How did Jane Austen die? Even after two centuries, nobody knows.
When Jane Austen died on July 18, 1817, at the age of 41, she left behind only six complete novels—and one of the most vexing medical mysteries of all time.
No one knows what exactly caused her death. But Austen experienced a curious assortment of symptoms late in life, ranging from recurring fevers and fatigue to stomach issues and concerns over her changing complexion.
The enduring mystery has piqued the interest of scholars and armchair sleuths alike, who have proposed a variety of medical conditions to explain her death, including cancer and accidental poisoning.
(Murder or madness: What really killed Edgar Allan Poe?)
The act of posthumously diagnosing Austen is part of a larger cottage industry of retrospective diagnosis, the practice of applying modern medical knowledge to diagnose someone from the past. But can it shed any insight into Jane Austen's life—and solve the mystery of her death?
Born on December 16, 1775, Jane Austen appears to have had a relatively healthy childhood and young adulthood.
'Jane Austen was vigorous and active until her attacks of ill health in the last year or so of her life,' says Juliette Wells, professor of literary studies at Goucher College and guest co-curator of A Lively Mind: Jane Austen at 250 at The Morgan Library & Museum. 'Until then, her letters include many mentions of enjoying dancing, often for hours at a time, as well as long country walks.'
(Jane Austen never wed, but she knew how to play the marriage game.)
Austen's health took a turn around the age of 40 in 1816 while she was finishing the novel Persuasion. Her symptoms, which included rheumatism and fatigue, came and went, and she reported them in a series of surviving letters.
On March 23, 1817, Austen described her complexion to her niece Fanny Knight as 'black and white and every wrong colour,' and observed, 'Sickness is a dangerous indulgence at my time of life.'
Two weeks later, she complained in a letter to her brother Charles of having been 'too unwell the last fortnight to write anything that was not absolutely necessary.' She was 'suffering from a bilious attack attended with a good deal of fever.'
Around that same time, her niece Caroline Austen visited and noticed the 'alteration' in her aunt. 'She was very pale, and her voice was weak and low, and there was about her a general appearance of debility and suffering; but I have been told that she never had much acute pain.'
'Jane made her will in late April, several months before she died––suggesting an understanding that her condition was serious,' notes Devoney Looser, Regents' Professor of English at Arizona State University and author of Wild for Austen: A Rebellious, Subversive, and Untamed Jane.
The next month, Austen and her sister Cassandra moved to Winchester, England, where the novelist sought medical care for an unknown illness. 'The treatment was not effective, and Jane died […] in Cassandra's arms,' Wells says.
(A guide to Regency Bath on the anniversary of Jane Austen's birth.)
'I have lost a treasure, such a sister, such a friend as never can have been surpassed,' Cassandra wrote two days after her sister's death. 'She was the sun of my life, the gilder of every pleasure, the soother of every sorrow.'
Jane Austen's surviving letters, and those of friends and family, serve as the main sources for information about her death. But those letters don't give a full picture. In the wake of Jane's death, Cassandra destroyed many of her sister's letters, likely to protect her privacy and reputation—and unwittingly opening the door to rampant speculation. Did Jane Austen have Addison's disease or lupus?
What caused Jane Austen's death? One of the most prevalent theories, first proposed in 1964 by surgeon Zachary Cope, is that Austen lived with Addison's disease, a condition in which the adrenal glands can't produce hormones such as cortisol.
Addison's disease causes symptoms like the fatigue and skin darkening that Austen's letters describe. But there is one problem with that theory. In 2021, emeritus consultants at London's St. Thomas' Hospital with an interest in Jane Austen lore Michael Sanders and Elizabeth Graham pointed out that Addison's disease in Austen's era was typically caused by tuberculosis.
'Jane had no chest or orthopaedic problems to suggest TB, and both her doctors, Curtis and Lyford, would have been familiar with the diagnosis,' they wrote.
Instead, they proposed a different autoimmune disease, lupus, which would account for Austen's 'rheumatism, facial skin lesions, fever and marked fluctuation of these symptoms.' Did Jane Austen die of cancer?
Others, including biographer Carol Shields, believe cancer was a 'very likely cause' of the novelist's death, speculating that breast cancer may have run in Austen's family.
Looser agrees that cancer appears to be 'a more plausible diagnosis,' since it 'was not uncommon' in Austen's era.
If Austen had cancer, the risk of it metastasizing would have been high. 'The only available cancer treatment, surgery, was very risky in Austen's day,' Looser observes. 'It relied on being able to identify and excise the tumor, at a time when surgery itself could kill, due to the risk of infection.'
