New ESISC Report Exposes Systemic Failures in Wikipedia's Governance and the Growing Risks of Disinformation
The report, titled 'Wikipedia: Immense but Uncontrollable Power?', meticulously documents numerous cases where factual inaccuracies, ideological bias, and coordinated defamation campaigns have persisted for extended periods without adequate intervention from the Wikimedia Foundation. Notable instances include manipulations within the Croatian-language Wikipedia, partisan content related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and defamatory entries targeting public figures, journalists, and private citizens.
One prominent example cited in the report involves Le Point, a leading French magazine, which initiated a petition after being targeted by a smear campaign on Wikipedia. Another case concerns Tamaz Somkhishvili, a British-Georgian businessman whose Wikipedia page contains a series of false and defamatory claims. Despite multiple efforts to present verified evidence to counter these allegations, the harmful content remains accessible – a clear indicator of Wikipedia's ineffective redress mechanisms for wrongly targeted individuals.
The authors argue that Wikipedia's structure increasingly mirrors that of a social media platform rather than a neutral and reliable information source. The report calls on the Wikimedia Foundation to address these systemic flaws, emphasizing the need to align Wikipedia's operations with the European Union's Digital Services Act, which mandates more stringent measures against disinformation.
As the report's authors state:
'Wikipedia has become a dominant actor in the global knowledge ecosystem, but it lacks the editorial responsibility and accountability required by this role. The absence of oversight enables harm that can be long-lasting and difficult to repair.'
The report concludes with a series of practical recommendations, including:
Appointing editorial representatives for each language version of Wikipedia.
Introducing clearer correction procedures to address inaccuracies and defamatory content.
Developing a more transparent governance model that balances openness with accountability.
The full report is available online in both English and French:
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
12 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Russia's long-range bombers kept up attack tempo, showing fleet's 'resilience' despite Ukraine's Spiderweb attack: UK MOD
Russia's long-range bombers are still assailing Ukraine at a steady pace despite June's daring drone attack against the fleet, the UK's defense ministry said in a recent assessment. In an intelligence update on Wednesday, the British ministry wrote that it had observed seven long-range attack packages launched against Ukraine in July, involving at least 70 "premier munitions" — powerful cruise missiles. "Russian Long Range Aviation bombers have maintained their offensive tempo, continuing to demonstrate the resilience and retained capability of the fleet following Ukraine's Operation Spiderweb on June 1, 2025," the ministry wrote. Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 13 August 2025. Find out more about Defence Intelligence's use of language: #StandWithUkraine — Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧 (@DefenceHQ) August 13, 2025 The assessment comes six weeks after Ukraine launched a surprise drone attack on four airbases deep inside Russia that housed the Kremlin's strategic bombers and early warning aircraft. Using first-person-view drones transported via truck, Ukraine damaged what it said was at least a third of Russia's bomber fleet. Dubbed Operation Spiderweb, the attack was hailed as one of the starkest examples of how asymmetric warfare can endanger high-level military assets like the $150 million Tu-95MS bomber. Ukrainian officials have said that the attack inflicted $7 billion worth of damage. Before the attack, Russia was believed to field roughly 67 strategic bombers in its active inventory, and videos released by Ukraine show that at least nine of them were heavily damaged in Operation Spiderweb. Ukraine reported that the attack damaged or destroyed at least 41 total aircraft, but independent analysts have said it's difficult to affirm that claim. Crucially, these aircraft can't be easily replaced. Russia is believed to have ceased production of the Tu-95 and Tu-22M, and while it's still making the newer Tu-160, only two have been reported manufactured in the last three years. Notably, long-range bombers are also one of the three key pillars of Russia's nuclear triad. Still, Russia has continued to bombard Ukraine after the June attack with a combination of one-way attack drones and missiles. Russia typically relies on its strategic bombers to fire cruise missiles, most commonly munitions from the Kh air-to-surface missile family. After Operation Spiderweb, one of Russia's biggest strategic bomber attacks unfolded on June 6, when Ukraine reported that Moscow launched at least 36 Kh-101 cruise missiles in one night. Ukrainian media, however, at the time cited unnamed sources saying that Russian forces had to compensate for a reduced fleet during the attack by loading each bomber to full capacity. Either way, Russia has continued using its bomber fleet in high-profile attacks. On July 12, Ukraine's air force reported another wave of 26 Kh-101 cruise missiles fired into Ukrainian airspace. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said that in July alone, Russia had fired over 3,800 Shahed explosive drones and 260 missiles. However, he did not specify which of the latter were launched by strategic bombers.
Epoch Times
an hour ago
- Epoch Times
US Says Hamas ‘Walked Away' From Gaza Talks After Albanese's Palestine Pledge
U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee says the White House has expressed a strong level of disappointment towards Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's official pledge to recognise a Palestinian state. Huckabee says all nations that have declared support for a Palestinian state have done so at the wrong time.
The Hill
2 hours ago
- The Hill
Trump says he'd like to see journalists granted Gaza access
President Trump said on Thursday that he would like to see foreign journalists granted access to the Gaza Strip by Israel. 'I'd like to see that happen, sure,' the president told reporters at the White House. 'I would be very fine with journalists going. And it's a very dangerous position to be in, as you know, if you're a journalist, but I would like to see it,' Trump added. Israel has faced criticism for objecting to figures released by Hamas-run centers in Gaza and not allowing international reporters into the war-torn enclave. So far, foreign reporters can, at times, access Gaza, but only when being escorted by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). Israeli officials have cited security reasons for limiting reporters' access to Gaza. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said during a press conference on Sunday that he plans to allow more journalists into the Gaza Strip. 'We have decided and have ordered, directed the military to bring in foreign journalists, more foreign journalists, a lot,' Netanyahu said, according to Agence France-Presse. 'There's a problem with assuring security, but I think it can be done in a way that is responsible and careful to preserve your own safety,' the Israeli leader added. Trump's remarks on Thursday come just days after an Israeli military strike killed journalists Anas al-Sharif, Mohammed Qreiqeh, Ibrahim Zaher, Mohammed Noufal, Moamen Aliwa and Mohammed Al-Khaldi. The IDF has claimed that al-Sharif and others were closely linked to Hamas, a Palestinian militant group designated a foreign terrorist organization by the U.S. government, accusations that were strongly denied by Qatar-based outlet.
