New detail in NRL star's mum's crash case
Uiatu 'Joan' Taufua is due to stand trial in the Supreme Court on three counts of manslaughter stemming from a devastating crash in Bonogin, in the Gold Coast hinterland region, in December 2022.
Police allege Ms Taufua was driving a black 2017 Mercedes wagon when it collided with another car just before 5pm on December 30 that year.
Susan Zimmer, 70, her partner Chris Fawcett, 79, and Ms Zimmer's 35-year-old daughter Steffanie were in a silver Mercedes when it was knocked from the road into a power pole from the force of the collision.
All three died. Uiatu 'Joan' Taufua is facing three counts of manslaughter over a horror triple-fatal crash in the Gold Coast hinterland in 2022. Supplied Credit: News Corp Australia Ms Taufua was the sole survivor of the two-car collision in Bonogin on December 30, 2022. Supplied Credit: News Corp Australia
Ms Taufua, the mother of Broncos forward Payne Haas, was the sole survivor.
On Wednesday, Brisbane Supreme Court was told an interstate psychiatrist had seen Ms Taufua since the last adjournment and a report was being prepared in relation to the charges.
Family members of the Zimmer family were seated in the public gallery to watch the proceedings.
Defence barrister Martin Longhurst said another four weeks would be required due to the need for 'objective evidence' to be obtained from applications on Ms Taufua's phone.
Mr Longhurst said the family was attempting to obtain backups from the phone's iCloud to hand over to the psychiatrist.
He said he had not received instructions regarding the delay over the issue with the phone applications.
Justice Lincoln Crowley reminded him a form for such a request still needed to be submitted a day before the review – necessitating an adjournment application instead.
'That's not necessarily your obligation to do that … (it's the) solicitor with carriage of the matter,' Justice Crowley said.
Mr Longhurst asked the court to set a date for the submissions on the report in three months.
'I have instructions that Ms Taufua wishes to engage King's Counsel to settle the submission,' he said. Steffanie and Susan Zimmer died in the crash. Supplied Credit: Supplied Chris Fawcett also died. Supplied Credit: Supplied
'The factual basis advanced by the brief (of evidence) isn't particularly complex, it really is a submission based on the psychiatric evidence.'
The Crown prosecutor called the length of time 'unacceptably long' and submitted it could have been done earlier.
An indictment in the Supreme Court was presented back in March.
Justice Crowley ordered the submissions on the report be delivered by October 16 before adjourning the matter to the same date for a further review.
Ms Taufua remains in custody on remand.
She was committed to stand trial on the charges following a committal hearing in Southport Magistrates Court in November last year. Ms Taufua is facing three counts of manslaughter over the crash and has been committed to stand trial in the Supreme Court. Supplied / 9 News Credit: Supplied Claudine Snow said her mum had a 'magic smile'. NewsWire / Nigel Hallett Credit: NCA NewsWire
Supporters of the victims' families and Ms Taufua's own family packed out the court as she waved and smiled to her group in the public gallery.
Asked by magistrate Jane Bentley if she wanted to say anything in response to the committal, Ms Taufua answered 'No, Your Honour'.
There were 34 witness statements tendered to the court.
In a memorial to her sister and mother in early 2023, Claudine Snow said growing up with Susan and Steffanie was like 'the three amigos'.
She remembered her mum always having a 'magic smile' despite her tough upbringing.
