Pennsylvania Rejects Application for Cyber Charter School with AI Teacher and Two Hours of Daily Class
The Pennsylvania Department of Education on Wednesday denied an application for a controversial cyber charter school that uses artificial intelligence called Unbound Academy, which was seeking to operate in Pennsylvania.
The proposed school would have been part of a multi-state network of schools where classes are led by AI tutors and human staff serve as 'guides.'
Related
'The artificial intelligence instructional model being proposed by this school is untested and fails to demonstrate how the tools, methods and providers would ensure alignment to Pennsylvania academic standards,' the Department of Education's decision said.
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
Human teachers' unions and advocacy groups applauded the decision.
'AI can help teachers, but it can never replace a teacher guiding a student's learning in a classroom,' Pennsylvania State Education Association President Aaron Chapin said in a statement. 'Pennsylvania's students are better off because the Department of Education rejected this cyber charter school application today.'
Susan Spicka, the executive director of Education Voters of PA, a nonprofit advocacy group, called Unbound Academy's cyber charter application 'egregiously deficient.'
Related
The decision to reject the application cited multiple issues with Unbound Academy's initial proposal. Those included concerns about unrealistic projections for enrollment growth, whether the school could attain insurance and its ability to support special education based on the proposed budget and tuition rates.
The Department of Education also said Unbound Academy's application failed to provide sufficient information about the curriculum, courses and planned student activities.
'The department finds multiple, significant deficiencies,' the decision read. 'These deficiencies, individually, collectively, and in any combination, are cause to deny the application. '
The website for 2 Hour Learning, the company that provides the AI model Unbound Academy hoped to use, says their students 'crush academics' at an accelerated pace with only two hours of academic instruction per day, based on data from their flagship 'Alpha School.'
'Traditional school is broken. It's outdated, full of busywork, and sadly for our kids, often a waste of time,' Mackenzie Price, the co-founder of 2 Hour Learning, says in a promotional video on their website. She said students at schools using their technology can learn 'twice as much in two hours per day as they would in six hours of traditional school.'
Related
The company says their program is already being used in schools in Texas and Florida, with more set to open in California and Arizona this fall.
Since it was announced, the proposed cyber charter school raised red flags with critics of cyber charter schools, as well as lawmakers in Harrisburg.
Sen. Lindsey Williams (D-Allegheny), the minority chair of the Senate Education Committee, said she plans to introduce a bill calling for a moratorium on the approval of new cyber charter schools, citing Unbound Academy specifically. A memo seeking co-sponsors said operators of schools like Unbound Academy 'perceive our state as ripe for profiteering off of Pennsylvania's children and taxpayers.'
The proposal is backed by Education Voters of PA.
Related
There are currently 14 cyber charter schools operating in Pennsylvania, and they've experienced an enrollment boom since the outbreak of the COVID pandemic. The schools are funded with taxpayer money, taken in part from the budgets of local school districts where their students would have otherwise enrolled. Though last year's changes to the school funding formula eased that burden by providing reimbursements for some of those lost funds.
This week, Education Voters of Pennsylvania released a report on spending at the state's largest online charter school, Commonwealth Charter Academy. They found that hundreds of thousands of dollars were used on vehicles, dining, travel, entertainment and retail purchases.
Commonwealth Charter Academy's chief branding and government relations officer told the Capital-Star that the findings were 'cherry-picked' and the expenditures were 'well within what is customary for organizations of like size that have a statewide footprint'
Related
A 2019 Department of Education report found that students at cyber charter schools typically performed worse or the same as those in traditional public schools based on academic tests. However, cyber charter students typically had higher rates of attendance and graduation.
A contact listed on Unbound Academy's application did not respond to a request for comment.
