Concerns grow over private hospital closures
Andy Park: Amid the ongoing Healthscope saga, patients are perplexed about what it means for them. Now in another challenge for the health sector, a private psychiatric hospital in Brisbane has announced its closure. The Australian Medical Association says private health insurance customers are now reconsidering their investment. Elizabeth Cramsie reports.
Elizabeth Cramsie: Jess McClusky is pregnant with her second child, but this time around she won't be able to give birth in the hospital of her choice.
Jess McClusky: People that have laboured in hallways and those kinds of things, so that's one of the major concerns I think for me, having to go to the public hospital, where I know that at the private, that doesn't happen.
Elizabeth Cramsie: Healthscope, which operates Darwin's only private hospital, has gone into receivership, and from next week there will be no private maternity services in Darwin. For patients like Jess, who pay for private health insurance, the move is making them reconsider.
Jess McClusky: If you're paying for the insurance and you can't get anything for it, what's the point? What's the point in having it?
Elizabeth Cramsie: But the upheaval in hospital care is not just limited to those operated by Healthscope. Now a major private Queensland hospital has announced it will close its doors. Management of Toowong Private Psychiatric Hospital says it's being forced to close due to insufficient payments provided by private health insurers. It's something that was put to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese on ABC Radio Brisbane yesterday.
Anthony Albanese: Quite clearly the health insurers need to pay additional money for the private health care that's provided and that is creating an issue across the board.
Elizabeth Cramsie: Brett Heffernan is the Chief Executive of the Australian Private Hospital Alliance.
Brett Heffernan: Toowong Private Hospital, it's been an institution in Brisbane, been there for 50 years. It's had the same management team for 30 years and they're closing their doors all because the health insurance industry refused to pay their bills in full.
Elizabeth Cramsie: With private hospitals accounting for 62% of all acute mental health care across Australia, Brett Heffernan warns more are dangerously close to shutting down.
Brett Heffernan: I've got another eight or so, most of which are mental health hospitals, who are earmarked for closure. Now, there's no comparison between public and private hospital mental health care. They do two very different things. So when these private mental health facilities shut down, there's pretty much nowhere for the patients to go.
Elizabeth Cramsie: Dr Danielle McMullen is the President of the Australian Medical Association.
Dr Danielle McMullen: It's really important that our governments come together with insurers and private hospitals and groups like the AMA, we think under a private health system authority, to really drive the reforms that we need to see.
Elizabeth Cramsie: In a statement, Federal Health Minister Mark Butler says the solutions lie with the insurers and hospitals working together. It's incumbent on them to come together and find solutions.
Andy Park: Elizabeth Cramsie there and private health insurers have been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
SA ambulance ramping surges to third-highest level on record as government 'falls desperately short' of its promise
South Australian patients spent 4,791 hours ramped in ambulances outside public hospitals in May — more than one thousand hours higher than the previous month — as the health system continues to struggle despite billions in extra funding. Two days after releasing a state budget with $1.9 billion in additional money for health, the state government on Saturday published data revealing May was the third-worst month for ambulance ramping in SA since records began in July 2017. The amount of time ambulances spent waiting outside public hospitals to discharge patients increased from 3,700 hours in April to 4,791 in May. The result is roughly in line with the 4,773 hours recorded in May 2024, which preceded a winter surge that saw ramping reach record levels in June (5,539) and July (5,284) of that year. Health Minister Chris Picton said public hospitals were under "significant pressure" last month. "But we've got people stuck in hospital that don't need to be there because they're waiting for a federal aged-care bed." There are 243 elderly patients in SA's public hospitals awaiting an aged care bed, according to the state government. The Royal Adelaide Hospital recorded the biggest spike in ramping hours last month, jumping from 1,194 to 1,698 hours, while the Flinders Medical Centre also spiked from 1,021 to 1,318. Ambulance response times to call-outs also worsened slightly in May. The percentage of