Mark Browne: Investigation into why top civil servant was replaced
Who is Mark Browne?
Mark Browne held the role of permanent secretary for a number of years, including a period when the Stormont Executive had collapsed.In the absence of a functioning government at Stormont from February 2022 until January 2024, departments were run by senior civil servants.As permanent secretary for education, Mr Browne had to make a number of difficult decisions on cuts in the absence of a minister.But in November 2024 Education Minister Paul Givan informed the chairman of the Stormont's Education Committee, Alliance assembly member Nick Mathison, that a temporary permanent secretary was being put in place.The former head of the Northern Ireland Prison Service, Ronnie Armour, subsequently became the acting permanent secretary at the Department of Education.
Why was Mark Browne replaced?
That is what members of Stormont's Education Committee have been trying to find out.According to correspondence seen by BBC News NI, the committee had a number of questions about the change at the top.In a letter to Givan on 10 January 2025, Mathison, as the committee chair, asked "why there is a vacancy."He said the committee also wanted to know "what difficulties may have arisen, what implications these may have and how they may be resolved."In his reply to the committee, the minister said moves at permanent secretary level were made by the head of the Civil Service (HOCS), a position currently held by Jayne Brady.But in a further letter to Givan in February, the committee sought "further clarification on senior staffing issues.""The committee is concerned about the adequacy of governance checks and balances," Mathison wrote."The committee's letter of 10 January asked 'why there is a vacancy.'""The committee considered that your reply of 21 January did not answer this question, and the committee agreed to ask you the question again."
Givan responded to that letter on 25 March, in which he said he "noted" the concerns of the committee.He again said that the head of the Civil Service had "moved the permanent secretary."Members of the Education Committee subsequently wrote to Ms Brady, asking "what were the considerations which underpinned your move of the permanent secretary."But BBC News NI understands that Ms Brady, as head of the Civil Service, had by that stage appointed a senior Scottish legal figure to investigate the circumstances behind Mr Browne's replacement at the Department of Education.
What has been the response from the Department of Education and Jayne Brady?
When contacted by BBC News NI, a spokesperson for the Northern Ireland Civil Service said: " We do not comment on internal confidential staffing matters."The Department of Education said it had nothing further to add to the response from the Civil Service.The FDA union, which represents senior civil servants, told BBC News NI they were not able to comment at this time.
But the MLA who chairs Stormont's Education Committee says they still have questions.Nick Mathison told BBC News NI "a number of concerns have been raised with me relating to the role of the Permanent Secretary in the Department of Education in recent months.""It was surprising to see an interim permanent secretary announced with no explanation," he said."Seven months on, despite calls for clarity and an explanation from the Education Minister and Head of the Civil Service, we remain in the dark as to why the previous Permanent Secretary is no longer in post or when the position will be filled permanently.""The role is the second most senior in education in Northern Ireland and the sector is facing multiple critical challenges, including school budgets, Special Educational Needs (SEN) provision and school maintenance.""It is vital clarity is given, so the public can have trust in the senior leadership structures across the sector."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
17 hours ago
- The Independent
Mike Johnson says Ghislaine Maxwell coming clean on Epstein case would be ‘a great service to the country'
Speaker Mike Johnson called on Jeffrey Epstein's accomplice, Ghislaine Maxwell, to come clean and told Americans that he "hoped" she could be trusted as he faces the growing uproar around the White House's handling of the investigation. Johnson appeared Sunday on NBC's Meet the Press, where moderator Kristen Welker asked him point-blank if the convicted sex-trafficker girlfriend of Epstein could be trusted to accurately testify about the crimes she and Epstein committed. Epstein was awaiting prosecution for sex trafficking underage girls after a previous conviction on similar charges when he died in federal custody. Maxwell has been thrust back into the spotlight as the MAGA base has grown frustrated with President Donald Trump and his administration's shutting down of the so-called Epstein files release. Last week, a top Department of Justice official met with Maxwell about the case. "Well, I mean, look; it's a good question. I hope so," Johnson told Welker in response. "I