Related
Pennsylvania Capital-Star is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Pennsylvania Capital-Star maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor for questions: info@penncapital-star.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
6 hours ago
- Newsweek
Student Loan Forgiveness Backlog Surges
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A federal program designed to help public service workers erase student debt is facing a growing backlog, with little sign of relief. Last week, a Department of Education court filing showed that the queue for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) Buyback program had continued to swell in recent months, even as the agency processed applications. The program allows borrowers to make a lump-sum payment so that periods of deferment or forbearance—when loan payments are temporarily paused—count toward the 10 years of qualifying payments required for Public Service Loan Forgiveness. The program is designed to ensure that nonpayment periods are counted toward loan forgiveness. Newsweek has contacted the Department for Education for comment via email. Why It Matters Over the past year, tens of thousands of borrowers caught in SAVE plan forbearance have turned to PSLF Buyback for relief. The program has become especially critical as about 8 million Americans have been barred from making student loan payments following a court injunction that temporarily halted the SAVE plan because of a Republican-led legal challenge. Because time spent in forbearance under SAVE does not count toward loan forgiveness, many borrowers who have already completed years of qualifying public service find themselves in uncertainty. PSLF Buyback was created to bridge that gap, particularly for those approaching the end of their 10-year repayment timeline. An exterior view of the Lyndon Baines Johnson (LBJ) Department of Education Building in Washington, D.C., on June 24, 2022. An exterior view of the Lyndon Baines Johnson (LBJ) Department of Education Building in Washington, D.C., on June 24, 2022. GETTY The Growing Backlog Even as some applications are processed, the department has struggled to keep up with demand. In its first filing on PSLF Buyback earlier this year, part of an interim agreement to provide monthly updates following a legal challenge over income-driven repayment plan delays, the department reported that it had processed 1,472 applications in April—with 49,318 still in the queue. In May, the number of pending requests grew to 58,761, while 3,312 requests were processed. At the end of June, there were 65,448 pending requests, with 2,224 given a decision that month. In July, the backlog grew further to 72,730, with 3,280 requests being processed. Overall, there has been a 47 percent increase in the number of requests between April and July. There is also a backlog for applications for income-driven repayment plans as many borrowers in SAVE forbearance have sought to switch into other plans to continue making progress toward loan forgiveness. The Trump administration increased pressure on borrowers to change plans after resuming interest charges earlier this month for those enrolled in SAVE. "The Department urges all borrowers in the SAVE Plan to quickly transition to a legally compliant repayment plan—such as the Income-Based Repayment Plan," Secretary of Education Linda McMahon said in a statement in July. "Borrowers in SAVE cannot access important loan benefits and cannot make progress toward loan discharge programs authorized by Congress." A major obstacle for borrowers is that switching repayment plans is not a quick process. The Department of Education is dealing with a massive backlog of income-driven repayment (IDR) applications, a problem made worse when the Trump administration temporarily shut down the entire processing system in the spring. While the department has reported some progress, the logjam remains significant. Last month, officials reported 1,511,504 pending IDR applications. As of the latest filing, the backlog had dropped to 1,386,406, with 304,844 applications processed in July.
Forbes
7 hours ago
- Forbes
Student Loans With This Servicer Will Be Transferred Within Months, Says Department Of Education
The Department of Education will begin transferring an unknown number of federal student loans from MOHELA to other servicers by the end of the year, according to recent correspondence between Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Secretary of Education Linda McMahon. The move could have significant impacts for thousands of student loan borrowers. The department outsources management of its vast federal student loan portfolio to several outside contractors. The current array of student loan servicers includes Nelnet, Aidvantage, EdFinancial, and MOHELA. MOHELA, which previously had managed the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program before its operations were migrated to has been the subject of withering criticism by student loan borrower advocacy organizations and elected officials for billing errors and poor customer service, not just limited to the PSLF program. For frustrated student loan borrowers whose accounts are currently handled by MOHELA, a transfer to a different loan servicer may be welcome news. But loan servicing transfers have historically been disruptive, and can sometimes lead to additional problems. Here's what borrowers should know. Department of Education Will Transfer Student Loans From MOHELA This Year The Department of Education confirmed last month that it plans to transfer federal student loan accounts from MOHELA to other loan servicers later this year. 'FSA is prioritizing efforts to improve customer service to students and parent borrowers,' said Sarah Ursprung, Acting Assistant Secretary for Legislation and Congressional Affairs at the Department of Education in a letter sent to Senator Warren last month. 