Is Virginia Giuffre unravelling or is she really on her deathbed?
After more than a decade in the spotlight, she was supposedly leading a quiet life with her family in a small beach town in north Perth, Australia. But this week, Virginia Giuffre's story took a shocking twist, when she claimed she had just days to live after being hit by a school bus.
On March 30, the 41-year-old, who accused Prince Andrew of sexual assault and Jeffrey Epstein of sex trafficking, wrote on Instagram that she had been involved in a car accident which had allegedly left her with renal failure.
'This year has been the worst start to a new year,' Giuffre wrote under a photo of herself seemingly covered in bruises. 'I won't bore anyone with the details but I think it important to note that when a school bus driver comes at you driving 110km [per hour]... that no matter what your car is made of it might as well be a tin can.'
'I've gone into kidney renal failure, they've given me four days to live, transferring me to a specialist hospital in urology,' she wrote. 'I'm ready to go, just not until I see my babies one last time, but you know what they say about wishes.... Thank you all for being the wonderful people of the world and for being a great part of my life.'
Yet her critics have doubted the veracity of her claims, after Western Australia Police said they had only one recent record of a 'minor' bus and car collision with 'no reported injuries' in the state, which occurred in Neergabby, 20km north of Perth, on the afternoon of March 24.
'The collision was reported by the bus driver the following day. The car sustained approximately $2,000 [£968] worth of damage,' police said in a statement.
Acting police commissioner Kylie Whitely confirmed during a press conference on April 1 that the incident involved a 71-year-old woman at the wheel of the car and a 41-year-old woman in the passenger seat.
Brad Edwards, a US lawyer who represented Giuffre in her previous legal cases, said it was a 'very bad situation… and we are hoping for better news in the coming days'.
But Prince Andrew's ex-girlfriend, Lady Victoria Hervey, was one of many who took to Instagram to pour scorn on Giuffre's claims. The aristocrat and model posted a series of messages to Instagram, including one stating that Giuffre was 'the Queen of the fake photo' – seeming to allude to the now-infamous photograph of a teenage Giuffre with Andrew and Ghislaine Maxwell.
In another Instagram story, she added: 'How is this diagnosis from a car crash?' A further post continued: 'Generally when you're dying you're not thinking about posting a selfie, you're actually dying'.
Lady Victoria, who dated Prince Andrew in 1999, also wrote the word 'karma' over the selfie supposedly taken by Giuffre in hospital, adding the soundtrack of the 1986 hit The Final Countdown.
Hervey also wrote: 'I don't believe it though, the FBI are on her right now and arrest warrants are coming. She's conveniently dying to evade jail. I think it's time that Robert Giuffre, who has custody of their teenage children, to speak [sic]. I know he knows the truth of the fake photo and all her con jobs.' But she gave no evidence for this claim.
Giuffre's last known address was a $1.9 million (£1m) home in the small Perth community of Ocean Reef with her husband of 22 years, Robert Giuffre.
The California-born Virginia Roberts met Giuffre, a martial arts teacher, in Thailand when she was 19, and married him 10 days later, moving to his home in Australia to start a family. When she delivered the news of her marriage and move to Epstein he reportedly responded, 'have a nice life' and hung up.
The Giuffres have now reportedly split up, and Virginia is living further up the coast with her French bulldog, Juno, who she describes as 'the love of my life'. Robert and Virginia have three children – two sons in their mid to late teens, and a daughter aged 14.
A week before she shared news of her car crash, Giuffre wrote on Instagram: 'My beautiful babies have no clue how much I love them and they're being poisoned with lies. I miss them so very much. I have been through hell and back in my 41 years but this is incredibly hurting me worse than anything else. Hurt me, abuse me but don't take my babies. My heart is shattered and every day that passes my sadness only deepen.'
Is she unravelling or is she really on her deathbed? If it's the latter, it will be the latest tragic development in a life marred by trauma. She spent her childhood in and out of foster care, being trafficked and sexually assaulted on the streets of Florida.
She first came forward about her experience with Epstein in 2011, alleging that she had been recruited by Maxwell in 2000 when she was just 16, while working at Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago resort, and spent the next few years being abused by Epstein and others while caught up in his sex-trafficking circle.
