French PM decries 'anti-Semitic hatred' after memorial tree cut down
An olive tree, planted in 2011 in Halimi's memory, was cut down, probably with a chainsaw, overnight Wednesday to Thursday in the northern Paris suburb of Epinay-sur-Seine, officials said.
The move stoked fresh concerns about an increase in anti-Semitic acts and hate crime against Jewish people in France.
"The tree for Ilan Halimi, a living bulwark against oblivion, has been cut down by anti-Semitic hatred," Bayrou said on X on Friday.
"No crime can eradicate memory. The never-ending fight against the deadly poison of hatred is our primary duty," he added.
Herve Chevreau, the mayor of Epinay-sur-Seine, said on Thursday he had filed a complaint.
Paris police chief Laurent Nunez condemned what he called a "despicable act."
"An investigation has been launched. Everything will be done to find the perpetrators and bring them to justice," Nunez said on X.
Jewish groups in France have said that the number of anti-Semitic acts has surged following the attack by Hamas on Israel on October 7, 2023 which was followed by Israel's bombardment of the Gaza Strip and aid blockade.
Advertisement
Halimi was lured by a 17-year-old girl to a housing estate basement in the suburbs, where he was attacked and subdued with ether.
Held prisoner for ransom, Halimi was tortured for 24 days before he was found naked and handcuffed to a tree near a railway track on February 13, 2006.
Halimi's kidnap and murder stirred debate about anti-Semitism in France after police initially refused to consider it a hate crime, with tens of thousands taking to the street to demand justice.
Youssouf Fofana, the head of the gang, was sentenced to life in prison.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
17 hours ago
- France 24
Serbia's student-led protesters wanted accountability. Now they're calling for elections
For the past three nights, Serbia 's streets have been shaken by fierce clashes between thousands of anti-government protesters and ranks of masked ruling party loyalists. The student-led demonstrators have accused the ruling Serbian Progressive Party (SNS)'s supporters of hurling flares, fireworks, rocks and glass bottles at them, triggering street skirmishes that ended with riot police driving the anti-government protesters off with tear gas and batons. Dozens of people have been injured and scores more arrested. President Alexandar Vučić, who began his political career in the far-right Serbian Radical Party before becoming a proponent of European Union membership, has promised that more arrests will soon follow. Vučić has accused the demonstrations, without evidence, of being plotted from abroad by unidentified foreign powers. The clashes mark a serious escalation in what has been more than nine months of largely peaceful protests and waves of civil disobedience. The demonstrations erupted in November following the fatal collapse of a concrete canopy in a recently renovated railway station that killed 16 people in Serbia's second city of Novi Sad – an accident that protesters, who have taken a blood-red handprint as their symbol, blame on cronyism and graft within Serbia's government and construction industry. Since then, a student-led movement of hundreds of thousands of Serbians have held mass demonstrations, occupied university campuses and blockaded the Balkan country's roads to protest what they describe as rampant government corruption. FRANCE 24 spoke with University of Belgrade Serbian Politics professor Nebojša Vladisavljević about how the mass protests have changed over the course of a struggle that how now lasted more than nine months. FRANCE 24: How have the mass demonstrations evolved in recent months, and why have their demands expanded? In the first few months, the demands of the protesters focused on the legal and political responsibility of those responsible for the deaths of 16 people in Novi Sad – meaning those involved in the renovation of the railway station, but also their political bosses. So the focus was on the judiciary, the prosecution service to initiate legal proceedings against these guys. But obviously that didn't work out, despite massive protests. These are unprecedented protests in this region, and probably even more broadly in Europe in the last few decades. The country is about 6 million people and you had literally hundreds of thousands of people protesting for months. Only in Belgrade, you had four protests in several months, each larger than a hundred thousand people. And Belgrade is a city of a million and a half. And one of these protests in mid-March was about 300,000 people, which is four to five percent of the population of the country as a whole, so it's massive. Tens of thousands of protesters rally against populist Serbian government 01:42 The government and the judiciary essentially ignored their demands for accountability. Even after several months, these proceedings that the prosecutors initiated, they were not confirmed by the courts. That obviously told people that nothing will happen. That's why demands were shifted to the political stage for early parliamentary elections, because it was obvious that under this government, nothing much would happen when it came to these initial demands. You had very peaceful protests for eight months. And in late June, there was this fourth protest in Belgrade, which was above 100,000 people, and then the police for the first time actually used massive force against peaceful protesters – and that was after the protest, when people were already dispersing. This is a major escalation because prior to late June, essentially the government and the security forces were sitting out protests – they waited for protests to subside exactly in the same way as they did in previous years, because we had several waves of protests in the last few years. But this time they actually changed strategy and used massive force and detained hundreds of people, most young people, across the country, which then radicalised protests in the following weeks. Earlier, you would have rallies or marches or short blockades of roads these were commemorative road blockades for 16 minutes, for the 16 people killed in Novi Sad. But now, after