Man deported to Mexico 7 times to stand trial in May for Hamilton slaying
Fermin Garcia-Gutierrez, 47, was arrested last April for the death of Fernando Reyna Oviedo, whose body was found in a garage. Shortly after Garcia-Gutierrez's arrest, Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones said in a press conference the defendant has been deported seven times.
He is charged with charged with several felony counts, including aggravated murder and two counts of murder.
His attorney, Keith Fricker, filed multiple requests, including for medical records from the Butler County Jail, a use of force report and the jail calls Garcia-Gutierrez made to prepare for the upcoming trial.
The Journal-News reported in December the defendant's attorney said police violated his rights, and his alleged confession should be thrown out. In addition to the aggravated murder and murder charges, Garcia-Gutierrez is charged with two counts of felonious assault and kidnapping with a firearms specification.
Oviedo, 41, was found dead on April 1, 2024, after Hamilton police officers were called about a body in the 1100 block of South 13th Street. Investigators believe Garcia-Gutierrez committed the homicide before he was arrested on other charges.
He was arrested on March 16, 2024 on possession of drugs, carrying a concealed weapon, using weapons while intoxicated, and obstructing official business.
Fricker had previously moved to suppress evidence, claiming because Garcia-Gutierrez is illiterate and "the Hamilton detective interrogated the defendant knowing he was unable to read or write either (English or Spanish) and without the aid of an interpreter being present."
McElfresh eventually overruled the motion to suppress last month.
Both criminal cases will be tried the week of May 12, McElfresh ordered, and Garcia-Gutierrez has a $5 million cash or surety bond.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
44 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump administration heightens ‘good moral character' standards for potential US citizens
The Trump administration is ordering officers at U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to take a more 'holistic' approach when determining whether to award U.S. citizenship to immigrants, saying they must weigh more factors in determining whether an applicant has 'good moral character.' The Friday memo from USCIS said officers must now weigh not just any disqualifying behavior but whether those seeking to naturalize are in good standing in their community. 'Going forward, USCIS officers must account for an alien's positive attributes and not simply the absence of misconduct,' the memo states. U.S. law has long prevented those convicted of murder and other serious violent crimes from gaining U.S. citizenship and applicants were already required to be considered as having good moral character. But the new memo also encourages officers to consider rejecting applicants with other convictions, including drug use or two or more convictions for driving under the influence. Officers are also encouraged to weigh conduct that may not be illegal but frowned upon, such as 'reckless or habitual traffic infractions' or soliciting. 'Repeated criminal conduct such as multiple DUI convictions undermines moral character unless rebutted by affirmative evidence of reform,' the memo states. 'In assessing conditional bars officers have authority—and now explicit directive—to weigh all relevant evidence, both adverse and favorable, before granting or denying naturalization.' Officers are also urged to consider evidence of reform, including compliance with court orders, payment of lapses in taxes of child support payments, or 'community testimony' from those who can assure their good character. The memo also encourages the officers to look at other 'positive factors,' such as 'sustained community involvement,' caregiving or raising a family, education and career achievements, and paying taxes. 'GMC findings must go beyond the absence of disqualifying acts, it must reflect a genuine positive assessment of who the alien is and how they have lived in their community,' the memo states, using an abbreviation for good moral character. Those seeking to naturalize already face multiple steps to doing so, including years of lawful presence in the U.S., compliance with U.S. laws, and passing a test on U.S. civics often conducted in English. 'U.S. citizenship is the gold standard of citizenship—it should only be offered to the world's best of the best,' USCIS Spokesman Matthew J. Tragesser said in a statement.
NBC News
5 hours ago
- NBC News
What we know about man killed while running from ICE agents in Monrovia
After a man was struck and killed by a SUV Thursday while running from a federal immigration enforcement operation at a Home Depot in Monrovia, immigrant communities are once again condemning the federal government's tactics while mourning the crash victim. The man who died on the 210 Freeway was identified as Roberto Carlos Montoya Valdez from Jutiapa, Guatemala, according to the National Day Laborer Organizing Network, which said the Guatemalan consulate confirmed the identity. Cellphone video from the deadly crash appears to show a passerby on the 210 Freeway, showing the body of a man who has been hit by a car just yards from where federal officers were arresting day laborers below. The man ran from the scene, crossed Evergreen Avenue and entered the eastbound 210 Freeway, said Monrovia City Manager Dylan Feik. CHP officers said they received a report just before 10 a.m. that someone had been hit by a SUV on the freeway near Myrtle Avenue. What exactly led up to the man running onto the freeway is unclear. 'Was it intentional? I don't think that is the case, but it ended up with a father, a brother being killed,' said Pablo Alvarado, co-executive director of the National Day Laborers Organizing Network. The Department of Homeland Security told NBC Los Angeles in a statement that Montoya Valdez was not being pursued by federal officials. But Alvarado blamed the federal officials' tactics that, he said, created fear. 'Whether they were chasing him or not, the fact is that when you have operations of this kind, the first reaction of any human being is to run.' Many others in the same Home Depot parking lot also ran, according to people who witnessed or experienced the raid. 'My boss told me to run because immigration was there,' Mattias, a worker who escaped the raid, said in Spanish. 'Some people ran regardless of their immigration status because nowadays, they don't know if undocumented or documented people will be detained.' Mattias said he hurt himself while jumping a fence. DHS said eight day laborers were arrested during Thursday's raid, including nationals from Mexico, Guatemala and Honduras. The department called the raid by U.S. Border Patrol a 'targeted immigration enforcement operation,' but did not mention the death of Valdez.
