Is suspending asylum requests the right way to curb immigration?
Greece has suspended asylum applications for people arriving by sea for three months.
That has come about after a large rise in the number of people crossing the Mediterranean Sea from Libya to the Greek island of Crete. list of 3 items list 1 of 3 list 2 of 3 list 3 of 3 end of list
Athens wants to stop their boats from even entering Greek waters.
Human rights groups said denying them asylum is against international law.
So can a change in policy really stop people heading to Europe? Are North African countries able to help in reducing the number of boats? And what are the likely outcomes of this suspension?
Presenter: Adrian Finighan
Guests:
Eleni Spathana – lawyer with Refugee Support Aegean and author of Legal Assistance for Asylum Seekers and Refugees in Greece
Amine Snoussi – political analyst and journalist
Marianna Karakoulaki – researcher at Birmingham University focusing on forced migration on Europe's Eastern Mediterranean migratory route
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Qatar Tribune
3 days ago
- Qatar Tribune
Thousands protest against plans for world's longest bridge in Sicily
agencies Thousands of people have marched in Sicily to protest against a government plan to build a bridge that would connect the Italian mainland to the Mediterranean island, and would be the world's longest single-span bridge. Some 10,000 demonstrators marched in the Sicilian city of Messina on Saturday to stage their opposition to the 13.5-billion-euro ($15.7bn) infrastructure project. Residents are against the proposed Strait of Messina Bridge project over its scale, earthquake threats, environmental effect, and potential mafia interference. The idea to build the bridge has been debated for decades. This week, however, it saw a major step forward when a government committee overseeing strategic public investments approved the plan. Transport Minister Matteo Salvini called it 'the biggest infrastructure project in the West'. Salvini cited studies estimating the project would create up to 120,000 jobs annually and help stimulate economic growth in lagging southern Italy, as billions more are invested in surrounding road and infrastructure improvements. Critics, however, are not convinced, and angered that about 500 families would have to be expropriated for the bridge to be built. Salvini says such families will be compensated. 'The Strait of Messina can't be touched,' protesters shouted as they marched in Messina. Many carried banners that said 'No Ponte' (No Bridge). 'They could offer me three times the value of my house, but that doesn't matter to me. What matters is the landscape. They must not touch the Strait of Messina,' Mariolina De Francesco, a 75-year-old resident of Messina whose house lies near the site of one of the bridge's planned 399-metre- (440-yard-)tall land towers, told The Associated Press news agency. 'Our lawyers will take action, and we will stop them. That's guaranteed.' The proposed bridge would span nearly 3.7km (2.3 miles) with a suspended section of 3.3km (more than 2 miles). It would surpass Turkiye's Canakkale Bridge by 1,277 metres (1,400 yards) to become the longest suspension bridge in the world. Preliminary work could begin in late September or early October, pending approval from Italy's Court of Audit. Full construction is scheduled to begin in 2026, with completion planned between 2032 and 2033. The bridge would reduce the time to cross the strait by ferry, usually up to 100 minutes, to 10 minutes by car. Trains would save 2.5 hours in transit time, Salvini said. The project could also support Italy's commitment to raise defence spending to 5 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) targeted by NATO, as the government has indicated it would classify the bridge as defence-related. Italy argues that the bridge would form a strategic corridor for rapid troop movements and equipment deployment, qualifying it as 'security-enhancing infrastructure'. Environmental groups, however, have lodged complaints with the European Union, citing concerns that the project would affect migratory birds. Italy's president has also insisted that the project remain subject to anti-mafia legislation that applies to all large-scale infrastructure projects.
