Minnesota Court of Appeals to decide if state can prosecute cannabis crimes on tribal lands
The Minnesota Court of Appeals will review whether the state may prosecute tribal members for cannabis crimes on most Native reservations in the state, wading into new legal territory after the state legalized recreational cannabis in 2023.
The case involves a White Earth citizen, Todd Thompson, who faces a felony charge for selling marijuana from his tobacco store in Mahnomen on the White Earth reservation.
Mahnomen County sheriff's deputies and White Earth tribal police raided his store on Aug. 2, 2023, a day after recreational cannabis became legal in Minnesota, and seized about 7.5 lbs of cannabis, 433 grams of marijuana wax and $2,748 in cash along with Thompson's cell phone and surveillance system.
More than eight months after the raid, Mahnomen County charged Thompson with felony possession, which carries a maximum sentence of five years in prison and a $10,000 fine.
Thompson asked Mahnomen County District Judge Seamus Duffy to dismiss the charge, arguing that the state doesn't have the legal jurisdiction to prosecute him.
Under what's called Public Law 280, Minnesota has the power to prosecute tribal members on certain reservations including White Earth's for criminal acts, but not civil or regulatory violations of state law. Thompson and his attorney, Claire Glenn, argued that after cannabis was legalized in Minnesota, possessing and selling the drug became a regulatory matter, not a criminal one.
Thompson also argued that prosecuting him for possession of cannabis violated his rights under the United States' 1855 Treaty with the Ojibwe, which guarantees the Ojibwe usufructuary rights to hunt, fish and gather on ceded lands.
The district court judge ruled that the state did have jurisdiction, allowing the case to proceed. He held that the matter was criminal and that treaties guarantee rights to tribes, not individuals.
Typically, criminal cases can only be appealed after a conviction, which raised the prospect that Thompson could be forced to go to prison before being able to appeal the judge's ruling.
Thompson's attorney, Claire Glenn, asked the Court of Appeals to make an exception and review the jurisdiction matter because his case presents new legal questions that will have implications for Native tribes and tribal members across the state. The appeals court judges agreed.
'A decision on the jurisdiction of the state to enforce Minnesota's cannabis-possession laws and on the extent of the rights reserved under applicable treaties will have an immediate statewide impact on all Tribes in Minnesota subject to Public Law 280 and on their members,' Chief Judge Jennifer Frisch wrote in the opinion on behalf of herself, and Judges Randall Slieter and Rachel Bond.
Glenn praised the decision, noting how rare it is for the Court of Appeals to intervene in the middle of criminal cases.
'We're very encouraged by that, but obviously we have a ways to go,' she said.
Both sides must now submit written briefs before oral arguments will be scheduled.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
7 days ago
- New York Post
Woman who allegedly murdered NYC girlfriend, cut her body into 13 pieces and took on her identity arrested 18 years later
A Georgia woman was arrested for the murder and years-long identity theft of her girlfriend, a New Yorker who was found dismembered beyond recognition in a burning body bag nearly 18 years ago, according to authorities. Angel Thompson has been charged with the December 2007 murder of Nicole Alston, a 24-year-old woman from Manhattan who was discovered cut into 13 pieces, with her hands, feet, and head missing in a burning body bag on the side of a quiet Georgia road, Fulton County officials announced at a press conference on Wednesday. 4 Angel Thompson has been charged with the December 2007 murder of Nicole Alston, a 24-year-old woman from Manhattan who was discovered cut into 13 pieces in a burning body bag on the side of a quiet Georgia road. Fulton County Sheriff Advertisement 'It took a true sociopath to do what happened here,' Clay Bryant, an investigator with the Troup County Sheriff's Department, said. The missing parts of Alston's body were never located, and the condition of her remains led to the 16-year lag in her identification, officials said. But, in early 2023, the case was reviewed, and DNA evidence that matched a relative helped authorities confirm the remains belonged to Alston, whose last known location was Manhattan. Advertisement Investigators learned that Alston left the Big Apple in 2007 to live with Thompson, who was wanted at the time in New York for theft and identity fraud, according to documents obtained by Fox 5 News. Thompson allegedly trafficked Alston before she was murdered, and the two had an abusive, coercive relationship, authorities said. 4 Nicole Alston had been using dating apps to look for a new partner on the night her girlfriend allegedly killed her. Fulton County Sheriff 'We believe this victim was trafficked prior to her murder, that this involved classic domestic violence, where this young lady [Thompson] was basically not going to allow both her lover and, i hate to say such a nasty term, but her cash cow, the person that was bringing her money, go,' Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis said at the press conference. Advertisement On the night Alston was killed, she had already begun to go on dating apps and look for other women, Detective John Nanoff told reporters. After Alston's remains were discovered, Thompson allegedly stole her identity to collect social security benefits, food stamps, and Section 8 housing under her name for eight years. She then opened bank accounts, email accounts, and even swapped Alston's photo with her picture on her driver's license in 2010, Nanoff said. 4 After Alston's remains were discovered, Thompson allegedly stole her identity to collect social security benefits, food stamps, and Section 8 housing under her name for eight years. Fulton County Sheriff Advertisement 'It's astounding what she was able to do, what she did for how long she did it,' Nanoff said. 'I've never seen something so calculated and meticulous before,' he said. In 2015, when the Social Security Administration contacted her to confirm her identity to continue benefits, Thompson began using her original identity, Fox 5 reported. She collected roughly $140,000 in government benefits under Alston's identity, Nanoff said. 4 Thompson allegedly trafficked Alston before she was murdered, and the two had an abusive, coercive relationship. Fulton County Sheriff In August 2023, Thompson was arrested for concealing Alston's death, the outlet reported. Finally, on Tuesday, she was arrested and charged with Alston's murder and two counts of identity theft, nearly two years later, records show. Sylvia Austin, the mother of the victim, said she never stopped looking for her daughter after she went missing. 'She didn't deserve this, and I wish I'd never let her come to Georgia,' she said. Advertisement 'She was the life of the party. She was happy, and through all of her trials and struggles, she always made everything seem OK. She was always the one people called on to talk to,' she said. Willis indicated prosecutors will take their time with Thompson's indictment due to the elaborate nature of the case. Officials urged anyone with information about Thompson or the couple to reach out to the Fulton County District Attorney's Office. The alleged killer is currently in custody at Fulton County Jail without bond, according to court records.
