Ramasamy: Mandor system should not be blamed but those behind the system of subservience
Editor's Note: On Monday (June 16), a source told Malaysiakini that Deputy Entrepreneur Development and Cooperatives Minister Datuk Seri R. Ramanan would be appointed chair of a newly formed committee to look into the interest of Malaysian Indians.
The mandor system was used by British planters during the colonial period in which Indians mandor or supervisor were appointed to manage the labour affairs.
The mandor might be a South Indian Tamil but he took instructions from the white managers in managing labour affairs in the plantations.
Unlike the Chinese kepala who had the material interest of Chinese labour, the Indian mandor functioned on behalf of the plantation bosses.
My book on plantation labour describes in detail that Chinese contract labourers earned higher wages than Indian labourers because the former who operated under the kepala system provided better material incentives than the mandor system.
'Blame non-Indians elites'
The political relevance of the analogy of mandor system was first used by the HINDRAF (Hindu Rights Action Force) leaders to describe and belittle Indian leaders who functioned on behalf of the Chinese and Malay leaders in DAP and PKR.
The use of the mandor analogy is to show that Indian leaders in the PH-led coalition have no real power but are subservient to the non-Indian leaders.
Subramaniam might be making a valid point by saying that Indian leaders in the government have no real power as it is being wielded by the Chinese and Malay leaders.
However, I differ from Subramaniam on the point of Anwar himself heading the ICAC to channel financial benefits to the Indian community.
While Subramaniam blames the Indian mandor, he has discounted the notion that the mandor phenomenon in the government is the consequence of the government adhering to the racist majoritarian policies.
In other words, the Indian mandor is not the real problem but those non-Indian elite who manipulate the subservience of these leaders for their particular interests.
Even if Indian leaders or mandor are not appointed, the result will be no different. It must be remembered that the crux of the problem is not the mandor system but those non-Indian leaders in power who make use of Indian leaders to camouflage the majoritarian racial and religious system for political expediency.
Political camouflage
Indian leaders or mandor are used by the non-Indian elite to impress upon the community of the existence of Indian representation. However, such a projection is nothing but a political farce.
Unfortunately, this Indian representation in the form of Indian leaders playing second fiddle to non-Indian leaders does not augur well for the economic and political well-being of the Indian community.
The pliant Indian leaders in the ruling coalition are a disgrace and humiliation to the Indian community that has immensely contributed to the nation in blood, sweat and tears.
This is the reason why the Malaysian Rights Party (Urimai) makes it a point to chart an independent political course for the Indian community without being entrapped by the vicious mandor system that prioritises the interest of the elite of the majoritarian community at the expense of ordinary Indians and others in the country.
At the core of the political struggle of Urimai is that Indians should be led by Indian leaders who are in a position to articulate the broader concerns of the community.
Urimai definitely does not want to exchange one form of domination to another form. Urimai is open to coalition building but such an effort will be predicated on independence, integrity and dignity.
It is not enough to decipher the vicious nature of the political system that has parallels with how plantation labour was controlled and exploited under the mandor system.
The present Indian mandor leaders are no different from their earlier counterparts but serve different masters under different political circumstances. – June 20, 2025
Former DAP stalwart and Penang chief minister II Prof Ramasamy Palanisamy is chairman of the United Rights of Malaysian Party (Urimai) interim council.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Trump's surprise Nvidia deal signals trade shift
NEW YORK: President Donald Trump's controversial plan to take a cut of revenue from chip sales to China has US companies reconsidering their plans for business with the country, offering a model for circumventing years of trade tensions. Experts and people familiar with the matter said the surprise deal, in which Nvidia Corp and Advanced Micro Devices Inc (AMD) agreed to pay 15% of their revenues from Chinese AI chip sales to the United States, provides a path to enter the Chinese market despite severe export controls, tariffs and other trade barriers. The question that companies must now confront is whether the risk is worth taking. People familiar with the matter, who asked not to be identified discussing private deliberations, said companies are struggling to figure out what the president's order means for their future, especially given the unpredictable nature of Trump's decision-making. 'This is truly bizarre and unusual, and the troubling thing – beyond the individual instances of AMD and Nvidia – is the possibility that this will be expanded,' said Gary Hufbauer, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics. 'Everything is now 'national security,' according to the new definition, which means it's all subject to export licences and then they give you a license based on your contribution.' There are concerns that US trade agencies could begin charging fees to companies every time there's a meeting to discuss tariffs, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified discussing private deliberations. Trump administration officials defend the idea as a smart way to generate revenue for the US government and suggest it will extend well beyond the chips sector. 'I think we could see it in other industries over time,' Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said in an interview with Bloomberg Television on Wednesday. 'I think right now this is unique, but now that we have the model and the beta tests, why not expand it?' Bessent defended the deal and rejected any national-security concerns around the decision to sell Nvidia's H20 chip to China – something that had been earlier barred for fear of giving China a boost in the artificial-intelligence (AI) race. 'There are no national security concerns here,' Bessent said. 'We would not sell any of the advanced chips. So, the H20, I don't know whether you'd say they're four, five, six levels down the chips stack.' Either way, the deal highlights how Trump has pushed to open a wave of new revenue streams including by taking ownership shares of companies or extracting higher fees to live or work in the United States. The US is weighing sales of a so-called 'gold card' residency permit, it won a 'golden share' to have direct say over corporate actions by United States Steel Corp, and it's secured investment pledges and potential revenue-sharing in country-level tariff talks. That's aside from the barrage of product tariffs that have at times left massive dislocations in globally traded markets. The matter surprised China hawks in Congress, who have been unimpressed by the administration's reassurances. Rep John Moolenaar, the Michigan Republican who chairs the US House Select Committee on China, questioned the legal basis for the move and suggested it does an end-run around controls put in place to limit the sale of sensitive technology to US adversaries. 