In 2009, she settled a $500,000 (£387,000) sexual-abuse lawsuit against Epstein, which at the time was confidential, but details of which emerged in 2022. She also sued Maxwell – who is currently serving a 20-year sentence after being convicted of child sex trafficking – for defamation in 2015 and settled in 2017.
In 2021, Giuffre filed a civil claim against Prince Andrew, who she says sexually assaulted her while she was being trafficked by Epstein and his associates. Prince Andrew has denied the allegations and claims never to have met Giuffre, but he too settled his case with her in 2022. The financial terms have not been made public, but legal experts have estimated it was somewhere around £12 million.
In the wake of the scandal, in 2022, the Royal family removed Prince Andrew's military titles and royal patronages, and he stepped down from public life.
Epstein died in a New York jail cell in August 2019, and although the autopsy concluded it was a suicide by hanging, his death fuelled widespread controversy and conspiracy theories.
Maxwell, now 63, failed to apologise to her victims in a recent interview, saying they should take their 'disappointment and upset' out on the US authorities who 'allowed' Epstein to be murdered. She also claimed she had no memory of her 'dear friend' Prince Andrew ever meeting Giuffre.
According to sources, one year after settling her lawsuit with Prince Andrew, Giuffre reportedly signed a multi-million dollar deal with an unknown publisher to write her memoir. She also settled her defamation lawsuit against former Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz, saying she might have 'made a mistake' when she accused him of sexually assaulting her as a teenager. 'I have long believed that I was trafficked by Jeffrey Epstein to Alan Dershowitz,' Giuffre said in a statement. 'However, I was very young at the time, it was a very stressful and traumatic environment.'
This week, Giuffre's father, Sky Roberts, said: 'She's not doing good. She's depressed because she misses her kids. She's got four days [to live] unless she gets another opinion from another doctor.' He is reportedly estranged from his daughter and says he has not seen her since the car crash, but her brother has.
Her father also wrote under her Instagram post: 'Virginia my daughter, I love you and praying you get the correct treatment to live a long and healthy life. If there is anything in the world, I can do to help you, please let me know. My spirit is with you now and holding your hand.'
In a statement, Giuffre's spokesman, Dini von Mueffling, said: 'Virginia has been in a serious accident and is receiving medical care in the hospital. She greatly appreciates the support and well wishes people are sending.'
The coming days will prove whether Giuffre was correct in her terminal diagnosis. But for Prince Andrew, Giuffre being in the headlines again is yet more embarrassment after he 'let the side down' and shows that – despite many millions of pounds – it's a case that simply won't go away.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
What is nihilism? A teen charged in a mass shooting plot and a car bomber subscribed to the same ideology, authorities say
Federal agencies National security TerrorismFacebookTweetLink Follow An Oregon teen arrested last month in connection with an alleged mass shooting plot targeting a mall in southwestern Washington subscribed to a 'nihilistic violent extremist ideology,' according to officials. Similarly, FBI officials said Guy Edward Bartkus, the man accused of bombing a Palm Springs, California, fertility clinic last month, 'had nihilistic ideations.' It's this 'preoccupation with themes of violence, hopelessness, despair, pessimism, hatred, isolation, loneliness, or an 'end-of-the-world' philosophy' – as the FBI defines nihilistic ideation – that allegedly drives these individuals to violence. Here's how experts and authorities describe nihilism. Nihilism, which is usually defined as a philosophical concept rather than a set of actions, is the belief that 'all values are baseless and that nothing can be known or communicated,' according to Alan Pratt, professor emeritus at Embry-Riddle University. Nihilism is 'associated with extreme pessimism and a radical skepticism that condemns existence,' Pratt wrote in a philosophical definition. 'A true nihilist would believe in nothing, have no loyalties, and no purpose other than, perhaps, an impulse to destroy.' Nihilism is also often connected to German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, who argued that 'its corrosive effects would eventually destroy all moral, religious, and metaphysical convictions,' according to Pratt. Retired senior FBI profiler Mary Ellen O'Toole, who has researched past violent actors to provide the FBI with its initial definition of nihilistic ideation, describes nihilism as 'something on a continuum.' 'A person's outlook on life is never black or white,' O'Toole told CNN. 