State witness in Joshlin Smith case granted prosecutorial immunity
This comes as the convicted trio, Kelly 'Racquel' Smith, Jacquen 'Boeta' Appollis and Steveno van Rhyn, were denied leave to appeal their sentences and convictions, with the judge saying he doesn't believe any other court would come to a different conclusion.
Judge Nathan Charles Erasmus ruled that Lombaard could not be prosecuted for the kidnapping of the six-year-old girl, noting that while she was aware of the arrangements and kept quiet, she played no role in the actual abduction.
'You may not be prosecuted for this offence,' Erasmus said.
The decision was made after considering her testimony and the legal provisions under Section 204 of the Criminal Procedure Act.
State prosecutor Zelda Swanepoel told the court that Lombaard had made 'huge personal sacrifices' by leaving her home and children to enter witness protection and face intense cross-examination.
'The court must understand the nerve, a witness box is not an easy place to be in. The cross-examination was intense,' Swanepoel said.
Lombaard's evidence was key in revealing that Joshlin had been sold to a sangoma for R20,000, a revelation that helped secure the convictions.
Advocate Eben van Tonder, acting for Lombaard, said she had 'much to lose' and that this in itself incentivised her to be truthful.
Defence lawyers for the three convicts continued to challenge the fairness of the trial, accusing the state of procedural violations, unlawful detention and withholding of information.
Advocate Nobahle Mkabayi, representing Van Rhyn, claimed her client's confession was extracted under duress and that they had appeared in court 'bare-handed and clueless'.
Advocate Fanie Harmse, for Appollis, argued that another suspect, Phumza 'Maka Lima' Sigaqa, was never charged despite evidence suggesting Joshlin may have been taken to her home.
He also pointed out that Appollis had injuries when arrested, saying that his injuries cannot be wished away.
The hearing was marked by tense exchanges between the judge and the defence, with Mkabayi accusing Erasmus of creating a hostile environment that denied her client the right to be heard.
Erasmus dismissed the claims, saying both sides had been given equal opportunity to present their cases.
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
12 hours ago
- The Herald
Amantle Samane's family in pain as her killer found guilty
The family of six-year-old Amantle Samane, who was murdered in Soweto last year, are struggling to contain the pain caused by her killer Phethe Sara Simiao. The Mozambican, who worked as a welder, was found guilty of rape, kidnapping, murder and contravention of the Immigration Act in the Johannesburg high court on Friday. He pleaded guilty earlier in the day, saying he was intoxicated when, on October 21 2024, he saw the child playing on the street, took her to his backyard shack, kept her there against her will, raped and strangled her. His case was postponed to Tuesday for pre-sentencing proceedings. Amantle's mother Ntombizodwa Samane sobbed when the plea statement was read into the court record. The family's spokesperson Brenda Mjiyako said it was a heartbreaking session when they heard his version of the murder. ' It brought back the memories: of her last day, the pictures of where we found Amantle deceased, and the mortuary. 'The mother broke down, we all broke down in tears. We knew this day would come b ut we didn't think it would be so difficult. When they were reading, step by step what had happened, you could reflect back. It was painful.' She said what Simiao did was inhuman. ' There is no normal human being who can do what [he] did to Amantle. 'Next week, on Tuesday, is the beginning of sentencing. Her mother will be on the stand again and it is Amantle's birthday on Tuesday. It is not going to be easy,' she said. Amantle was playing with other children across the street from her home that day. Her mother was preparing clothes for her grade R graduation ceremony and completing other household chores, TimesLIVE reported previously. When she finished, she looked outside and saw Amantle was not there. She began searching and made the discovery of her child's body, partially undressed and covered in a blanket, only a few doors away. National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson Phindi Mjonondwane welcomed the decision by Simiao to not waste the NPA and the court's time by pleading guilty. 'W e look forward to the next step, which is pre-sentencing proceedings. As the state, we will prepare a victim impact report and further evidence will also be led' she said. TimesLIVE
The Herald
15 hours ago
- The Herald
'I was drunk when I attacked Amantle Samane': killer admits guilt
Phethe Sara Simiao, 25, says he was drunk when he kidnapped six-year-old Amantle Samane in Orlando, Soweto. The details of how he kidnapped the girl and took her to his backyard shack are contained in his plea statement. The Mozambican, who worked as a welder, pleaded guilty to charges of rape, kidnapping, murder and contravention of the Immigration Act in the Johannesburg high court on Friday. 'On the day [October 21 2024] I was drinking whisky with my friend on the streets and I saw Amantle playing on the street and called her,' he said in the plea statement. 'I took her to my shack without her permission. 'I left her in my shack and went outside to buy beer. I prevented her from leaving.' On his return he undressed, raped and strangled her. 'I was aware that killing someone was wrongful and unlawful and punishable by the law.' Amantle was playing with other children across the street from her home that day. Her mother Ntombizodwa was preparing clothes for her child's grade R graduation ceremony and completing other household chores, TimesLIVE reported previously. When she finished, she looked outside and saw Amantle was not there. She began searching and made the discovery of her child's body, partially undressed and covered in a blanket, only a few doors away. The court is expected to deliver its verdict later on Friday.
The Herald
15 hours ago
- The Herald
Korsten kidnapping victim released
A Korsten businessman who was kidnapped on Wednesday has since been released. Police spokesperson Captain Sandra Janse van Rensburg confirmed that the 47-year-old man was released on Thursday. 'The SA Police Service (SAPS) confirms that the man that was taken in Nielson Street, Neave Industrial area on Wednesday evening was released on Thursday in the vicinity of Motherwell. She however remained tight lipped about details of the case. 'The circumstances surrounding his release will form part of the investigation. 'He is 47 years old, investigation is at a sensitive stage and his name cannot be released due to security reasons.' The man's release comes as a threating voice note directed at kidnappers in Gqeberha surfaced on social media. 'Let this message go out to all the kidnappers,' it states. This as a man goes on to mention six names and their alleged accomplices. 'If you don't release that Muslim brother and that white lady... tonight by 9.30 all the kidnappers, all the kidnappers will face the consequences! 'So you better see that you release these people or else all the kidnappers will face the consequences tonight.' The 47-year-old's kidnapping comes after Kariega resident Theresa Minnie, 73, was kidnapped while backing her car out of her driveway in the quiet Kariega suburb of Fairbridge Heights at about 5.30am on Monday. The Hawks were yet to respond to an enquiry regarding Minnie's case by the time of publication. This is a developing story. The Herald
