Former drug-using league professional Dean Scott avoids 501 deportation from Australia
He went there on a scholarship with the Manly-Warringah league club in Sydney, but failed to make the first-grade team and moved to Queensland.
Scott then took up a contract with the Noosa Pirates league team on the Sunshine Coast.
'From the moment he arrived in Australia, he was using drugs, particularly marijuana and speed,' the Administrative Review Tribunal of Australia said in a recent decision.
Scott remained a user of recreational drugs but managed to function well for years, both as a family man and a business owner after quitting professional league.
'Rot set in' with meth
However, the tribunal said 'the rot set in' when he was introduced to methamphetamine.
After he appeared in court on drug-related charges in 2009, his marriage broke up and his relationship with his children suffered.
As his addiction spiralled out of control, he became involved in drug distribution.
In 2011, Scott was asked to leave the family home.
'He was no longer a reliable partner or parent, and he was a heavy and regular drug user,' the tribunal decision said.
In 2017, he was charged with trafficking in a dangerous drug, involvement in organised crime, six counts of perjury and several lesser drug-related offences.
He was granted bail and remained on bail in the community for more than five years before he was eventually convicted and jailed in 2023.
Because he was sent to prison for more than 12 months, his visa to be in Australia was cancelled on May 19, 2023, opening the way for his deportation under Section 501 of the Australian Migration Act.
Thousands of New Zealanders who have criminal records have been deported under this provision and are collectively known as '501s'.
Scott appealed against his visa revocation to the Australian Review Tribunal, which weighed up the factors for and against him being forced to leave Australia.
It noted that during those more than five years on bail, between being charged in 2017 and being convicted and imprisoned in 2023, Scott went and saw his former partner and asked for her help.
She said she would help, but only if he stopped using drugs. If he did not, the family would 'turn their back on him'.
The tribunal decision said this had a 'stunning effect' on him and he turned his life around.
Went 'cold turkey'
He immediately went 'cold turkey'. He told the tribunal he had not used illicit drugs since and even avoids painkillers such as paracetamol.
The tribunal said he was regularly drug-tested, and never failed a test.
His family and other people who know him are all 'certain' he has not touched drugs since 2017.
Scott began working up to 70 hours a week for an asphalt company and arranged for his ex to take over his finances, giving him a small amount to live on.
He reconnected with his children, one of whom drove him to a rehabilitation programme. A grandchild was born a few weeks before he went to prison.
'He had more than five years to commit further offences but did not do so,' the tribunal decision said.
'His behaviour since November 2017 has been exemplary.
'There was a trend of increasing seriousness in his criminal offending, but that trend came to an abrupt halt in 2017.'
Tribunal deputy president Damien O'Donovan said he was satisfied the risk of Scott engaging in further serious criminal behaviour was 'very low'.
O'Donovan said Scott has two adult children and two grandchildren to whom he is close.
'While he did everything he possibly could to ruin his relationship with them [his children] and their mother when he was addicted to drugs, the way in which he has gone about rebuilding those relationships is compelling,' O'Donovan said.
'The picture that emerges from the evidence is of a man with deep ties to the Australian community.
'Deportation would remove him from every important relationship he has in the world.'
