English school boards threaten to sue Quebec over budget cuts in education network
English school boards are threatening to sue the Quebec government over 'astronomical' cuts to the education network that they argue are unconstitutional.
The controversial cuts were announced at the end of the school year when the Ministry of Education said it would have to slash spending by more than half a billion dollars by fall 2025.
English school boards and French-language service centres were asked to cut $510.8 million from the 2025-2026 fiscal year, and an additional $56.9 million from the private schools – for a total of $567.7 million.
The Quebec English School Boards Association (QESBA) intends to file the lawsuit in the coming weeks.
President Joe Ortona said one of the main sticking points is the government's directive that bars the school boards from dipping into surplus money accumulated over the years to use as needed.
He said QESBA has made it clear that the government can't micromanage how English school boards spend their money and doing so would be in breach of the Court of Appeal judgment on Bill 40 earlier this year.
'It's been radio silence on their part, so they either don't understand it or don't care,' Ortona told CTV News.
'The government puts us in a position where we have no choice but to file a lawsuit because they think that they can run the education system in the English sector like it's a service centre, and we are not service centres. We fought for the right to keep school boards and fought for the right to have local management and control. As long as the government doesn't get that, it's unfortunate, but court challenges are going to keep mounting.'
Following mounting pressure from opposition parties and unions about the cuts, Education Minister Bernard Drainville said that the province would invest 'up to' $540 million for the school network and that all funds 'must be used to finance direct services to students, not for anything else.' The announcement on July 16 did not mention whether or not the requested budget cuts still stand.
The funding is conditional on many unreachable targets, Ortona said, including caps on hiring, despite school boards having already made hiring decisions for the next school year 'in conformity with the collective agreements that the government themselves negotiated with the union.'
'So the government's turning around and saying, 'You can't hire the jobs that you guaranteed to hire. And by the way, if the unions grieve and sue the school boards, you're left on your own to deal with that as well,'' he said.
Minister Drainville's office did not respond to a request for comment on Monday.
Ortona could not say how many school boards are planning to join the proposed lawsuit as they are in the middle of reviewing how the budget cuts will affect them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
‘Do not roll over': Ford says he told Carney to hit Trump back ‘as hard as we possibly can' on trade
Ontario Premier Doug Ford said he and his government will 'continue fighting' U.S. President Trump and his 'radical views.' Ontario Premier Doug Ford said he and his government will 'continue fighting' U.S. President Trump and his 'radical views.' Ford says he told PM Carney to 'not roll over' in trade negotiations with Trump Ontario Premier Doug Ford says he is urging Prime Minister Mark Carney to stand firm against renewed tariff threats from U.S. President Donald Trump. 'I wouldn't roll over, and I told the prime minister: 'Do not roll over.' Hit that guy back as hard as we possibly can. And that's what we need to do and we can do it,' Ford said Thursday. He made the comment while speaking with reporters at a news conference in Thunder Bay, Ont. 'We can build anything here in Canada, absolutely anything from the beautiful trains that we build here to the planes to automobiles to satellites to jet engines and the list goes on and on and on.' Both Carney and Ford were elected this year on the promise of standing up to Trump's economic threats against Canada. But despite meetings between Canadian and U.S. officials since Carney was elected in April, Trump has signalled in recent weeks that a new trade deal with Canada may be more slippery to pin down than hoped. Trump has threatened to impose 35 per cent tariffs on Canada if a trade deal is not reached by Friday, though goods covered under the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) would be exempt. Trump also posted on social media Thursday that Carney's announcement that Canada plans to recognize a Palestinian state 'will make it very hard for us to make a trade deal with them.' The U.S. has been demanding concessions from trading partners around the world, aggressively renegotiating trade deals to be more favourable to it. Ford said Thursday that Carney is trying to get a deal, but Trump is impossible to predict. 'You know, Prime Minister Carney is trying his best, but this guy (Trump) will say something one day, and he'll wake up and the cheese slips off the cracker, and then all of a sudden he goes the other way. And you're thinking, 'how do you deal with a guy like this?'' Ford said. 'Are we hoping that we can get a deal with zero tariffs, yes, but I always say, how can we kick back.' For his part, Ford said he is continuing to bolster Ontario's economy in the face of the trade threats by spending some $200 billion on infrastructure, as well as onshoring as many industries as possible, such as aluminum can manufacturing, in order to make Ontario less reliant on trade with the U.S. 'Now we're going to be making aluminum cans. They (U.S. manufacturers) are going to lose a billion dollars of the business in the U.S., and same with tin cans,' Ford said. He urged people to continue buying Canadian products whenever possible. Speaking to the Thunder Bay, Ont. crowd, Ford also reiterated that he is pushing the City of Toronto to go with Alstom for a deal to acquire 55 new subway cars for Line 2, a project the province is kicking in $758 million for. Alstom has a local manufacturing facility and Ford said that would mean bolstering Ontario's economy. 'I'm urging the City of Toronto and the federal government to reach a deal with Alstom. There's no way we're building them anywhere else,' Ford said. With files from The Canadian Press
National Post
an hour ago
- National Post
'Growing number' of state threats from Iran concern Canada and NATO allies
OTTAWA — Canada and many of its NATO allies released a joint statement Thursday condemning a 'growing number' of state threats from Iranian intelligence services. Article content The joint statement said the countries are united in their opposition to attempts to 'kill, kidnap and harass' people in North America and Europe. Article content The statement was also signed by the governments of Albania, Austria, Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Spain, Sweden, the United Kingdom and the United States. Article content It said Iranian intelligence services are increasingly collaborating with international criminal organizations to target journalists, dissidents, Jewish citizens and current and former government officials. Article content Article content The statement did not cite any specific incidents but said the attacks violate the countries' sovereignty and calls on Iranian authorities to 'immediately' put an end to illegal activities. Article content In 2022, Ottawa declared Iran's leaders — including senior government and security agency officials — inadmissible to Canada due to involvement in terrorism and human rights violations. The Canada Border Services Agency said last month that three people were found ineligible to remain in Canada in recent years because they were senior officials of the Iranian regime. Deportation orders were issued for all three and one has been removed from Canada. Article content Article content Hostilities in the Middle East have drawn more attention to the possible activities of Iranian regime representatives in Canada. The border agency has said it works very closely with domestic and international partners by sharing relevant information on border and national security issues. Article content
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
In Winnipeg, supporters hopeful after Canada says it will recognize Palestinian state
People with ties to Palestine and those who oppose Israel's actions in Gaza welcomed the news that Canada is planning to recognize the Palestinian state in September. But there's also concern that the move can be seen as rewarding the terrorist group Hamas, which controls the Gaza Strip.
