China scion's fight with half-siblings sends succession warning
But Kelly is now grappling with two overlapping legal challenges stemming from unresolved matters left behind by her father, cases that could set a legal precedent for wealth succession in China and cast a shadow over the reputation of one of the country's most iconic beverage empires.
In a Hong Kong court this month, Kelly was asked to help set up three trusts worth US$2.1 billion for people who identify as her 'half brothers and sister' following what they say were her father's directives. The case has raised eyebrows and lit up on Chinese social media.
Separately, the 43-year-old heiress is being sued by some former Wahaha employees seeking to void a 2018 share buyback, according to sources familiar with the case, who requested not to be named because it cannot be accessed by the public. The employees argue that the repurchase price was unfairly low, the sources said. The lawsuit has been reported by local media, including Caixin.
Wahaha's labour union said the share repurchase move was approved by staff representatives and was lawful, according to a September statement it posted on social media platform Weibo.
The cases have once again thrust Wahaha's leadership and its ownership structure into the spotlight, reminiscent of the corporate power struggle following the death of founder Zong Qinghou. The disputes also threaten to derail Kelly's long-standing efforts to take all or part of Wahaha public, following previous failed attempts.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Wahaha's affairs are also a government concern, as a Chinese state-owned firm has a 46 per cent stake and the company is a flagship enterprise for Hangzhou, where it is headquartered. Kelly owns 29.4 per cent, while the group's staff union holds 24.6 per cent, according to Qichacha.
'Chinese family business founders need to take careful note of the Wahaha case,' said Marleen Dieleman, family business professor at IMD based in Singapore. 'Especially when founders have smaller stakes, succession can quickly spiral into a battle for control.'
Since Kelly took over as chairwoman in August last year, some of Wahaha's existing production facilities have been shut down, leading to layoffs as part of business restructuring, the sources said.
Kelly has been accused of trying to transfer a series of Wahaha's trademarks and some production of its water business to external entities, according to a March letter seen by Bloomberg News that was addressed to both state-owned and individual shareholders of the company's water business unit.
Wahaha said in a statement in February that its trademark transfers were lawful and it did not harm the company's operation or assets. The move awaited approval from the country's intellectual property watchdog, it added at the time. Representatives for Kelly and Wahaha did not provide comments on multiple queries for this story.
Hong Kong case
The Zong family has a family fortune of at least US$3.3 billion, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index.
The Hong Kong court case offers a rare glimpse into the family feud within the closely held group, which reported around 70 billion yuan (S$12.5 billion) in revenue last year, according to local media.
The three plaintiffs, Jacky, Jessie and Jerry Zong, filed the lawsuit in December against Kelly and Jian Hao Ventures, a British Virgin Islands vehicle controlling an HSBC Holdings bank account in Hong Kong. The suit sought to disclose the assets held in the account and to prevent Kelly from moving them.
One month before Qinghou passed away in February last year, he gave a 'hand-written instruction' to one of his subordinates, asking the source to 'get ready to go to Hong Kong. Set up trusts at HSBC, US$700 million each', according to statements from the attorney for the plaintiffs in court on Jul 11.
Shortly after, when they found out the account had a balance of around US$1.8 billion, the senior Zong said: 'If the USD is not enough, covert yuan,' and told the source to 'set up the two for Jacky and Jessie first', the plaintiffs' lawyer said at the hearing.
The plaintiffs' lawyer said that Kelly had agreed on Feb 2 last year to follow an instruction from her father to set up the trusts funded with money from Jian Hao, which counted Qinghou as the sole director.
Paperwork for the three trusts remains stalled, with no final agreement in place. Kelly's lawyer argued that the handwritten instructions were not addressed to her, and that it's unclear where the funding to cover a US$300 million shortfall would come from.
'We agreed to set up the trusts from the start, but only on the condition that the trust assets would be clearly defined,' Kelly's lawyer said.
The Hong Kong High Court will hand down a decision on Aug 1, according to its website.
The delay in setting up trusts has prompted the three half-siblings to also file a lawsuit in Hangzhou with similar demands.
