Cttee hears Triple Lock dilutes Ireland's sovereignty
The Joint Committee on Defence and National Security is debating the legislation that would remove the need for UN approval when deploying more than 12 members of the Defence Forces overseas.
The Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025 would remove the Triple Lock when they are serving as part of an international force.
Former TD Cathal Berry, a former army ranger, said that the Triple Lock "absolutely" dilutes Ireland's sovereignty.
He said that, currently, Ireland is giving some of its "democratic power" to "kings and queens and authoritarian rulers and wannabe dictators all over the world".
The UN Charter encourages regional oversight of peacekeeping which, he said, the Triple Lock undermines.
Major General Maureen O'Brien (Retired) said that when she was selecting from the 119 nations which contribute to UN forces, whether a country was neutral or had a Triple Lock was "never a consideration".
It is seen only as a "national issue".
Major General O'Brien deployed overseas nine times, eight times with the UN.
She led a multinational force of 1,100 that oversaw a ceasefire between Israel and Syria and said that impartiality was essential in dealing with both sides.
From UN headquarters she oversaw all peacekeeping deployments.
She told the committee that the Triple Lock prevents Ireland from deciding where to deploy its peace troops.
"We cannot make our own decisions. We are dependent on five countries telling us whether we can deploy. I think that reduces our sovereignty. And perhaps our neutrality as well," she said.
"12 troops isn't enough to do anything," she said. "You need at least 50 people."
General Kieran Brennan (Retired) said he supports the proposed changes to the Triple Lock, as countries such as Gaza, Ukraine and Congo are crying out for peacekeepers.
"No, I've no reservations," he replied, when asked if he had concerns over there being sufficient safeguards in the legislation.
Colonel Colm Doyle (Retired) said that Ireland has the longest unbroken record "of any nation" for sending troops on UN peacekeeping missions, something he described as "noble".
He said that claims that changes to the Triple Lock would undermine neutrality were "greatly misjudged".
The UNSC is flawed, he said, as Ireland's participation on peacekeeping "can effectively be held hostage" by any permanent member of the security council.
Labour TD Duncan Smith cautioned against Ireland turning its back on the UN which is greatly weakened.
Major General O'Brien told the committee that when a country provides personnel to the UN, it must sign a Statement of Unit Requirements.
This is a contractual agreement covering finances and all conditions of the troops' deployment.
For Irish personnel, the statement always includes a provision that military command and control remains with the Irish unit at all times.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Guyana's high-stakes oil and climate debate - and Ireland's role in it
When the UN's International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled last month that nations failing to curb fossil fuels could be liable for compensation and restitution , Guyana took notice. The fossil fuels and climate debate has been a dominant one in the small South American country since US energy giant ExxonMobil struck oil off its coast a decade ago. Back then, Guyana was considered a climate champion due to its conservation of lush Amazon forests and strong environmental protection laws, but ExxonMobil's discovery set the country on a very different path. While the Guyanese government argues that oil extraction and environmental protection can coexist and it has a right as a developing nation to utilise its resources, critics believe that, amid a worsening global climate crisis, Guyana is backing the wrong horse. Add to that what is widely recognised as a poorly negotiated contract with ExxonMobil and its partners, Guyana's vulnerability to rising sea levels, and rapid inflation, and you have a complex landscape that threatens the country's stability and future prosperity. READ MORE Still, the oil has been flowing since 2019 at a rate unprecedented in the industry. 'When the fifth project comes online next year, we'll reach a million barrels a day in just over 10 years,' says Alistair Routledge, president of ExxonMobil Guyana. 'For most other basins, it takes 50 years.' This speed of extraction concerns environmentalists, who have lobbied the government to hold ExxonMobil to unlimited liability in the event of an oil spill (ExxonMobil has posted a $2 billion guarantee while it appeals a court ruling on the issue) – a political football still being kicked around in advance of the country's general elections in September. All this makes the recent ICJ opinion stating that countries are legally liable for the actions of the private sector all the more relevant. [ The Irish Times view on the ICJ climate change decision: a far-reaching legal statement Opens in new window ] While Routledge says ExxonMobil is 'committed to delivering what society is looking for and ensuring we're doing that in a way that protects the environment', many take assurances such as these as empty promises. Melinda Janki, a Guyanese international lawyer who was instrumental in persuading her government to include the right to a healthy environment as a fundamental constitutional right in the early 2000s, says that renewables out-competing fossil fuels shows the oil industry has no future. That is, Janki says, despite IMF figures showing governments subsidised fossil fuels to the tune of $7 trillion in 2022 alone. 'Remove those subsidies and the oil industry will collapse. The Guyanese government is living in the past, and Guyana will be left with a mess to clean up.' Mike McCormack, a representative of the Guyana Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, echoes that view, dismissing the notion that Guyana has a right to use its oil to catch up with the rest of the world. 'The problem is the way you are trying to catch up is the same reason you're behind now,' he says. 'Exploitation from colonial countries got us in this mess.' McCormack believes the oil should stay in the ground, but if it is to be extracted, he says revenues should be used more progressively, for example by helping Caribbean countries mitigate risk of climate-related disasters. 'Instead, we're doing nothing,' he says. 