 2026. The 6-foot-1, 185-pound defensive back plays football for Houston County High School in Warner Robins, Georgia. He is the No. 56 prospect and No. 6 safety in the nation, according to 247Sports. Smith committed to the Georgia Bulldogs on May 11 and the seventh-best recruit in the Peach State. The Georgia Bulldogs' 2026 class is chock-full of elite secondary recruits. Four-star safety Zech Fort was the first to commit on Jan. 30. Then, three-star safety Kealan Jones committed on Apr. 12, the same day as G-Day. After Smith committed on May 11, four-star cornerback Justice Fitzpatrick, who is the brother of All-Pro safety Minkah Fitzpatrick, committed on June 3. Smith is the third player in Georgia's signing class to conclude his recruitment, joining Fitzpatrick and three-star wide receiver Brady Marchese, who have also shut down their recruitment. Of course, there's nothing stopping these players from changing their minds later down the road. It is still a long way away from December's early signing period. After a slow start in the recruiting cycle, during which Georgia only had five commits by April, the Bulldogs have ramped up their recruiting efforts. According to 247Sports, Georgia now boasts the fifth-ranked recruiting class in the nation. UGA has the SEC's best class of 2026.