'Over the years, there have been some people that have planned mass violence, where their nihilistic thinking, or view of the world, was very extreme, and then you have some where it's less extreme.' Both FBI investigators and Justice Department prosecutors have recently deployed a new specialized term to describe those radicalized by nihilism – Nihilistic Violent Extremists, or NVEs. In court records on a separate case, the FBI defines NVEs as 'individuals who engage in criminal conduct within the United States and abroad, in furtherance of political, social, or religious goals that derive primarily from a hatred of society at large and a desire to bring about its collapse by sowing indiscriminate chaos, destruction, and social instability.' 'NVEs work individually or as part of a network with these goals of destroying civilized society through the corruption and exploitation of vulnerable populations, which often include minors,' the definition continues. Investigators have found these types of extremists often use social media platforms to 'connect with individuals and desensitize them to violence … corrupting and grooming those individuals towards committing future acts of violence … for the purpose of accelerating the downfall of society.' CNN's Elle Reeve, in her book 'Black Pill: How I Witnessed the Darkest Corners of the Internet Come to Life, Poison Society, and Capture American Politics,' describes the way individuals on social media platforms like 4chan deal in explicit nihilism – with the 'black pill' concept. 'The black pill is a dark but gleeful nihilism: the system is corrupt, and its collapse is inevitable. There is no hope. Times are bad and they're going to get worse. You swallow the black pill and accept the end is coming,' Reeve described. 'You start searching for evidence to prove to yourself that you're correct, and it's easy enough to find … The hardships and heartbreak you've faced can now be explained as the inevitability of a sweeping historical force,' she wrote. 'You spend more time in blackpilled online forums, where the darker the commentary, the more attention it gets, so you compete to write the most creative description of the depravity,' Reeve continued. 'Incels traffic in explicit nihilism too, with the '(black pill)' concept providing an ideological veneer to cover their self-loathing and isolation,' a Just Security article explains. 'Incel,' short for 'involuntary celibate,' describes someone, usually a male, who is frustrated by their lack of sexual experiences. 'Many school shooters and incels display and act upon the same suicidality that also characterizes much nihilist activity. For instance, incels have adopted a phrase, 'going ER,' to describe the phenomenon of taking one's own life in a bloody murder-suicide plot against society,' according to the article. The phrase refers to Elliot Rodger, a 22-year-old who in May 2014 killed six people in Isla Vista, California, before fatally shooting himself. O'Toole says decades ago, the concept of nihilism and holding nihilistic ideations was a phenomenon – but added the 'black pill' terminology first popularized over the last 15 years shows how normalized the nihilistic worldview has become. 'Twenty-five years ago, the shooters that we looked at … didn't have social media, so they couldn't compare notes, and so that didn't give them the opportunity to say, 'Hey, do you feel the same way I do? Yeah, I feel the same way you do,'' O'Toole said. 'Behaviors that were really anecdotal 25 years ago are now being normalized because other people share them.'
2 hours ago
Amid recent string of attacks inspired by Israel-Hamas war, some experts worry counterterrorism not a priority
Five alleged high-profile terrorist attacks have occurred across the United States in the first six months of 2025, including four that investigators suspect were motivated by the war in Gaza or radicalized by the ISIS terrorist group. But as law enforcement investigates the violent incidents -- from the New Orleans truck rampage to the Molotov cocktail attack in Boulder -- some counterterrorism experts say they're worried the federal government has taken its eye "off the ball" in preventing terrorism as its priorities shift -- from counterterrorism to mass deportation. "It's stunning to me that we're making the same mistakes we did in the lead-up to 9/11," said Elizabeth Neumann, a former Department of Homeland Security assistant secretary for counterterrorism during the first Trump administration. "Now that does not mean that we're going to have another 9/11, but it's very alarming to me that we are repeating mistakes." A DHS senior official said in a statement to ABC News, "Any suggestion that DHS is stepping away from addressing terrorism is simply false." "Under President Trump, the Department of Homeland Security will use every tool and resource available to secure our border, protect the homeland, and get criminal illegal aliens out of our country," the DHS official said. "The safety of American citizens comes first." The wave of extremist violence has come against a backdrop of a rising number of assaults, vandalism and harassment nationwide linked to the Israel-Hamas war. The war erupted on Oct. 7, 2023, when the Hamas terrorist group staged a widespread ambush in Israel, killing 1,200 people, including children, and taking 