Al Jazeera
3 days ago
- Al Jazeera
Thousands protest plan to build world's longest bridge from Sicily to Italy
Thousands of people have marched in Sicily to protest against a government plan to build a bridge that would connect the Italian mainland to the Mediterranean island, and would be the world's longest single-span bridge. Some 10,000 demonstrators marched in the Sicilian city of Messina on Saturday to stage their opposition to the 13.5-billion-euro ($15.7bn) infrastructure project. Residents are against the proposed Strait of Messina Bridge project over its scale, earthquake threats, environmental effect, and potential mafia interference. The idea to build the bridge has been debated for decades. This week, however, it saw a major step forward when a government committee overseeing strategic public investments approved the plan. Transport Minister Matteo Salvini called it 'the biggest infrastructure project in the West'. Salvini cited studies estimating the project would create up to 120,000 jobs annually and help stimulate economic growth in lagging southern Italy, as billions more are invested in surrounding road and infrastructure improvements. Critics, however, are not convinced, and angered that about 500 families would have to be expropriated for the bridge to be built. Salvini says such families will be compensated. 'The Strait of Messina can't be touched,' protesters shouted as they marched in Messina. Many carried banners that said 'No Ponte' (No Bridge). 'They could offer me three times the value of my house, but that doesn't matter to me. What matters is the landscape. They must not touch the Strait of Messina,' Mariolina De Francesco, a 75-year-old resident of Messina whose house lies near the site of one of the bridge's planned 399-metre- (440-yard-)tall land towers, told The Associated Press news agency. 'Our lawyers will take action, and we will stop them. That's guaranteed.' The proposed bridge would span nearly 3.7km (2.3 miles) with a suspended section of 3.3km (more than 2 miles). It would surpass Turkiye's Canakkale Bridge by 1,277 metres (1,400 yards) to become the longest suspension bridge in the world. Preliminary work could begin in late September or early October, pending approval from Italy's Court of Audit. Full construction is scheduled to begin in 2026, with completion planned between 2032 and 2033. The bridge would reduce the time to cross the strait by ferry, usually up to 100 minutes, to 10 minutes by car. Trains would save 2.5 hours in transit time, Salvini said. The project could also support Italy's commitment to raise defence spending to 5 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) targeted by NATO, as the government has indicated it would classify the bridge as defence-related. Italy argues that the bridge would form a strategic corridor for rapid troop movements and equipment deployment, qualifying it as 'security-enhancing infrastructure'. Environmental groups, however, have lodged complaints with the European Union, citing concerns that the project would affect migratory birds. Italy's president has also insisted that the project remain subject to anti-mafia legislation that applies to all large-scale infrastructure projects.
Al Jazeera
7 days ago
- Al Jazeera
A migrant march in Mexico continues despite scrutiny of organiser's arrest
A march has begun from the southern Mexican state of Chiapas northward to the central part of the country, in protest of policies that make legal immigration status difficult to achieve. Wednesday's march set out from the border city of Tapachula, near Guatemala, and nearly 300 migrants, asylum seekers and supporters took part. But the demonstration was overshadowed by the arrest one day earlier of one of its leaders, prominent immigration activist Luis Garcia Villagran. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum addressed the arrest in her morning news conference on Wednesday. She alleged that Garcia Villagran had been detained for taking part in human trafficking. 'That is the crime,' she said, adding that Garcia Villagran was 'not an activist'. She added that an arrest warrant had been pending for the activist for years. But it was unclear why his arrest was carried out now. The nonprofit Pueblo Sin Fronteras, however, disputed Sheinbaum's characterisation of Garcia Villagran. 'The detention of Luis Villagran, director and human rights defender, is an unacceptable assault,' the nonprofit's head, Irineo Mujica, wrote in a post to social media. 'Luis Villagrán's only 'crime' is to defend those who have no money or voice, and to tell the truth, which bothers the powerful. Stop criminalising human rights defenders!' Mujica – who was detained himself in 2019 on similar charges, only to be released – argued that Garcia Villagran's arrest was a political distraction. 'This is a smokescreen: dirty and corrupt politics to cover up the true networks of corruption,' he said. Mujica and Garcia Villagran have both been prominent voices in a movement to make legal immigration pathways more accessible. They have also been among the organisers associated with the trend of the migrant 'caravans' that travel from southern Mexico to the United States border in recent years. Some of those past caravans have involved thousands of people, many of whom banded together for protection against criminal networks, corrupt officials and other threats they may face as they migrate. Migration northwards, however, has slowed, particularly since US President Donald Trump took office for a second term in January. Trump quickly attempted to bar asylum claims at the border, a move that has spurred a legal backlash. Last month, a court blocked his asylum ban on the basis that it created an 'alternative immigration system' without deference to Congress's laws. But Trump's policies have nevertheless had a dampening effect on immigration at the border. In June, US Customs and Border Protection recorded only 9,306 'encounters' with migrants and asylum seekers at the country's southern border – a nearly 93 percent drop compared with the same period last year. Wednesday's march had a different objective than those past caravans, though, particularly as migrants and asylum seekers turn away from the US and seek other destinations. Organisers of the march sought to draw attention to the slow processing time for asylum applications in Mexico and other hurdles to achieving legal immigration status. It also served as a demonstration against Mexican policies that have sought to keep undocumented migrants and asylum seekers in the south of the country, away from the US border. The Trump administration has pressured Mexico to crack down on immigration into the US, including through the threat of tariffs. Garcia Villagran's arrest in the hours leading up to the march, however, left some migrants and asylum seekers fearful of taking part in the march. The news agency AFP obtained one message that was circulating among participants that read, 'Hide, don't let yourselves get caught.' A Catholic priest who took part in Wednesday's march, Heyman Vazquez, told The Associated Press news agency that Garcia Villagran's arrest was 'unjust'. He added that the arrest revealed a sense of insecurity in the government over the question of migration. The solution, he explained, would be to make it easier for migrants and asylum seekers to obtain legal status, thereby removing the need for such protests.
