Colm Collins critical of Munster decision to separate Cork and Kerry in football championship
Cork
and
Kerry
in next year's provincial football championship. The former Clare manager and member of Jim Gavin's
Football Review Committee
also suggested that the FRC model be used to reform football championship structures.
At Thursday night's meeting, Munster delegates took the decision that the top two counties, judged by league standing, should be drawn in the semi-finals and kept apart – on the basis that it would boost gate receipts by optimising provincial attendances between the two most successful counties, who would have an enhanced chance of reaching the final.
It was ratified for a three-year period beginning in 2026.
Kerry have been the only Munster county in the league's top flight for what will be 10 years next season. Cork finished this year in fifth place in Division Two. Next came Clare, third in Division Three.
READ MORE
'The Munster Championship is a complete joke,' said Collins, 'in the sense that you've got a Division One team, probably the best Division One team, playing counties that are below them. Munster Council, in their profound wisdom, have decided to give Cork a leg up the ladder by seeding them.
'The point is that the Munster finals haven't been competitive, but they're not going to solve it by doing this. I wouldn't mind if there were two Division One teams in Munster and they were consistently doing well.
'I don't know how some of these delegates will go back and face their football squads after voting for this.'
This brings to an end 35 years of the open draw in Munster. The late Noel Walsh campaigned to introduce the structure for 1991 on the basis that it was demanding too much of smaller, less successful counties to have to beat both Cork and Kerry if they were to win the provincial title.
At the time, Cork were All-Ireland champions. In the first year, Limerick reached a first final since 1965 and in the second, Clare won a first title for 75 years.
It was later tweaked so that the provincial finalists would be seeded for the following year but not kept apart. Collins's argument is that the decline of Cork has had far more of an impact on the championship than the open draw.
'Tipperary have won Munster more recently than Cork,' he said, 'and it's a long time since they have come close to filling a ground in Munster.'
Although Cork took the eventual winners to extra-time in the Munster semi-final, they were beaten by 11 in the All-Ireland round-robin fixture and there is little sign that the Cork public are swinging behind their footballers, who haven't attracted more than 20,000 to a match with Kerry since 31,836 attended the 2017 provincial final in Killarney.
Collins would love to see a high-powered committee, along the lines of the FRC, review and make recommendations on future structures for the football championship.
'It would be great to see a committee in charge that would have teeth and would be allowed to review championship structures and that politics and vested interests by the provinces would be prevented from blocking proper development.
'It has to be a priority at this point to get rid of these mismatches. There is no point in having one of the powerhouses, a Division One team taking on a Division Four team in the provincial championships in the name of keeping these championships.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
32 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Paul Casey: 'We knew when we met them this morning that they were ready for it'
TG4 All-Ireland SFC final: Dublin 2-16 Meath 0-10 Dublin joint manager Paul Casey said he knew when the squad assembled on Sunday morning that they were poised to go all the way and reclaim the TG4 All-Ireland senior title. 'It's obviously absolutely fantastic. When you have so much experience as we have in that group, to get a day when they all bring that experience to the pitch is just superb. We knew when we met them this morning that they were ready for it,' said Casey. 'They had a pep in their step and they probably came in here bouncing, but it's nothing like the way they're going to leave here because it's absolutely fantastic. 'A day when you're hoping that all your big names and stars will turn up and give a performance. I think that they went over and beyond that. It was fantastic.' He praised the contribution of Player of the Match Orlagh Nolan who battled back from injury to produce a stunning performance on the biggest day of all. 'Orlagh has worked so, so hard to come back. When we were up in Clonshaugh and Craobh Chiarain in the dark and the muck, Orlagh was in the gym and she was working so hard to come back. She always did it with a smile on her face. 