'FSA is collaborating with MOHELA to help the servicer manage the multiple strains on its portfolio to help drive overall improvement. As part of these efforts, FSA intends to transfer a portion of MOHELA's PSLF portfolio to other servicers later this year.' Ursprung did not provide specifics, however, in terms of the number of accounts that will be transferred to other student loan servicers, the timeline of these transfers, or which of the department's other servicers will receive the transferred accounts. However, Ursprung suggested that some, but not necessarily all, borrowers who are on track for PSLF would be subject to a loan servicing transfer. Now that MOHELA is no longer managing the PSLF program following the system migration to that was completed last year, borrowers do not need to be with a specific servicer to pursue student loan forgiveness under the program. MOHELA Has Been Criticized For Badly Managing Student Loans MOHELA has been widely criticized for its student loan servicing practices. Under the Biden-Harris administration, the loan servicer was penalized for allegedly sending untimely or incorrect billing statements to borrowers. More recently, MOHELA sent letters to borrowers containing misleading information about interest accrual; MOHELA subsequently issued a clarifying statement. The servicer has also been accused of using controversial call deflection tactics resulting in extremely long call hold times and an inability for borrowers to reach customer service agents to help them navigate an increasingly complex federal student loan system. A joint report released last year by the Student Borrower Protection Center and the American Federation of Teachers accused MOHELA of intentionally pushing student loan borrowers into a 'byzantine loop of misinformation and false promises." 'The 'call deflection' scheme diverts borrowers away from customer service representatives—often to non-operative parts of the MOHELA website—even though many servicing functions can only be performed by a customer service representative,' said the SBPC and AFT in a joint statement announcing the report last year. Senator Warren echoed many of these criticisms in her response earlier this month to the Department of Education's letter confirming that student loan accounts with MOHELA will soon be transferred to other loan servicers. 'You also disclosed that ED will be moving some of the Missouri Higher Education Loan Authority's (MOHELA's) federal student loan portfolio to other servicers later this year, a process that the Biden Administration set into motion given MOHELA's abysmal performance,' said Senator Warren in her response letter. 'You admitted that you were doing so to improve MOHELA's performance, and I appreciate your acknowledgement and action—to my knowledge, the first such admission from the Trump Administration—in response to MOHELA's failures to adequately serve borrowers.' Warren went on to say, 'MOHELA has consistently exhibited atrocious customer service, even compared to all other federal student loan servicers. For example, in the fourth quarter of 2024, MOHELA took roughly seven times as long to answer phone calls from borrowers compared to the servicer with the second-worst average wait time.' In her letter, Warren demanded that Secretary McMahon release more information on MOHELA's performance, and explain how the department would respond if MOHELA's student loan servicing operations do not improve. MOHELA has vehemently denied allegations of poor customer service or inadequate student loan servicing. 'Any claims that MOHELA does not act in the best interest of the borrowers we serve as a federal contractor is simply not true,' said a MOHELA spokesperson last year in response to the SBPC and AFT report. "MOHELA's priority has always been on helping the student borrowers that we are here to serve while they navigate the often complex and overwhelming federal repayment process, and that is what we remain proudly committed to doing." And the Department of Education under the Trump administration has defended MOHELA, arguing that its operations are improving. 'MOHELA's performance is steadily showing progress, and FSA's focus remains on improving the borrower experience,' said Ursprung in her letter to Senator Warren last month, appearing to acknowledge that MOHELA's loan servicing operations may have had some room for improvement. 'The Department looks forward to continuing to review the performance of all our current contractors with the goal of improving service delivery on behalf of American students, their families, and taxpayers.' Transferring Student Loans To Other Servicers Can Cause New Problems While borrowers who have been frustrated by MOHELA's performance may welcome a transfer to a different student loan servicer, historically these types of transfers have not always gone well. 'Where a borrower's data has become lost or corrupted as a result of poor data management by a particular servicer, subsequent transfers may result in servicers sending inaccurate periodic statements, borrowers losing progress toward forgiveness, and borrowers having difficulty in rectifying past billing errors,' said the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in a 2022 report. The Department of Education sought to provide assurances that any student loan servicing transfers would go smoothly. 'This work will be done thoughtfully and in a responsible way that avoids negative impacts to borrowers,' said Ursprung in her letter last month. The CFPB urges borrowers who may be subject to student loan servicing transfers in the coming months to remain vigilant. The agency suggests that borrowers ensure their contact details with their current loan servicer and at are up to date and accurate; open all correspondence (mail and email) that is sent by the Department of Education and its contracted loan servicers; download and save key records and correspondence including payment histories and important letters; and be prepared to have to re-establish auto-debit or billing information to keep student loans on track once the loan servicing transfer has occurred.