The tribunal reversed the revocation of Scott's visa.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
13 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
'Terribly made': NZ buyers and shops hit by fake boutique clothing store scams
By Matthew Hutching of RNZ Online advertisements for fake boutique clothing stores with New Zealand locations in their names have been surging, with hundreds of complaints to Consumer NZ. An attractive photo of what looks like a designer garment can appear in your social media feed, taking you to a website for an apparently independent local clothing store. In many cases, there is an emotional message about the business closing down and all prices are on clearance sale. David Wellington is one of the many fake stores, aggressively targeting New Zealanders on social media. ''Sadly, we are forced to close our boutique,'' it says at the top of the website. ''What began as a simple idea - a father and his daughter wanting to spend quality time together - grew into something truly special. For the past 20 years, we have poured our heart and soul into creating clothing that reflects warmth, care and character. ''From shirts and jackets to trousers, dresses, sandals, blouses and bags - each item was made with love, with the hope of leaving a piece of ourselves in every detail. ''We built our boutique to be more than just a store; we aimed to create a welcoming space for our community here in New Zealand. But as the cost of living has continued to rise, keeping our boutique open has become increasingly difficult - and now, sadly, impossible.'' RNZ staff member Jeremy Parkinson was a recent victim of the scam. ''We read the story, looked at the pictures and made a couple of purchases,'' he said. When the garments arrived, he quickly realised they were fake. ''It was quite funny actually, because I opened them up and they were flimsy. Clearly not wool, really badly made, terribly made... I just laughed out loud. It was just a cable-knit pattern printed on God knows what sort of material.'' It was definitely not worth the $240 they spent, he said. ''They've gone to scammer school and they came top of the class. Initially they said, 'Yes we are a New Zealand company' and blah blah blah, and then they offered a refund, but we had to pay to send it back to China.'' Luckily for him, he had made the purchase through PayPal, which tried to contact the seller. ''It came back with a refund through PayPal because the seller hadn't made contact with them. So that was good. We got the money back.'' Others have not been so lucky. In the same week Mr Parkinson was scammed, RNZ heard from an Auckland woman who had lost $80 when buying an item on the David Wellington website using her credit card. She was not able to get a refund, but Consumer NZ's Sahar Lane said banks should be able to help. ''You can use a credit card or debit card. That way if things go wrong you can request a charge back from your bank,'' she said. ''Something else worth keeping in mind is that if you do go through the purchase, you can act quickly to make sure that your... details aren't compromised. You can call your bank and let them know that you've made a potentially dodgy purchase, or pause your card.'' Unfortunately, it was very difficult to enforce New Zealand's consumer laws on such scammers, she said. ''Under the Fair Trading Act, it is illegal for traders to mislead customers, give them false information or make misrepresentations, and under the Consumer Guarantees Act there's also protections. "If the item is faulty or damaged when it arrives or doesn't match the description, but it can be really challenging to enforce rights against an overseas entity.'' Online boutique fraudsters are also affecting New Zealand's real independent stores. Ms Lane said the best advice was still for the buyer to beware. Consumer New Zealand has a petition open at present called Stamp Out Scams. It wants to put pressure on the government to introduce a national scam framework that holds businesses to account. As for Mr Parkinson, he will be more careful. ''The lesson is to not make purchases in the middle of the night when you can't sleep. Really think about what you want and actually just make sure if you think you're buying locally that you are actually buying locally.''
Otago Daily Times
14 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Fake fashion scams hit NZ buyers and shops
By Matthew Hutching of RNZ Online advertisements for fake boutique clothing stores with New Zealand locations in their names have been surging, with hundreds of complaints to Consumer NZ. An attractive photo of what looks like a designer garment can appear in your social media feed, taking you to a website for an apparently independent local clothing store. In many cases, there is an emotional message about the business closing down and all prices are on clearance sale. David Wellington is one of the many fake stores, aggressively targeting New Zealanders on social media. ''Sadly, we are forced to close our boutique,'' it says at the top of the website. ''What began as a simple idea - a father and his daughter wanting to spend quality time together - grew into something truly special. For the past 20 years, we have poured our heart and soul into creating clothing that reflects warmth, care and character. ''From shirts and jackets to trousers, dresses, sandals, blouses and bags - each item was made with love, with the hope of leaving a piece of ourselves in every detail. ''We built our boutique to be more than just a store; we aimed to create a welcoming space for our community here in New Zealand. But as the cost of living has continued to rise, keeping our boutique open has become increasingly difficult - and now, sadly, impossible.'' RNZ staff member Jeremy Parkinson was a recent victim of the scam. ''We read the story, looked at the pictures and made a couple of purchases,'' he said. When the garments arrived, he quickly realised they were fake. ''It was quite funny actually, because I opened them up and they were flimsy. Clearly not wool, really badly made, terribly made... I just laughed out loud. It was just a cable-knit pattern printed on God knows what sort of material.'' It was definitely not worth the $240 they spent, he said. ''They've gone to scammer school and they came top of the class. Initially they said, 'Yes we are a New Zealand company' and blah blah blah, and then they offered a refund, but we had to pay to send it back to China.'' Luckily for him, he had made the purchase through PayPal, which tried to contact the seller. ''It came back with a refund through PayPal because the seller hadn't made contact with them. So that was good. We got the money back.'' Others have not been so lucky. In the same week Mr Parkinson was scammed, RNZ heard from an Auckland woman who had lost $80 when buying an item on the David Wellington website using her credit card. She was not able to get a refund, but Consumer NZ's Sahar Lane said banks should be able to help. ''You can use a credit card or debit card. That way if things go wrong you can request a charge back from your bank,'' she said. ''Something else worth keeping in mind is that if you do go through the purchase, you can act quickly to make sure that your... details aren't compromised. You can call your bank and let them know that you've made a potentially dodgy purchase, or pause your card.'' Unfortunately, it was very difficult to enforce New Zealand's consumer laws on such scammers, she said. ''Under the Fair Trading Act, it is illegal for traders to mislead customers, give them false information or make misrepresentations, and under the Consumer Guarantees Act there's also protections. "If the item is faulty or damaged when it arrives or doesn't match the description, but it can be really challenging to enforce rights against an overseas entity.'' Online boutique fraudsters are also affecting New Zealand's real independent stores. Ms Lane said the best advice was still for the buyer to beware. Consumer New Zealand has a petition open at present called Stamp Out Scams. It wants to put pressure on the government to introduce a national scam framework that holds businesses to account. As for Mr Parkinson, he will be more careful. ''The lesson is to not make purchases in the middle of the night when you can't sleep. Really think about what you want and actually just make sure if you think you're buying locally that you are actually buying locally.''