'We would have loved to have her back playing full games, maybe in the quarter-final, but our medical team were very strict in terms of just easing her back into it. It fell perfectly for her to have her first start today," added Casey. Hannah Tyrrell, Kate Sullivan and team captain Carla Rowe registered an impressive combined tally of 0-13 as Dublin bossed matters throughout. Nicole Owens and Niamh Hetherton also bagged goals in a dominant opening half as Dublin ended their first season under the joint management of Casey and Derek Murray with the Brendan Martin Cup back in their possession for the seventh time in history in front of a crowd of 48,089. Meath, bidding for their third TG4 All-Ireland senior title, were always chasing the game and manager Shane McCormack said his side battled to the end but they knew it was going to be an uphill battle. 'I'm just gutted for the girls, to be honest. We were always doubted, even at the start of the year before a ball was thrown in, to even get to a quarter-final stage. But we did believe within our circle that we would achieve it. We played Dublin three times this year. A 16-point trimming in the league wasn't good, so we sat down that week and had a chat among ourselves and we kind of worked on different tactics. 'In fairness to the girls with the Leinster campaign, obviously we lost to Dublin in the Leinster final, but we were gutted because Dublin got the last eight points without a reply from us. So coming into today's game, we knew what was going to happen but the game was nearly over at half-time. In fairness to our girls, they battled to the end. I think we were 11 down at half-time. 'In the second half, pretty pleased that we came out of the blocks quick enough. I think we lost the second half by a point. But I'm just gutted for the girls because they're a fantastic bunch," said McCormack. Tyrrell, needing just three points to secure the ZuCar Golden Boot for 2025, got the ball rolling in a repeat of the 2021 All-Ireland decider with an early two-point salvo on her way to a haul of 0-5. Things got even better for the Sky Blues when Owens struck a clinical sixth minute goal and Sullivan also added her name to the scoresheet before Emma Duggan finally opened Meath's account with a successful free on 10 minutes. While Duggan was on hand to cancel out a score from Rowe, Dublin pushed into overdrive either side of the first quarter mark with four points on the bounce from Tyrrell (two), Orlagh Nolan and Sullivan. The rampant Jackies then moved 12 clear when Hetherton buried a shot to the roof of the Meath net in the 22nd minute and even though Duggan contributed a brace of frees in response to Sullivan's third from play, Dublin brought an emphatic 2-9 to 0-4 buffer into the break. This left the Royals with an enormous uphill task on the restart, but Meath were provided with fresh impetus when Duggan kicked two more points in advance of her Dunboyne club-mate Vikki Wall posting a fine effort from play. However, Dublin reinforced their superiority when Rowe knocked over a place-ball effort of her own and Tyrrell's fifth point of the day meant they were once again in front by double figures at 2-11 to 0-7. With Sullivan bringing her own personal haul up to 0-4 off a subsequent attack, the Metropolitan outfit were on the brink of another top-tier crown heading into the closing quarter. Ciara Smyth, skipper Aoibhin Cleary and Duggan (with her seventh of the tie) all found the target for Meath as the final whistle approached, but although Tyrrell was withdrawn through injury late on, points from Hetherton, Niamh Crowley and the influential Rowe (two) ensured Dublin eased towards their second All-Ireland success in the space of three years. Scorers for Dublin: H Tyrrell (0-5, 3f), C Rowe (0-4, 2f), K Sullivan (0-4), N Hetherton (1-1), N Owens (1-0), N Crowley, O Nolan (0-1 each). Scorers for Meath: E Duggan (0-7, 6f), A Cleary, C Smyth, V Wall (0-1 each). DUBLIN: A Shiels; J Tobin, L Caffrey, N Donlon; S Goldrick, M Byrne, N Crowley; E O'Dowd, H McGinnis; N Owens, C Rowe, O Nolan; H Tyrrell, N Hetherton, K Sullivan. Subs: S McIntyre for Owens (49), A Kane for McGinnis (51), H Leahy for Donlon (54), L Grendon for Tyrrell (55), C Darby for Sullivan (57). MEATH: R Murray; K Kealy, MK Lynch, A Sheridan; S Ennis, S Wall, A Cleary; O Sheehy, M Farrelly; M Thynne, N Gallogly, C Smyth; E Duggan, V Wall, K Cole. Subs: K Bermingham for Farrelly (25), Farrelly for Ennis, E Moyles for Sheehy (both 42), N McEntee for Cole (49), C Lawlor for Kealy (51). Referee: Gus Chapman (Sligo).
