Divided Supreme Court sides with Trump to block teacher grants
The 5-4 emergency ruling, for now, lifts a lower order that allowed the Education Department to resume the grants in eight Democratic-led states that are suing.
Five of the court's six conservatives sided with the administration to grant the request. Chief Justice John Roberts and the court's three liberal justices dissented.
The decision is not a final ruling in the case, and the dispute could ultimately return to the Supreme Court.
In February, the administration began canceling disbursements under two federal education grants aimed at developing educators and combatting teacher shortages: the Teacher Quality Partnership Program and the Supporting Effective Educator Development Program.
Officials have cast the freezes as part of the administration's broader crackdown on DEI, and it also comes as Trump and Education Secretary Linda McMahon look to effectively gut the department.
U.S. District Judge Myong Joun, an appointee of former President Obama who serves in Boston, issued a March 10 temporary restraining order mandating the administration immediately resume the grant programs in the eight states.
The Trump administration's Supreme Court emergency appeal comes after a three-judge panel on the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals declined to lift Joun's ruling. The administration has filed a series of such applications urging the justices to rein in lower courts that have blocked Trump's policies.
'Beyond the systemic, irreparable constitutional harm to the Executive Branch from judicial arrogation of executive functions as to how and when agencies will disburse or cancel grants, even the court of appeals acknowledged that the government 'may incur some irreparable harm if it cannot recoup this money,'' the Justice Department wrote in court filings.
The states, whose lawsuit alleges applicable regulations don't permit the administration to stop the grant programs, noted the lower ruling is temporary and normally not appealable.
'The district court acted appropriately in granting a narrow and time-limited restraining order while it proceeds to a prompt ruling on the motion for a preliminary injunction. There is no sound basis for this Court to stay or vacate that order,' the states wrote.
Led by California, the coalition also comprises Massachusetts, New Jersey, Colorado, Illinois, Maryland, New York and Wisconsin.
Their lawsuit now returns to the trial court, where Joun is mulling whether to grant a longer injunction after holding a Friday hearing.
And it is just one of two lawsuits challenging the frozen teacher grants. A similar case filed by private education groups remains at a mid-level appeals court.
The new ruling marks the Supreme Court's second emergency decision implicating the second Trump administration's sweeping efforts to cut aspects of federal spending.
In March, the court in a 5-4 decision rejected the administration's request to freeze $2 billion in foreign aid payments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
4 minutes ago
- Forbes
Trump-Zelenskyy Meeting: What To Know As Macron, Meloni, Starmer And More Will Attend
Leaders from major European allies, NATO and the European Union are traveling to Washington, D.C., to join Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy at his Monday meeting with President Donald Trump—setting up what appear to be crucial talks as Trump pushes for a ceasefire in the war in Ukraine that has been raging since the Russian invasion in 2022. Leaders from the EU and NATO will join the Ukrainian president at the White House. Getty Images Zelenskyy will travel to meet with Trump at the White House on Monday. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte will reportedly take part in the talks, as well as leaders of individual allied nations including French President Emmanuel Macron, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Finnish President Alexander Stubb. Trump administration officials have provided few details about what concessions the Russians may have offered at the negotiations in Alaska on Friday, but speaking to CNN on Sunday morning, U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff described the Trump-Putin meeting as 'game-changing.' Witkoff said the Trump administration would likely discuss Ukraine exchanging territory with Russia, what he called a 'fundamental issue' for the Russians, but the administration would not make any decisions for Ukraine when it came to territory. 'We intend to discuss it on Monday,' Witkoff told CNN's Jake Tapper. The special envoy did not offer concrete details on what concessions the Russians may have offered in terms of territory, but added 'that discussion is going to specifically be detailed on Monday, when President Zelenskyy arrives with his delegation and some of the other European leaders,' Witkoff said. 'And, hopefully, we can cut through and make some decisions right then and there on that.' Russia illegally annexed the Ukrainian territory Crimea in 2014, and three years after its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Russia controls the majority of the Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions. The Trump administration said the Russians may support Ukraine signing a future security deal with the U.S. and European allies—but even with the security guarantees, convincing the Ukrainians to cede territory could prove difficult for the Trump administration. Zelenskyy has consistently rejected peace offers that include territorial exchanges in the past, and reiterated this sentiment in a statement posted on social media Sunday, shortly after meeting with European leaders in Brussels. 'There is clear support for Ukraine's independence and sovereignty,' the Ukrainian president said. 'Everyone agrees that borders must not be changed by force.' What Is Article 5? The Trump administration says that Russian negotiators indicated they would agree to allow Ukraine to sign a future security agreement with the U.S. and European allies—one that would offer similar protections like those outlined in Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, the document that forms the basis of NATO. Article 5 guarantees that if one NATO member is attacked, it is considered an attack on all member states, and all member states are compelled to take necessary action to 'restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area.' Witkoff told Tapper the administration got the Russians to agree to allow the U.S. and European nations to 'effectively offer Article 5-like language to cover a security guarantee.' However, he was adamant that this would not amount to Ukraine actually joining NATO—something he said the Russians still viewed as a 'red flag.' The special envoy did not elaborate on the details of the guarantee. European leaders are trying to avoid a repeat of the tense press public meeting Zelenskyy held with Trump and Vice President JD Vance in February, Reuters and other outlets reported Sunday. However, Secretary of State Marco Rubio rejected this notion while speaking to CBS News' Margaret Brennan on Sunday morning. 'We've been working with these people for weeks,' Rubio said. 'They're coming here tomorrow because they chose to come here tomorrow. We invited them to come.' Rubio said the Trump administration was focused on hammering out a peace deal. 'Look, our goal here is not to stage some production for the world to say, oh how dramatic he walked out,' he said. 'Our goal here is to have a peace agreement to end this war.'
