CAT upholds CCP decision, confirms pharma co misled hospitals by false marketing
ISLAMABAD: The Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT) has upheld a significant decision by the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP), confirming that a pharmaceutical company misled hospitals by falsely marketing a life-saving product for kidney patients.
The Tribunal dismissed the appeal of 3N LIFEMED Pharmaceuticals and endorsed the Commission's finding of deceptive marketing—though it reduced the monetary penalty from Rs20 million to Rs2 million.
The CCP had received a formal complaint from M/s Renacon Pharma Limited, which accused 3N LIFEMED of using fake quality certifications to market Haemodialysis Concentrate, a crucial product used in the treatment of kidney failure. The CCP's investigation revealed that 3N LIFEMED had falsely claimed its product was certified with Conformité Européene (CE) and Quality Management System (QMS) marks, obtained from a non-accredited firm based in Islamabad. These certifications, although voluntary under Pakistani laws, are widely seen as benchmarks of quality and are often required in public procurement tenders.
The misleading claims were found to have misinformed hospitals and patients, creating a false impression of superior safety and efficacy in a sensitive market segment. Haemodialysis Concentrate is classified as a medical device by the Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (DRAP) and is used to create dialysis fluid, which must closely match the patient's natural blood chemistry to prevent complications.
During the CAT proceedings, 3N LIFEMED's counsel argued that the company ceased using the disputed markings after receiving a show-cause notice from CCP and insisted that the product was DRAP-approved. They also attempted to shift blame to SIMS-AGS, the Islamabad-based company that issued the certifications, whose international accreditation was revoked in 2020.
However, CCP's counsel countered that 3N LIFEMED, as a pharmaceutical company, should have known that such certifications cannot simply be purchased but must be earned through rigorous inspections. The Tribunal agreed with CCP's position, observing that while such certifications may not be legally mandatory, they influence procurement decisions and public trust—and misusing them constitutes deception.
In light of 3N LIFEMED's financial capacity, the Tribunal reduced the penalty to Rs2 million but imposed a strict compliance deadline: failure to pay within ten days will attract an additional fine of Rs100,000 per day.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
Radiocontrast film shortage stalls diagnosis at govt hospitals
In Punjab's government hospitals, there are significant challenges in accessing essential imaging services such as X-ray, ultrasound, MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging), and CT (Computed Tomography) scan, despite official claims of free medicines and treatment facilities. Although government hospitals claim to provide immediate access to X-ray, ultrasound, MRI, and CT scan services in emergency situations, routine patients, on the other hand, often face long waiting times due to overcrowding. This is in spite of the fact that each quarter, the government disburses billions of rupees to hospitals in Lahore, including the Mayo, General, Services, Jinnah, and Guru Nanak Dev hospitals, to support medical facilities. Abdul Rehman, a resident of Lahore, shared his experience at the Services Hospital, where his brother was taken after an accident. After receiving medical attention in the emergency department, his family encountered a troubling situation when they sought a CT scan and X-ray. 'When I brought my brother to the radiology department, the technician told me that I should take a picture of the reports with my mobile phone since films were not available. I am a poor man, and I do not own a smartphone with a good-quality camera. Eventually I had to sought help from someone else to capture the images, which were then shown to the doctor. Similarly, the X-ray image was simply printed on plain paper,' said Rehman. According to the Health Department, government hospitals across Punjab are grappling with severe financial challenges. Although the Punjab government recently released additional funds worth Rs2 billion to support hospital operations, the issues plaguing the healthcare system persist. In recent years, the government has upgraded hospital infrastructure, renovated buildings, and increased annual budgets however, the rapidly growing population has led to a surge in the influx of patients, placing immense pressure on public healthcare facilities. Public health expert, Dr Muhammad Ajmal, highlighted the fact the increasing population in the country necessitated the construction of more hospitals. 'Currently, the situation has become such that X-ray, MRI and CT scan films are not available, due to which patients have to take photos on their phones. Doctors check reports on their phones, and this practice is becoming a part of their routine. At present, resources are scarce, but doctors are doing their job within these resources. More hospitals should be built and the number of radiological machines should also be increased,' said Dr Ajmal. At the same time, it is also worth emphasizing that private-sector healthcare has become increasingly unaffordable for many citizens. Over the past three years, the prices of medical supplies have skyrocketed, but the budget allocation for government hospitals has not kept pace. Despite government funding, the gap remains unfilled. Similarly, the prices of imported X-ray, MRI, and CT scan films have increased significantly due to the rise in the dollar's value, much like the raw materials for medicines. Although medicines are being provided, shortages are still observed. Sources have reported that the budget allocations for government hospitals are determined based on the number of beds each facility has. For instance, the Mayo Hospital, which has 2,484 beds, receives an annual allocation of Rs3.3 million per bed. However, other hospitals in Lahore reportedly receive a higher per-bed allocation. The correspondent tried contacting the Provincial Health Minister Salman Rafiq however, the official was unable to comment on the matter.
