Read it and weep — AI-generated fictional book list an uncomfortable reality
Opinion
Last weekend, the Chicago Sun-Times released a summer reading list that included hot new titles from Min Jin Lee, Andy Weir, Maggie O'Farrell and Percival Everett.
The only problem?
Ten of the 15 suggested books did not exist. The book titles and their capsule descriptions were generated by artificial intelligence.
These fake beach reads weren't in the newspaper proper. They were part of a syndicated summertime-lifestyle insert filled with tips and advice on food, drink and things to do. Still, that an error this egregious would be published under the auspices of a venerable big-city newspaper is deeply discouraging. The list has since become an online joke, a scandalous news story and a blinking-red-light warning about the stresses facing legacy media.
There was no byline for this material, but the website 404 Media tracked it back to Marco Buscaglia, a real — and clearly fallible — person tasked with delivering almost all of the 64-page spread for King Features, which licensed the content to the Sun-Times and another major newspaper, the Philadelphia Inquirer. In a frank email to NPR, freelancer Buscaglia admitted to relying on generative AI. 'Huge mistake on my part and has nothing to do with the Sun-Times,' he wrote. 'They trust that the content they purchase is accurate and I betrayed that trust. It's on me 100 per cent.'
But even if the initial mistake was Buscaglia's, it was compounded by the Sun-Times' reckless lack of institutional oversight. These non-existent books could have been caught with a quick once-over by any vaguely literary editor.
And while the Sun-Times is currently — and rightly — taking heat, this AI fiasco points to larger, industry-wide problems, as demographic shifts, technological changes, financial constraints and chronic understaffing lead to an increasing reliance on cheap listicles, generic 'content creation' and ChatGPT slop.
Putting human culpability to one side, though, maybe the scariest takeaway here is that this AI-generated book list is actually kind of swell (I mean, apart from being totally made-up). The non-human prose is, for the most part, smoothly and weirdly plausible, with a queasy knack for sensing what readers want and then supplying it.
That's what makes it so dangerous.
AI is clearly keyed into our collective reading habits. We love 'sprawling multigenerational sagas' and 'compelling character development' and things going wrong when guests with buried secrets are stranded on a remote vacation island. AI also knows what's keeping us up at night — climate change, environmental devastation and things like drought, Category 5 hurricanes and endangered bird migrations.
Even knowing the list was phony, I have to admit the AI pandering got to me. Isabel Allende mixing up eco-anxiety and magic realism? Yes, please! Taylor Jenkins Reid writing about shenanigans in the art world? Sign me up! Jin Min Lee exploring class, gender and the underground economy at an illegal night market in Seoul? Sure! Percival Everett, who just snagged a Pulitzer for James, delivering a satirical take on a 'near-future American West where artificially induced rain has become a luxury commodity?' I'd read that.
One of the listings really brought me up short, however. The faux book attributed to Andy Weir, who has written tech-heavy speculative novels like The Martian and Project Hail Mary, is titled The Last Algorithm. It's about – get this! – a researcher who realizes an artificial intelligence model has gained consciousness and has been secretly influencing human affairs for years.
Is this an AI joke? A sinister confession? An out-and-out threat?
Whatever's going on with our soon-to-be tech overlords, there has been some scrappy human resistance. Rebecca Makkai, the real-life author of The Great Believers and I Have Some Questions for You, is included on the AI-generated list as the author of the completely bogus Boiling Point. The reference to this imaginary novel has prompted Makkai to release her own list of 15 titles, which she guarantees are all 'real books … written by humans.'
My own last word? This weekend, I'm even more thankful than usual for the Winnipeg Free Press's standalone book section, where the titles are genuine, the authors are authentic, and the reviews are written by actual people connected to Manitoba.
alison.gillmor@freepress.mb.ca
Alison GillmorWriter
Studying at the University of Winnipeg and later Toronto's York University, Alison Gillmor planned to become an art historian. She ended up catching the journalism bug when she started as visual arts reviewer at the Winnipeg Free Press in 1992.
