Starmer's approval ratings at lowest level since becoming PM after welfare chaos
The prime minister 's support among the public reached fresh depths after the climbdown and in the wake of Rachel Reeves being seen crying in the Commons, a new poll shows.
Conducted in the hours after Wednesday's PMQs, the More in Common survey found Sir Keir's approval rating at -43.
The poll, first reported by The Sunday Times, also found that just a year after coming to power, seven in 10 voters think Sir Keir's government is at least as chaotic as the Tories' previous term.
That includes one in three voters, who believe it is more so.
More in Common's UK director Luke Tryl said: 'It is an unhappy birthday for the prime minister, his personal approval has hit an all time low, while Britons blame him rather than his chancellor for the welfare mess and think he has lost control of his party.'
Mr Tryl said the 'big winner' from the government's failings is Reform UK. 'Although we are a long way from an election and much will change, Nigel Farage 's Party are demonstrating that they are now close to the level where they could command an outright majority. Britain's political landscape has transformed entirely from just a year ago,' Mr Tryl said.
More in Common's poll found that Reform would emerge as the biggest party if an election were held tomorrow, winning 290 seats. Labour 's vote would collapse, falling from having won 412 seats last July to just 126. And the Conservatives would win just 81 seats, 40 fewer than at the last general election.
More in Common's MRP, often dubbed a mega poll, showed that a majority of cabinet ministers would lose their seats as things stand.
Those whose seats are vulnerable include Angela Rayner, Reeves, Pat McFadden, Yvette Cooper, Wes Streeting, Bridget Phillipson, Ed Miliband and more.
The main reason voters gave for turning away from Labour was broken promises and U-turns on previous commitments, More in Common said.
More than a third said they were turning away from Labour due to the ongoing cost of living crisis, while more than a quarter said they had been put off Labour by the party's cuts to winter fuel payments.
Labour has been haemorrhaging support to Mr Farage's party, with Reform surging in May's local elections, taking control of 10 councils and winning the Runcorn by-election.
The poll came after Sir Keir's chancellor was warned she must raise taxes or put Labour's agenda at risk.
Jim O'Neill, a former Goldman Sachs chief turned Treasury minister who quit the Conservatives and later advised Reeves, said she faces no choice but to abandon key parts of her economic policy – including her commitment not to raise income tax, national insurance contributions for employees or VAT.
'Without changing some of the big taxes, welfare and pensions, they [Labour] can't commit to things like Northern Powerhouse Rail, small modular nuclear reactors, and various other things that will make an investment and growth difference,' he told The Independent.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
37 minutes ago
- Sky News
Met Police Chief, Mark Rowley, says race disparities in crime and justice are 'shameful' for London
Speaking to Sky's Trevor Phillips, Sir Mark Rowley explains the Met's relationship with minority communities. Sunday 13 July 2025 04:16, UK
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Senior aides to the King and Duke of Sussex pictured together in London
Senior aides to the King and Duke of Sussex have been pictured together in London in what is reported to be an initial step towards restoring the relationship between Harry and the rest of the royal family. Images obtained by the the Mail On Sunday show Meredith Maines, the duke's chief communications officer, and Liam Maguire, who runs Harry and Meghan's UK public relations team, meeting the King's communications secretary Tobyn Andreae at the Royal Over-Seas League near Clarence House. The Mail reports it is not known which side initiated the meeting, but a source told the paper: 'There's a long road ahead, but a channel of communication is now open for the first time in years. 'There was no formal agenda, just casual drinks. There were things both sides wanted to talk about.' Both parties have been contacted for comment. The rift between the Sussexes and the royal family opened significantly following their 2021 interview with Oprah Winfrey, during which they alleged a member of the family was concerned about their son Archie's skin tone before he was born. Then the duke claimed in his controversial memoir, Spare, his brother the Prince of Wales had physically attacked him and that the King put his own interests above Harry's and was jealous of Meghan. Harry's level of security changed in 2020 when he and Meghan stepped down as working royals and moved to California for financial and personal freedom, and he suggested the royal family and officials hoped his realisation of the increased safety risk 'would force us to come back'. The duke failed in an appeal against the dismissal of his High Court claim against the Home Office, over the decision of the Executive Committee for the Protection of Royalty and Public Figures (Ravec) that he should receive a different degree of protection when in the UK. In a BBC television interview after losing the latest round in his court battle over his security, Harry claimed the King will not speak to him and he does not know 'how much longer my father has' as he spoke of his hopes for a 'reconciliation' with his family. Charles was diagnosed with cancer in February last year.
