'I am a surgeon in Gaza – food aid points are designed to be death traps'
Siobhan McNally is a Senior Features Writer for the Mirror and Sunday Mirror – in print and online. Previously she was a columnist and edited the Community Column at the Mirror. Now back in London after 25 years in Winchester – complete with travelling circus of two cats, one ancient pug and a grumpy teenager – Siobhan specialises in general interest national stories, nostalgia, history and music. Also has a passion for quirky, fun foodie ideas and a sudden age-related interest in gardening. Get in touch with ideas and stories to siobhan.mcnally@mirror.co.uk
Professor Nick Maynard, consultant gastrointestinal surgeon at Oxford University Hospital
I've been operating on trauma injuries in Nasser Hospital, Khan Younis, for the last four weeks. My health care colleagues from Gaza have described the aid points as death traps designed to create chaos and incite rioting.
This is my third trip to Gaza since October 7 – and although many things are similar in terms of air strikes, what is different is the rise in the number of shootings at the food distribution points. We're several km away from the aid sites – we're the nearest hospital and all the people come to us.
Food is kept in a compound which is locked, and they wait until hundreds of aid seekers have collected and then open up a very narrow gate, and then there's just complete chaos and everyone fighting for food. An anaesthetist colleague of mine from Gaza rushed down to the food site in between operations to get food for his family, came back covered in cuts and bruises because of the rioting.
All of our surgeons have seen a pattern of injuries among predominantly – but not exclusively – young teenage males who are sent by their starving families to get food.
They seem to be targeting different body parts on different days. Some days they come in with gunshot wounds to the head or the neck, the next day the chest, the next, the abdomen.
Nine days ago we saw four small, four young teenagers who had all been shot in the testicles at the same time.
I have seen all abdominal and chest injuries – that's what I operate on – and terrible injuries to the pancreas, duodenum, bowel, you name it. So the pattern is a very clear pattern of targeting and it's almost like they're playing a game.
I'm getting identical descriptions from people of Israeli soldiers just shooting indiscriminately at people, I've been told they're using artificial intelligence, and remotely controlled hovering quadcopters with four rotors and cameras and guns attached.
A friend of mine who's a theatre nurse at Nasser Hospital was shot last year when a quadcopter came into the operating theatre and shot him in the chest.
As well as the teenage boys, I've seen women in tents near the food distribution centre and they describe quadcopters firing indiscriminately at all the tents. One woman was three months pregnant and another was breastfeeding her three-month-old baby at the time.
It is inconceivable to me that these are collateral damage. This is deliberate targeting and what all of us have witnessed.
This is not a famine. It is mass extermination
Omar Abdel-Mannan, founder of Health Workers 4 Palestine
As we speak, Gaza is being deliberately starved. Today, ambulances across the Strip turned on their sirens in unison – a collective cry for help from a population pushed to the brink.
The majority of the territory is now classified as Category 5: the most severe level of food insecurity. Even if aid were allowed in today, many would still die. This is not a famine. It is mass extermination.
What's happening in Gaza is not just enabled by Israel – it is facilitated by its allies. And the UK is complicit. It continues to supply Israel with components for F-35 fighter jets – the very aircraft used to flatten homes, hospitals, and refugee camps. British-made parts are helping to slaughter civilians. This is not neutrality; it's active participation. History will judge this moment. And those in power – including Keir Starmer – will not be absolved. They will be remembered as enablers of war crimes.
Inside Gaza, doctors are being assassinated, detained, tortured – over 1,500 killed to date and over 400 detained illegally. This is a systematic erasure of a healthcare system – the murder of those who save lives. Meanwhile, in the UK, medics who speak out face career-threatening smear campaigns and regulatory complaints driven by pro-Israel lobby groups. NHS England has already confirmed that antisemitism is covered under the Equality Act, yet the Health Secretary is now interfering with the independence of the regulator to appease political allies.
We must end this complicity. We must fight for a future where Palestinian health workers – those who have risked everything – are not only protected, but empowered to lead the rebuilding of their shattered health system. That means Palestinian-led healthcare. That means sovereignty, dignity, and justice.
• Voices of Solidarity, which took place on Saturday 19 July, was the UK's largest cultural fundraiser for Palestine, raising money for the Health Workers 4 Palestine (HW4P) Solidarity Fund. Proceeds go towards life-saving healthcare on the ground and supporting health workers under siege – www.healthworkers4palestine.com/donate
The waste of human lives is sickening
Laura Janner-Klausner, former senior rabbi to Reform Judaism and rabbi of Bromley Reform Synagogue
We need world leaders to step in and help us get out of this sickening situation. The Israeli government, Hamas, Islamic Jihad – who are also holding hostages – should be applying pressure to stop immediately what they are doing, to ensure there is safe and sufficient humanitarian aid, including food and medicine, getting directly to the Gazans who desperately need it.
Release all the hostages, stop the attacks – on both sides. That's for the short term. In the medium term, we need an honourable, quick divorce so there is an end of war, not just a shaky ceasefire. And in the long term, we need to live together: two peoples. Separation has not helped us in the past, and we need responsible adults back in the room who can set aside their hatred for each other and work together to stop the senseless violence.