Other theories include Hodgkin's lymphoma. Jane Austen scholar Annette Upfal considered Austen's full medical history and concluded that the author may have suffered earlier in life than most believe, noting 'she was particularly susceptible to infection, and suffered unusually severe infective illnesses, as well as a chronic conjunctivitis that impeded her ability to write.'
In 2017, the British Library raised new questions about Austen's health when it tested three pairs of glasses that may have belonged to her and found that the glasses all had different lens strengths. According to the library, a consulting optometrist examined the results and said it was possible that Austen may have developed cataracts. He also floated a theory that those cataracts were caused by 'accidental poisoning from a heavy metal such as arsenic,' which was prevalent in the 19th century.
Looser considers this 'the least credible theory.' The glasses were 'found in her writing desk' but 'may or may not have been hers.' And though Austen was 'described [as] having weak eyes,' poor vision can have many causes—not just arsenic-induced cataracts. 'So you can see how this is a leap and a stretch––from desk to glasses to vision problems to arsenic poisoning,' she says. Why it's so hard to diagnose historical figures
In addition to examining old letters and belongings, scholars may also leverage surviving medical casebooks and physician's notes to diagnose historical figures. But even these shouldn't be taken at face value, notes Mindy Schwartz, professor of medicine at The University of Chicago. 'What they prioritize, what they leave out––these texts show the biases of the time and the priorities that the physicians had when creating them.'
It also shows the limited resources of the time. For example, physicians in Austen's era would have made a clinical diagnosis, which took into account the patient's history and a physical examination. But this probably wouldn't have yielded a definitive diagnosis because many conditions have overlapping symptoms.
'We didn't have microbiology, CAT scans, or blood work [at the time of her illness], so it would have been hard to make an accurate diagnosis,' says Schwartz.
Osamu Muramoto, senior scholar at Oregon Health & Science University's Center for Ethics in Health Care, also points out, 'Human beings are evolving, microorganisms are evolving, genes are evolving. So how can we say that disease X from 200 years ago is the same disease X as today?'
Even if you could posthumously diagnose historical figures, there is some debate over whether you should.
'Some people might be concerned that this is an invasion of privacy,' explains Steven Joffe, Art and Ilene Penn Professor of Medical Ethics & Health Policy and chair of the department of Medical Ethics & Health Policy at the University of Pennsylvania. 'In my opinion, those privacy considerations diminish with time.'
However, he adds, ethical considerations nonetheless should factor into any retrospective diagnosis. For example, any genetic conditions have implications for the person's surviving descendants. Muramoto also points out that there's a risk in making diagnoses that carry reputational harm because they are considered taboo, such as sexually transmitted infections.
At the same time, making retrospective diagnoses about historical figures can help normalize conditions that have long been stigmatized. 'Let's say you can convincingly show that Abraham Lincoln had major depression,' Joffe theorizes. 'To me, that is actually quite de-stigmatizing because it shows how somebody can have major depression and yet be one of the most influential people in American history.'
Making these diagnoses can also help recontextualize the historical figure's life and work. Take 19th-century philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, Muramoto says. 'He spent almost a decade with very, very poor health, mental illness, dementia.' Muramoto thinks tertiary syphilis is the likely diagnosis, saying it 'would explain, in my view, the paranoid tone of his later writings.'
This is likely not the case for Jane Austen. 'I wouldn't say her novels reflect the state of her health,' cautions Looser. Nonetheless, she adds, when Austen's symptoms were intensifying, she was starting to write Sanditon, an unfinished novel that 'features a send up of hypochondriacs and quack medicine.'