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Sunday Times letters: Rowley's radical police force proposals
Write to letters@ In 2009, on his retirement as chief constable of West Midlands police, I asked Sir Paul Scott-Lee what was the main issue facing UK policing. He replied: 'The answer isn't 43' — the number of police forces in England and Wales. The problem is even more pressing today, as Sir Mark Rowley highlighted ('The police are here to protect — we are not social workers', Jul 6). The main obstacle to reform is the financial differential between policing metropolitan, Labour-led areas and Conservative-led counties. The creation of police and crime commissioners added further obstacles. The reform of our 43-force model is long overdue — but in all public sector reorganisations where those in charge are left to reorganise themselves, the predicted cost cuts are never delivered. I suggest any reorganisation is overseen by the National Audit Office and an independent oversight board with the authority to veto aspects that do not meet the cost-cutting ConnorIndependent member of West Midlands Police Authority (2007-16)Independent member of West Midlands Strategic Policing Board (2016-22) As a retired police officer who worked for 13 years at Police Staff College, Bramshill, and who advocated a restructure to make seven regional forces in England and a single Welsh force, I was pleased to read that Sir Mark Rowley, the Metropolitan Police commissioner, has come to similar conclusions regarding funding. I have long stated that technology provides the possibility of a complete overhaul of the outdated county police system, which requires more than 40 headquarters, chief constable teams and attendant costs, and only facilitates a career path for senior officers. Let's make use of the economies of scale Rowley suggests and return to neighbourhood policing by increasing officer O'BrienStrensall, N Yorks Sir Mark Rowley makes persuasive points regarding reform of our police force but we must be careful about what he calls 'technology that boosts efficiency'. China is a leader in facial recognition technology. If we bought its systems we would have to ensure that there was no transmission of data back to Beijing, which has a history of targeting dissidents who have sought sanctuary in this HoggettWinchester When Lord Trenchard was commissioner of the Met in the 1930s he introduced a direct-entry recruitment system that produced outstanding chief constables. When Sir Robert Mark held the role, he was known for his lack of tolerance of corruption and wrote a bestselling autobiography. What will Sir Mark Rowley be remembered for? He could leave a legacy by introducing league tables that show which divisions have the highest sickness rates, get the most complaints and claim the most KennyAcle, Norfolk Sir Mark Rowley's assertion that the 'police are here to protect' is true, but the absence of officers patrolling on foot makes it an ambition based more on hope than reality. His statement that police are 'not social workers' is also true, but British policing has always included working in social settings for the public benefit. His conclusion that we need 'serious reform' makes the most sense. The last time a royal commission made recommendations on policing was in 1960, when we still had PowerSenior Met officer (ret'd) Lyndhurst, Hants Your report on the 'HS2 money train' (investigation, Jul 6) named many of the companies and organisations that have benefited from this grossly mismanaged white elephant. The report did not, however, name any of the leading politicians from the main parties who forced this project through in the teeth of vociferous and well-informed local opposition, nor how many heads have rolled at the Department for Transport. Another investigation in the pipeline, FletcherGreat Missenden, Bucks Regarding your investigation into the mismanagement and huge overspend of HS2, another example of wasted money during the project has been the compulsory purchase of homes. For example, at Whitmore Heath, near Newcastle-under-Lyme, about 25 expensive, detached properties were bought a number of years ago with a view to HS2 construction work being carried out in the area. Many years later these properties still stand empty, a situation which I'm sure has been replicated in other parts of the Richard JacksonNewcastle-under-Lyme, Staffs I was not surprised to find out that staff receive cash bonuses for catching out passengers with 'oversized