Express Tribune
14 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Rs20bn development push for Hyderabad misses the basics
The Sindh government is going to inject more than Rs20 billion on an array of development schemes in Hyderabad in fiscal 2025-26. However, some of the most needed development projects pertaining to water filtration plants, sewage treatment plants and public parks do not find a mention in the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP). The pollution of the Indus River and its canals in Hyderabad will continue unabated for the years to come because the government appears least bothered in treating municipal, commercial and industrial sewage, released in the waterways. Besides, the city's water needs have increased manifold due to the population surge but only small capacity water filtration facilities of around six million gallons per day are being built instead of a central plant with a higher capacity. The toxic industrial wastewater from Hyderabad SITE area is discharged in Phuleli canal, which is a drinking and irrigation water source for Hyderabad, Tando Muhammad Khan and Badin districts. The zone's industrialists are being assured for some years that the provincial government will build for them a combined effluent treatment plant. The budget, however, has kept the status of CEPT for Hyderabad SITE as unapproved with an outlay of Rs100 million and zero allocations for this year. Moreover, there are also reflections of schemes, which have witnessed years-long delay in release of the earmarked funds, consequently delaying the projects' completion and ending up in increasing the costs. There are some other projects which although appear less significant but have secured massive funds. Two years ago in 2023 the government had approved installation of three traffic signals in Hyderabad with the expenditure of Rs233.486 million. A paltry sum of Rs11.674 million was released in the outgoing financial year while the next year Rs30 million more will be provided, totalling 18% of the total allocation. This abundantly shows how the authorities waste years to complete some of the vital projects for the city, which ought to be rounded off in a few months in view of the rampant traffic congestion issues. The phase III of the greater Qasimabad drainage scheme was kicked off in 2017 with a revised budget of Rs3.1 billion. That project is likely to be completed by June 2026 with the release of the remaining total amount of Rs230 million. Another project approved in 2017 concerns construction of road, retaining wall, drain and prestressed bridge on the right side of old Phuleli canal, stretching from Preetabad to Darya Khan pumping station. A revised sum of Rs4.923 billion is to be spent on the project whose completion status will be 85% in June 2026, even after eight years. The provincial government had approved the construction of a sanitary landfill site for Hyderabad in February 2017. Out of the total estimated cost of Rs461.9 million, it will get only Rs25 million in 2025-26. The construction of 9.66-kilometer long Tando Jam bypass road on Hyderabad-Mirpurkhas road was also approved in May 2017, with over Rs2 billion outlay. With Rs98.5 million fund allocation for next fiscal, 90% of the total budget for the bypass road will be released by June 2026. The authorities have also planned to recondition and construct two of some most important roads in Hyderabad. One of them stretches from Shahbaz Flyover on Thandi Sarak to Latifabad Unit 7 railway underpass and the other from the grid station in Qasimabad to former National Highway. However, shockingly though, a colossal sum of Rs1.038 billion has been proposed in the budget for the two roads whose combined length is around 2 kms. The government will release Rs519.3 million for the project in the upcoming budget year. The ongoing widening and reconditioning of Autobahn, the longest commercial road in the city, has already taken too long to utter dismay of the traders and the commuters. The Rs3.2 billion project, which also includes construction of a new drainage system under the road, will receive 94% of the total sanctioned funds. The scheme was approved in October 2022, and it was revised on May 29, 2023. In the higher education sector, the Government College University will receive Rs119.7 million to complete the construction of boundary wall at the total cost of Rs200 million while for varsity's upgrade Rs17.8 million will be given.