251 hostages, with about 20 still held in captivity. According to the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health, the death toll in Gaza is nearly 54,000 since the war began. Federal and state law enforcement agencies and the Department of Homeland Security have repeatedly issued bulletins, warning the country is vulnerable to terrorism, especially at large events, as a result of the Gaza war. The New York City Police Department, responsible for protecting the largest Jewish population in the world outside of Israel, issued a bulletin last month, saying, "Jewish people and institutions continue to be the target of violent assaults, harassment, intimidation, hate crimes, and threats, especially since the onset of the Israel-Hamas war." On Thursday night, the FBI and Department of Homeland Security warned of an "elevated threat" facing the Jewish community in the wake of the back-to-back incidents in Washington, D.C., and Boulder. However, the DHS and FBI did not indicate there are any known threats in a joint intelligence bulletin sent to law enforcement on May 23. "Violent extremist messaging continues to highlight major sporting and cultural events and venues as potential targets, and threat actors -- including domestic violent extremists (DVEs), homegrown violent extremists (HVEs) inspired by Foreign Terrorist Organizations (FTOs), and other mass casualty attackers not motivated by an ideology -- previously have targeted public events with little to no warning," according to the bulletin. John Cohen, a former Department of Homeland Security undersecretary of intelligence, said he is concerned that at this time of heightened security, the White House has proposed cutting the FBI's fiscal-year 2026 budget by $545 million dollars, or about 5% of the bureau's budget. An internal memo from the FBI Chicago office, obtained in March by ABC Chicago station WLS-TV, confirmed that members of the office's Joint Terrorism Task Force (JTTF), and terrorism task forces nationwide, will be supporting Homeland Security task forces focused on making immigration arrests. "So at the very time that we are seeing more and more acts of violence and destructive demonstration activity by people who are being, in some cases, not only inspired but facilitated by foreign threat actors, the concern is that the resources being devoted to addressing that threat are being decreased," said Cohen, an ABC News contributor. Neumann said it's not just the FBI's counterterrorism departments getting slashed. She said an office she helped establish within the Department of Homeland Security to help communities across the nation prevent hate-fueled attacks is being drastically cut back. ProPublica reported this week that the office, the Center for Prevention Programs and Partnerships (CP3), is currently being spearheaded by a 22-year-old recent college graduate with no previous counterterrorism experience. "What this office does is it creates capability locally, within a state, to be able to educate bystanders on the signs and indicators of somebody that might be radicalizing ... and then it helps states create the capability for mental health practitioners and other professionals to be able to intervene with individuals," Neumann said. "It was needed because we just have so many people moving into that stage of, 'Well, they might commit an act of violence, but they haven't done anything criminal yet.'" Neumann, an ABC News contributor, said she has noticed a complacency set in after the U.S. declared victory over ISIS in 2019 and withdrew troops from Afghanistan in 2021. "We are moving our eye off the ball to focus on things that I don't know are what I would put in the top of my counterterrorism bucket," Neumann said. 'Immigration security IS national security' In a statement to ABC News, White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said concerns that the administration has taken its eye off counterterrorism to focus on its deportation crackdown are unfounded. "Immigration security IS national security -- look no further than the terrorist, who was in the United States illegally, that firebombed elderly Jewish women," Jackson said, referring to 45-year-old Egyptian citizen Mohamed Soliman accused of throwing Molotov cocktails at a group of marchers advocating for the release of hostages being held in Gaza. "Enforcing our immigration laws and removing illegal aliens is one big way President Trump is Making America Safe Again." Soliman entered the U.S. in 2022 on a B2 visa that expired in February 2023, according to DHS. A senior official told ABC News he was then granted a work permit that expired in March 28, 2025. Answering critics questioning the administration's preparedness for protecting the homeland in the wake of the string of recent terror attacks, Jackson said, "But the President can walk and chew gum at the same time -- we're holding all criminals accountable, whether they're illegal aliens or American citizens. That's why nationwide murder rates have plummeted, fugitives from the FBI's most wanted list have been captured, and police officers are empowered to do their jobs, unlike under the