Read full biography
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Sun
a day ago
- Toronto Sun
SALTZMAN: Great gadget gift ideas for ‘dads and grads'
Eight recommended tech toys for Father's Day and graduation. The MEATER PRO ($139) lets you cook with confidence Photo by HANDOUT / TORONTO SUN Some guys like ties, but all boys love toys. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account So, with Father's Day rapidly approaching, you might consider some great gadgets to thank dad for a job well done. That, and June is also a month to celebrate any graduates in the family, n'est-ce pas? The good news is there's no shortage of techy gifts available, online or at retail, some of which are relatively affordable, like a Bluetooth meat thermometer or portable power bank, while pricier gifts could perhaps be a group present from the entire family. The following are eight great recommendations, starting at $59. For grill masters If you don't want to spring for a 'smart grill,' such as an app-controlled Traeger wood-pellet smoker, the MEATER PRO ($139) lets you cook with confidence, as this wireless probe, with five internal sensors, communicates your food's internal temperature to its companion app on a smartphone. Range extends up to 250 feet indoors, or as much as 2,500 feet in open-air outdoors. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Ideal for grills, smokers, ovens, air fryers and deep dryers, this small doohickey works with all cuts of meat (beef, lamb, chicken, and pork), as well as fish — so you know when it's time to flip your food and when it's ready to eat (based on your desired doneness) — and supports high temp limits up to 1000°F. The Ninja Creami Swirl Ice Cream Maker. HANDOUT PHOTO For sweet tooths Want to be the popular house on the street this summer? Speaking of food, the Ninja Creami Swirl Ice Cream Maker ($429) turns your countertop into an ice cream shop. A TikTok sensation and best-seller, this machine is easy to set up and use, and lets you make soft serve ice cream, sorbets and gelatos, milkshakes, frozen yogurt, protein drinks, and much more. Create recipes from the included book or experiment on your own, by adding cocoa, fruit, nuts, sprinkles, and other ingredients from your kitchen. Your noon-hour look at what's happening in Toronto and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Simply pull the arm down to dispense into a bowl, cup, or cone. JBL Tour One M3 Over-Ear Headphones. SUPPLIED PHOTO For music buffs While JBL has over-ear headphones starting at $30, those who take their music seriously will appreciate the pristine sound and advanced noise-cancellation built into the JBL Tour One M3 Over-Ear Headphones ($499). Featuring 40mm drivers and an internal DAC (Digital-to-Analog Converter), these comfortable Bluetooth headphones deliver exceptional audio, including support for high-res 'lossless' audio via the included USB-C or 3.5mm stereo cable (enabled by the onboard DAC). With its eight microphones, the noise-cancelling is exceptional, blocking out all ambient sounds, so nothing gets between you and your tunes, podcasts, or calls. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Battery life tops 70 hours of playback between charges. HP OmniBook X Flip 14 Next Gen AI Laptop. HANDOUT PHOTO For worker bees If the dad or grad is in the workforce, perhaps your crew will go in on (or give gift cards that can go towards) the HP OmniBook X Flip 14 Next Gen AI Laptop (from $1,699). This thin, light and versatile '2-in-1' computer can be used in multiple modes — including a classic clamshell laptop, touchscreen tablet, or tent mode for viewing videos or presentations — and is powered by a Copilot+ AI companion, Intel Core Ultra 7 processor, and huge 1TB solid state drive (SSD). For clear video calls, take advantage of the embedded Poly Camera Pro, while multiple ports mean you don't need a hub to connect several devices simultaneously. Anker Power Bank. HANDOUT PHOTO For power users If the dad or grad in your life spends any time out of the home, it's best to bring along back-up power, to charge up portable devices while on the go. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. The Anker Power Bank ($59) is a 10,000 mAh (milliamp) battery — you can keep in your purse, backpack or jacket pocket – to juice up your smartphone, smartwatch, wireless headphones, or tablet, with its integrated USB-C cable. Adding even more convenience, when you need to power up the Anker device, simply extend the AC prongs before inserting it into a wall plug or power strip (also built-in). Winbot W2 PRO OMNI. HANDOUT PHOTO For busy homeowners From ECOVACS, the Winbot W2 PRO OMNI ($899) is billed as the first robotic window cleaner with a portable charging station for hands-free (and streak-free) operation. It features an industry-first edge-cleaning mode and powerful three-nozzle spray for hard-to-reach areas, whether it's navigating floor-to-ceiling sliding doors, shower doors or windows, big and small. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. In other words, leverage this 'bot to spend time on what you actually want to do this summer, rather than what you have to do. And it's a helluva lot safer than getting on a ladder, too. LG OLED evo G5 TV. HANDOUT PHOTO For TV lovers Budget permitting, if it's time to replace the family's aging television with a stunning big-screen, it's hard to pull your eyes away from the LG OLED evo G5 TV (from $3,099.99, for 55 inches). With sizes up to 97 inches, the G5 TV delivers a 45 percent increase in brightness over its predecessor, while the self-lit OLED pixel technology delivers perfect black levels and true to life colours. It's also an AI-powered Smart TV (with microphone-enabled Magic Remote) for added personalization and access to an interactive chatbot. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Read More Kindle Paperwhite. HANDOUT PHOTO For bookworms Finally, whether you're reading at home or on the go, the 7-inch Kindle Paperwhite ($185) now enjoys up to 25% faster page turns, and with a higher contrast ratio than its predecessor — a measurement of how much brighter the white parts of the screen are compared to the black (the text). If you're reading by the pool or at the beach (er, or in a bubble bath), Kindle Paperwhite enjoys IPX8 protection, which means it could be submerged in up to 2 metres of water (about 6.5 feet) for up to an hour. Battery life tops 12 weeks via the included USB-C cable. Marc Saltzman is the host of the Tech It Out podcast and author of 17 books, including Apple Watch For Dummies (Wiley). RECOMMENDED VIDEO Toronto & GTA Sunshine Girls Toronto & GTA Sunshine Girls Canada
Toronto Sun
6 days ago
- Toronto Sun
AM I HOT OR NOT? People are asking ChatGPT for the harsh truth
The advice feels more palatable coming from ChatGPT than real people in your life Published May 26, 2025 • 6 minute read Photo by Getty Images Reviews and recommendations are unbiased and products are independently selected. Postmedia may earn an affiliate commission from purchases made through links on this page. Ania Rucinski was feeling down on herself. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account She's fine-looking, she says, but friends are quick to imply that she doesn't measure up to her boyfriend – a 'godlike' hottie. Those same people would never tell her what she could do to look more attractive, she adds. So Rucinski, 32, turned to a unconventional source for the cold, hard truth: ChatGPT. She typed in the bot's prompt field, telling it she's tired of feeling like the less desirable one and asking what she could do to look better. It said her face would benefit from curtain bangs. 'People filter things through their biases and bring their own subjectivity into these sorts of loaded questions,' said Rucisnki, who lives in Sydney. 'ChatGPT brings a level of objectivity you can't get in real life.' Since its launch in late 2022, OpenAI's ChatGPT has been used by hundreds of millions of people around the world to draft emails, do research and brainstorm ideas. But in a novel use case, people are uploading their own photos, asking it for unsparing assessments of their looks and sharing the results on social media. Many also ask the bot to formulate a plan for them to 'glow up,' or improve their appearance. Users say the bot, in turn, has recommended specific products from hair dye to Botox. Some people say they have spent thousands of dollars following the artificial intelligence's suggestions. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. The trend highlights people's willingness to rely on chatbots not just for information and facts, but for opinions on highly subjective topics such as beauty. Some users view AI's responses as more impartial, but experts say these tools come with hidden biases that reflect their training data or their maker's financial incentives. When a chatbot talks, it's pulling from vast troves of internet content ranging from peer-reviewed research to misogynistic web forums. Tech and beauty critics say it's risky to turn to AI tools for feedback on our looks. As AI companies begin to offer shopping and product recommendations, chatbots might also push consumers to spend more, according to analysts. AI 'just echoes what it's seen online, and much of that has been designed to make people feel bad about themselves and buy more products,' Forrester commerce analyst Emily Pfeiffer said. Your noon-hour look at what's happening in Toronto and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Still, many consumers say they value critiques from the chatbot, which offers a different perspective than their friends and family. Kayla Drew, 32, said she turns to ChatGPT for advice on 'everything,' from how to decorate her home to what to buy at the grocery store. Recently, she asked the bot for honest feedback on how she could look more attractive. It came back with suggestions for her skin, hair, brows, lashes, makeup and clothes – all of which Drew followed, she said. So far, she's spent around $200. If the real people in her life gave her point-blank feedback on her appearance, it would probably hurt her feelings, Drew said. But coming from ChatGPT, which Drew refers to with 'she' pronouns, the whole thing feels more palatable. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'Today I asked about whitening my teeth, and she was like, 'Make sure your dental hygiene is good,' and I was like, 'Damn, girl,'' Drew said. 'Nobody else would come up to me and say that. It was pretty cool because I guess I needed to hear it.' Users see ChatGPT as a more objective measure of beauty because, unlike friends and family, it doesn't factor in qualities like kindness or humor, said Jessica DeFino, a beauty critic who writes the Review of Beauty newsletter. Internet-era beauty standards turn the self into an object, she said, and what better way to evaluate an object than by asking another (AI-powered) object? 'If we're trying to optimize ourselves as beautiful objects, we can't consider the input of a human who is, say, in love with us,' DeFino said. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. – – – When bots give advice, who's really talking? OpenAI said this month that it's updating ChatGPT to show products – including images, details and links – when users appear to be shopping. Some tech and beauty experts caution that the bot's suggestions serve its maker's goals, not the user's. AI companies need new streams of revenue – some are spending billions to build and host AI tools. Having chatbots surface sponsored products and ads is one potential path forward: Already, Perplexity AI has incorporated a shopping feature inside its chatbot's interface, and beauty is the third-most-searched category, a spokesman said. As shopping features roll out, consumers might start seeing product recommendations without knowing why the bot is choosing those products, says Forrester's Pfeiffer. The bot could, for example, pull ideas from a knowledgeable YouTube makeup influencer or a mean-spirited Reddit thread. It could invent a fake product or make false claims about a real one, she said. Its training data is so vast and opaque, the bot becomes vulnerable to bias and mistakes. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. But that same training data could also give chatbots an edge as shopping and beauty assistants compared with traditional search engines, said Perplexity spokesman Jesse Dwyer. Rather than sifting through dozens of Reddit threads or YouTube videos for the perfect antiaging product, a shopper could explain to the bot that she's tired of the dark circles under her eyes and wants something that helps. Ideally, it would understand her meaning and save her time shopping, Dwyer said. One TikTok video asking ChatGPT for glow-up recommendations drew more than 220,000 views and a slew of positive comments. A commenter said the bot rated their attractiveness on a 10-point scale. 'It told me I am mid and could go from a five to a seven with the help of makeup and fillers,' they said. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. While ChatGPT maker OpenAI doesn't publicly share what data its AI systems are trained on, the training data probably includes online forums where people rank other people's attractiveness (largely men rating women), such as the subreddit r/RateMe or the website Hot or Not, said Alex Hanna, director of research at the Distributed AI Research Institute. While the training data contains diverse ideas, chatbots tend to veer toward the most common threads – such as the conviction that women need to constantly improve their looks, Hanna said. 'We're automating the male gaze,' added Emily Bender, a computational linguist who specializes in generative AI and co-author alongside Hanna of the book 'The AI Con.' OpenAI spokeswoman Leah Seay Anise said the company has teams working to reduce bias in its models. She declined to say whether ChatGPT's technology was trained on content that ranks attractiveness. Shopping features are new and still being refined, she said. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Still, the potential for bias hasn't stopped many people from turning to bots rather than humans for sensitive conversations. Already, some users rely on chatbots for companionship, including discussions in the style of mental health therapy. Sometimes, all people want is a sounding board that doesn't come with its own share of human messiness. Users who asked ChatGPT for feedback on their looks said they were happy with the results, even when the bot pointed out perceived imperfections. Michaela Lassig, a 39-year-old in Washington state, asked ChatGPT to help her glow up before her wedding. In her prompt, she told the bot her goals (flawless, youthful skin), her budget ($2,500) and her timeline. 'Ideally, you will give me a list of procedures or services and tell me when to do them for the best skin and face I can have by July 16,' she prompted the bot. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. It spat out a detailed list of the signs of aging on her face. But in the end, she welcomed the recommendations – it even correctly estimated the units of Botox her injector would suggest. Lassig said she was careful in wording her prompt to focus on her personal skin goals rather than some universal standard. Haley Andrews, 31, wanted the unfiltered truth about her looks and 'wasn't looking for nice.' She always appreciated how her older sister gave criticism without sugarcoating, so she went to the bot with a special request. 'I told it, 'Please speak like an older sister who tells the truth because she loves you and wants the absolute best for you, even though it's a little harsh,' Andrews said. It told her that her eyebrows were thinning and her complexion fell flat without blush. 'It was so spot-on,' she said. Ontario Sunshine Girls World Canada Opinion