'We don't even stop the flaring properly. We have no sense of restraint. Exxon wants it quicker and quicker because they can see the writing on the wall.' For Prof Ivelaw Griffith, author of new book Oil and Climate Change in Guyana's Wet Neighborhood, the Guyana predicament is 'a living paradox' – a nation pursuing the promise of oil while living the potential peril of climate change. Speaking to The Irish Times, Griffith expresses concern about how the country's gamble on oil might play out for the average Guyanese person and the ethnic division it could cause. He also believes planning for a new capital must begin due to Georgetown's exposure to coastal flooding. Kaieteur Falls, one of the most powerful single-drop waterfalls in the world, which is located in Kaieteur National Park, central Essequibo Territory, Guyana However, he says you cannot talk about the oil and climate debate in Guyana without addressing the Essequibo question – the region, which makes up 74 per cent of Guyana, that neighbouring Venezuela lays claim to. 'If you lose that to Venezuela, it undermines all the work you did for the oil to develop the country,' he says. 'Most of Essequibo is Amazonian forest, which produces the carbon sink that captures all that bad stuff produced by fossil fuels. So, the complexity goes beyond oil, it extends to the climate change dynamics.' [ 'Our country is deeply divided, but Adriana's death has created closeness': How anger over girl's drowning has united rivals in Guyana Opens in new window ] The Essequibo controversy, which Griffith describes as the albatross around Guyana's neck, is expected to be addressed by the ICJ sometime before 2027, when it will rule on the legitimacy of the existing borders. Guyana, with a population of about 835,000, might not be on Ireland's radar, but there's undoubtedly interest for Ireland in all of this. Not only because of the global impact of fossil fuel production, but also because, according to a report from Trócaire and ActionAid Ireland , €31 billion in fossil fuel investments flows through the country. And the company receiving the most investment from asset managers based in Ireland? ExxonMobil. There's a lot at stake for Guyana – and the world. And while the ICJ opinion is not legally binding, it will carry weight as more and more climate-related decisions are made in the courts rather than in national parliaments. Guyanase will hope their country doesn't become a compensation use case for the future. simon cumbers This reporting was supported by the Simon Cumbers Media Fund Voices of Guyana, an accompanying exhibition of photographs by Joseph O'Connor, runs at Blanchardstown Library until August 15th.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
New ‘big help to working families' €1,900 childcare boost in ‘critical' Budget 2026 plan after €200 max fee cap shake-up
CHILDREN'S Minister Norma Foley is exploring plans to extend Ireland's free pre-school programme as part of Budget 2026. A daily extra hour of pre-school could save parents on the Early Childhood Care and Education programme up to €1,900 each year. 1 An extension of the ECCE scheme could benefit hard-pressed Irish families Credit: Getty Images The ECCE is a free, universal two-year preschool programme available to all children between two years and eight months of age and five years six months of age. A total of 108, 616 children were registered to it in the 2022/23 year. It currently runs five days a week for 38 weeks of the year and provides three hours of free pre-school a day, for two years. Foley is currently drawing up plans to provide children with an extra and free daily hour of childcare in the second year of pre-school. The minister's plan revolves around the "targeted help" criteria that the Government is working on as part of Budget 2026. The State has already confirmed it is "working on" a targeted second-tier of Child Benefit worth an average €285 each month, which would allow lower-income families to top up the existing €140-a-month pay. Hourly creche and childcare prices vary by location and the number of children managed - but parents could save between €30 and €25 each week on childcare with an extra hour of ECCE. Hard-pressed parents in Dublin could benefit by at least €50 a week. Emer Currie, Fine Gael's Spokesperson on Childcare, urged Foley to consider extending the scheme as part of Budget 2026 and said it would be "a big help to working families" across Ireland. I worked in nursery & there's 5 red flags when choosing one for your child Deputy Currie said: "The current ECCE Programme provides three hours of free pre-school per day, five days a week over the school year. "The ECCE Programme has been a great success and enjoys participation rates of 96 per cent each year. "Over 70 per cent of families on low income report that they would not be able to send their child to pre-school without this Programme. 'Providing a fourth hour of ECCE would help ease the burden on working parents and provide them with more flexibility." GOVT COMMITMENT Currie said that, although the ECCE scheme itself is free, she has been made aware of many parents who are being forced to fork out their cash for additional hours of care for their child. She continued: "The Programme for Government commits to examining an extra hour of ECCE each day in the second year of pre-school. "I have raised the matter with Minister Foley who has confirmed the estimated cost of this measure would be in the region of €38million. "We know early childhood education is critical and an extra hour would also be beneficial for a young child's social and learning development and I think this is something Government should strongly consider as part of the forthcoming Budgetary process." The demand for an increase in the ECCE scheme comes after Foley confirmed childcare fees for around 190,000 parents across Ireland will be capped at just under €200 each week. MAXIMUM FEE CAP The Fianna Fail TD said the move marks "important steps" towards the commitment to reduce the cost of childcare to €200 per month per child over the course of this Government's five-year term. A new maximum fee cap will now be introduced for all new services availing of State funding through the Core Funding scheme from this September. This will lower the maximum fees that can be charged depending on the number of hours provided. The Department of Children estimates that this will impact families facing the highest fees across the country in around 10 per cent of early learning and childcare providers. Under these new maximum fee caps, the highest possible fees will be no more than €295 per week for a full day place of between 40-50 hours per week. This will bring these fees closer to the average weekly fee of €197 for full day care. These fees for parents are then reduced by State subsidies under the National Childcare Scheme and the free, universal two-year Early Childhood Care and Education preschool programme. A parent being charged the maximum permissible fee of €295 per week for a full day place would be entitled to receive the universal National Childcare Scheme subsidy of €96.30. This means a parents co-payment would be no more than €198.70 each week. However, it has been confirmed that "higher subsidies are available for many parents", depending on their level of income and the age and number of children in their family.