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
N.J. town's property taxes soar as school district struggles with ‘nothing left' in reserves
Old Bridge homeowners are facing nearly a 10% increase in their property tax bills this year, and township officials say the schools are largely to blame. The Township Council held a meeting Aug. 12 after fielding weeks of calls and letters from residents upset over the spike. For a home assessed at the township average of $157,373, the total property tax bill rose about $900 to $9,950. The largest factor, officials said, was the school tax levy, which jumped 13.87% and added more than $728 to the average bill. Mayor Debbie Walker said the township has been unfairly blamed for the increase, even though it only controls the municipal tax rate — which rose just 1.58% this year compared to the school district's double-digit hike. 'Some people just don't have that money to put out, and it's not only senior citizens this tax increase is affecting. It's affecting young families that just bought their homes,' Walker said. 'The only thing we can control is our municipal tax. And I hate that we're taking the blame for this very large increase because I wouldn't do this to residents,' the mayor added. The median household income in the town was about $106,900 in 2023, according to the latest U.S. Census data. Tensions rose at the council's tax presentation meeting, with some members blaming the school district for shifting the burden onto taxpayers. But Old Bridge Public School officials say they've been forced into difficult decisions of their own — weighing steep tax hikes against deep cuts to programs and services. Before approving their $185 million budget for the 2025-26 school year in May, school officials warned they were staring at an $18 million deficit fueled by state aid reductions. Since New Jersey revised its school funding formula in 2018, the district has lost millions in aid, forcing the district to sell property, close an elementary school and eliminate about 85 staff positions. 'There's nothing left. We've been able to plug holes with reserves, but there are no more reserves,' board member Marjorie Jodrey said at the district's May budget hearing. 'We're already operating on reduced staff and programs, and we still need to give Old Bridge students a good education.' Rising expenses including salaries, benefits, energy and transportation have only deepened the gap, alongside this year's 3% cut in state aid, the board said. Old Bridge will receive about $23.6 million in state funding for the upcoming school year — $730,000 less than last year, according to state Department of Education figures. Without raising taxes, the district's shortfall could have forced drastic cuts — including eliminating full-day kindergarten, closing schools, reducing elementary art programs and scaling back security coverage, officials said. To help close this year's gap, the district applied for the state's Tax Levy Incentive Aid program, which provides additional funding to districts that increase their local tax levy. The application was approved earlier this month. New Jersey's school funding law, fully implemented for the first time last year, was intended to shift aid from districts deemed 'overfunded' to those historically underfunded. But the Old Bridge Board of Education argues the formula unfairly penalizes their community, leaving them little choice but to raise the school tax levy. Student enrollment in Old Bridge has steadily declined over the past six years to about 8,000 across its 14 public schools — a drop officials say is another factor affecting funding. Across New Jersey, districts grappling with steep faid cuts have resorted to similar drastic measures, from raising property taxes to laying off staff and closing schools. Recently, the Jackson School District in Ocean County filed a lawsuit blaming the loss of two schools, 385 jobs and major program cuts on what officials called the state's 'systemic and unconstitutional underfunding.' Our journalism needs your support. Please subscribe today to Nyah Marshall may be reached at nmarshall@ Solve the daily Crossword