New York Times
4 minutes ago
- New York Times
Monday Briefing: A Trump-Zelensky Meeting
Ukrainian and E.U. leaders visit the White House President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine is set to meet today with President Trump. Their sit-down comes shortly after Trump met with President Vladimir Putin of Russia and broke with allies to back Putin's proposed peace plan, which would require Ukraine to cede a large portion of territory. Here are the latest updates and what you need to know. European leaders — including Germany's chancellor, Friedrich Merz; President Emmanuel Macron of France; and Prime Minister Keir Starmer of Britain — said they would accompany Zelensky in a show of solidarity. Trump's friendly meeting with Putin in Alaska on Friday was a setback for Ukraine and its European allies. But Kyiv was left with one small glimmer of hope: a U.S. proposal to create security guarantees for Ukraine, designed to deter future Russian aggression. Context: Russia's proposal to end the war centers on persuading Ukraine to give up the Donbas, the industrial Russian-speaking region in the east. On the ground: Ukrainians who were forced to leave their homes because of Russia's aerial bombardments called the Trump-Putin summit an insult. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
CNN
4 minutes ago
- CNN
US suspends visitor visas for Gazans
Donald Trump The Middle East Federal agenciesFacebookTweetLink Follow Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Sunday that the State Department suspended visitor visas for Gazans because it received 'evidence' that some organizations facilitating the visas to the US 'have strong links to terrorist groups like Hamas,' without providing further details. The State Department announced in a post on X on Saturday that it would halt all visitor visas for individuals from Gaza as it reviews the process that allows them to temporarily enter the US for medical and humanitarian reasons. Rubio told CBS' 'Face the Nation' on Sunday that 'evidence' had been presented to the Trump administration by 'numerous congressional offices' and that the department had received 'outreach from multiple congressional offices asking questions about it.' He did not give details on the evidence or the offices that presented it. Far-right Trump ally Laura Loomer has taken credit for the pause in the visas following her claims that the families arriving from Gaza 'threaten our national security.' Loomer specifically criticized HEAL Palestine, an American nonprofit dedicated to providing critical aid to Palestinian families, including bringing kids suffering from severe injuries, psychological trauma and malnourishment to receive care in the US. The group says it has evacuated 63 injured children and 148 total people. The group, which returns Palestinians back to the Middle East after they are treated in US hospitals, criticized the Trump administration's move to halt visitor visas, saying in a statement on Sunday, 'this is a medical treatment program, not a refugee resettlement program.' As of May, the US has issued almost 4,000 visas to people holding Palestinian Authority passports permitting them to seek medical treatment in America. That number also includes Palestinians living outside of Gaza, such as in the West Bank. Rubio said Sunday that while a 'small number' of visas had been issued to children, 'they come with adults accompanying them, obviously, and we are going to pause this program and reevaluate how those visas are being vetted.' 'We're not going to be in partnership with groups that have links or sympathies towards Hamas,' he continued, without naming any specific groups or providing more information to corroborate the administration's concerns. CNN reached out to the State Department for more information about the evidence cited by Rubio. President Donald Trump acknowledged last month there is 'real starvation' in Gaza, breaking with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whom Trump has grown increasingly frustrated with. 'I see it, and you can't fake that. So, we're going to be even more involved,' Trump told reporters of the humanitarian crisis.