'In business families, conflict can be severe as the stakes are high and conflict is both financial and emotional,' said Dieleman. BLOOMBERG
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
5 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Economic anxiety leads more consumers to embrace ‘Christmas in July'
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Rising costs, inflation and uncertainty around tariffs are pushing shoppers, particularly parents, to take early holiday shopping more seriously. Tucked deep inside Ms Catherine Spruill's bedroom closet sit two plastic bins beneath a mountain of clothes. One holds emergency gift cards. The other, Christmas presents. She has been stockpiling gifts for the December holidays since June, hunting for summer sales across big-box retailers in her hometown, Stratford, Connecticut, stretching her income across two children, extended family and a long list of friends. Ms Spruill, 34, has already picked up more than 25 toys and video games for around US$350 (S$451). Her best find so far: matching holiday pajama sets for herself and two sons, ages 13 and three – all for US$28, thanks to a 50 per cent off sale at Kohl's. Black Friday no longer marks the beginning of the holiday retail season, as a growing number of shoppers and retailers are embracing what's being called 'Christmas in July'. 'These are the best weeks to do Christmas shopping because you're going to get more bang for your buck,' said Ms Spruill, who is a home health aide. 'Stores are trying to get rid of stuff to the point they're handing it to you.' Ms Spruill has been doing her holiday shopping months in advance since 2020, when she watched a coupon clipper on YouTube rave about using July clearance sales for holiday shopping. That same summer, she scored a bicycle on sale for US$48 at Walmart, marked down from around US$120. Over the past five years, Ms Spruill said, she has saved thousands using this strategy. Rising costs, inflation and uncertainty around tariffs are pushing shoppers, particularly parents, to take early holiday shopping more seriously. Some 21 per cent of 1,062 people surveyed by CivicScience, a Pittsburgh-based research firm, said they had already started holiday shopping this summer, up from 16 per cent in 2024. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Grace Fu apologises for Tanjong Katong sinkhole, says road may stay closed for a few more days Singapore Terrorism threat in Singapore remains high, driven by events like Israeli-Palestinian conflict: ISD Singapore S'pore can and must meaningfully apply tech like AI in a way that creates jobs for locals: PM Wong Singapore 7, including child and firefighter, taken to hospital after fire breaks out in Toa Payoh flat Sport IOC president Kirsty Coventry a 'huge supporter' of Singapore Singapore ICA inspector obtained bribes in the form of sex acts from 6 foreign men in exchange for his help Singapore Doctor who forged certificates for aesthetic procedures gets 4 months' jail Singapore 12 motorists nabbed for providing illegal private-hire services: LTA Early holiday shopping isn't entirely new. Retailers have long nudged customers toward early-bird deals for the holiday season. But the Covid-19 pandemic helped push the timeline up even earlier because of supply chain issues and concerns over not getting gifts on time, said Mr Ted Rossman, a senior industry analyst for Bankrate. Despite ongoing uncertainty around tariffs, consumer anxiety is starting to ease. After a brief dip in May, retail sales rose 0.6 per cent in June, with year-over-year gains in big-ticket items like furniture and cars, according to the Census Bureau. 'Consumers are climbing the wall of worry and spending anyway,' Mr Rossman said. Retailers are responding to the shift in consumer activity with extended sales and deeper discounts. Amazon's Prime Day sale, which debuted in 2015 as a 24-hour event, lasted four days in 2025. Walmart and Target now run events around the same time to capture shopper attention, turning July into a broader summer sales period. Amazon reported record Prime Day sales in a news release but did not disclose exact figures. Macy's ran a 'Black Friday in July' sales event for five days starting July 23. It also marketed a 'Christmas in July' sale July 25 for the first time, offering holiday and general merchandise, according to a news release. A spokesperson for TJX, owner of T.J. Maxx and Marshalls, said in an e-mail that the company was aware that some of its customers would get a head start on their holiday shopping as early as July, but did not offer specifics on sales or traffic. Kohl's declined to comment. Target did not respond to requests for comment. Small businesses are also jumping on the trend. In Mobile, Alabama, Ms JulieAnna Lindsey organised her second annual 'Christmas in July' small-business event with more than 40 local vendors and boutique retailers selling items ranging from Christmas tree ornaments to gingerbread earrings. More than 250 people attended the one-day event at a church during the state's tax-free weekend in July. 'Now you see a ton of businesses really moving away from Black Friday, trying to really push Christmas in July to get a boost in sales,' said Ms Lindsey, 38, a middle school teacher and owner of Pink Post Office Boutique. 