The vast majority of British Jews are absolutely distraught about what is happening in Gaza. The waste of human lives is sickening. An Israeli child and a Palestinian child are the same. Sick and injured people need full medical care wherever they live. Food is food, and people are starving.
Both sides are dehumanising each other, but they need to find a way to live together.
International community has failed to deliver
Tufail Hussain, director of Islamic Relief UK Today's latest atrocities in Gaza are beyond cruel. Desperate, starving people should never be targeted, yet the Israeli military continues to do so. It is heartbreaking to see people who want to feed themselves and their families being heartlessly murdered. This is a man-made catastrophe that the international community could have put a stop to by now.
This latest barbarity will once again be condemned, but without political action to demand a ceasefire, lift the siege of Gaza and force Israel to let international aid in, then these condemnations are hollow. For almost two years, aid agencies and human rights groups have been demanding a ceasefire, which the international community has failed to deliver.
They must now finally take action to prevent the future horrors that will be inflicted upon the Palestinian people.
They are kettling desperate, starving people
Brian Brivtai, CEO of the Britain Palestine Project
The whole Israeli campaign in Gaza is entirely disproportionate to any kind of self defence. The purposeful targeting of civilians, and the starvation of a population, are crimes against humanity. Recent developments are incredibly disturbing.
First, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation aid operation, which concentrates people in smaller and smaller areas, has basically created shooting galleries. They are kettling people who are desperate and starving, who see food and try and get it, and who then are being shot dead.
But Israel's plan for a 'humanitarian city' is the most terrifying development of all. If you concentrate 2 million people in a single, tiny location, and deny them the means to life because you've destroyed their hospitals and reduced the amount of food you're giving them, then you are intentionally committing genocidal acts.
Israel wants to reduce the Palestinian part of Gaza to an absolutely minimum geographical area, and they are going to flatten the rest of it, then annex it. We laughed at Trump's suggestion of the Gaza Riviera, but I think that's what we are going to see happen.
All the British government needs to do is obey international law, not more than that. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has deemed it plausible that Israel is creating a plausible case for genocide, and it's our responsibility under that amendment to prevent it.
Not to wait until Israel has killed 200,000, 300,000 Palestinians, but to act to prevent it now.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
12 minutes ago
- ITV News
IDF 'handcuffed, stripped and interrogated' aid workers in Gaza, World Health Organisation claims
The World Health Organisation (WHO) has said its staff were strip searched and its warehouse attacked by Israeli troops in Gaza on Monday. The UN agency has accused the IDF of attacking a building in Deir al-Balah, central Gaza, in which its staff and their families were sheltering. Male staff and family members were reportedly handcuffed, stripped and interrogated at gunpoint, while women and children were forced to evacuate. Two WHO staff and two family members were reportedly detained, with one staff remaining in custody. Israeli troops entered the central Gazan city on Monday, for the first time in the conflict. Deir al-Balah had previously been considered one of the less hard-hit parts of the territory, and had been a key hub for humanitarian efforts. In a statement, WHO said its main warehouse in the city had been damaged in what it called a "pattern of systematic destruction of health facilities," before being later looted by "desperate crowds." It added: "WHO condemns in the strongest terms the attacks on a building housing WHO staff in Deir al Balah in Gaza, the mistreatment of those sheltering there, and the destruction of its main warehouse. "Staff and their families, including children, were exposed to grave danger and traumatized after airstrikes caused a fire and significant damage. "Israeli military entered the premises, forcing women and children to evacuate on foot toward Al-Mawasi amid active conflict. Male staff and family members were handcuffed, stripped, interrogated on the spot, and screened at gunpoint. "With the main warehouse nonfunctional and the majority of medical supplies in Gaza depleted, WHO is severely constrained in adequately supporting hospitals, emergency medical teams and health partners, already critically short on medicines, fuel, and equipment. "WHO urgently calls on Member States to help ensure a sustained and regular flow of medical supplies into Gaza." Responding to the claims, the IDF confirmed it had detained several individuals it suspected of "involvement in terrorism", but maintains it had "continuous and consistent contact" with international organisations prior to entering Deir al-Balah. In response to the latest strikes in Gaza, the United Kingdom, France and 23 other Western-aligned countries issued a statement on Monday calling for the war to end and criticising Israel's "drip feeding" of humanitarian aid into Gaza. 88% of Gaza now under evacuation orders or within Israeli-militarized zones as it seeks to pressure Hamas to release more hostages. Gaza health officials said at least 18 people, including three women and five children, were killed in Israeli strikes on Sunday night and into Monday.
Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Strictly's Greg Wise addresses family heartbreak as he admits 'it nearly killed me'
Former Strictly Come Dancing star Greg Wise appeared on Good Morning Britain to discuss the lack of paid respite care, as he opened up on his family heartbreak Former Strictly Come Dancing star Greg Wise confessed "It nearly killed me" as he shared his family heartbreak. The 59 year old actor, who competed in the 2021 series of Strictly alongside professional partner Karen Hauer, appeared on Good Morning Britain on Tuesday (July 22) to discuss the shortage of paid respite care. Greg spoke to presenters Kate Garraway and Ed Balls about looking after his sister, Clare, who died in 2016 at the age of 51. Clare was originally diagnosed with breast cancer, which subsequently returned as bone cancer. "I was a 24/7 carer for my sister, Clare, who was dying from bone cancer. I did it for three months, it nearly killed me," Greg frankly told GMB, reports Edinburgh Live. "It's extraordinary, isn't it? We know the truth is you're either going to be cared for or be a carer, everyone is at some point in their life, and actually, it's only when you're in it that the reality hits you," Kate then said, reflecting on her own experiences of caring for her late husband, Derek Draper. Greg went on: "A lot of studies have been done on carers. Carers start to mirror the people they've been caring for, it's called compassion fatigue or carer's fatigue. "And of course, it's understandable, you become anxious, you become isolated, you are fearful, you can become depressed, you can start self-medicating." The actor then revealed that he "got into a bit of a problem" with drinking, but managed to "get off it". Greg emphasised the crucial role of carers in society, stating that if every British caregiver decided they couldn't continue, it would cost taxpayers tens of billions of pounds. "You find yourself in a place where you're so completely alone and unsupported. I was fantastically fortunate that I was able to drop my life for a finite period of time and go and help my sister die," he expressed. "One in ten of us in this country is a carer, we have over six million carers here unpaid." Greg concluded: "The unpaid carers are saving the public purse the entire NHS budget, and what we're asking for is for the most vulnerable of this six million to be helped." His comments come as hundreds of carers are marching to Westminster to protest the lack of paid respite care available to them.
BBC News
5 hours ago
- BBC News
WHO condemns Israeli raid on Gaza residence and warehouse attack
The World Health Organization (WHO) says Israel's ground offensive in central Gaza has compromised its efforts to continue working, after its facilities came under UN agency accused Israeli forces of attacking a building housing its staff and their families in the city of Deir al-Balah on Monday and mistreating those sheltering there. Its main warehouse was also attacked and Israeli military has not yet first major ground operation in Deir al-Balah since the start of the war with Hamas 21 months ago has displaced tens of thousands of Palestinian civilians, amid warnings of a severe hunger crisis across the territory. The UN said on Monday it was receiving reports of malnourished people arriving at clinics and hospitals in extremely poor health, while the Hamas-run health ministry said 19 people had died from malnutrition since Saturday. On Sunday, the Israeli military ordered the immediate evacuation of six city blocks in southern Deir al-Balah, warning that it would be operating "with great force to destroy the enemy's capabilities and terrorist infrastructure".The estimated 50,000 to 80,000 people living in the affected areas were instructed to head south towards the al-Mawasi area in the south of the UN's humanitarian office said UN staff would remain in Deir al-Balah despite the evacuation order, spread across dozens of premises whose co-ordinates had been shared with Israel, and stressed that they had to be Monday night, the WHO put out a statement saying it condemned "in the strongest terms" attacks on its said the WHO staff residence was attacked three times, and that staff and their families, including children, were "exposed to grave danger and traumatized after air strikes caused a fire and significant damage"."Israeli military entered the premises, forcing women and children to evacuate on foot toward al-Mawasi amid active conflict. Male staff and family members were handcuffed, stripped, interrogated on the spot, and screened at gunpoint," it added."Two WHO staff and two family members were detained. Three were later released, while one staff member remains in detention."The WHO demanded the immediate release of its detained staff member and the protection of its other staff, who have been relocated with their families to its office in Deir al-Balah. The WHO's main warehouse in the city was damaged after "an attack caused explosions and fire inside", the organisation said. The warehouse was later looted by desperate crowds, it agency did not attribute blame for the attack, but said it was "part of a pattern of systematic destruction of health facilities". The WHO warned that its operational presence in Gaza was "now compromised, crippling efforts to sustain a collapsing health system and pushing survival further out of reach for more than two million people".There has been no comment yet from the Israeli military on the attacks on the WHO's premises or on the wider offensive in Deir Israel's Haaretz newspaper reported on Monday that troops were operating to "establish a corridor that will cut through the city, severing it from the al-Mawasi area and preventing free movement between central Gaza refugee camps where the Israeli army has no ground presence".According to the UN, about 87.8% of Gaza is now covered by Israeli evacuation orders or is within Israeli militarized zones, leaving the 2.1 million population squeezed into about 46 sq km of land where essential services have sources say that the possible presence of Israeli hostages held by Hamas is one reason why Deir al-Balah has so far not been the target of a ground offensive. At least 20 of the 50 hostages still in captivity are believed to be families have expressed concern that an offensive could endanger Israeli military launched a campaign in Gaza in response to the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on 7 October 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 others were taken least 59,029 people have been killed in Gaza since then, according to the territory's health ministry.