priority two call-outs met within the benchmark 16 minutes decreased from 67.7 per cent in April to 60 per cent in May. Priority one call-outs — triaged for a response within eight minutes — stayed the same, with 72.3 per cent of calls met on time. The Malinauskas government highlighted that the May 2025 response times are significantly improved on its early months in office — in May 2022, 54.9 per cent of priority one call-outs and 34.8 per cent of priority two call-outs were being met on time. The head of South Australia's paramedics union said today's ramping figures have given him "grave concerns" about the winter months ahead. Paul Ekkelboom, general secretary of the Ambulance Employees Association (AEA), said his members were also "very frustrated" with the situation. "I get messages every day from regional and metropolitan crews about the extended … hospital ramp times they're having," he said. Asked about the outlook for the next few months, Mr Ekkelboom said: "I've got some grave concerns, obviously." He said the current ramping levels were only around 700 to 800 hours below last year's record numbers and "we've not even hit winter". "If something's not done dramatically, then I think it's going to be even worse than what we saw last year, and that's detrimental to people in the community," he said. The Malinauskas government has invested an additional $9 billion in the state's health system since coming to office in March 2022, according to the state budget papers released on Thursday. Labor won the 2022 election with a core pledge to "fix the ramping crisis" through new spending on hospital beds, ambulances and staff. Opposition health spokesperson Ashton Hurn said the government was falling "desperately short" of its promise. "Labor are now three quarters of the way through their term in office and we're yet to see any green shoots when it comes to delivering on their number-one election promise which was to fix ramping," she said. "We really need to move away … from looking at the statistics here and actually remember what this means for people. "What this means is that sick South Australians are left stranded outside of our hospitals desperate to get in for the care that they need." But the Health Minister said the government was "throwing the kitchen sink" at the problem. "We are opening additional beds which has been called for for years and years and years. "We're putting extra into mental health which has been called for for years and years and years, we've hired an additional, above attrition 2,800 extra doctors, nurses, paramedics and allied health professionals. "But we've got a blockage at the other end of the system that is depriving us of that, so every bed that we're opening is pretty much being filled with an aged care resident that can't get into aged care." Thursday's state budget revealed that demand on public health services is estimated to have grown by more than 4.5 per cent in 2024-25, with the government stumping up $1.7 billion over five years just to cope with increasing demand. The state government says it is building and opening more than 330 new hospital beds across Adelaide in 2024 and 2025.
Daily Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
Dubbo real estate: The latest auction and sales results for week ending June 7
Don't miss out on the headlines from Hyperlocal. Followed categories will be added to My News. A four-bedroom house in Dubbo was the most expensive sale reported in Dubbo last week. The property at 60 Cunningham Street sold for $665,000 by private sale. Only one property was sold via auction last week. data division Proptrack has reported 10 local auction and private sale results in the past seven days. Guide to reading auction and private sale results PI - Passed in PT - Sold by private treaty S - Sold at auction SA - Sold after auction SB - Sold before auction VB - Passed in on vendor bid W - Withdrawn from auction Auction and private sale results in Dubbo Click on the address to know more. Dubbo 60 Cunningham Street, 4-bedroom house, PT, $665,000 Agency - Bob Berry Real Estate - Dubbo 12 Shoreview Lane, 3-bedroom house, PT, $659,000 Agency - Southlakes Estate - DUBBO 1 Campese Court, 4-bedroom house, PT, $651,000 Agency - Bob Berry Real Estate - Dubbo 5 Banksia Crescent, 3-bedroom house, PT, $520,000 Agency - Bob Berry Real Estate - Dubbo 7 Giles Court, 3-bedroom house, PT, $517,500 Agency - Ray White - Dubbo 35 Carnegie Avenue, 5-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - Property Now - BRISBANE CITY 13 Tamworth Street, 2-bedroom house, S, Undisclosed Agency - Elders Dubbo Rural Wellington 127 Arthur Street, 3-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - Sterling Turner Real Estate - Wellington 3 Marsh Street, 3-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - Colin Hewett Real Estate - DUBBO Track the value of your home today.
