Closing addresses underway in Erin Patterson trial
Erin Patterson's defence barrister has told the jury in her triple-murder trial that the "devoted" mother had no motive to deprive her children of their "wonderful" grandparents.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
SBS Australia
an hour ago
- SBS Australia
Tasmanian Police officer killed on duty identified as 25-year veteran Keith Smith
Tasmanian Police officer killed on duty identified as 25-year veteran Keith Smith Published 17 June 2025, 10:56 am Tasmania Police have identified an officer killed in the state's north-west. The officer was shot while attending a home in a rural area to serve a warrant for the repossession of a house. It's the first fatal shooting of a Tasmania Police officer in over one hundred years. The man who allegedly shot him remains in police custody in hospital and is yet to be charged.
ABC News
3 hours ago
- ABC News
Trump returns to US from G7 summit
Photo shows Ukraine Drone Strike: Screengrab shows a small drone hovering above a truck's trailer with a plume of smoke in the background. Has Video Duration: 1 minute 41 seconds . 1 m 41 s
Sydney Morning Herald
5 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘Who would kill these kind people?': Defence says lack of motive shows mushroom deaths were accidental
One thing everyone can agree on is that Erin Patterson's four lunch guests were all lovely people. Heather Wilkinson helped care for the accused woman's daughter, Ian Wilkinson was the local Baptist church pastor and Don and Gail Patterson were loving parents and grandparents. But on Tuesday, jurors in Erin Patterson's triple murder trial were told to put all their empathy and emotion for the group aside. Defence barrister Colin Mandy, SC, said that just like judges of the law, the jury must use their heads and not their hearts to decide on Patterson's guilt or innocence. 'In this case, three people died, one person very nearly did. This was a terrible tragedy for those people and their families,' Mandy said in his closing address on Tuesday. Mandy said it was clear that Ian Wilkinson was a good person, and there was no reason not to believe that Don, Gail and Heather were as well. 'There's two reasons why it's important to acknowledge that,' he said. 'The first is that as human beings, specially as members of this wider community, you [the jury] would have felt empathy for those witnesses and for the families and for their loss. A deep empathy because it's desperately sad.' But Mandy added that while jurors might have an instinctive reaction to say someone must be held to account for the three guests' deaths, their job was to decide whether a criminal offence had occurred beyond reasonable doubt. 'We know the actions of Erin Patterson caused the death of three people and the serious illness of another, and as ordinary people ... [that] might bring that desire for retribution or revenge. But a jury has to fiercely guard against that reaction.