Biden Administration's soft-on-crime regime." According to the Department Justice and annual FBI violent crime statistics, that nation's murder rate has fallen for the past three consecutive years. The White House also pointed to President Donald Trump's proclamation on Wednesday banning travel from 12 countries -- including Afghanistan, Iran and Libya -- and imposing travel restrictions on seven other countries as evidence the administration has not lost its focus on national security concerns. Egypt, where the suspect in the Boulder attack is from, was not included in the list of countries. Ben Williamson, the FBI's assistant director for public affairs, told ABC News in a statement that while the bureau does not comment on specific personnel decisions, "our agents and support staff are dedicated professionals working around the clock to defend the homeland and crush violent crime -- a mission which certainly overlaps with the consequences of the previous administration's open border policies for four years." Williamson added, "We are proud to work with our interagency partners to keep the American people safe." DHS: Terrorist attacks linked to Gaza war Cohen, the former DHS intelligence official, said neither the Trump administration nor the Biden administration have done enough to prevent terrorism, while foreign actors and terrorist groups like ISIS have upped their game on the internet to radicalize converts within the U.S. "We're continuing to see efforts to not just inspire but instruct those individuals who are angry, who are certain, who are looking for the justification to engage in violence, to express that anger," Cohen said. "So content is developing and introduced online that's intended to inspire them to commit violence, but also providing instructions on just how to do it. We've seen videos talking about vehicle ramming. We've seen videos talking about how to construct explosive devices. We've seen video online encouraging mass shootings at the same time." In August 2024, two Austrian teenagers were arrested and accused of plotting to attack Taylor Swift concerts in Vienna. Authorities said both suspects appeared to have been inspired by ISIS and al-Qaeda, and one of them had researched bomb-making techniques and uploaded to the internet an oath of allegiance to the current leader of the Islamic State. "Law enforcement analysts over the last several months have seen online content posted by al-Qaeda-related and Hamas and Iranian-linked groups advocating violence as a way for people to respond to their concerns about what's going on in Gaza," Cohen said. 'COVID is a huge reason why it's more complicated' Neumann said the pandemic opened the door for terrorist groups to manipulate people during a time of extreme vulnerability. "COVID is a huge reason why it's more complicated," said Neumann, adding that the usual modus operandi of terrorist groups is "offering a certainty in an uncertain world." "It's offering this black-and-white answer of why the bad thing happened to them," Neumann said. "When you look at why people mobilize to violence or radicalize, it is not the ideology. The ideology is kind of the bow that comes on top after all of these other factors have kind of gotten into play for an individual." She added, "We, largely as a field, understand those that commit acts of violence have underlying psychosocial factors that have led them to this place where they are willing to be convinced that violence is the right solution for their problems." Neumann pointed to a 2023 poll by University of California, Davis Violence Prevention Research Program that found 32.8% of respondents considered violence to be usually or always justified to advance some political objectives. "And then you add to it, COVID, Oct. 7, social media, it's just a perfect cauldron for a lot of people to be led astray," Neumann said. In three of the alleged U.S. terrorist attacks that have occurred since mid-April, investigators said the suspects were motivated by the war to commit violence on American soil. The suspect in the April 13 firebombing of the Pennsylvania governor's residence allegedly targeted Gov. Shapiro, who is Jewish, "based upon perceived injustices to the people of Palestine," according to a criminal complaint. The man who allegedly gunned down two Israeli embassy staff members on May 21 outside the Capital Jewish Museum in Washington, D.C., was captured on video shouting "Free Palestine" following the shooting. Neither suspect has entered a plea. In Boulder, Colorado, on June 1, authorities say Soliman, shouting "free Palestine" and wielding a makeshift flamethrower and Molotov cocktails, targeted demonstrators, injuring 15. Soliman has been charged in both state and federal court. He is also charged with hate crimes in the federal case. He has yet to enter a plea to any of the charges. The year started off with the New Year's Day truck-ramming on Bourbon Street in New Orleans that left 14 people dead. The suspect, who was killed in a gunfight with police, had pledged support for ISIS, according to investigators. In a Facebook video the suspect posted as he drove to commit the attack, he