How did Jane Austen die? Even after two centuries, nobody knows.
When Jane Austen died on July 18, 1817, at the age of 41, she left behind only six complete novels—and one of the most vexing medical mysteries of all time.
No one knows what exactly caused her death. But Austen experienced a curious assortment of symptoms late in life, ranging from recurring fevers and fatigue to stomach issues and concerns over her changing complexion.
The enduring mystery has piqued the interest of scholars and armchair sleuths alike, who have proposed a variety of medical conditions to explain her death, including cancer and accidental poisoning.
(Murder or madness: What really killed Edgar Allan Poe?)
The act of posthumously diagnosing Austen is part of a larger cottage industry of retrospective diagnosis, the practice of applying modern medical knowledge to diagnose someone from the past. But can it shed any insight into Jane Austen's life—and solve the mystery of her death?
Born on December 16, 1775, Jane Austen appears to have had a relatively healthy childhood and young adulthood.
'Jane Austen was vigorous and active until her attacks of ill health in the last year or so of her life,' says Juliette Wells, professor of literary studies at Goucher College and guest co-curator of A Lively Mind: Jane Austen at 250 at The Morgan Library & Museum. 'Until then, her letters include many mentions of enjoying dancing, often for hours at a time, as well as long country walks.'
(Jane Austen never wed, but she knew how to play the marriage game.)
Austen's health took a turn around the age of 40 in 1816 while she was finishing the novel Persuasion. Her symptoms, which included rheumatism and fatigue, came and went, and she reported them in a series of surviving letters.
On March 23, 1817, Austen described her complexion to her niece Fanny Knight as 'black and white and every wrong colour,' and observed, 'Sickness is a dangerous indulgence at my time of life.'
Two weeks later, she complained in a letter to her brother Charles of having been 'too unwell the last fortnight to write anything that was not absolutely necessary.' She was 'suffering from a bilious attack attended with a good deal of fever.'
Around that same time, her niece Caroline Austen visited and noticed the 'alteration' in her aunt. 'She was very pale, and her voice was weak and low, and there was about her a general appearance of debility and suffering; but I have been told that she never had much acute pain.'
'Jane made her will in late April, several months before she died––suggesting an understanding that her condition was serious,' notes Devoney Looser, Regents' Professor of English at Arizona State University and author of Wild for Austen: A Rebellious, Subversive, and Untamed Jane.
The next month, Austen and her sister Cassandra moved to Winchester, England, where the novelist sought medical care for an unknown illness. 'The treatment was not effective, and Jane died […] in Cassandra's arms,' Wells says.
(A guide to Regency Bath on the anniversary of Jane Austen's birth.)
'I have lost a treasure, such a sister, such a friend as never can have been surpassed,' Cassandra wrote two days after her sister's death. 'She was the sun of my life, the gilder of every pleasure, the soother of every sorrow.'
Jane Austen's surviving letters, and those of friends and family, serve as the main sources for information about her death. But those letters don't give a full picture. In the wake of Jane's death, Cassandra destroyed many of her sister's letters, likely to protect her privacy and reputation—and unwittingly opening the door to rampant speculation. Did Jane Austen have Addison's disease or lupus?
What caused Jane Austen's death? One of the most prevalent theories, first proposed in 1964 by surgeon Zachary Cope, is that Austen lived with Addison's disease, a condition in which the adrenal glands can't produce hormones such as cortisol.
Addison's disease causes symptoms like the fatigue and skin darkening that Austen's letters describe. But there is one problem with that theory. In 2021, emeritus consultants at London's St. Thomas' Hospital with an interest in Jane Austen lore Michael Sanders and Elizabeth Graham pointed out that Addison's disease in Austen's era was typically caused by tuberculosis.
'Jane had no chest or orthopaedic problems to suggest TB, and both her doctors, Curtis and Lyford, would have been familiar with the diagnosis,' they wrote.
Instead, they proposed a different autoimmune disease, lupus, which would account for Austen's 'rheumatism, facial skin lesions, fever and marked fluctuation of these symptoms.' Did Jane Austen die of cancer?
Others, including biographer Carol Shields, believe cancer was a 'very likely cause' of the novelist's death, speculating that breast cancer may have run in Austen's family.