We might never know why Jane Austen died. But we do know that she could poke fun at illness, Looser says, 'even in the face of her own growing physical problems.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


USA Today
an hour ago
- USA Today
Cleo Laine, Grammy-winning jazz singer, dies at 97: Reports
British jazz singer Cleo Laine, who performed with musical greats such as Frank Sinatra and starred as an actor in London's West End and on Broadway, has died at 97, according to reporting from multiple outlets. The Guardian and The New York Times reported the news July 25, citing a statement from Laine's children, musicians Jacqui and Alec Dankworth. "It is with deepest sadness that we announce the passing of our dearly beloved mother, Cleo, who died peacefully yesterday afternoon," the statement to The Guardian read. "We will all miss her terribly. The family wish to be given space to grieve and ask for privacy at this very difficult time." The Stables Theatre, a U.K. music venue that Laine co-founded with her late husband, confirmed the news in a statement posted to its website. Born to an English mother and a Jamaican father in a suburb of London in 1927, Laine initially worked as a hair-dresser, a hat-trimmer and a librarian. She first married in 1946 and had her first son, Stuart. Driven by her dream of becoming a singer, she divorced and got her big break in 1951, when she joined the band of English saxophonist and clarinetist John Dankworth at 24. How Clementine Campbell became Cleo Laine At the time, she had thought she'd been born Clementine Campbell, though a passport application later revealed her mother had used her own surname Hitching on the birth certificate. The men of the Dankworth Seven band thought her name was too cumbersome for a poster, and that her nickname Clem was too cowboy-like. They settled on a new stage persona for her by drawing "Cleo" and "Laine" from hats. In 1958, she and Dankworth married. Their home became a magnet for London's jazz set: Friends included stars from across the Atlantic such as Oscar Peterson and Ella Fitzgerald, Lester Young and Dizzy Gillespie. After acting as well as singing in Britain through the 1960s, Laine toured Australia in 1972 and performed at New York's Lincoln Centre. The recording of a further show, at Carnegie Hall, won her a Grammy Award. Her recordings included "Porgy and Bess" with Ray Charles. In 1992, she appeared with Sinatra for a series of shows at the Royal Albert Hall in London, but she was best known for her work with Dankworth's bands. He later became her musical director. The couple built their own auditorium in the grounds of their home near London and were friends with Princess Margaret, the sister of the late Queen Elizabeth II. Their two children went on to become musicians. Dankworth – who Laine described as being "joined at the hip" with her – died in 2010. Hours after his death, Laine performed a scheduled show in their auditorium, announcing the news about her husband only at the end of the concert. Contributing: KiMi Robinson, USA TODAY


Eater
5 hours ago
- Eater
4 Restaurants to Try This Weekend in Los Angeles: July 25
Every Friday, our editors compile a trusty list of recommendations to answer the most pressing of questions: 'Where should I eat?' Here now are four places to check out this weekend in Los Angeles. And if you need some ideas on where to drink, here's our list of the hottest places to get cocktails in town. For a party atmosphere with equally vibrant food: Lucia A dimly lit room with a central bar with palm-shaped structures emerging at Lucia. Wonho Frank Lee Walking into Lucia, a vibrating new restaurant on Fairfax, begins with a funhouse mirror effect. But entering the space from the column-glass vestibule entrance moves the experience from a fractal one to one of integration — an experience that deals in high-concept design and unmitigated Black joy. Scalloped structures behind the bar mirror that cave-like banquettes that line the main dining room, where the mood lighting gets even moodier come 8 p.m., the time when Lucia's early-dinner energy turns into a more party-like late-dinner atmosphere with louder music and bigger groups vying for tables or bar seats. (The okra martini beckons.) Don't miss the vegan lychee ceviche, wine red from its sorrel infusion; the wagyu patties with mango scotch-bonnet sauce; the dripping jerk chicken; or the verdant snapper swimming in a coconut-culantro sauce. Bed it all in the equally coconuty rice and peas to sop up the sauces — and let the boisterous room be your entertainment for the night. 351 N. Fairfax Avenue, Los Angeles, CA, 90036. — Nicole Adlman, Eater cities manager For Los Angeles's most beautiful sourdough: Hasi Bread in Mar Vista A cut loaf of colorful blue and yellow sourdough bread from Hasi Bread. Matthew Kang Farmers market regulars Hasi Bread finally has a space to call its own. The sourdough bakery has settled into its first permanent space in the Del Rey/Mar Vista area in the former home of Hotcakes Bakes. Here, Hasi's signature yellow-and-blue sourdough bread, tinged with turmeric and butterfly pea flower, lives on full display. The rest of the pastry case comprises croissants, challah, English muffins, and more from baker Matias Barang. The bread is excellent in sandwiches, or as next-day French toast, but its best form may be with just a pat of salted butter. 4119 S. Centinela Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90066.