1News
a day ago
- 1News
Inquest into Australian triple murder cold case has 'extensive evidence'
An investigation into the murder of three friends while on holiday 46 years ago is gathering "extensive" evidence ahead of hearings into the cold case, a coroner has heard. Two of the slain were New Zealanders. Karen Edwards, 23, Tim Thomson, 31, and Gordon Twaddle, 21, left Alice Springs with their dog, Tristie, for a motorcycle trip to Mount Isa on October 2, 1978. Trixie. (Source: Queensland Police) The trio were found dead with gunshot wounds in remote bushland at Spear Creek, 12km north of Mount Isa. ADVERTISEMENT Queensland coroner David O'Connell was today given an update on preparations for an inquest into the deaths, which is due to start hearings in October. Counsel assisting Amelia Hughes said parties involved would receive a copy of the brief of evidence and witness list in September. "It's quite an extensive brief. That process is still underway with investigations ongoing," she said today. Edwards' sister and other family members listened remotely to the coroner's pre-inquest conference by phone. Thomson and Twaddle were family friends from New Zealand and shared a passion for motorcycles. Edwards was Thomson's girlfriend. Tim Thomson's BMW motorcycle. (Source: Queensland Police) ADVERTISEMENT Once they reached Cairns, the friends planned to head south to Melbourne for Christmas with family. They were last seen alive leaving the Moondarra Caravan Park in Mount Isa in a brown and white Toyota Landcruiser station wagon four wheel drive with a man on the morning of October 5, 1978. Queensland police in 2019 renewed a AU$250,000 reward for information which leads to the apprehension and conviction of the person or persons responsible for the murders. Former NSW prison guard Bruce John Preston was charged in April 2019 with the murders and granted bail in February 2020. Crown prosecutors dropped all charges against Preston in July 2023. The inquest will hold hearings over nine days in Brisbane Coroners Court from October 7. The hearings are due to end days before the 47th anniversary of the victims being found dead. ADVERTISEMENT Timeline of events Monday, October 2, 1978 – the trio embark on motorcycle trek from Alice Springs with Tim and Karen travelling with their dog on a distinctive red 1977 BMW 100S with a homemade side car carrying Tim's nine-month old Doberman, 'Tristie'. Gordon was riding a blue 1977 Suzuki GS750 with Victorian registration. The group travelled to Aileron and camped at Ti Tree in NT overnight. Tuesday, October 3, 1978 – the group stopped at Wauchope, 'Devils Marbles' and 'The Three Ways'. They meet a male motorcycle enthusiast at Frewena before camping with him overnight at Barry Caves. Wednesday, October 4, 1978 – group continued to travel with the man to Mount Isa but only Karen, Tim and Gordon checked into the Moondarra Caravan Park in the afternoon. On Wednesday evening, the trio were joined by a man in a brown and white Toyota Landcruiser. ADVERTISEMENT Thursday, October 5, 1978 – the trio are seen leaving the caravan park with the man in the Toyota Landcruiser, leaving the motorcycles and dog behind. Later on Thursday, the same vehicle returns to the park with a man seen alone looking for the dog. Friday, October 6, 1978 – all property except for the sidecar has been removed from the campsite and the dog located at the Mount Isa Dump. October 24-25, 1978 – the bodies of Karen, Tim and Gordon are discovered in bushland at Spear Creek November 13, 1978 – a 23-year-old local man is arrested after being found in possession of Tim's red BMW motorcycle. — timeline source, Queensland Police.