Looser agrees that cancer appears to be 'a more plausible diagnosis,' since it 'was not uncommon' in Austen's era.
If Austen had cancer, the risk of it metastasizing would have been high. 'The only available cancer treatment, surgery, was very risky in Austen's day,' Looser observes. 'It relied on being able to identify and excise the tumor, at a time when surgery itself could kill, due to the risk of infection.'
Other theories include Hodgkin's lymphoma. Jane Austen scholar Annette Upfal considered Austen's full medical history and concluded that the author may have suffered earlier in life than most believe, noting 'she was particularly susceptible to infection, and suffered unusually severe infective illnesses, as well as a chronic conjunctivitis that impeded her ability to write.'
In 2017, the British Library raised new questions about Austen's health when it tested three pairs of glasses that may have belonged to her and found that the glasses all had different lens strengths. According to the library, a consulting optometrist examined the results and said it was possible that Austen may have developed cataracts. He also floated a theory that those cataracts were caused by 'accidental poisoning from a heavy metal such as arsenic,' which was prevalent in the 19th century.
Looser considers this 'the least credible theory.' The glasses were 'found in her writing desk' but 'may or may not have been hers.' And though Austen was 'described [as] having weak eyes,' poor vision can have many causes—not just arsenic-induced cataracts. 'So you can see how this is a leap and a stretch––from desk to glasses to vision problems to arsenic poisoning,' she says. Why it's so hard to diagnose historical figures
In addition to examining old letters and belongings, scholars may also leverage surviving medical casebooks and physician's notes to diagnose historical figures. But even these shouldn't be taken at face value, notes Mindy Schwartz, professor of medicine at The University of Chicago. 'What they prioritize, what they leave out––these texts show the biases of the time and the priorities that the physicians had when creating them.'
It also shows the limited resources of the time. For example, physicians in Austen's era would have made a clinical diagnosis, which took into account the patient's history and a physical examination. But this probably wouldn't have yielded a definitive diagnosis because many conditions have overlapping symptoms.
'We didn't have microbiology, CAT scans, or blood work [at the time of her illness], so it would have been hard to make an accurate diagnosis,' says Schwartz.
Osamu Muramoto, senior scholar at Oregon Health & Science University's Center for Ethics in Health Care, also points out, 'Human beings are evolving, microorganisms are evolving, genes are evolving. So how can we say that disease X from 200 years ago is the same disease X as today?'
Even if you could posthumously diagnose historical figures, there is some debate over whether you should.
'Some people might be concerned that this is an invasion of privacy,' explains Steven Joffe, Art and Ilene Penn Professor of Medical Ethics & Health Policy and chair of the department of Medical Ethics & Health Policy at the University of Pennsylvania. 'In my opinion, those privacy considerations diminish with time.'
However, he adds, ethical considerations nonetheless should factor into any retrospective diagnosis. For example, any genetic conditions have implications for the person's surviving descendants. Muramoto also points out that there's a risk in making diagnoses that carry reputational harm because they are considered taboo, such as sexually transmitted infections.
At the same time, making retrospective diagnoses about historical figures can help normalize conditions that have long been stigmatized. 'Let's say you can convincingly show that Abraham Lincoln had major depression,' Joffe theorizes. 'To me, that is actually quite de-stigmatizing because it shows how somebody can have major depression and yet be one of the most influential people in American history.'
Making these diagnoses can also help recontextualize the historical figure's life and work. Take 19th-century philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche, Muramoto says. 'He spent almost a decade with very, very poor health, mental illness, dementia.' Muramoto thinks tertiary syphilis is the likely diagnosis, saying it 'would explain, in my view, the paranoid tone of his later writings.'
This is likely not the case for Jane Austen. 'I wouldn't say her novels reflect the state of her health,' cautions Looser. Nonetheless, she adds, when Austen's symptoms were intensifying, she was starting to write Sanditon, an unfinished novel that 'features a send up of hypochondriacs and quack medicine.'