'More people, I feel like, are out to shop or to be going ahead and thinking about holidays now.' For some consumers, 'Christmas in July' is not just about saving money. It's also about saving time and avoiding the holiday rush for popular items. Ms Alicia Thomas, 32, was in search of a Paw Patrol aircraft carrier toy during the 2023 holiday season. Though Target's website listed it in stock in multiple stores, she said, she came up empty-handed at nearly every one she checked. She found the toy in the end but said all the stress and time she had spent driving around were unnecessary. After attending Ms Lindsey's Christmas in July event last summer in Mobile, Ms Thomas said, she decided to get a head start on holiday shopping for her three boys, ages seven, five and two. For this summer's event, she bought two outfits at a children's boutique for around US$30. Ms Kuila Cannon, 47, started her 2025 holiday shopping this spring for her four children, whose ages range from nine to 30. With few shopping options in her rural town near DeFuniak Springs, Florida, she usually drives over an hour to find gifts at various stores. So when a local boutique tucked inside a pharmacy ran a 70 per cent off sale, she jumped on it. She bought several gifts, including a grill set and a holiday advent calendar, saving nearly US$190 through discounts. The store was slashing prices to compete with a Walmart that had opened nearby, Cannon said. It was a steal for her. 'I've never seen prices like that before,' Ms Cannon said. 'That was kind of crazy.' NYTIMES
Business Times
35 minutes ago
- Business Times
Microsoft's access to OpenAI tech is focus of contract talks
[SEATTLE] Microsoft is in advanced talks to land a deal that could give it ongoing access to critical OpenAI technology, an agreement that would remove a major obstacle to the startup's efforts to become a for-profit enterprise. The companies have discussed new terms that would let Microsoft use OpenAI's latest models and other technology even if the startup decides it has reached its goal of building a more powerful form of AI known as artificial general intelligence (AGI), according to two people familiar with the negotiations. Under the current contract, OpenAI attaining AGI is seen as a major milestone at which point Microsoft would lose some rights to OpenAI technology. Negotiators have been meeting regularly, and an agreement could come together in a matter of weeks, according to three people with knowledge of the situation, who requested anonymity to discuss a private matter. OpenAI chief executive officer Sam Altman and Satya Nadella, his Microsoft counterpart, discussed the restructuring at the Allen & Co conference in Sun Valley, Idaho, earlier this month, two of the people said. While the tone of the talks has been positive, some of the people cautioned that the deal is not finalised and could hit new roadblocks. Moreover, OpenAI's restructuring plans face other complications, including regulatory scrutiny and a lawsuit filed by Elon Musk, an early backer who split with the company and accused the startup of defrauding investors about its commitment to its charitable mission. (OpenAI has pushed back at Musk's claims and said the billionaire is trying to slow down the company.) Negotiations over OpenAI's future as a profit-company have dragged on for months. Microsoft, which backed OpenAI with some US$13.75 billion and has the right to use its intellectual property, is the biggest holdout among the ChatGPT maker's investors, Bloomberg previously reported. At issue is the size of Microsoft's stake in the newly configured company. The talks have since broadened into a renegotiation of their relationship, with the software maker seeking to avoid suddenly losing access to the startup's technology before the end of the current deal, which expires in 2030. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Microsoft and OpenAI declined to comment. A fraying partnership The partnership between the two companies helped inaugurate the AI age. Microsoft built the supercomputer that OpenAI used to develop the language models behind ChatGPT and, in exchange, won the right to bake the technology into its software offerings. The relationship began to fray when the OpenAI board fired (and then rehired) Altman in November 2023, an episode that shook Microsoft's faith in its partner. The rift only widened when the two companies began competing for the same customers – consumers who use their chatbots at home and corporations that have deployed the AI assistants to boost office productivity. Even as executives publicly touted their close ties, OpenAI sought to loosen its dependance on Microsoft, winning permission to build data centres and other AI infrastructure with rival companies. OpenAI is eager to alter its complicated nonprofit structure, in part to secure additional funding to keep building data centres to power its next-generation AI models. SoftBank Group, which has said it would back OpenAI with tens of billions of US dollars, has the option to reduce that outlay if OpenAI's restructuring isn't completed by the end of the year. OpenAI wants a larger slice of the revenue currently shared with Microsoft, and has sought adjustments to Microsoft's access to its intellectual property, two of the people said. Microsoft is looking for continued access to OpenAI technology after the current contract expires in 2030. There are range of concerns for OpenAI. The startup wants to ensure its business is well-positioned with whatever share of revenue and equity Microsoft receives in part to guarantee its nonprofit will be well-resourced with a significant stake in OpenAI, one person said. OpenAI also wants the ability to offer customers distinct products built on top of its models even if Microsoft has access to the same technology, the person said. And OpenAI wants to be able to find