'Export controls are a front-line defence in protecting our national security, and we should not set a precedent that incentivises the government to grant licences to sell China technology that will enhance its AI capabilities,' he said. It also raises questions about where the administration will steer the revenue. Trump has mused about issuing tariff rebate checks – though he has yet to seriously pursue the idea – while at other times he's said it would go toward narrowing the large budget deficit. The administration had debated launching a sovereign wealth fund before shelving those plans for now. It's too soon to say whether the administration will seek to revive the fund and steer revenue there, one official familiar with deliberations said. 'Trump's aides argue that these measures will strengthen America's AI leadership by maximising its global influence and market share,' Hal Brands, a professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies and a former Pentagon official, wrote in Bloomberg Opinion. 'Yet it is also possible that they will simply eat into America's innovation advantage.' — Bloomberg
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Pakistan committed to advancing CPEC for prosperity: senate's deputy chairman
ISLAMABAD, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- Pakistan's Senate Deputy Chairman Syedaal Khan Nasar has reaffirmed his country's resolve to advance the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), calling it "the key to the development and prosperity of the people of Pakistan, especially Balochistan." Speaking at an event titled "CPEC in My Eyes" in Islamabad, Nasar hailed China as a "brother" that has stood by Pakistan in every difficult time. "The journey from Quetta to Gwadar that once took 34 hours can now be completed in 12 hours via road, that is the progress CPEC has brought to ordinary people," he said, adding that all stakeholders in Pakistan are now "on one page" to drive growth through the corridor. Nasar underscored the need to further engage communities in agriculture, education, and trade under the CPEC so that "they will not only benefit but also help strengthen Pakistan-China cooperation." Chinese Ambassador to Pakistan Jiang Zaidong said that with support of leaders of both countries, the corridor has been promoted and achieved fruitful results, helping Pakistan consolidate its development foundation and unleash its development potential. China and Pakistan will work together to build an upgraded version of the corridor and accelerate the building of a China-Pakistan community with a shared future, he added.
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Roundup: Ethiopian experts hail China's ecological conservation, urge deeper cooperation
by Xinhua writers Habtamu Worku, Liu Fangqiang ADDIS ABABA, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- Ethiopian experts have lauded China's extraordinary achievement in transforming from ecological fragility to environmental leadership, calling it a practical model for addressing climate change and land degradation. They argue that China's experience, coupled with deepening Sino-Ethiopian cooperation in ecological conservation, offers valuable lessons for Ethiopia as it pursues ambitious environmental goals amid mounting climate challenges. Aberu Tena, chief executive officer of Green Legacy and Plantation Forest under Ethiopian Forestry Development, told Xinhua that the two countries' ecological cooperation has matured into a robust and highly effective South-South partnership, "successfully transitioning from high-level agreements to tangible ground-level projects." Tena identified technology transfer as a cornerstone of the collaboration, with Ethiopia benefiting from Chinese expertise in combating environmental challenges, particularly desertification. He cited satellite remote sensing for monitoring land degradation, advanced water-saving irrigation methods, and dune stabilization techniques as transformative technologies now in active use. According to Tena, Chinese experts have conducted training workshops for Ethiopian officials, technicians, and researchers, focusing on building local capacity in sustainable land management. Pilot zones have also been established to adapt China's successful ecological restoration schemes, such as the Kubuqi model, to Ethiopia's diverse highland and lowland conditions. Tena stressed that the ecological cooperation extends beyond desertification control, forming an integral part of a broader green development relationship with "tangible and transformative outcomes" across sectors vital to Ethiopia's sustainable future. Renewable energy is another major success, complementing Ethiopia's climate-resilient green economy strategy and its goal of carbon-neutral growth. "Chinese financing and technology have been instrumental in developing Ethiopia's vast renewable energy potential, particularly in hydropower and wind energy," Tena said. He also highlighted the flagship Chinese-built Ethiopia-Djibouti Railway as a "green transport corridor" that significantly cuts carbon emissions compared to road freight, demonstrating how economic development and environmental sustainability can advance hand in hand. Reflecting on China's "remarkable reversal of desertification" achieved through decades of unwavering, state-led policy, Tena said the experience underscores the importance of sustained political commitment beyond short-term cycles. He also praised the "well-coordinated and integrated" nature of China's reforestation and rehabilitation efforts, which "align seamlessly with broader national objectives and are supported by targeted scientific research and interventions." Bitew Shibabaw Abate, chief executive officer of Forest Products Utilization and Law Compliance under Ethiopian Forestry Development, described China's approach as "unique and globally exemplary," crediting its success to the seamless integration of science, policy, and mass mobilization. He emphasized the country's strong reliance on scientific research to develop plant species adapted to local environments and praised Chinese experts for their dedication and openness. "The enthusiasm of the Chinese researchers, scientists, and experts stationed at different sites, who were eager to share their experiences and practical insights with us, was remarkable," Shibabaw said. The expert called for more concrete strategies to elevate the China-Ethiopia ecological partnership, particularly in policy-making, financing, innovation, and environmental governance. Noting the ecological diversity shared by the two countries, Shibabaw said Ethiopia's varied landscapes provide "fertile ground" for applying China's proven conservation, rehabilitation, and reforestation strategies. "This shared ecological diversity creates a natural laboratory for collaborative problem-solving," he said.