We might never know why Jane Austen died. But we do know that she could poke fun at illness, Looser says, 'even in the face of her own growing physical problems.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Buzz Feed
8 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
50 People Learning Things In The Funniest Way Possible
Sometimes it feels like life is just one long lesson teaching us things again and again. Thankfully, not all of the things life teaches us are boring. In fact, some are PRETTY DAMN FUNNY! Here are 50 hilarious lessons people learned by just living their lives: This poor music fan learned that they should not do things — like use their AirPods — while sleep deprived: This grandpa had his kids over when he learned that his smart TV keeps a record of his previous searches: And this cat owner learned that kitties and blinds don't mix: These school girls learned there is a second purpose for traffic cones: This grandma is learning how to use email (sort of): And this worker at Fox learned that it's best to reread your work before putting graphics onscreen: This person learned that making their email address their business name (Mucky Pups) + their city name (Exmouth) wasn't a good idea: This restaurant worker learned the importance of proofreading: And these parents learned what happens when you let your teenage twins decorate their own birthday cake: This person learning English took a course that was VERY thorough: This traveler learned the hard (and gross) way they really should have scanned down to the English translation: And this linguist learned how to say "Hi!" in Mandarin: This wife learned never to leave her phone open around her husband: This guy is still learning how to get over his ex: And this mom learned that maybe, just maybe, she is on her phone too much: This person learned in a very painful way what these wipes are — and aren't — for: Tourists who visit this place learn there is a good reason two-story outhouses never caught on: And this person learned how to perpendicular park, LOL: This person learned that this fly swatter could give visitors to their home the wrong idea about their sex life: This person learned that a towel and some makeup were enough to anthropomorphize their washing machine: And this sign writer learned that phrasing is important: This mom found these drawings by her 4-year-old and learned it might be time to stop getting dressed in front of her kid, LOL: This city learned that going with the lowest bidder isn't always a good idea: And this person learned firsthand the old saying, "Life will lead you exactly where you should be": This person had an epiphany that they really should think through their permanent life choices more: This person learned that some fast-food workers are barely paying attention (I imagine they said something like, "Can I get a burger with a coconut shake and some ranch?"): And this person learned why you should NEVER wash a wool sweater in hot water: This traveler saw this sign and realized that some people urinate in cooler ways than the rest of us: This kid learned that if you're going to forge a fake note from your teacher, you gotta make it look more real than this: And the person who sent out this email is probably learning the same lesson: This woman learned that lily pads aren't as strong as they look: This fifth-grader learned how to write a three-paragraph letter in the funniest/laziest way possible: It reads:Dear [Name],I am [Name], and I'm in fifth grade. I have a school project where I have to choose a state, and I picked Missouri! For this project, I need to send letters to ten places in Missouri, so if you're reading this, consider yourself one of the lucky ones!It was really hard to pick which places to send letters to because all the places are so cool! There are three parts to this project: one is sending letters, another is collecting things from the places, and the last part is making a brochure with the information I gather. You're probably thinking, "Wow, that's a lot of work!" And yeah, it kind of is — I really need your help!If you'd like to help (which I hope you do!), please send some photos and information about your location. I'm not writing this letter for fun — I promise! I'd also love to visit someday, but I'm only 11, so maybe in the future. My teacher said this letter should be at least three paragraphs, so I'm trying my best here. Oh, and if you can, could you also send some artifacts or cool things from your area? That would be amazing (but only if you want to, of course).I think this counts as three paragraphs, right? Anyway, thank you so much for reading my letter and for sending anything back — even if it's just a short note. (But please don't send a hate letter! You know what they say in kindergarten — 'If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.') Okay, this is the end now — thanks again, and goodbye! Yours truly,[Name] And this third-grader really, REALLY needs to learn their proverbs: This person figured out the best way to get rid of your broken, old flatscreen TV (just bait some porch pirates): This kid is learning — slowly, LOL — to control his emotions: And this person learned it is a mistake to try to sneak out a fart near this indoor air quality monitor at their friend's house: This middle-aged man learned that eventually mom — even 25 years later — will find your stash book (and not be happy!): This grandma learned that "Merry Christmas" can be rearranged into something, shall we say, less festive: And this pub made it their mission to teach octogenarians to read the fine print: This person learned firsthand the old chestnut, "ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer": This