a way to provide its services to more customers, including government providers, not all of which are on Azure, Microsoft's cloud computing platform, the person said. At the same time, OpenAI seeks to guarantee that Microsoft adheres to strict safety standards when deploying OpenAI's technology, especially as it gets closer to AGI, the person said. The AGI question Reaching agreement on what happens once OpenAI achieves artificial general intelligence has been particularly thorny. It's not clear why the language is in the contract, but it gives OpenAI a built-in way to strike out on its own just as its technology matures. The startup publicly defines AGI as 'highly autonomous systems that outperform humans at most economically valuable work.' The existing contract has separate clauses related to that threshold, which can be triggered by technical or business milestones, according to two people familiar with the matter. OpenAI's board has the right to determine when the company has reached AGI on a technical level. Under that scenario, Microsoft would lose access to technology developed beyond that point, one of the people said. The business milestone would arrive once OpenAI has demonstrated it can reach around US$100 billion in total profits for investors including Microsoft – giving it the wherewithal to repay the return Microsoft is entitled to under the existing contract, one person said. In that scenario, Microsoft would lose its rights to OpenAI technology, including products developed before that trigger, another person said. Microsoft has the right to weigh in on the business milestone, but if the two companies end up at odds over the claim, they could wind up in court, two people said. Another provision in the current contract bars Microsoft from pursuing AGI technology itself, some of the people said. Microsoft, for its part, has demonstrated some flexibility in revised contract terms. The company agreed to waive some intellectual property rights related to OpenAI's US$6.5 billion acquisition of io, the startup co-founded by iPhone designer Jony Ive, two of the people said. The software giant was less accomodating over OpenAI's proposed acquisition of AI coding startup Windsurf, the people said. That deal fell apart earlier this month, in part because of the tension with Microsoft, Bloomberg reported. Windsurf, which sells coding tools that compete with Microsoft's products, did not want the tech giant to have access to its intellectual property – a condition that OpenAI was unsuccessful in getting Microsoft's agreement on, people familiar said. Ultimately, Windsurf's co-founders and a small group of staffers agreed to join Alphabet's Google in a US$2.4 billion deal. In recent weeks, the companies have been negotiating Microsoft's ownership in a restructured OpenAI – with the two sides discussing an equity stake for Microsoft in the low- to mid-30 per cent range, according to a person familiar with the matter. The Financial Times previously reported on the stake talks. But if Microsoft deems the stake and other changes to the contract insufficient, the company is willing to abandon the talks and stick with the current contract terms, another person said. BLOOMBERG
Business Times
35 minutes ago
- Business Times
Temasek to buy a 5% stake in Italian luxury group Ermenegildo Zegna
[SINGAPORE] Temasek has signed a share-purchase agreement with Ermenegildo Zegna to purchase a 5 per cent stake in the Italian luxury group at US$8.9 a share, for a total of US$126.4 million on Tuesday (Jul 29). The shares will come from the company's treasury shares, and, combined with Temasek's share purchases on the open market, will bring Temasek's stake to 10 per cent after the transaction is completed on Jul 30. The cash consideration will add to Ermenegildo Zegna's balance sheet and enable the company to seize selected opportunities for organic growth of its brand portfolio. Ermenegildo 'Gildo' Zegna, chairman and chief executive officer of the luxury fashion brand, said: 'This investment is a strong endorsement of our vision and long-term growth potential, while firmly recognising the global significance of the Italian luxury sector.' Nagi Hamiyeh, head of Europe, Middle East and Africa for Temasek, is expected to join Ermenegildo Zegna's board of directors in June 2026. The customer base of the fashion house comprises high-net-worth individuals (HNWI) who have been more resilient in their spending. A BCG report noted that this segment spends more than 50,000 euros (S$74,380) a year on luxury brands; the wealthiest top-tier clients comprise just 1 per cent of the personal luxury goods market, but generate 22 per cent of the value. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Aspiration consumers, which make up 60 per cent of the market, have faltered in recent years, but the big spenders have consistently grown their expenditure. The segment is set to grow from about 940,000 HNWIs, holding about 68 trillion in wealth in 2024, to about 1.4 million HNWIs in 2030, with about 100 trillion in wealth. This group is also growing in confidence. Half of them say they expect to increase spending by between 5 and 25 per cent over the next 18 months. Temasek will bring its experience in the luxury sector and knowledge of the Asian market to Ermenegildo Zegna under this deal. The state investor will also support expansion in key geographies where the company's presence is underdeveloped. Hamiyeh said: 'Our investment in them underscores our ongoing commitment to support leading European businesses with strong track records and global potential.'