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Pictures: Farmers in good spirits at Tullamore Show
More than 60,000 people attended the Tullamore Show and FBD National Livestock Show — the largest one-day agricultural event in the country — which took place on the 250-acre Butterfield Estate in Blue Ball, Co Offaly, on Sunday. Warm dry weather conditions prevailed for the day, and farmers in attendance were in good form, bolstered by strong farm gate prices, favourable weather conditions and good grass growth. However, IFA president Francie Gorman said while people were upbeat, there were still concerns among farmers. 'CAP remains absolutely pivotal to the future of Irish livestock farming, which is why the proposed CAP reforms announced by the EU Commission last month cannot be allowed to become reality', he said. The quality of the stock on display here today is a testament to the investment that farmers have made and the pride they take in what they produce. The display at Tullamore Show today simply would not exist without dedicated funding for farmers. "Their efforts stretch well beyond the farm gate through the processing sector and onto our export profile. Any reduction in the CAP budget would have reverberations through the rural economy,' he said. Matthew and Pat King from Toomevara, Tipperary; at the Tullamore Show. Picture: Jeff Harvey The IFA president said the Government would have to lead a sustained and determined diplomatic push in Brussels to re-centre the debate around food production and the twin-pillar approach. The show was officially opened by Tánaiste Simon Harris, who acknowledged the significant contribution agriculture makes to life in Ireland: 'In good times and in bad times, agriculture and farming keep this country going, keep the economy going and provide jobs and employment in every community across Ireland'. Beatrice Appelbe with the overall champion Hereford owned by Derik Appelbe from Cork at Tullamore Show. Picture: Alf Harvey 'We cannot lose sight of the fact that agriculture is not a nice to have, it's not a nice to do. It's not nice to support agriculture; it's not a useful thing to do, but it's absolutely essential. If the last number of months in terms of turbulence, trade and tariffs have taught us anything, it's the fact that we now more than ever should be supporting indigenous industry. The Fine Gael leader said the Government 'must back farming, back it to the hilt'. The Tánaiste said there were three big pieces of work to be done at European level. "There's CAP, there's Mercosur and, of course, there's a nitrates derogation," he said. "In the weeks ahead, we will be continuing to build alliances at a European level to make sure that any future EU budget has a well-funded and ring-fenced Common Agricultural Policy'. Elise McWey and Terry O'Halloran from Ballina in Tipperary with their shopping at the Tullamore Show. Picture: Jeff Harvey The FBD National Livestock Show is one of the main attractions of the show, with the prizes competed for by the very best livestock producers in Ireland vying for the many national titles and the coveted gold medals on offer. The champion Aubrac owned and shown by Leo Dooley and Bridget Barron from Bunclody, Co Wexford, with MEP Barry Cowen; Aisling Molloy, Tullamore Show; Freda Kinnarney, ISA president; Nina Carberry MEP and Amanda Dunne from FBD at the Tullamore Show. Picture: Alf Harvey The sheep section hosted the largest number of classes, with every sheep breed on show, according to organisers, with a new class this year for Valais Blacknose. The reserve champion Simmental owned by Tony, James and Ava O'Leary from Ballincollig, Co Cork, with MEP Barry Cowen; show chairman John Keena; Stephen Kelly, Tullamore Show; Freda Kinnarney, ISA president; and Alan Geraghty from FBD. Picture: Alf Harvey The commercial cattle section of this year's show saw increased entries once again, with Mayo man Kevin Devine's outstanding heifer Ruby tapped out as overall senior champion. The champion Belgian Blue owned and shown by Tommy and Pauline Fitzgerald from Clonaslee, Co Laois, with MEP Barry Cowen; Aisling Molloy and Stephen Kelly, Tullamore Show; Freda Kinnarney, ISA president; Kathleen Leonard from FBD; and Nina Carberry MEP. Picture: Alf Harvey The Sustainable Livestock Village returned to the show this year, with a strong emphasis placed on the role of young farmers in delivering sustainable change. Macra joined the village for the first time to highlight generation renewal and youth-led innovation. Nicole Watts from Tuam, Co Galway, with her Belgian Blue Rosie. Picture: Alf Harvey The 'village' was officially launched by MEP Barry Cowen, and was powered by a hydrogen unit, the first ever at a show in Ireland, according to organisers.