'Susan endures many obstacles but possessed immense talent and an even fiercer resolve,' Ms Snow said to the packed crowd at Bill Deacon Pavilion at Mudgeeraba Showgrounds.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
2 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Outback Wrangler Matt Wright offered chopper crash survivor's family $10K
An Aussie reality television star offered the family of his paraplegic pilot $10,000 to help during his recovery in the wake of a catastrophic chopper crash, a court has been told. The mother of Sebastian Robinson has accused Netflix and Apple TV reality star Matt Wright of pressuring her 28-year-old son to manipulate flight records after the helicopter crash on February 28, 2022. Mr Robinson was the sole survivor after a Robinson R-44 crashed into a paperbark swamp over the King River, Arnhem Land during a crocodile egg collecting mission, killing his friend and 34-year-old father, Chris 'Willow' Wilson. Croc egg collector Chris Wilson was killed, while his pilot Sebastian Robinson was critically injured in a helicopter crash on the King River, West Arnhem on February 28. Their boss and the star of 'Outback Wrangler' and 'Wild Croc Territory' Mr Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice. It is alleged Mr Wright knew the helicopter should never have flown that morning, as it had overrun a 2200 flight hour maintenance requirement. Mr Robinson, along with his brother, uncle and mother have all alleged Mr Wright visited Brisbane Hospital to ask the critically injured pilot to move 'a few hours' from the crashed helicopter's records to his personal R-44. On Wednesday, Mr Robinson's mother confirmed Mr Wright offered her family $10,000 to help with their bills during his first visit on March 11. 'That is another example of how he was trying to help you, your family and Sebastian, wasn't it?' Mr Wright's senior defence counsel David Edwardson asked. 'No,' she replied. Pilot Sebastian Robinson during filming of Kane Chenoweth's documentary Sky Cowboy in February 2022. Mr Robinson's mother said they declined Mr Wright's $10,000 offer, saying 'we told him we didn't want it'. Ms Chellingworth's diary records claimed on that same visit, 'Matt Wright came in today and tried to persuade Seb to put hours on his helicopter'. Over two days of evidence, Mr Edwardson has accused Ms Chellingworth and her two sons of putting 'your heads together and made these false allegations against Mr Wright'. She denied Mr Edwardson's accusations she forged her diary records. Seb Robinson's mother Noelene Chellingworth approaching the Supreme Court in Darwin, giving evidence at the trial of Outback Wrangler Matt Wright on Wednesday August 20. Picture: NewsWire / Pema Tamang Pakhrin The jury heard Mr Wright had not covered any of Mr Robinson's medical expenses and he has been unable to access worker's compensation. In emotional testimony, his mother recounted how doctors initially told her that her son was 'unlikely to survive that night'. The Darwin mother described the relief, and then grief as her son woke up from his coma only to be told he would never walk again. 'I was so devastated,' Ms Chellingworth said through tears on Wednesday. 'I said to God: 'Why? You let me have a quadriplegic brother that I cared for for 20 years, and now I've got a paraplegic son'. 'He must have given it to me because I could handle it.' She said her son was an adventurous, active and outdoorsy young man who had been crocodile egg collecting for almost a decade, but after the crash Mr Robinson faced the real prospect he would never work again. 'He wasn't going to be dropped in a wheelchair to collect eggs, was he?' prosecutor Jason Gullaci said. Ms Chellingworth said following the crash she got legal advice, but was told her son could not receive any workers' compensation as he was an independent contractor, rather than Mr Wright's employee. Seb Robinson's mother Noelene Chellingworth approaching the Supreme Court in Darwin, giving evidence at the trial of Outback Wrangler Matt Wright on Wednesday August 20. Picture: NewsWire / Pema Tamang Pakhrin The jury was shown two versions of invoices from Mr Robinson for his Wet Season flights, prepared by Ms Chellingworth after the crash. The first invoice detailed each individual flight Mr Robinson took that egg collecting season, which Ms Chellingworth said she sent to Wild Harvest NT director Mick Burns. A second $21,500 bill was then sent to Mr Wright, only providing monthly totals for the flights. Ms Chellingworth's diary included an entry on March 13 alleging it was Mr Wright who asked her to re-invoice the bill with less detail for her son's egg collecting season. 'Matt doesn't want days on his invoice, only monthly totals,' Ms Chellingworth wrote. She denied Mr Edwardson's accusations she forged that diary note and only filed the second invoice to Mr Wright 'in the hope that you might be able to claim workers' compensation under his insurance policy'. The trial continues. Originally published as Outback Wrangler Matt Wright offered paraplegic pilot Seb Robinson's family $10,000 in hospital visit, court told
Perth Now
5 hours ago
- Perth Now
Judgment day for Brittany Higgins
A judgment in the long running defamation suit launched by former senator Linda Reynolds against her former junior staffer Brittany Higgins will be handed down next week. Justice Paul Tottle will deliver his verdict in the defamation case against Ms Higgins and her husband David Sharaz in the WA Supreme Court next Wednesday. Ms Reynolds sued the pair over a series of social media posts they made in 2022 and 2023, claiming they damaged her reputation. Ms Higgins relied on the truth defence claiming the social media posts were substantially true during the defamation proceedings. A verdict in former senator Linda Reynolds' defamation case against Brittany Higgins and David Sharaz will be handed down in the WA Supreme Court on August 27. NewsWire / Sharon Smith Credit: News Corp Australia Former senator Linda Reynolds brought the defamation proceedings after social media posts made by Ms Higgins and Mr Sharaz. NewsWire / Sharon