logo
Readers' comments: Kerala HC's recognition of trans family is progressive but precarious

Readers' comments: Kerala HC's recognition of trans family is progressive but precarious

Scroll.in19-07-2025
The piece thoughtfully captured the Kerala High Court's progressive judgement recognising the right of a transgender couple to be recorded as 'parents' instead of 'mother' or 'father' on their child's birth certificate (' How a landmark Kerala High Court judgment recognised the existence of transgender families ').
The judgement not only reaffirmed the right of transgender persons to self-identify, but also takes it beyond: into the intimate and deeply social realm of parenthood and partnership. By allowing the transgender partners to be designated with a gender-neutral parental identity, the judgment simultaneously upheld the dignity of transgender lives while resisting the bureaucratic violence embedded in documentation procedures.
Nonetheless, a critical dimension that remained underexplored was how the construct of 'parenthood' itself is essentially binary. The court providing for a gender-neutral term like 'parent' marks a significant rupture. However, it still operates within a context where the very idea of parenting is saturated with heteronormative, cis-gendered expectations that are culturally disseminated along a male/female axis. Even the need to petition for neutral recognition reflects how deeply entrenched the binary structure of parenthood is.
While the ruling opens new possibilities, it also reveals the urgent need to rethink how the law and society continue to articulate childcare, family, and partnership through a gender-essentialist lens. A need for an intersectional analysis of transgender rights also emerges, one that would engage with how caste, class, disability, or religion may intersect with trans parenthood to create compounded vulnerabilities.
The ruling also exposes the uneven terrain of legal reform in India, where constitutional jurisprudence outpaces policy implementation. The judgement heavily relies on judicial interpretation in the absence of adequate legislative reform. Clearly, birth registration forms and state procedures still do not accommodate gender-neutral or non-binary categories systemically. As such, while the judgment is progressive, it is also precarious: it remains dependent on the discretion of sympathetic judges and the political will of administrative actors.
This indicates that without structural changes to registration norms, policy frameworks and civil service training, transgender parents and their children will continue to face systemic apathy. The judgement's full potential will only be realised through generating a broader jurisprudence that looks at childcare, partnership and family through the lens of lived, complex, and queer realities. – Swarupa Deb
***
The Kerala High Court has delivered a landmark ruling on the rights of the transgender community and respectable living in Indian society. It is also significant that the couple's interfaith marriage did not spark false allegations 'jihad' of any sort. The judge's acumen in understanding the difficulties faced by trans individuals and delivering a thoughtful ruling deserves praise. This was a perceptive story by Vineet Bhalla. Thank you, Scroll for such in depth stories. – Naresh Dev
Anti-India article on Indus Water Treaty
India has given away three major Rivers with 80% of the water in India's river system to Pakistan while retaining only one major river – Sutlej (' How the river flows: There is another way the Indus Water Treaty could help defeat terror '). Pakistan, as a lower riparian state, gets most of the water. China contributes little to the Brahmaputra water, most of which comes from India, Nepal and Bhutan. Always publishing anti-Indian articles doesn't make you fair. Scroll is being unfair by making irrelevant comparisons. It is no wonder you need help from people. – N Kanakasabhai
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Wrong to claim India halted Operation Sindoor under pressure, Rajnath Singh tells Parliament
Wrong to claim India halted Operation Sindoor under pressure, Rajnath Singh tells Parliament

Scroll.in

time9 minutes ago

  • Scroll.in

Wrong to claim India halted Operation Sindoor under pressure, Rajnath Singh tells Parliament

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh told Parliament on Monday that it was ' absolutely wrong ' to claim that India halted Operation Sindoor under any pressure. Opening a 16-hour debate in the Lok Sabha on the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor, Singh said that India decided to pause its action against the terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir as it had achieved its political and military objectives. The defence minister also said that nine terror camps were destroyed at the start of the operation of May 7, and that India has proof of damage caused inside Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. Singh said that the operation on May 7 lasted 22 minutes and was 'non-escalatory' in nature. He added that the armed forces had taken all precautions to avoid civilian casualties. 'Before executing Operation Sindoor, our forces studied every aspect and chose the option that would cause maximum damage to terrorists, while ensuring no harm to innocent civilians,' he said. Singh said that while the Opposition had questioned the government's claims, they had not once asked how many Pakistani aircraft had been shot down. 'I believe these questions do not reflect national sentiments,' he said. 'Their question should be whether India destroyed terror bases, and whether Operation Sindoor has been a success,' the defence minister said. 'The answer is yes. They should ask whether any of our brave soldiers have been harmed in the operation. The answer is no.' Tensions between New Delhi and Islamabad escalated on May 7 when the Indian military carried out strikes – codenamed Operation Sindoor – on what it claimed were terrorist camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. The strikes were in response to the terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam, which killed 26 persons on April 22. The Pakistan Army retaliated to Indian strikes by repeatedly shelling Indian villages along the Line of Control in Jammu and Kashmir. At least 22 Indian civilians and eight defence personnel were killed in the shelling. India and Pakistan on May 10 reached an 'understanding' to halt firing following the four-day conflict.

