logo
Drowning victim's family seeks law to prosecute people posting video of tragedies online

Drowning victim's family seeks law to prosecute people posting video of tragedies online

Irish Times06-05-2025
A friend of a man who drowned in the River Lee in Cork
while people filmed the tragedy rather than coming to his aid
has called for the introduction of legislation to prosecute people who film and post such tragedies online.
Kelly Ann Peyton was a close friend of Luke Hyde (33),
who got into difficulty while swimming in the north channel of the River Lee
on April 29th. She said she and Mr Hyde's family are seeking to have legislation introduced to stop people filming such unfolding tragedies.
Ms Peyton told The Neil Prendeville Show on Cork's Red FM that she believed '100 per cent' that it should be an offence to film a tragedy like what happened to Mr Hyde and the legislation should be called 'Luke's Law' to save other families from going through what the Hyde family have had to endure.
Mr Hyde had gone to swim across the north channel of the Lee from Pope's Quay to Lavitt's Quay with a friend who made it across, and she had since spoke to Mr Hyde's friend who told her people had lined the quays and filmed the tragedy on their phones rather than help.
READ MORE
'As far as I know, he [Mr Hyde] reached out for help in the water a few times, his hand went up as if to say, 'Help'. There was loads of people around the quay wall, and they were all pointing [phones] at him... not one person took a life buoy - and there are four either side - and threw one in,' she said.
'It should be an offence, because when the guards and the ambulance personnel arrived on the scene, they had to fight, like, practically push people out of the way to get in, to try and lend help to get Luke, to get him out of the water.'
Mr Hyde's mother, Lily, had spoken last week on The Neil Prendeville Show of her horror and disgust when she arrived on the scene to discover her son had drowned while scores of people had lined Pope's Quay, Lavitt's Quay and the linking Shandon Footbridge to watch and film the tragedy.
'Luke … was my baby son. I was disgusted when I heard you talking this morning about those people down there. It was like a circus, watching my son drown, instead of trying to help him,' said Ms Hyde, who had lost another son, Brian, in 2019.
'What have people in this world come to? Morons, I don't think there's even a word to describe them. It will never leave me, and the clips I saw on the news... I don't know how I'll ever, ever forget it. I never will, it will live with me forever more.'
Ms Peyton said she and the Hyde family would lobby local Cork North Central TDs such as Thomas Gould and Ken O'Flynn to table legislation on the floor of the Dáil to make it an offence to film and post footage of such tragedies online.
Ms Peyton said she had trawled the internet over the weekend for footage of the tragedy, and while such material appeared to have been taken down from major social platforms, she appealed to anyone who may have received film footage on their phones to delete it out of respect for the Hyde family.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Gardaí rule out foul play after man's body found in Cork house
Gardaí rule out foul play after man's body found in Cork house

Irish Times

time2 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Gardaí rule out foul play after man's body found in Cork house

Gardaí investigating the death of a man in his fifties, whose body was found in a Cork city property yesterday, have ruled out foul play. The alarm was raised at 4pm on Tuesday, August 5th, by a man who was passing by at Lower Barrack View, off Cathedral Walk, and spotted the body inside a window of a terraced house. Gardaí attended the scene and discovered the man's body inside. The Office of the State Pathologist was notified and the scene was preserved for a full technical examination. There was no evidence of forced entry at the property. A postmortem examination was carried out today at Cork University Hospital. The death is not being treated as suspicious. READ MORE Gardaí will prepare a file for the Cork City Coroner and an inquest is expected to be heard at a later date.

Man (59) charged over €2.1m Cork drug seizure ‘maintaining his innocence', court hears
Man (59) charged over €2.1m Cork drug seizure ‘maintaining his innocence', court hears

Irish Times

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Man (59) charged over €2.1m Cork drug seizure ‘maintaining his innocence', court hears

A truck driver charged in connection with a €2.1 million drug seizure in Cork is 'maintaining his innocence' in the matter, a court has heard. Robert Slivar (59), of no fixed abode, but formerly of Ivanic in Croatia , appeared before a special sitting of Cork District Court last Saturday. He was charged with two offences relating to the seizure of 93 packages of herbal cannabis with a weight of 107kg. Mr Slivar, who travelled to Cork by ferry from Zeebrugge in Belgium, was charged with cannabis possession and possession of cannabis for sale or supply at the Port of Cork, Ringaskiddy, on July 27th. . The alleged offence is contrary to section 3 and section 15 of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977. Det Garda Ryan Dillon previously objected to bail in the case, citing the strength of evidence and the seriousness of the charge facing the accused. He said Mr Silvar made no reply after each charge was put to him under caution. READ MORE At Cork District Court on Wednesday, defence solicitor Diarmuid Kelleher told Judge John King that his client maintains his innocence of any wrongdoing. A statement of means was handed in to the court and free legal aid was assigned. Mr Kelleher said the employers of the accused were 'very concerned about their truck'. Mr Silvar, who was not required to speak, was assisted throughout the short hearing by a Croatian interpreter. Sgt John Kelleher applied for a four-week remand in the case, which he described as being in its 'early stages.' He said that 'DPP directions are still outstanding.' Judge King remanded Mr Silvar in custody to appear in court by video link on August 20th for directions.

Man denies involvement in arson attack causing €550,000 damage to elderly couple's home
Man denies involvement in arson attack causing €550,000 damage to elderly couple's home

Irish Times

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Man denies involvement in arson attack causing €550,000 damage to elderly couple's home

A man accused of involvement in an arson attack that caused €550,000 damage to an elderly couple's home is 'protesting his innocence', a court has heard. Paul McCarthy (37) appeared before Cork District Court on Wednesday on a charge of arson at Fernbrook in Ballincrokig, Co Cork, on April 24th. The court has heard Mr McCarthy, of Dowth Avenue, Cabra, Dublin, was allegedly one of three men who drove from Dublin to Cork to set fire to the house. Gardaí allege the arson was video recorded by one of the men and that the pensioners were not the target of the attack. READ MORE Sgt John Kelleher told Judge John King that €550,000 in fire damage was caused to the property. He said this led to the 'complete destruction' of the house. Mr McCarthy has been remanded in custody since May 7th in connection with this incident. Sgt Kelleher said forensic results were awaited in the case following the search of two properties. He applied for Mr McCarthy to be remanded in custody for four further weeks. Nicholas Hall, defending, said his client insisted he was innocent of the crime. He said searches were carried out 'early on' and asked for the issues to be expedited. Judge King remanded Mr McCarthy in custody until August 20th to await directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions. Gardaí objected to bail when the matter first came before Cork District Court. It is alleged three people arrived in a car at the Ballincrokig house on April 24th. Two of them entered the curtilage of the property, 'ignited two glass petrol bombs with a blowtorch', smashed a bedroom window and threw in the petrol bombs, Garda Brian Murphy told the court in May. 'The third person – believed to be Paul McCarthy – stands close to the vehicle and allegedly films the incident on his mobile phone,' the court heard. Gda Murphy said a husband, aged 87, and wife, aged 86, were watching television in the house. The house was engulfed in flames, but the couple were unharmed, he said. 'Paul McCarthy had complete disregard for the elderly occupants ... From the initial investigations, gardaí are not of the belief that these persons were the intended victims,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store