Smith Credit: News Corp Australia The posts were critical of Ms Reynolds' handling of Ms Higgins' allegation she was raped in the senator's office at Parliament House in 2019 by her then-colleague Bruce Lehrmann. He was charged with rape and faced trial in 2022, but the trial was aborted due to juror misconduct. The charge was dropped and Mr Lehrmann continues to maintain his innocence. Mr Lehrmann lost a subsequent civil defamation case in April last year when the Federal Court determined, on the balance of probabilities, that Mr Lehrmann had raped Ms Higgins at Parliament House. He is appealing the decision. Private text messages and emails between federal ministers, senators, staffers, press gallery journalists and lawyers were laid bare during the five-week blockbuster trial last year. Ms Higgins' defence team called for the action to be dismissed entirely at the end of the high-stakes legal battle. Brittany Higgins and David Sharaz sold the French chateau they called home to pay for legal fees. Credit: Supplied Ms Reynolds, who has retired from politics, mortgaged her home in a bid to clear her name. Ms Higgins and Mr Sharaz sold their French home to pay for legal fees, as she maintained her version of events about what happened to her at Parliament House. It was revealed Ms Reynolds was seeking more than half a million dollars in damages. Her lawyer Martin Bennett asked the court to 'nail the lies' Ms Higgins allegedly perpetuated after making her rape allegation public in 2021. The court was told Ms Higgins 'grossly defamed' her former boss in social media posts shared years later. Ms Higgins' defence lawyer Rachael Young said it was a series of events in 2021 that led to the then-Senator Reynolds' distress and reputational damage, not social media posts created by her client two years later. Ms Young argued Ms Reynolds' decline was caused by backlash from her referring to Ms Higgins as a 'lying cow', a senate grilling over the allegations, her hospitalisation, losing the defence ministry and missing out on a shadow ministry under Peter Dutton. Ms Higgins' defence lawyer Rachael Young argued it was a series of events in 2021 that led to Ms Reynolds distress and reputational damage, not social media posts created by her client two years later. NewsWire / Sharon Smith Credit: News Corp Australia She said the former senator tried to besmirch the people she blamed for her political demise, namely Ms Higgins, who continued to face the heaviest burden in all this. Two dozen witnesses were called to give evidence including former prime minister Scott Morrison. A who's who of the nation's parliament, media and legal circles were dragged into the proceedings as diary entries, minutes and communications between senators, staffers, journalists, police officers and lawyers were exposed in court. The trial centred around what happened in the aftermath of Ms Higgins speaking out about her alleged rape in a article and The Project interview that were published on February 15, 2021, two years after the alleged incident. Ms Reynolds' lawyer Martin Bennett argued in court statements that Ms Higgins made in those media interviews and in her personal injury claim were wrong and that she had lied. Former senator Linda Reynolds lawyer Martin Bennett argued every fairytale needs a villain. NewsWire / Sharon Smith Credit: News Corp Australia He said his client had been cast as a villain in Ms Higgins and Mr Sharaz's fictional story that alleged Ms Reynolds had tried to cover-up a rape. 'Every fairytale needs a villain, and in 2020 or 2021, Ms Higgins and her then-partner and now-husband, Mr Sharaz, cast Ms Reynolds in that role for their fictional story of a cover-up of the rape,' Mr Bennett told the WA Supreme Court. 'The fact she had been raped was traumatic and terrible but it needed something more to attract the attention, to attract media interest, to attract the promotion of Ms Higgins, so she made it a political sex scandal.' Ms Young argued the matter was not, and never had been, a 'fairytale' for her client saying the comments were misplaced, harassing and retraumitising. Ms Young told the court Ms Reynolds had picked the 'wrong target' for the hurt and distress and that her reputation was already 'baked in' when her client posted to social media in the years that followed.
The Age
7 hours ago
- The Age
The TWU's millions: How much will sacked Qantas workers get?
The Transport Workers' Union will be able to spend the $50 million it was awarded in the Qantas penalties case however it sees fit, say lawyers and labour specialists. The TWU's National Council, made up of elected officials and rank-and-file members, is expected to meet 'in due course' to discuss how best to deploy the funds towards advancing campaigns across road and aviation sectors. The $90 million in penalties announced on Monday, along with the $120 million in workers compensation agreed to last year, combined are worth more than five times the union's total revenue of $39.5 million across all its branches. The penalty judgment handed down this week includes $50 million awarded directly to the union and a further $40 million that is intended as pay for the workers, but that will be decided through a later legal process. The TWU told the court the balance of any penalty paid to it 'would be used to advance the workplace rights, pay, conditions, wellbeing and welfare of transport workers consistently with' union rules and the Fair Work Act. Justice Michael Lee characterised the promise as having 'dubious utility' because it requires the TWU only to obey an aspect of the law. Former Qantas baggage handler Damien Pollard said the time it was taking to receive compensation was difficult. 'Of course it's frustrating to all of us how long this process has taken,' Pollard said. 'The last five years has felt exceptionally long. There have been relationship breakdowns, people have had to sell their houses.' The reality was that the blame lay on Qantas, he said. 'If Qantas had accepted its wrongdoing the first time it would not have been such a long road. But it's a huge relief to be getting to the end of it.'