bags' at the departure gates ('Airport staff's oversize bag bonus', Jul 6). However, I was surprised to read that this incentive scheme has been set up to reward staff for 'doing the right thing'. If you pay someone to 'do the right thing', it is no longer the right MalthouseBristol I believe in the importance of history and heritage. However, our public services — the armed forces, NHS, care system, etc — are desperate for money to fund essential improvements. Therefore, in what way does it make sense to consider spending £9.6 million on a new door for the House of Lords (politics, Jul 6)?Celia LovegroveReading Has no one told the BBC or Wimbledon organisers that the Covid pandemic is over? There is no need for Annabel Croft et al to conduct on-court, post-match interviews while standing literally yards away from the HenryGood Easter, Essex Jeremy Clarkson was right in his critique of Sir Keir Starmer ('Take cover! Here comes the weapon of Marxist destruction', Jul 6). Opinion polls suggest many agree with him. But the problem is more widespread. There is a lack of leadership among our politicians, many of whom seem more motivated by what they are against than what they stand for. We need gifted leaders to replace the lightweight chancers who struggle to tell the truth. History suggests chaos like this leads to dictatorship and the promise of equally shallow solutions. Let's find the right people with the right leadership skills before it's too MustardLydford, Devon A Sunday Times poll reported 'welcome news' for Rachel Reeves: 12 per cent of voters think more of politicians for crying, while it makes no difference to 60 per cent ('In the stocks', news, Jul 6). I am one of the 60 per cent. I still think she is a dreadful ForshawBolton Regarding your report on 'revenge quitters' (news, Jul 6), arriving in the City one day I found the street outside my office blocked by a large car. A revenge quitter had abandoned it and dropped the keys down a drain. Another revenge trick, when you were asked to hand back the keys to the company car, was to post them after leaving the vehicle in one of Heathrow's ferociously expensive short-term car ThomasBrill, Bucks Regarding potential misuse of the benefits system, when my father died aged 39 my mother had to raise four small children on a means-tested supplementary benefit, with no recognition of my brother, who was intellectually disabled. I still recall her fear and shame when an inspector called to walk round the house to ensure she was not misspending the paltry sum. Perhaps it's time to reintroduce such a CrouchGlasgow This may be a naive suggestion but why don't energy companies put solar panels on pylons? They are already a blot on the landscape — so no change there. Pylons undergo regular maintenance. Adding a few solar panels should be MobsbySlawston, Leics The BBC will only emerge strongly from its charter renewal if independence from the government is maintained. I have little confidence, however, after sources were quoted as saying Lisa Nandy would seek to use the process to seize powers that include sacking board members ('Teflon Tim feels the heat from culture secretary', Jul 6). Members of this government should ask themselves whether they would be content if, after the next general election, Nigel Farage held the power to sack BBC board members and replace them with people of his own MillerLiverpool When will the government start talking about our expanding national debt? It is close to £3 trillion and will never be paid off in our lifetime. We shouldn't leave it to our children to pay it ClarkeHinchley Wood, Surrey Like many readers I have been inspired to donate to a good cause after reading a Sunday Times article ('When you're touched by our stories, you give so generously', Jul 6). I did so after reading a column by Richard Coles. He wrote about my local hospice, which relies on donations for 70 per cent of its funding. I had just won a Premium Bonds prize so I donated a percentage to the hospice. I have continued to do so each time I win. Perhaps it has brought me luck in TaylorPevensey Bay, E Sussex Rhiannon Carvell suggests using smaller dinner plates to reduce portion sizes (letter, Jul 6). Combine this with wearing reading glasses that magnify and you have the perfect recipe for weight BaconHarrow, Middx Send your letter to: letters@ Please include an address for publication and a phone number in case of any queries. Letters should be received by midday on the Thursday before publication.