person was walking through their park, learning about the local flora, when they stumbled upon this curious plant called a "lamp post": And this husband — upon discovering this pile — realized his wife is her workplace's official pen thief: This middle-aged couple is going to learn that not ALL products should be bought in bulk (unless they are really, really, REALLY irregular): The person responsible for this sign probably should learn some more math: And anyone who reads this will learn why men maybe shouldn't write advice columns: Anyone who read this sign learned the TRUTH: This person learned their dog is obsessed with carrots: This boss learned he should really lock his truck after this prank: This sign-maker learned that different age groups need different messaging: And lastly, this one will teach YOU something (it's wild how this actually works!):


New York Post
17 hours ago
- New York Post
This acclaimed novelist is also a master puzzle writer
When it comes to writing books, author Christopher J. Yates has a unique approach. 'My secret sauce for writing novels is I set to myself a puzzle I have to solve,' said Yates, who has published three novels and written for the puzzle pages of various publications — including The Post — for decades. His new novel, 'The Rabbit Club,' is a thriller set in academia. It exists in two time periods:1994, when wide-eyed 18-year-old Ali McCain arrives to study literature at Oxford University — and track down his English rock-star father — and 2019, when an unnamed academic in New York looks back on the events of Ali's formative years. Advertisement 5 Christopher J. Yates writes both novels and puzzles — and he says the process has more in common than you might imagine. Courtesy of Christopher J. Yates 'His voice just came to me, and I wrote like pages and pages of this crazy narrator. I was like, 'Who is this guy? I have no idea.' But I realized I had to solve the puzzle of who he was,' said Yates, a 53-year-old native of Kent, England, who now lives in the Hudson Valley. 'When I worked it out, I was like, 'No way, you can't get away with that. You can't pull it off.' And then I was like, 'What if I did it?'' Yates' earlier DELETE two novels, 2015's 'Black Chalk' and 2018's 'Grist Mill Road,' had puzzles of their own. Advertisement 'Black Chalk,' which is also set at Oxford, sees six students embroiled in a deadly game. The reader knows early on that one of them will die, but not which one. 'Grist Mill Road' takes place in a small New York town in the early 1980s. It starts with a teenage boy tying a young girl to a tree and shooting her with a BB gun, ultimately blinding her. The puzzle, Yates said, was figuring out why he did that. 5 Yates' new novel, 'The Rabbit Club,' is a puzzle of sorts, set at Oxford University. 'It could have been he's a psychopath, but that wasn't interesting to me,' he said. Advertisement Yates wrote about 80% of the book before the boy's motive came to him. 'I was terrified, and I just walked into my kitchen to make some tea, and this overwhelming explosion of information occurred in my head. I had to stop moving. I just stared into the middle distance as all of the answers kind of came to my head,' he recalled. 'I think it's like, people who've done crosswords will often experience. You can stare at a crossword, you can't get the last three answers, so you walk away, you do something else, you have some lunch, you come back, you look at the newspaper — and all of your answers just bang, bang, bang are in your head. I think your subconscious works it out for you.' Yates started writing puzzles — in the traditional sense — at age 22. 5 Yates's first novel, 'Black Chalk,' was also set at Oxford. It sees six students embroiled in a deadly game. The reader knows one of them will die, but not which one. Advertisement After graduating from Oxford, where he studied law, in 1993, he couldn't land a big job and took a six-week gig writing a database of crossword clues. 'That led to becoming a puzzle magazine editor and then editor of more important puzzle magazines,' he said. In his early 20s, he even represented the United Kingdom at the World Puzzle Championship in Holland. 'That was the most surreal experience of my life,' he said. 'Brilliant puzzle people aren't necessary completely normal.' 5 'Grist Mill Road' is Yates' second novel. It starts with a teenage boy tying a young girl to a tree and shooting her with a BB gun, ultimately blinding her. The puzzle, Yates said, was figuring out why he did that. He placed near the top in one of the rare word puzzles at the event, but most of the games involved math due to language differences. Overall, he was nearly last. Yates currently creates the weekly Word Force game for The Post. Last year, he published, with co-writer Bruce Pitchers, his first puzzle book, '5 Minute Murder: 100 addictive crime mystery puzzles for logical sleuths.' His fondness and aptitude for puzzles date back to childhood and visits to his paternal grandparents in London. Advertisement 5 Last year, Yates co-authored his first puzzle book, '5 Minute Murder.' 'They were literally Victorians and therefore never spoke to me and my sister,' he said. 'They would just give us puzzle magazines and leave us in a room and occasionally take us for a walk to the park and serve us dinner.' Yates, who begins most days playing the New York Times' 'Spelling Bee' game, is unsure if he has a natural knack for puzzles or just developed a skill or them while Grandpa smoked his pipe in the next room. 'It's hard to know, isn't it? Chicken or egg situation,' he said. 'But I do think my strongest suit in life is words.'