Indianapolis Star
8 hours ago
- Indianapolis Star
Trump's takeover of Washington D.C.: Would it be legal in Indiana or elsewhere?
Things are tense in Washington D.C. The night of Aug. 13 – two days after President Donald Trump announced he would flood the streets with 800 National Guard soldiers and seize control of the city's police force – masked men wearing Homeland Security Investigation vests established a checkpoint and began pulling over cars for small infractions. A Spanish-speaking man was loaded into a black pickup and taken away, the Washington Post reported. Others, meanwhile, were checked for 'driving eligibility' and 'status.' The checkpoint eventually drew an angry crowd. They booed and screamed for officers to 'read the Constitution.' One man – who the Trump administration later claimed worked in the Office for International Affairs – was charged with a felony for pelting an officer with a submarine sandwich. He could face up to eight years in prison. In the days since, authorities have begun clearing homeless camps and attempting to ramp up federal control of the city. Trump claims he took over D.C. because of supposedly high crime levels. But the specific impetus came earlier this month, when 10 juveniles allegedly attacked a teenage DOGE staffer who calls himself 'Big Balls.' The president has also said he'd like to extend the operation to other locales across the country, including Chicago, Los Angeles and Baltimore. Doing so outside of D.C., however, could prove complicated. Matt Hanka, a professor of political science at the University of Southern Indiana, said the nation's capital is its own animal – a city without a state and the only one in the country where the National Guard is controlled not by a governor but the president himself. That makes it unlikely that situations like Washington's could spread to Indiana or other locales, at least according to the letter of the law. Hanka, along with laws that stretch back as far as the Bill of Rights itself, shed light on what's occurring in Washington, if it could ever metastasize across the country, and what could possibly happen next. According to a 52-year-old law, they are – at least for now. 'Under the Home Rule Act of 1973, the federal government has the authority to have control over D.C.,' Hanka said. 'And it can take control of the police for up to 30 days during what's called an emergency.' Trump claims D.C.'s crime precipitated that emergency, even though local officials say crime rates have actually dropped compared to the last couple years – something that's echoed in metropolitan police's official data. Law stipulates that Congress can extend Trump's 30-day limit. And considering Republicans control both chambers, that would likely happen if the president asked. But there are lots of possibilities beyond that, Hanka said. 'Congress can grant him that authority,' he said. 'But Congress also has the authority to even change the Home Rule Act.' They could give him greater power or even repeal the act altogether, he said. Not according to the 10th Amendment – and another long-standing law that boasts a title you would normally hear in a western. Unlike every other city in the country, Washington D.C. doesn't reside in a state and therefore isn't under the rule of a governor. In places like Chicago or L.A. or even Indianapolis and Evansville, mobilizing a state's National Guard is the job of the governor. For the local D.C. guard, that falls to the president. The separation between state and federal power makes up the idea of federalism: something that's enshrined in the 10th Amendment. During an interview with the Courier & Press, Hanka read it verbatim: 'the powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.' Then there's the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878. It bars the military from being used in civilian law enforcement. 'Whoever, except in cases and under circumstances expressly authorized by the Constitution or Act of Congress, willfully uses any part of the Army or the Air Force as a posse comitatus or otherwise to execute the laws shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than two years, or both.' It's since been updated to include the Marines, Navy and Space Force. The National Guard, however, isn't specifically included in that, which could give Trump 'wiggle room,' Hanka said – especially in D.C. That should be a nonstarter in cities under the control of governors. But that wasn't the case in Los Angeles. In June, scores of residents took to the streets to protest ICE crackdowns in the city. Trump went against the wishes of Gov. Gavin Newsome and deployed more than 700 Marines and 4,000 National Guardsmen in an attempt to quell the protests. That led to nationwide concerns that Trump could unilaterally declare "martial law" and crack down on cities as he pleased. In an interview with the Courier & Press in June, however, USI Associate Professor of Political Science Nick LaRowe pointed out that "martial law" is a hazy, ill-defined term that doesn't turn up anywhere in the U.S. or Indiana constitutions. So far Trump's threats to expand situations like D.C.'s into the more parts of the country have centered on cities in Democrat-led states: Chicago, Baltimore, L.A., etc. That's despite the fact many red-state cities have some of the highest homicide rates in the country, according to FBI data. Indianapolis has battled a rash of gun violence over the summer, so much so that the head of the city's police union asked Gov. Mike Braun and state lawmakers to 'step in,' Indy Star reported. Despite Trump's focus on blue states, Hanka could see a future in which Trump-aligning governors acquiesce to the president's wishes if his gaze ever falls upon their cities. "I certainty can see situations where they comply to mobilizing the National Guard," he said. "I can't say anything beyond that." Yes. On Thursday, U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi attempted to expand Trump's order by naming Terry Cole, head of the Drug Enforcement Agency, 'emergency police commissioner.' That led D.C.'s own attorney general, Brian Schwalb, to file a federal lawsuit. He called the move a 'brazen usurpation' of D.C.'s sovereignty. Meanwhile, Trump has already signaled he plans to ask Congress to extend the federalization beyond 30 days, the New York Times reported. The very fact he has to ask is a key tenet of American democracy. Hanka said the Founding Fathers' experience with the King of England imbued them with a desire to put checks and balances on the power of any American ruler.