I miss you, mummy: Nimisha Priya's daughter seeks mercy in Yemen death row case
I miss you, mummy: Nimisha Priya's daughter seeks mercy in Yemen death row case

India Today

time9 minutes ago

  • India Today

I miss you, mummy: Nimisha Priya's daughter seeks mercy in Yemen death row case

Thirteen-year-old Mishel, daughter of imprisoned Indian nurse Nimisha Priya, has arrived in Yemen to appeal to the authorities for her mother's release. Accompanied by her father Tomy Thomas and Global Peace Initiative founder Dr KA Paul, the teenager is seeking mercy on behalf of her mother who has been sentenced to death in the Priya, a nurse from Kerala, has been behind bars in Yemen for several years. Her daughter has not seen her in over a decade. In an emotional appeal made in both Malayalam and English, Mishel said, 'I love you, mummy. Please help bring my mother back home. I so badly want to see her. I miss you mummy.'advertisementMeanwhile, Tomy Thomas, Nimisha's husband, made a direct plea: 'Please save my wife Nimisha Priya and help her reach her hometown.' Addressing Yemeni authorities alongside Mishel and her father Thomas, evangelist Dr KA Paul expressed his gratitude to the Yemeni authorities and the Talal family, reportedly involved in the negotiations. 'Nimisha's only daughter did not see her for 10 years. Mishel is here. I want to thank the Talal family. As soon as you release Nimisha, hopefully tomorrow, the day after tomorrow, we shall be very grateful. God will bless you,' he is seen saying in the video posted by Nimisha a 'symbol of peace', Dr Paul continued, 'The nation of Yemen will bring investments and prosperity when you address the world because Nimisha has become the daughter of India and the symbol of peace. What you are doing is an amazing gesture. God bless you. Love is more powerful than hatred, you are proving your love.'Dr Paul referred to the mission as 'purely humanitarian' and urged global attention to the suffering caused by war and hatred. 'We are unfortunately in a world that's crumbling because of wars and confrontation that are extremely unnecessary. We hope and pray that this mission will be a success so that it will be an example to many parts of the world that are suffering too,' he another religious leader — Sunni Muslim 'Grand Mufti of India' Kanthapuram AP Aboobacker Musliyar, from Priya's native state Kerala — had intervened too. The Indian government later said that its diplomatic outreach through friendly governments had led to the suspension of Nimisha Priya's execution, which had been scheduled for July are also underway to pay blood money to the victim's family, who have so far refused the offer and instead demanded that her death sentence be carried out. Nimisha's case has drawn international attention for years. Nimisha was convicted in March 2018 for the murder of her local sponsor. She was sentenced to death by a Yemeni court in 2020. Efforts to save her intensified over the past few months after Yemeni President Rashad al-Alimi approved her execution in December 2024. The matter escalated when Houthi leader Mahdi al-Mashat gave his approval for the same in January 2025.- Ends IN THIS STORY#Kerala

Abhishek Banerjee accuses ECI of working as an extended arm of BJP
Abhishek Banerjee accuses ECI of working as an extended arm of BJP

Hans India

time9 minutes ago

  • Hans India

Abhishek Banerjee accuses ECI of working as an extended arm of BJP

Kolkata: Trinamool Congress (TMC) national general secretary Abhishek Banerjee on Monday alleged that the Election Commission of India (ECI) was working as an extended arm of the BJP to help the party win upcoming elections in different states. Referring to the Election Commission's recently concluded special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, Banerjee said that it was such a shame that the commission was working as an extended arm of the BJP to help it gain an advantage in every election. 'It is helping the ruling party in the country to loot votes. Voting rights are being taken away from a large number of people. Even fake voter identity cards have been issued.. In the name of conducting SIR, people are being harassed. We have seen it happening in 2021 West Bengal Assembly polls when central force personnel had shot four people dead in Cooch Behar district's Sitalkuchi," Banerjee told media persons outside the Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International Airport in Kolkata. Responding to queries on the allegations of Bangladeshi Muslims and Rohingyas residing in Bengal illegally, Banerjee said it was the responsibility of the Union Home Ministry and BSF to stop infiltration. "Even if I agree that these people have entered the country illegally, then who is responsible for stopping their entry? Who mans the international borders? If the security of the country is compromised, then the Union Home Minister, BSF's director general, and IB director should resign,' he added. At the same time, Banerjee made a social media post on Monday, criticising calls to separate politics from sports and rejecting the idea of sporting ties with Pakistan. "INDIA MUST NOT ENGAGE WITH PAKISTAN in any sphere. The only engagement we should have with Pakistan is on the BATTLEFIELD, and the only prize worth WINNING is Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK)," Banerjee wrote. He accused Pakistan of exporting terror for decades and causing irreparable loss to Indian lives and families. "When a nation wages a proxy war, there is no 'neutral ground.' THERE IS NO CRICKET PITCH WISE ENOUGH TO WASH OFF THE BLOOD OF OUR MARTYRS," he said. He further stressed that while cricketers are respected, the nation owes its freedom and security to the armed forces. "Our TRICOLOUR flies high not because of a bat and ball, but because of the unmatched courage and valour of our armed forces. We honour our cricketers, but as a nation, we revere our soldiers."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store