the use of force by the police, you had road blockades for hours. And protesters were avoiding contact with the police – whenever the police would come, they would go to another street and then block another street. In the last few days, we've seen another escalation, which is by the use of the ruling party's hired gangs, who pose as supporters of the ruling party. You recognise them by kind of being uniformly dressed – they're in civilian clothes, but you see that they all have black t-shirts, black short pants, black baseball caps, some are hooded – and they go together, some carrying sticks, to guard offices of the ruling party across the country and provoke protesters so that the police would then beat them up. And that's what we've seen in the last few days. To what extent do this week's confrontations mark a change in the scale of the mobilisation of these kinds of extra-legal security forces? It's the question of scale, essentially. They've used these guys often in previous years, but always kind of trying to do it when nobody sees what's going on – so they were used to beat up people here and there on behalf of the ruling party to put pressure on all sorts of people, even their own party members who wouldn't toe the party line, but especially against government critics. But again, not in public, really, and they were rarely uniformly dressed as they are now. So now, they are obvious to everybody. What we see these days is that they are working closely with the police – in some cases, police are even getting orders from some of them, which is something that we haven't seen before, and we even see some people with criminal records among them. One of the more famous ones is Djordje Prelić, who was convicted for the murder of Brice Taton, the French football supporter who died in Belgrade in 2009, essentially murdered by local thugs. So one of those guys was seen among these titushky in the last few days [Editor's note: A term for mercenary agent provocateurs, often dressed as football hooligans, that was popularised under former Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovich]. They try to present this now as some sort of counter-mobilisation of supporters of Vučić, but actually, it's not. It just hired gangs. Just a few years ago, the ruling party had the capacity to mobilise quite a few people in support of Vučić and the ruling party. We had several waves of opposition protests in the last few years, and in 2019 the ruling party held a counter rally in Belgrade, which actually mobilised about 60,000 people. It was a very large protest that rivalled the opposition protests. This year, they tried to do this on several occasions, but actually mobilised very few people – only those who actually had to be there, party officials, public sector workers, some temporary contracts, people on social benefits who are afraid that they will lose some if they don't come. Now they can't even mobilise anybody to come to defend them. That's why they are now using these hired gangs, obviously, because they can't mobilise anybody else. To what extent is Vučić 's government trying to actively defuse some of these calls for accountability and responsibility rather than merely meeting the protests with naked force? When it comes to the rhetoric, he's being doing it throughout, trying to pose as if he were doing something to achieve accountability when it comes to what happened in Novi Sad. But actually, they've done nothing much when it comes to this. In late July two former ministers and a few other people, they were arrested for serious charges. Not for small things, but for fraud of over $100 million when it comes to this fast railway from Belgrade to Subotica. Serbia targets journalists in crackdown on independent media 01:46 It's still unclear where it came from – having in mind how the Vučić press and tabloid media attacked those prosecutors who initiated this, it seems that he's losing control over the prosecution service and the judiciary. He obviously has some guys firmly under control. Vucic and his loyalists at the top of the government have been quite nervous when these arrests happened. So it seems that he's losing control within the judiciary at this point. But again, it is really unclear whether this will end up in convictions. How do you explain Vučić's reticence to call early elections that his coalition might be able to use to bolster its legitimacy in the face of these protests? The trouble that they face at this point is that their popularity fell substantially in the last few months. It's true that initially many people who were actually government critics and from the opposition didn't want to raise the question of snap elections for several reasons. Firstly, because they felt that this would move attention away from what happened in Novi Sad and from the accountability issue – and that was the stance for most people. But also because they felt that Vučić was still at that point popular and the opposition wouldn't be able to gain much in elections. But that was early this year. In the meantime, things have changed … There was a credible opinion poll done by two of my colleagues, professors from the faculty of political science at the University of Belgrade. They did a large poll: the government at this point has fewer supporters than the opposition. So it's about 40, 41 percent for the whole ruling coalition and over 50 percent for the opposition. Now, obviously, we still don't know if we had a snap election whether there will be one opposition list or two or three. But they were assessing all of these possibilities, and whichever possibility you take, whether it's one opposition list or two or three – the opposition wins. The poll was done about a month ago. So, there is a good reason why Vučić avoids early elections at this point – because it seems according to the polls that he would lose even an unfair election, even an authoritarian election. That's why he's trying to kind of postpone this. But my guess is we will have an election in the next few months. Because the country is totally blocked. Nothing works. You can't do anything – the government has lost the capacity to rule, essentially. The only way out is by elections.