hope that she would want to come clean." "I hope she's telling the truth. She is convicted, she's serving a 20-year sentence for child sex trafficking. Her character is in some if she wants to come clean now, that would be a great service to the country. We want to know every bit of information that she has." The House Oversight Committee voted this week to issue a subpoena for Maxwell after the Justice Department announced its own plans to speak with her. Agency officials did so for nine hours between Thursday and Friday, after making a statement seeming to confirm that her testimony hadn't been aggressively sought before. Some have called Maxwell to testify and suggested she should be given a pardon for sharing what she knows about the Epstein case. She was convicted of sexual abuse against minors and sex trafficking for helping Epstein carry out crimes. Johnson touted the Oversight subpoena favorably Sunday, casting it as evidence that GOP leadership supported efforts aimed at transparency. The Trump administration turned speculation about Epstein's death and the so-called 'Client List' of his co-conspirators into a raging wildfire in early July. The Justice Department and FBI published a joint memo explaining that future releases from the files would not take place, and that the list of Epstein's accomplices was not found. Epstein was rumored to have cultivated personal relationships with many powerful men and institutions. Critics of the president have alleged that a cover-up is in the works regarding the Epstein files. Democrats have hammered the president for his reversal, and a pair of scoops from the Wall Street Journal have reported on the president's connections to Epstein, to Trump's fury. The newspaper reported the contents of a message allegedly penned by Trump to Epstein as part of a 50th birthday celebration in 2003, including allusions to a shared 'secret' between them. Trump firmly denied authoring the note, and sued the Journal and its reporters in response. A second article from the Journal days later reported that Attorney General Pam Bondi informed Trump in May that he was mentioned in the Epstein investigation multiple times, thought it was not clear in what context. The White House called that story 'fake' and has repeatedly insinuated that Democrats including Joe Biden tampered with evidence while Trump was out of office. Being mentioned in the files does not mean wrongdoing, and hundreds of names are reportedly included. The lead GOP co-sponsor behind a House resolution that would force the Justice Department to release the entirety of its collected evidence related to Epstein said Sunday that his push was to help the convicted pedophile's victims and would only grow stronger in the coming weeks. Earlier on the same network, Rep. Thomas Massie appeared alongside the resolution's lead Democratic co-sponsor, Rep. Ro Khanna, as the two promoted a resolution that would force Attorney General Pam Bondi to release 'all unclassified records, documents, communications, and investigative materials' related to the Epstein and Maxwell investigations. Massie told Welker that 'the release of the Epstein files is emblematic of what Trump ran for' and explained that the president's MAGA base expected results. 'There seems to be a class of people beyond the law, beyond the judicial all thought that when Trump was elected, he would be the bull in the china shop and break that all up,' said Massie. Massie went on to say that the Trump administration had lost his trust on the issue after publicly supporting transparency around the investigation, then doing an abrupt about-face. The administration is now calling on its supporters to move on from the issue and focus on hashing out issues with the 2016 'Russiagate' investigation instead of Epstein. Top administration officials, including Vice President JD Vance, also spent months calling for the very releases the Justice Department says it won't authorize. 'People who were allegedly working on this weren't sincere in their efforts,' Massie said. 'Somebody should ask Speaker Mike Johnson, why did he recess Congress early so that he didn't have to deal with the Epstein issue?' 'Politics is the art of the doable. There's enough public pressure right now that we can get 218 votes and force this to a vote on the floor,' said Massie. He also firmly rejected a DOJ memo explaining the administration's position against further releases of information from the Epstein files, despite the very public promises of Bondi and others to do the opposite. In the memo, agency officials said that explicit imagery involving children was 'intertwined' throughout the files collected by the Justice Department. Some have said the files should not be released to protect sex-abuse victims of both Maxwell and Epstein. 'That's a straw man [argument],' Massie responded on Sunday, after Welker read part of the memo. 'Ro [Khanna] and I carefully crafted this legislation so that the victims' names would be redacted, and that no child pornography will be released.'
