Lawsuits accuse insurers of colluding to drop coverage in fire-prone parts of California
Two lawsuits filed in Los Angeles allege major home insurance companies have colluded to limit coverage in California communities at high risk for wildfires and force homeowners onto the state's last-resort insurance plan that offers basic coverage and high premiums.
Insurers, including State Farm and 24 other companies that hold 75% of California's home insurance market, were part of an 'illegal scheme' in violation of California's antitrust and unfair competition laws, according to one of the lawsuits, filed last week.
The lawsuit said the companies worked together in 2023 to 'suddenly and simultaneously' drop coverage or halt writing new policies in fire-prone areas, including in neighborhoods like Pacific Palisades and Altadena that were leveled in the January wildfires that destroyed nearly 17,000 structures and killed at least 30 people. That has forced hundreds of homeowners onto the FAIR Plan that offers limited coverage capping at $3 million, leaving them underinsured and now struggling to rebuild after the fires, says the lawsuit filed by a group of homeowners who lost their houses in the LA fires.
The other lawsuit includes all policyholders who obtained the FAIR Plan after January 2023, when the conspiracy allegedly began, the suit says.
' Insurance is a product that homeowners hope never to need, but rely on for peace of mind in normal times and for critical help rebuilding after a catastrophe,' Michael J. Bidart, who represents the homeowners, said in a statement. 'The complaints allege that, by colluding to push plaintiffs and so many like them to the FAIR Plan, the defendants have reaped the benefits of high premiums while depriving homeowners of coverage that they were ready, willing, and able to purchase to ensure that they could recover after a disaster like January's wildfires.'
The lawsuits come as California is struggling to rein in an ongoing insurance crisis, where companies are boosting rates, limiting coverage or pulling out completely from regions susceptible to wildfires and other natural disasters in the era of climate change. In 2023, several major insurance companies either paused or restricted new business in the state, saying they can't truly price the risk on properties as wildfires are becoming more common and destructive in California due to climate change.
The state Department of Insurance said it is not involved in the suits but said its focus is on protecting consumers.
'Californians deserve a system that works — one where decisions are made openly, rates reflect real risk, and no one is left without options,' department spokesperson Gabriel Sanchez said in a statement.
State Farm, the largest home insurer in California with roughly a million policies, didn't immediately respond to requests for comment. Representatives from the American Property Casualty Insurance Association, the largest national trade association representing home, auto and business insurers, also did not respond for comment.
The FAIR Plan is an insurance pool that all the major private insurers pay into, and the plan then issues policies to people who can't get private insurance because their properties are deemed too risky to insure. The plan, with high premiums and basic coverage, is designed as a temporary option until homeowners can find permanent coverage, but more Californians are relying on it than ever. There were more than 555,000 home policies on the FAIR Plan as of March, more than double the number in 2020.
The complaints also allege that insurers were pushing policyholders onto the FAIR Plan because companies wouldn't have to shoulder all financial responsibility to sustain the plan. When the state's top insurance regulator in February ordered insurers to provide $1 billion to the FAIR Plan to help it pay out claims related to the LA wildfires, he allowed for half of the cost to be recouped from policyholders statewide. Another lawsuit was filed last week to block the cost-shifting regulation.
California has been in the process of implementing various new regulations to give insurers more latitude to raise premiums in exchange for issuing more policies in high-risk areas. That includes regulations allowing insurers to consider climate change when setting their prices and allowing them to pass on the costs of reinsurance to California consumers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
22-05-2025
- Daily Mail
Americans are fleeing woke coastal areas and flocking to unexpected Southern gems
Americans are packing up and heading to warmer, cheaper cities, with new data revealing where people are flocking to — and the places they can't escape from fast enough. The South continues to dominate as the nation's top relocation hotspot, according to a new report from PODS Moving and Storage. The region led for move-ins last year, and it's on track to do the same in 2025. Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, and Wilmington, North Carolina, top this year's list of most popular move-in destinations. The area's warm weather, relaxed lifestyle, and relatively low cost of living make it a magnet for retirees and families alike. Other East Coast standouts in the top 10 include Raleigh and Charlotte in North Carolina, as well as Greenville-Spartanburg in South Carolina. Ocala, Florida — a small city of 63,000 known for its thoroughbred farms and scenic forests — ranked second nationwide. Dallas–Fort Worth, Texas, made a surprise leap to fifth place, after failing to crack the top 10 last year. Experts say the city's strong job market, mild winters, and affordability are behind the surge. The data shows a 'desire for warmer climates, lower costs of living, and a greater focus on balance and quality of life,' Rich Schwartz of PODS said of this year's report. 'While the Southeast continues to dominate the top of the list, we are seeing areas across the south, like Dallas-Fort Worth, making big moves.' Californian saw three of its cities in the top 10 places with the most move-outs this year. Los Angeles topped the list, followed by the San Francisco area in second and San Diego in fifth. Los Angeles has been battered by the devastating wildfires earlier this year, and residents now also face rising home insurance costs. The East Coast also took a battering with Long Island in New York seeing the fourth biggest loss of residents this year. Also in New York the Hudson Valley north of Manhattan also made the top 10. Central Jersey in New Jersey and Boston, Massachusetts ranked 6th and eight respectively. Meanwhile, there are increasing fears that the US property market could crash. In fact, realtors warned last week that South Florida 's pandemic property boom has officially reversed. After years of surging demand due to the pandemic real estate boom, the region's real estate market is flooded with listings as desperate homeowners rush to sell amid soaring costs and vanishing buyers. According to a new report from Cotality, the number of homes for sale across Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties has quadrupled since 2022 — hitting the highest level in nearly a decade.