said he "originally planned to harm his family and friends, but was concerned the news headlines would not focus on the 'war between the believers and the disbelievers.'" Cohen said, "Regional conflicts in the past were isolated events occurring in foreign lands. But because of the internet, they are now taking place in communities across America." A fifth terrorist attack, that was apparently unrelated to the Middle East war, occurred on May 17 in Palm Springs, California, where a car packed with large quantities of ammonium nitrate was detonated, allegedly by a 25-year-old man who investigators said died in the blast and lived by "pro-mortalism, anti-natalism, and anti-pro-life ideology," or the belief that people should not be born without their consent. An alleged co-conspirator in the Palm Springs attack was arrested this month with federal authorities saying he provided large quantities of ammonium nitrate to the suspect killed in the blast. The attacks in Washington, D.C., New Orleans and at Gov. Shapiro's Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, residence were all allegedly carried out by U.S. citizens, according to investigators. The suspect in the Boulder attack is an Egypt-born man who lived in Kuwait until he moved to Colorado three years ago and had overstayed his B2 tourist visa, investigators said. Additionally, a dual American-German citizen was arrested on May 19 after he allegedly attempted to attack the U.S. embassy in Tel Aviv, but was thwarted by a guard, investigators said. The suspect was captured after dropping a backpack filled with Molotov cocktails, authorities said. "We have to do a better job at maintaining awareness of the threat, and that means by tracking what foreign domestic threat actors or what foreign intelligence services terrorist groups are posting online, the types of attacks they're calling for and the techniques that they are promoting to conduct those attacks," Cohen said. "Law enforcement can take that intelligence then and have a better understanding of the targets that are at risk and ensure that security measures are put in place to reduce the likelihood that these types of public events would be targeted." Neumann said that the current threat environment requires an urgent response from the federal government. "As with everything that happens in Washington, there will be another attack of such a scale that people are going to say, 'We should do something,' and then all of a sudden, the money will flow, and then they'll be like, 'Oh, look, here's this new shiny object that we can solve this problem with,'" Neumann said. "It will get restarted, but we will have lost a long period of time and expertise and will have to make some similar mistakes again as we relearn. That's kind of sad, because in the intervening time people will die because we're not investing in this now."
New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
Once Champions of Fringe Causes, Now in a ‘Trap of Their Own Making'
Dan Bongino, the intense and voluble media personality tapped by President Trump to be a top F.B.I. official, appeared on Fox News last month to deliver news that should not have been news: Jeffrey Epstein, he said with glum resignation, had not been murdered after all. 'I've seen the whole file,' said Mr. Bongino, sitting next to his boss, Kash Patel, the bureau's director. 'He killed himself.' Investigations into Mr. Epstein's 2019 death in a Manhattan prison cell found serious management errors but no evidence of criminality. Yet Mr. Trump, once a friend of the financier accused of sexually abusing dozens of teenage girls, has long suggested Mr. Epstein was silenced by shadowy clients of his sex trafficking ring. In a 2023 episode of his popular podcast, Mr. Bongino, now the bureau's No. 2 official, implored listeners, 'Please do not let that story go.' They obliged. A Trump-allied podcaster suggested the F.B.I. leaders were 'beholden to some unseen powers.' A former F.B.I. agent who has been critical of the bureau posted a parody of a law firm ad with Mr. Bongino standing next to a sign that read 'Trust Me & Bro Consulting.' Tucker Carlson, a friend of Mr. Bongino's, said Trump appointees were 'making a huge mistake, promising to reveal things and then not revealing them.' Alex Jones, a founding father of the modern conspiracy movement, referred to Mr. Patel's own handling of the Epstein case as flat-out 'gaslighting.' Mr. Patel and Mr. Bongino, partisan showmen placed in positions previously held by people with greater experience, earned their bona fides in Mr. Trump's camp by promoting conspiracy theories, making promises of what they would accomplish under Mr. Trump when he returned to power based on fictional or exaggerated premises, pledging to reveal deep-state secrets and vowing swift vengeance on their enemies. It has now fallen on Mr. Patel, Mr. Bongino and Attorney General Pam Bondi to make good on the promises explicit and implied — or show how hard they are trying. But they are running what amounts to a conspiracy theory fulfillment center with unstocked shelves, critics say. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