Buzz Feed
20 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
21 Hit Songs You Never Knew Were Actually Covers
Many people prefer certain song covers to the original, which is perfectly fine. On the other hand, there are songs that people are clueless about, even if they are song covers in the first place! Which means I can now rock out to two versions of these classics! Here are 21 songs you didn't know were actually covers: "1985" by Bowling for Soup is a cover of the song by American pop-punk band SR-71, which was released just two months earlier in Japan before the manager believed it was a better fit for Bowling for Soup. Although probably more well-known, the emotional song "Hurt" by Johnny Cash is a cover of the song performed by the rock band Nine Inch Nails. "Respect" by Aretha Franklin is a cover of Otis Redding's 1965 song by the same name. Franklin really flipped the lyrics on their head to create an all-time classic. "Renegades of Funk" by Rage Against the Machine is a cover of the Afrika Bambaataa & The Soul Sonic Force song of the same name. The song "It's My Life" by No Doubt is a cover of the English band Talk Talk's original release in 1984. The iconic "I Will Always Love You" by Whitney Houston is a cover of the 1974 song by Dolly Parton, which was featured on her famous album "Jolene." An absolute shocker to my '90s brain, but the 1997 hit song "Torn" by Australian singer Natalie Imbruglia is actually a cover originally sung by American rock band Ednaswap, which was released in 1995. The popular song "Don't Cha" by The Pussycat Dolls is a cover of the original song by Tori Alamaze. The popular '80s hit "Tainted Love" by Soft Cell is a cover of Gloria Jones's "Tainted Love," released in 1964. The song "Superman" by R.E.M. is a cover of "Superman" by The Clique. A B-Side track on the album "White Tornado," it's an R.E.M. gem. The mega summer hit from 1999 "Mambo No. 5" by Lou Bega is a sample of the original version by Cuban musician Dámaso Pérez Prado from 1950. The 1992 song "Achy Breaky Heart" by Billy Ray Cyrus is a cover of "Don't Tell My Heart," which was first recorded in 1991 by The Marcy Brothers. The song "If I Were A Boy" by Beyoncé was performed initially by BC Jean in 2008. The song "Black Magic Woman" by Santana is a cover of the song by Fleetwood Mac. Mind blown. In my defense, the Santana version has more views on YouTube than any other version by Fleetwood Mac. "Blinded by the Light" by Manfred Mann's Earth Band might be the more popular version, but it was originally written and recorded by Bruce Springsteen. The popular Joan Jett & the Blackhearts song "I Love Rock 'n Roll" is a cover of the British glam band Arrow's song "I Love Rock 'n 'Roll." "Dancing in the Moonlight" by the English band Toploader is a cover of the song originally recorded by Sherman Kelly's band, Boffalongo, which first released it in 1970. Then, Kelly rereleased the song with his new band, King Harvest, in 1972. So, technically, Kelly covered his own song. "Black Betty" by Ram Jam is a cover of a song credited to songwriter Huddie Ledbetter. The oldest recorded version was performed by James "Iron Head" Baker and a group of Texas prisoners in the 1930s. "Take Me to the River" by American rock band Talking Heads is a cover of the 1974 soul song by Al Green. The 1995 hit "Gangster's Paradise" by Coolio (ft. L.V.) is actually a cover of Stevie Wonder's "Pastime Paradise" from 1976. Lastly, and mainly for the youngins, Post Malone's cover of the alternative rock song "Only Wanna Be With You," originally released by Hootie & the Blowfish, is now a pop song featured in the Pokémon 25 soundtrack, which has 18M views on YouTube. Is there a song you were stunned to learn was a cover? Comment below (the song and artists)!