The Guardian
21-05-2025
- The Guardian
State Farm pursues additional 11% rate increase in California after emergency rate hike approval
Condo owners and renters could see a larger jump in insurance costs as State Farm General pursues an overall 30% rate increase for homeowners policies in California. This comes just a week after the company was granted a 17% emergency interim hike, down from the nearly 22% increase it originally requested, following a ruling approved by insurance commissioner, Ricardo Lara. State Farm confirmed to the Guardian that it plans to seek an additional 11% rate hike the company had proposed last year. First reported by the San Francisco Chronicle, State Farm says these increases are necessary due to 'severe capital depletion', especially after the devastating Los Angeles County wildfires. If approved, the average annual premium could rise by about $600 for homeowners, $163 for condo owners and $30 for renters, the Chronicle reported. A spokesperson for the California department of insurance told the Guardian that a rate hearing on the same request is scheduled to 'get to the facts'. 'They want more? We want more data, more transparency, more policyholders served, and more policies written in wildfire distressed areas,' a spokesperson for the department said in a statement. 'State Farm wanting a rate increase doesn't change the law. All rates must be justified so consumers don't pay more than is required.' The increase will apply to all of the roughly 1 million homeowners State Farm insures in the state. The next hearing is scheduled for 20 October. State Farm General has said that the rate hike intends to help 'stabilize' the company's financial position and ensure its ability to serve Californians over the 'long-term'. The company said that the increase was not to cover wildfire losses, but rather a 'critical first step' in restoring its overall financial health, which is essential for paying future claims. 'While we are pleased that Commissioner Lara approved the interim rate of 17% for State Farm General Insurance Company, this change only addressed part of the original request of 30% filed in June 2024,' a spokesperson for State Farm General Insurance Company said. Back in February, State Farm General estimated its direct wildfire-related losses at about $7.6bn, including both reported and anticipated claims. 'We remain deeply concerned about the financial position of State Farm General, as it is difficult to match price to risk in California,' the insurer said in a May update. In June of last year, the company sought a 30% rate hike for homeowners' policies, as well as a 36% increase for condo owners and a 52% increase for renters. The sudden increase raised questions about the insurer's financial stability. State Farm chose not to renew fire insurance for 1,626 State Farm customers in the Palisades neighborhood in 2024, according to California's insurance office. They represented about 70% of State Farm's market share in Pacific Palisades, according to the San Francisco Chronicle. Sign up to Headlines US Get the most important US headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion 'This decision was not made lightly and only after careful analysis of State Farm General's financial health, which continues to be impacted by inflation, catastrophe exposure, reinsurance costs, and the limitations of working within decades-old insurance regulations,' the insurer said. The consumer advocacy group Consumer Watchdog said it had urged Lara to reject the emergency interim rate increase during a hearing in April, stating that State Farm General had 'failed to meet the legal standard required under California law to justify a mid-proceeding rate hike'. The group also questioned how fair the proposed settlement was between the Department and State Farm. They cited testimony from State Farm's expert, Dr David Appel, who claimed that the interim rate increase poses 'no risk to policyholders'. 'Dr Appel evaluated the settlement from State Farm's perspective alone,' said William Pletcher, litigation director at Consumer Watchdog. 'But $40 or $50 a month is a serious hardship for California families already struggling to stay afloat.' The already-approved rate hikes will appear on homeowners' bills at their next renewal date after 1 June. An additional rate increase, if approved, would take effect at each customers' first renewal in 2026, according to the Chronicle.
Daily Mail
15-05-2025
- Daily Mail
California greenlights State Farm Home insurance rate increase
State Farm General, California's largest home insurer, has been granted approval to raise its home insurance rates across the state — triggering fierce backlash from consumer advocates. A judge and Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara (pictured) approved the hike, which will see average home insurance premiums rise by 17 percent. Condo owners and renters will also see average increases of 15 percent, while rental property owners will be hit hardest with a staggering 38 percent jump. 'It is unthinkable that State Farm would do this after so many families in the area were affected by wildfires,' said Los Angeles native Andrea Smith, referencing the blazes that ravaged parts of the city in January. The rate hike follows a year-long standoff between the insurer and the state, which regulates premium increases. Experts had warned that price hikes were inevitable as insurers faced massive payouts for wildfires that severely damaged the Pacific Palisades neighborhood and thousands of other homes across Los Angeles County. State Farm says the latest round of price increases is necessary to stop the company going bust, especially in the wake of the devastating Los Angeles fires which damaged its bottom line further. State Farm has so far received nearly 12,700 claims from wildfire victims, and has paid customers more than $3.5 billion, the San Francisco Chronicle reported. Although regulators have approved the price rise, a public hearing has also been instigated at which State Farm will have to prove its finances are in a state that justifies the enormous price rise for consumers. As part of the agreement State Farm will also not drop the additional customers it had threatened to cut until at least the end of the year. This includes keeping all its customers in Los Angeles County for at least a year. The ruling has faced fierce pushback from consumer advocacy groups including Consumer Watchdog. 'Today's decision that would make consumers pay now but allow State Farm to wait months before having to show its math is a great disappointment for consumers,' the group's executive director said in a statement. 'Voter-approved Proposition 103 says a rate hike shouldn't come before the rate justification, but that's what happened here.' Other insurance companies, including Allstate and Farmers Direct, have also limited cover or stopped doing business entirely in the Golden State. This led to California introducing new regulations aimed at easing the state's home insurance crisis - days before the deadly fires broke out. Want more stories like this from the Daily Mail? Hit the follow button above for more of the news you need.