Daily Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
Coffs Harbour real estate: The latest auction and sales results for week ending June 7
Don't miss out on the headlines from Hyperlocal. Followed categories will be added to My News. A six-bedroom house in Boambee was the most expensive sale reported in Coffs Harbour last week. The property at 62 Symons Avenue sold for $1.5 million by private sale. The cheapest property was a two-bedroom unit at 219/63 Ocean Parade, which sold for $515,000 by private sale. data division Proptrack has reported 31 local auction and private sale results in the past seven days. Guide to reading auction and private sale results PI - Passed in PT - Sold by private treaty S - Sold at auction SA - Sold after auction SB - Sold before auction VB - Passed in on vendor bid W - Withdrawn from auction Auction and private sale results in Coffs Harbour Click on the address to know more. Boambee 62 Symons Avenue, 6-bedroom house, PT, $1,475,000 Agency - Nolan Partners - Coffs Harbour Boambee East 16 Cuthbert Street, 5-bedroom house, PT, $979,000 Agency - McGrath - Coffs Coast 32 De Castella Drive, 4-bedroom house, PT, $930,000 Agency - Unreal Estate Coffs Coast - Coffs Harbour Bonville 258A North Bonville Road, 7-bedroom house, W, Undisclosed Agency - Laing+Simmons - Coffs Harbour 20A Mimiwali Drive, 4-bedroom house, PT, $830,000 Agency - Stone Real Estate - Coffs Harbour Coffs Harbour 18 Peterson Road, 4-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - First National Real Estate Coffs Coast 4/47 Prince Street, 3-bedroom unit, W, Undisclosed Agency - McGrath - Coffs Coast 22 Pearce Drive, 4-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - Aleta & Co Realty - COFFS HARBOUR 219/63 Ocean Parade, 2-bedroom unit, PT, $515,000 Agency - @realty - National Head Office Australia 18 Mathie Street, 3-bedroom house, PT, $741,000 Agency - @realty - National Head Office Australia 76 Thompsons Road, 4-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - First National Real Estate Coffs Coast 56 Buchanans Road, 5-bedroom house, PT, $815,000 Agency - PRD - Coffs Harbour Corindi Beach 41 Simon Street, 4-bedroom house, PT, $875,000 Agency - Michael Smith - Woolgoolga 37 Saltwater Crescent, 4-bedroom house, PT, $915,000 Agency - Michael Smith - Woolgoolga Gleniffer 290 Roses Road, 3-bedroom house, PT, $1,265,000 Agency - OpenHome Online - Bellingen Moonee Beach 8 Beechwood Place, 5-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - The Agency Coffs Harbour - COFFS HARBOUR North Boambee Valley 12 Highlander Drive, 4-bedroom house, PT, $950,000 Agency - Dobbs & Co. - COFFS HARBOUR Safety Beach 5 Admiralty Drive, 5-bedroom house, PT, $1,175,000 Agency - Vision Property Sales Sapphire Beach 50 Ivory Cct, 4-bedroom house, PT, $1,125,000 Agency - PRD - Coffs Harbour Sawtell 18 Sabal Drive, 4-bedroom house, PT, Undisclosed Agency - McGrath - Coffs Coast Toormina 8 Walsh Close, 3-bedroom house, PT, $697,500 Agency - Century 21 - Coffs Coast Ulong 99 Pine Avenue, 2-bedroom house, PT, $580,000 Agency - The Edge - Coffs Harbour Urunga 43 High Street, 3-bedroom house, PT, $649,000 Agency - Warren Weick Real Estate - Bellingen Woolgoolga 9 Greys Road, 4-bedroom house, PT, $845,000 Agency - Vision Property Sales Track the value of your home today.