Irish Examiner
32 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Christy O'Connor Talking Points: Tyrell goes out with a bang as Canavan All-Ireland dynasty continues
Tyrrell goes out with a massive Bang With six minutes remaining in yesterday's All-Ireland senior final, Hannah Tyrrell went to ground after twisting her knee, her hand signal immediately indicating the seriousness of the injury, her body language confirming the distress and pain Tyrrell was in. This is exclusive subscriber content. Already a subscriber? Sign in Take us with you this summer. Annual €130€65 Best value Monthly €12€6 / month
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Hannah Tyrrell and Nicole Owens hang up boots after glittering careers with Dublin
And just like that they were gone, three of the very best to have ever played ladies football. Hannah Tyrrell pulled the curtains down on a relatively brief, but spectacular, Dublin senior ladies career after clinching her second winner's medal at Croke Park. Five points from the 34-year-old former rugby international propelled her to the top of the Championship's scoring stakes and, more importantly, her county to a seventh All-Ireland. A fitting stage to call it quits and to end her love affair with elite sport having previously excelled as a soccer player and, most notably, in the oval ball game. The knee injury that left her crumpled in agony on the Croke Park pitch late on here wasn't a particularly pleasant ending to it all. That could yet be a serious setback though, true to the sheer determination of a genuine ladies football icon, Tyrrell insisted on walking off the pitch. "I was determined to walk off on my own two feet, if it was going to be my last time in Croke Park," she smiled afterwards. She had daughter Aoife in her arms while she was speaking to RTÉ TV. "How lucky am I?" she said. "I've been lucky enough to be from Dublin, to play for Dublin, to finish my career in Croke Park and to go out on a high." Read More Dominant Dublin ease past Meath to regain All-Ireland Senior title Nicole Owens called it quits on the grandest stage of all too, bowing out after capturing her fifth All-Ireland medal. The 32-year-old has been plagued by ACL injuries throughout her career but will still go down as one of the greats, like Tyrrell. And when the story of the 2025 final is told in years to come, they will reflect on Owens' sixth minute goal as being the game's decisive score. Even at that early stage, it was hard to see a way back for Meath who were already five points behind. Owens rans herself into the ground before being taken off to a chorus of approval from the Dublin supporters in the near 50,000 crowd. She didn't mention retirement in the main post-match press conference, focusing mainly on how difficult it had been to get herself back into the sort of shape to swing an All-Ireland final Dublin's way, as she did. "I was on the fence about coming back or not this year," she revealed. "I think I was in a bad way starting the year. I would have chatted to Paul Casey and Derek Murray, the management, I was in a really bad way at the start of this year, and they just kind of put an arm around me and got me back in." Later on, in a separate interview with Jerome Quinn on the Croke Park pitch, Owens officially called it quits. "That is me done," she said. "I made the decision, win or lose, because I knew that if we didn't get over the line, it would be a hard decision to make. I think the big thing for me today was just to come in and have fun. I did, I enjoyed the crowd. I enjoyed the first-half, not so much the second-half but the first-half I enjoyed." There could yet be more to follow Tyrrell and Owens into retirement. Sinead Goldrick is 35 and a five-time senior All-Ireland medallist too while Martha Byrne, who has six medals now, along with Leah Caffrey and Orlagh Nolan are all 31. If they do leave, it would probably be more to do with mileage and having given so much over such a long period of time because all three are still at the peak of their powers. Nolan was Player of the Match. Caffrey and Byrne locked down Dublin's defence expertly, holding a Meath attack that contained Emma Duggan, Vikki Wall and rising stars like Kerrie Cole and Ciara Smyth to just three points from open play. Meath defender Aoibhin Cleary got Meath's other point from play. The third player we spoke of who may very well have played their last inter-county game was Meath's powerful forward Wall. If Meath were to win this All-Ireland, they needed the Dunboyne colossus to have a big game and while she emptied the tank, not a lot worked out for her. She kicked three wides including an early goal chance that needed to go in if her team was to avoid a fourth consecutive loss to Dublin this year. In the coming days, Wall will leave Ireland for Australia to resume duties with AFLW Premiership holders North Melbourne. Wall signed a three-year deal with the club earlier this year and, at 27, there are clearly no guarantees that she will be back. If the Kangaroos insist on her being a full-time player for them, that could very well be that. If it was her last game in green, the defeat and the frustration she clearly felt over a number of decisions, like Gus Chapman's insistence on pulling the ball back for a free to Meath in the second-half instead of playing advantage when they were chasing a goal, won't affect her legacy. She has done everything in the game, powering Meath to All-Ireland senior wins in 2021 and 2022, as well as intermediate success prior to that. She has been an All-Star and a Player of the Year and dragged her club Dunboyne from the junior to the senior ranks. Her sister, Sarah, was on Meath's team too and at one stage they collided while trying to gain possession. Vikki came off the worst but directed referee Chapman to keep the game going before falling down on her hunkers, clearly winded. That's the spirit she always displayed in green and that the Royal County's supporters will remember if this was her swansong.