France 24
21 hours ago
- France 24
Macron pledges action over anti-Semitic 'hatred' after memorial tree vandalised
President Emmanuel Macron on Friday vowed punishment over an act of anti-Semitic "hatred" after a memorial tree planted in tribute to a Jewish man tortured to death in 2006 had been cut down outside Paris. "Cutting down the tree in honour of Ilan Halimi is tantamount to killing him a second time," Macron said on X. "Every effort will be made to punish this act of hatred," he said, adding that the country will not forget the "son of France who died because he was Jewish." On January 20, 2006, 23-year-old Ilan Halimi, was kidnapped by a gang of youths and tortured in a housing estate in the Paris suburb of Bagneux. Found three weeks later, he died on the way to hospital. An olive tree, planted in 2011 in Halimi's memory, was cut down, probably with a chainsaw, overnight Wednesday to Thursday in the northern Paris suburb of Epinay-sur-Seine, officials said. The move stoked fresh concerns about an increase in anti-Semitic acts and hate crime against Jewish people in France. French Prime Minister Francois Bayrou condemned an act of "anti-Semitic hatred". "The tree for Ilan Halimi, a living bulwark against oblivion, has been cut down by anti-Semitic hatred," Bayrou said on X on Friday. "No crime can eradicate memory. The never-ending fight against the deadly poison of hatred is our primary duty," he added. Herve Chevreau, the mayor of Epinay-sur-Seine, said on Thursday he had filed a complaint. Paris police chief Laurent Nunez condemned what he called a "despicable act." "An investigation has been launched. Everything will be done to find the perpetrators and bring them to justice," Nunez said on X. Jewish groups in France have said that the number of anti-Semitic acts has surged following the attack by Hamas on Israel on October 7, 2023 which was followed by Israel 's bombardment of the Gaza Strip and aid blockade. Halimi was lured by a 17-year-old girl to a housing estate basement in the suburbs, where he was attacked and subdued with ether. Held prisoner for ransom, Halimi was tortured for 24 days before he was found naked and handcuffed to a tree near a railway track on February 13, 2006. Halimi's kidnap and murder stirred debate about anti-Semitism in France after police initially refused to consider it a hate crime, with tens of thousands taking to the street to demand justice. Youssouf Fofana, the head of the gang, was sentenced to life in prison.
France 24
a day ago
- France 24
Macron vows to punish antisemitic 'hatred' after memorial tree cut down
Politicians across the political spectrum condemned the act as an attack against the memory of Ilan Halimi, who was kidnapped by a gang of around 20 youths in January 2006 and tortured in a low-income housing estate in the Paris suburb of Bagneux. Found three weeks later, the 23-year-old died on the way to hospital. An olive tree, planted in 2011 in Halimi's memory, was cut down, probably with a chainsaw, on Wednesday night in the northern Paris suburb of Epinay-sur-Seine. The incident stoked fresh concerns about an increase in antisemitic acts and hate crimes in France as international tensions mount over Gaza. "Every effort will be made to punish this act of hatred," Macron said on X, adding that France's fight against antisemitism will be "uncompromising". "The nation will not forget this son of France who died because he was Jewish," Macron said. Prime Minister Francois Bayrou called the tree "a living bulwark against oblivion". "The never-ending fight against the deadly poison of hatred is our primary duty," he added. Officials pledged to plant a new memorial tree "as soon as possible". - 'Extremely painful' - Members of France's Jewish community -- one of the largest in the world -- have said the number of antisemitic acts has surged following the attack by Hamas on Israel on October 7, 2023 which was followed by Israel's bombardment of the Gaza Strip and aid blockade. In 2006, Halimi's murder struck horror into France's Jewish community and stirred debate about antisemitism in France. Police at the time initially refused to consider the murder a hate crime, and tens of thousands took to the street to demand justice. Yonathan Arfi, president of the Representative Council of Jewish Institutions in France (CRIF), said on Friday the felling of the tree was "extremely painful". "There is nothing more cowardly, and those who have murdered his memory are no better than those who took his life 20 years ago," Arfi told AFP. "This is not just another antisemitic act, it is a way for antisemites to shout that they are here more than ever." Herve Chevreau, the mayor of Epinay-sur-Seine, filed a criminal complaint. Paris police chief Laurent Nunez condemned what he called a "despicable act" and said an investigation had been launched. Halimi was lured by a 17-year-old girl to a housing estate basement in the suburbs, where he was attacked and subdued with ether. Held prisoner for ransom, Halimi was tortured for 24 days before he was found naked, bound and gagged on February 13, 2006. Youssouf Fofana, the head of the gang dubbed the "Barbarians", was sentenced to life in prison. The son of Ivorian immigrants, Fofana had recruited followers among youths from Paris's bleak immigrant suburbs. Two other trees planted in tribute to Halimi were vandalised and sawn down in 2019 in the southern suburb of Sainte-Genevieve-des-Bois, where Halimi was found dying near a railway track. Reported antisemitic acts in France surged from 436 in 2022 to 1,676 in 2023, before dipping to 1,570 last year, according to the interior ministry.