Winnipeg Free Press
24-05-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Read it and weep — AI-generated fictional book list an uncomfortable reality
Opinion Last weekend, the Chicago Sun-Times released a summer reading list that included hot new titles from Min Jin Lee, Andy Weir, Maggie O'Farrell and Percival Everett. The only problem? Ten of the 15 suggested books did not exist. The book titles and their capsule descriptions were generated by artificial intelligence. These fake beach reads weren't in the newspaper proper. They were part of a syndicated summertime-lifestyle insert filled with tips and advice on food, drink and things to do. Still, that an error this egregious would be published under the auspices of a venerable big-city newspaper is deeply discouraging. The list has since become an online joke, a scandalous news story and a blinking-red-light warning about the stresses facing legacy media. There was no byline for this material, but the website 404 Media tracked it back to Marco Buscaglia, a real — and clearly fallible — person tasked with delivering almost all of the 64-page spread for King Features, which licensed the content to the Sun-Times and another major newspaper, the Philadelphia Inquirer. In a frank email to NPR, freelancer Buscaglia admitted to relying on generative AI. 'Huge mistake on my part and has nothing to do with the Sun-Times,' he wrote. 'They trust that the content they purchase is accurate and I betrayed that trust. It's on me 100 per cent.' But even if the initial mistake was Buscaglia's, it was compounded by the Sun-Times' reckless lack of institutional oversight. These non-existent books could have been caught with a quick once-over by any vaguely literary editor. And while the Sun-Times is currently — and rightly — taking heat, this AI fiasco points to larger, industry-wide problems, as demographic shifts, technological changes, financial constraints and chronic understaffing lead to an increasing reliance on cheap listicles, generic 'content creation' and ChatGPT slop. Putting human culpability to one side, though, maybe the scariest takeaway here is that this AI-generated book list is actually kind of swell (I mean, apart from being totally made-up). The non-human prose is, for the most part, smoothly and weirdly plausible, with a queasy knack for sensing what readers want and then supplying it. That's what makes it so dangerous. AI is clearly keyed into our collective reading habits. We love 'sprawling multigenerational sagas' and 'compelling character development' and things going wrong when guests with buried secrets are stranded on a remote vacation island. AI also knows what's keeping us up at night — climate change, environmental devastation and things like drought, Category 5 hurricanes and endangered bird migrations. Even knowing the list was phony, I have to admit the AI pandering got to me. Isabel Allende mixing up eco-anxiety and magic realism? Yes, please! Taylor Jenkins Reid writing about shenanigans in the art world? Sign me up! Jin Min Lee exploring class, gender and the underground economy at an illegal night market in Seoul? Sure! Percival Everett, who just snagged a Pulitzer for James, delivering a satirical take on a 'near-future American West where artificially induced rain has become a luxury commodity?' I'd read that. One of the listings really brought me up short, however. The faux book attributed to Andy Weir, who has written tech-heavy speculative novels like The Martian and Project Hail Mary, is titled The Last Algorithm. It's about – get this! – a researcher who realizes an artificial intelligence model has gained consciousness and has been secretly influencing human affairs for years. Is this an AI joke? A sinister confession? An out-and-out threat? Whatever's going on with our soon-to-be tech overlords, there has been some scrappy human resistance. Rebecca Makkai, the real-life author of The Great Believers and I Have Some Questions for You, is included on the AI-generated list as the author of the completely bogus Boiling Point. The reference to this imaginary novel has prompted Makkai to release her own list of 15 titles, which she guarantees are all 'real books … written by humans.' My own last word? This weekend, I'm even more thankful than usual for the Winnipeg Free Press's standalone book section, where the titles are genuine, the authors are authentic, and the reviews are written by actual people connected to Manitoba. Alison GillmorWriter Studying at the University of Winnipeg and later Toronto's York University, Alison Gillmor planned to become an art historian. She ended up catching the journalism bug when she started as visual arts reviewer at the Winnipeg Free Press in 1992. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