Business Recorder
19 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PTI criticises energy policies of govt
ISLAMABAD: The opposition Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) on Saturday launched a scathing attack on the government, accusing it of enacting 'short-sighted, flawed, and misguided' policies that have crippled the power sector and driven electricity beyond the reach of millions. Speaking at a presser, Opposition Leader in National Assembly Omar Ayub took direct aim at the government's energy and fiscal management, flanked by senior PTI leaders Shibli Faraz, Sheikh Waqas Akram, and Taimur Jhagra. Together, they painted a grim picture: ballooning utility bills, decaying infrastructure, and chronic mismanagement. 'Electricity was far more affordable under our government,' Ayub said. 'Now, its prices have skyrocketed, and even the federal capital is experiencing frequent outages. The infrastructure is outdated, the number of feeders is inadequate, and demand continues to rise.' Citing escalating global oil prices exacerbated by the ongoing Israel-Iran conflict, Ayub warned that the economic fallout could drive Pakistan further toward collapse. ASRE 2025: Economic and energy policies must be aligned: experts Turning to the federal budget, Ayub called it a disaster, criticising the government's approach to energy policy. They can't stand the idea of affordable electricity, he said. 'The projects we initiated for Rs450 billion are now costing Rs2,000 billion – not due to inflation, but because of mismanagement and sheer incompetence.' He condemned the recurring Fuel Price Adjustments (FPA), arguing that they disproportionately burden ordinary citizens. 'Rates shift every three months, and it is always the people who pay,' he lamented. Ayub also accused the government of blocking the broadcast of his budget speech. 'They are afraid of the truth and that's the reason they censored my speech on the finance bill,' he claimed. He warned of a ballooning budget deficit – Rs6,501 billion – and looming threats of oil shortages and surging interest rates. 'This government must be held accountable. There is no alternative but to send them home.' However, Shibli Faraz echoed Ayub's concerns. 'Regional conflict will only drive fuel prices higher, and it is the people who will bear the cost. We have been saddled with corrupt, incompetent rulers.' Despite a reported 80,000 megawatt generation capacity under the PTI government, Faraz argued, power remains unaffordable. 'People want to pay their bills but they simply can't.' He also criticised the government's decision to impose an 18 per cent tax on solar panels, calling it a penalty on those seeking alternatives. 'We had a strategy in 2022 to promote competition. None of it has been implemented.' He pointed to a rising circular debt, inconsistent electricity supply, and outstanding payments to energy firms. 'There has been zero meaningful progress. PML-N and PPP are directly responsibility for this crisis.' Though the current generation capacity stands at 46,000 megawatts, Faraz said, cities remain in darkness, and load-shedding is worse than ever. Taimur Jhagra, an ex-provincial finance minister of PTI, severely criticised the government's limited privatisation effort – targeting only LESCO, FESCO, and IESCO – as insufficient and uneven. 'Millions in ex-FATA remain entirely without electricity,' he said. 'Who will be held accountable?' He said the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa budget had been presented and citizens would soon see the difference. He also raised questions about the legal basis for the ongoing isolation of PTI patron-in-chief Imran Khan. 'What law allows this? Why is he being punished?' Jhagra said Punjab now endures more than 12 hours of daily load-shedding, while KP swelters under 46°C heat. 'Basic rights are being denied. Agriculture has completely collapsed. Even Bangladesh has gone ahead of us in energy.' Closing the presser, PTI spokesman Sheikh Waqas Akram spotlighted the crisis in rural areas of the country particularly in KP, Balochistan, Sindh, and southern Punjab, where power shortages have become acute. He said privatisation would fall short without fundamental reforms in IESCO and LESCO. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