— Rebecca Roland, deputy editor, Eater Southern California/Southwest For a comforting meal in the heart of Old Pasadena: Agnes Cornbread eclais with chicken liver mousse, chives, and Luxardo Cherries. Matthew Kang Thomas and wife/partner/cheesemonger Vanessa Tilaka Kalb have really put together one of Pasadena's most appealing restaurants of the past few years. Opened in the early days of the pandemic and navigating a challenging location in a mostly chain restaurant area, Agnes has managed to become a mainstay in Old Pasadena. The versatile space, with a cozy main dining room that overlooks an open kitchen, as well as the airy back patio, offers different experiences depending on the occasion. Soaring ceilings, open skylights, brick walls, black and white family photos, and grandma-print upholstery convey a place to relax and enjoy a meal. Most people will want to start with the cornbread eclairs topped with piped chicken liver and topped with marinated cherries. It's such a postcard of the Kalbs' Midwest sensibility with mid-century elegance. Hazelnut hummus acts as a spreadable pillow underneath the beet-Asian pear salad, a vegetable interlude before more substantial mains like the baked potato gnocchi, a truly brilliant dish that rejiggers the steakhouse side. Thai-inflected grilled skirt steak gains the smokiness of the wood-burning grill, while crispy Thai-style fried chicken would warm any grandmother's heart. Even the child's chicken tenders, long pieces of chicken cutlet, are one of the best kid's menu dishes in Los Angeles. The only caveat is that the cavalcade of rich cheese and heaviness from so much of the food will start to accumulate, so don't over order and leave room for either a cheese plate for dessert or the inventive s'mores choco taco to finish. 40 W. Green Street, Pasadena, CA 91105. — Matthew Kang, lead editor, Eater Southern California/Southwest To support two young hot dog entrepreneurs: Glizzy Street in Long Beach Hot dog, or 'glizzy' from Glizzy Street Mona Holmes If you're in Los Angeles and scroll through Instagram or TikTok regularly, then you know about Glizzy Street. In late June, the 16-year-old Chazz and Chaze Clemons opened their hot dog cart in their family's gas station parking lot. In less than one week, Glizzy Street went viral, and supporters drove in from neighboring regions, waiting up to an hour to try one of their bacon-wrapped hot dogs topped with onions, bell peppers, jalapeños, and barbecue sauce. The duo were recently flown to New York City to appear on NBC's Today with Jenna & Friends, upgraded their equipment with additional grills, gifted custom hats, and, well, you get the drift. The Clemons twins and Glizzy Street have hit the big time. The twins spend their morning prepping, then from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m., they serve their dogs, blue raspberry Kool-Aid, and aguas frescas. It's not as if one can't find these ubiquitous bacon-wrapped staples anywhere else in Los Angeles, especially when exiting a concert venue. But the Clemons brothers encapsulated something that the embattled region needs right now: Being part of a massive community that supports two young locals operating a budding business on the border of Long Beach and Compton. American Oil Gas Station, 6850 Long Beach Boulevard. Long Beach, CA, 90805. — Mona Holmes, editor, Eater Southern California/Southwest Related The 38 Best Restaurants in Los Angeles Eater LA All your essential food and restaurant intel delivered to you Email (required) Sign Up By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Matty Healy's Mom Shades Taylor Swift as Travis Kelce Posts Rare PDA Pics With the Pop Star
Denise Welch — the mother of Taylor Swift's ex-boyfriend Matty Healy — is making her feelings about the pop star known! On the Thursday, July 24, episode of Watch What Happens Live, host Andy Cohen asked Welch about her reaction to Swift's 2024 album, The Tortured Poets Department, which fans speculated was about her son. 'Obviously, on pain of death, can I talk about that episode, but not being her mother-in-law is a role that I am glad that I lost,' the English TV personality admitted. 'Not that I have anything against her at all. It was just — it was tricky.' 'She — listen, you're not allowed to say anything, and then she writes a whole album about it, but Matty has taken it all in completely good grace,' she continued. Welch said that the The 1975's lead singer, 36, is now 'very happy' with his 'gorgeous' fiancée, Gabbriette Bechtel, noting 'we've moved on.' Swift, 35, and Healy had a brief romance, dating from May to June 2023. The 14-time Grammy winner has since moved on with Travis Kelce, whom she linked up with in the summer of 2023. On the same day Welch appeared on WWHL, the Kansas City Chiefs tight end, 35, posted an Instagram Carousel showcasing how he spent his NFL offseason — which included making memories with the 'Cruel Summer' singer. The cover shot featured the three-time Super Bowl champion and Swift wearing all-white outfits and donning hats that read 'Captain' and 'First Mate.' Other photos included the couple at a restaurant, playing hockey and enjoying time with celebrity friends, including Charissa Thompson, Erin Andrews, Este Haim, Ashley Avignone, and Ross Travis. 'Had some adventures this offseason, kept it 💯,' Kelce captioned his post. Fans took to the comment section to gush over the rare content. 'Taylor genuinely looks so happy😭🥹❤️,' one fan gushed. 'Wait the 13 pictures are you kidding me 😭🥹,' a second fan pointed out, referring to how Swift's lucky number is 13. ''Thank you Travis!!!' we all said in unison,' a third fan wrote. The Chiefs official Instagram account also dropped a comment which read, 'Things we love to see: travis happy 🥹❤️.' In July, Kelce opened up about his relationship with the singer-songwriter on an episode of the Bussin' With The Boys podcast. 'We're having fun with it, man, being a couple,' he explained. 'We're just enjoying life and having fun going to hockey games, kinda introducing her to some more of the sports world.' Solve the daily Crossword