The Hill
7 days ago
- The Hill
Man charged with cyberstalking murdered UnitedHealthcare CEO's family
(NewsNation) — A 40-year-old upstate New York man was arrested Wednesday on federal cyberstalking charges for allegedly sending threatening voicemail messages to a family member of murdered UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in the days following his December killing. Shane Daley of Galway was charged with cyberstalking after authorities say he made multiple harassing calls between Dec. 4 and 7, 2024, beginning just hours after Thompson was gunned down in Midtown Manhattan. According to a criminal complaint, Daley placed several calls to a work phone line used by a Thompson family member, leaving voicemails that expressed satisfaction over Thompson's death and said the victim and Thompson's children 'deserved to meet the same violent end.' George Strait, KISS among Kennedy Center honorees 'Daley, as alleged, gleefully welcomed this tragedy and did all that he could to increase the Thompson family's pain and suffering,' said acting U.S. Attorney John A. Sarcone III of the Northern District of New York. The cyberstalking charge carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison, a $250,000 fine and up to three years of supervised release. Thompson, 50, was fatally shot outside a Manhattan hotel in December 2024 in what authorities called a targeted attack. The killing sparked widespread attention and debate over the health insurance industry. Daley is scheduled to be arraigned Wednesday afternoon before U.S. Magistrate Judge Daniel J. Stewart in Albany. The FBI investigated the case.
New York Post
7 days ago
- New York Post
NY man harassed slain CEO Brian Thompson's mourning wife, leaving her vile voicemails night he was allegedly killed by Luigi Mangione: feds
An Upstate New York man was charged Wednesday with sending threatening voicemails to the wife of slain UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson mere hours after his chilling murder on a Midtown sidewalk. Saratoga County resident Shane Daley, 40, gloated about Thompson's cold-blooded killing in three vile voicemails left on the work phone line of a Minnesota woman — who court papers make clear was Thompson's wife Paulette — on Dec.4, 2024, the night of his death. 'Your [family member] got lit the f–k up because he's a f–king asshole,' Daley said in one of the expletive-filled message, federal court papers allege. 'Profiting off the… backs of poor Americans.' Shane Daley harassed the family of slain healthcare CEO Brian Thompson just hours after his death, the feds say. Daley — who later conceded to an FBI agent that he'd been drinking when the calls were made — claimed in an unhinged message left three minutes later that Thompson's children deserved to die as well, according to a criminal complaint. Federal prosecutors in Albany and Manhattan did not identify the woman who received the calls by name, calling her 'Victim-1' in the filing. But the criminal complaint says that Daley, in his third voicemail that night, mocked Paulette Thompson's statement calling her husband 'an incredibly loving, generous, talented man who truly lived life to the fullest and touched so many lives.' 'The caller was mocking Victim-1's public statement regarding Thompson's murder,' the complaint reads. The Galway, NY man yet again called the mourning woman on the night of Dec.7, leaving a final voicemail wishing the Thompson family suffering and reiterating that the killed CEO 'deserved to f–king die,' court papers alleged. The feds traced the profane voicemails to Daley's phone, and an FBI agent who interviewed him recognized his voice from the messages, the criminal complaint reads. Thompson was fatally shot in Midtown on Dec. 4, 2024, on the morning of UnitedHealthcare's annual investor conference. Matthew McDermott Daley initially denied making the calls, but later 'asserted that he'd been drinking during that period and conceded that it was possible that he made such calls,' court papers say. Daley faces up to five years in prison if convicted of one count of felony cyberstalking. He made his first appearance in Albany federal court Wednesday afternoon in front of USMagistrate Judge Daniel J. Stewart. It was not immediately clear whether he had entered a plea. His attorney didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. Luigi Mangione, 27, was charged with Thompson's murder after a dramatic, days-long manhunt. Mangione is fatally shooting Thompson at close range on the morning of UnitedHealthcare's annual investor conference in what prosecutors call a targeted 'act of terror' meant to prompt public outcry about what the accused killer says is a predatory healthcare industry. He has pleaded not guilty. Christopher Raia, who runs the FBI's New York office, said in a statement Wednesday that 'the recurrent calls and messages in the days following Brian Thompson's murder were more than callous and cold-hearted harassment – they were threatening and terrified a family already suffering following the violent death of their loved one.' 'The FBI will continue to bring to justice any individual attempting to stalk and harass innocent Americans,' Raia said. Acting US Attorney for the Northern District John Sarcone, and interim US Attorney for the Southern District of New York Jay Clayton said in a joint statement that their offices collaborated on Daley's case.