The Independent
18 hours ago
- The Independent
Oklahoma's MAGA superintendent who demanded Bibles in class faces investigation after TV in his office shows naked women
Oklahoma's Trump-loving top school official, known for mandating Bibles in every classroom, is now facing an investigation after naked women were seen on TVs in his office, according to reports. What should have been a mundane Oklahoma State Board of Education executive session Thursday turned shocking after board members saw naked women appear on a TV screen behind Ryan Walters, the Oklahoma State Superintendent of Public Instruction and board chair, in his office, according to The Oklahoman. The Independent has reached out to Walters for comment. A spokesperson for Walters branded the incident as a "junk tabloid lie' to the outlet. Now, the state's Senate has launched a porn probe. Senate President Pro Tempore Lonnie Paxton told the Oklahoma Voice that 'leadership at the agency is working through proper channels to initiate the investigation.' 'This is a bizarre and troubling situation that raises serious questions about the events and what took place during yesterday's executive session at the Oklahoma State Board of Education meeting,' Paxton told the outlet in a statement. 'The accounts made public by board members paint a strange, unsettling scene that demands clarity and transparency.' It's not immediately clear who was responsible for showing the women. Some board members said Walters was facing away from the TV during the meeting. His spokesperson told The Oklahoman: "Any number of people have access to these offices. You have a hostile board who will say and do anything except tell the truth, and now, the Wokelahoman is reporting on an alleged random TV cable image.' Becky Carson, a board member who attended the meeting, said she was "disturbed" by what she saw on TV. 'I saw them just walking across the screen, and I'm like, 'no.' I'm sorry I even have to use this language, but I'm like, 'Those are her nipples.' And then I'm like, 'That's pubic hair.'...I was so disturbed by it…I was very stern, like I'd been a mother or a classroom teacher. And I said, 'What am I watching? Turn it off now!'' she told The Oklahoman. Walters then promptly shut it off, Carson told the outlet. She added: "It looked like it was made in the '60s, maybe.' Fellow board member Ryan Deatherage, who also attended the meeting, said the TV was on throughout the session but the volume was turned down. 'Quite frankly, I didn't know how to handle it. I was just in shock. I was being human and I didn't know what to think. … I kept thinking that it was just going to go away and so I quit watching it,' he told the outlet. He told The Oklahoma Voice that Walters should be held to account. 'We hold educators to the strictest of standards when it comes to explicit material,' Deatherage told the outlet. 'The standard for the superintendent should be no different.' Walters has argued strictly against showing what he deemed 'pornography' in schools. Last year, Walters advocated for banning books that he claims contain 'pornography,' such as the novel The Kite Runner, which contains sexual content. He threatened to lower the accreditation of a school district if it didn't remove such books from libraries' shelves. Edmond Public Schools then filed a lawsuit against Walters. "Edmond Public Schools not only allows kids to access porn in schools, they are doubling down to keep pornography on the bookshelves," Walters said in a statement. The Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled in favor of the school district last June, determining Walters and the state's department of education overstepped. Walters has also touted the teachings of the Bible. Last June, he issued a mandate requiring the historic text be a fixture in classrooms and curriculum— for grades 5 through 12 — across the state. 'The left is upset, but one cannot rewrite history,' he said last June. Faith leaders and parents then sued Walters last October. 'The Mandate interferes with the parents' ability to direct the religious and moral upbringing of their children. The children themselves face coercive instruction on religion in their public schools that is contrary to their own beliefs,' the plaintiffs argued. The state supreme court temporarily blocked the mandate in March. Last week, however, he filed a motion with the state's highest court, demanding it lift the stay. 'The Left has launched an all-out assault on Christianity in this country and will stop at nothing to destroy the Bible's significance in our country and the principles that shaped this country,' Walters said in a statement Tuesday. 'Students cannot fully understand American History without understanding the Bible's role in it, despite the liberal hysteria we continue to see.'
The Independent
18 hours ago
- The Independent
Thomas Massie says Epstein files need to be released ‘for the victims' and demands a vote to release info
The lead GOP co-sponsor behind a resolution that would force the Justice Department to release the entirety of its collected evidence related to Jeffrey Epstein said Sunday that his push was to help the convicted pedophile's victims and would only grow stronger in the coming weeks. On NBC's Meet the Press, Rep. Thomas Massie appeared alongside the resolution's lead Democratic co-sponsor, Rep. Ro Khanna, as the two promoted a resolution that would force Attorney General Pam Bondi to release 'all unclassified records, documents, communications, and investigative materials' related to the Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell investigations. The issue has become divisive among the Trump-aligned right, especially on podcasting and new media platforms, as Donald Trump angrily insists that his supporters must move on from the investigation and has sought to distract MAGAworld with new allegations about Barack Obama and the investigation into his own 2016 run for the White House. Massie told moderator Kristen Welker on Sunday that 'the release of the Epstein files is emblematic of what Trump ran for' and explained that the president's MAGA base expected results. 'There seems to be a class of people beyond the law, beyond the judicial all thought that when Trump was elected, he would be the bull in the china shop and break that all up,' said Massie.
