Shares in lenders soar after motor finance court ruling
The decision – which was handed down after the market close on Friday – saw FTSE 100 listed Lloyds shares jump nearly 8%, while Close Brothers stock soared by as much as 34% at one stage in the FTSE 250.
Barclays and NatWest shares lifted 2% as the wider sector also received a shares boost.
Lloyds and Close Brothers are seen as the most exposed to the motor finance saga and have put by hefty provisions for possible compensation bills relating to the affair.
The UK's highest court ruled that lenders are not liable for hidden commission payments in car finance schemes, finding that car dealers did not have a relationship with their customers that would require them to act only in the customers' interest.
The decision has been seen as a 'win' for lenders by significantly limiting the potential payouts in compensation, according to experts.
But the judgment left open the door for potential redress claims for very large commissions, which the Supreme Court said were unfair and therefore potentially unlawful.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said on Sunday that it would consult on an industry-wide compensation scheme, meaning millions of drivers could be owed a share of up to £18 billion – though most payouts are expected to be less than £950 each.
Close Brothers – which together with South Africa's FirstRand Bank had mounted the legal challenge against a Court of Appeal ruling that 'secret' commission payments on motor finance were unlawful – said over the weekend that it welcomed the Supreme Court judgment.
It had put by £165 million to cover potential redress, which sent it slumping to a £103.8 million half-year loss, and warned in March over a further £22 million hit to annual figures from legal and other costs linked to the motor finance case.
Close Brothers said there 'remains uncertainty as to the range of outcomes, and the financial impact to the group, including any impact on its provisioning assessment' until the outcome of the FCA's consultation is clear.
On Monday, it added: 'We look forward to engaging with the FCA in respect of the consultation.'
Lloyds said it believes any change to the group's cash set aside for motor finance compensation was 'unlikely to be material', following Friday's court ruling.
It has aside £1.2 billion to cover potential costs and compensation related to commission arrangements.
The group is exposed to the motor finance market through its Black Horse business.
But Lloyds said there continues to be a 'number of uncertainties' and will continue to review its provision.
Lloyds said: 'After initial assessment of the Supreme Court judgment – and pending resolution of the outstanding uncertainties, in particular the FCA redress scheme – the group currently believes that if there is any change to the provision it is unlikely to be material in the context of the group.'
Matt Britzman, senior equity analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, said the court ruling was 'a win for UK lenders, bringing some much-needed legal certainty'.
'But it's not a home run as the FCA announced plans to explore a compensation scheme that could cost the industry £9 billion to £18 billion.'
He added that Lloyds investors should be 'relatively pleased with this outcome'.
'It's broadly aligned with existing expectations, helping to alleviate fears that the final bill could be significantly higher.'
The FCA said on Sunday that the consultation will be launched by early October. If the compensation scheme goes ahead, the first payments should be made in 2026.
It urged consumers who are concerned they were not told about commission and think they may have paid too much to their motor finance lender to complain now.
They do not need to use a claims management company or law firm and doing so could cost them around 30% of any compensation paid, according to the FCA.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Blue chips in favour ahead of likely Bank of England interest rates cut
The FTSE 100 closed higher on Wednesday ahead of an expected interest rate reduction by the Bank of England on Thursday. The FTSE 100 index closed up 21.58 points, 0.2%, at 9,164.31. The FTSE 250 ended 24.19 points higher, 0.1%, at 21,925.88 and the AIM All-Share finished up 0.87 of a point, 0.1%, at 764.35. The Bank of England is expected to maintain its quarterly pace of interest rate cuts so far in 2025 with a further quarter-point reduction on Thursday, as it maintains a balance between the trade-off of elevated inflation and softening growth and a cooling labour market. The UK's central bank held interest rates in June at 4.25%, after a 25 basis points cut in May. This followed interest rates cuts in February this year, and November and August 2024, when the base rate was first cut from 5.25%. Analysts at Citi said: 'We expect the MPC to cut the bank rate by 25bps to 4.0%. This outcome is largely consensual by now and priced accordingly. This, however, is where the clarity ends. 'There is little consensus regarding the expectations for content and tone of the MPC communication; the vote split in the committee; the forecast updates; and of course, the subsequent rate path. 'Unless the MPC actively attempts to narrow the range of expectations by displaying a stronger degree of agreement, this situation might not change much after Thursday.' At its June meeting, the nine-member monetary policy committee voted 6-3 in favour of a hold. This time around, analysts expect Catherine Mann to vote for the status quo, with Swati Dhingra likely to put the case for a larger 50 basis points cut. Morgan Stanley said BoE chief economist Huw Pill could vote for a cut 'but our level of confidence is not high'. In addition, Morgan Stanley said Alan Taylor could join Dhingra in voting for a 50bp reduction. In Europe, the CAC 40 in Paris edged up 0.2%, while the DAX 40 in Frankfurt rose 0.3%. In New York, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was up 0.3%, the S&P 500 was 0.6% higher, and the Nasdaq Composite advanced 0.8%. Stocks received some support as US President Donald Trump claimed that Washington was 'very close to a deal' to extend a China tariffs truce provided some optimism. Dozens of economies around the world including the EU and India are set to face higher US tariffs on Thursday, as Mr Trump's long-threatened 'reciprocal' duties over trade practices he deems unfair take effect. AJ Bell analyst Danni Hewson said an agreement between Washington and Beijing would 'remove the last remaining big uncertainty around tariffs as a 12 August deadline approaches'. Mr Trump on Wednesday imposed an additional 25% tariff on Indian goods over New Delhi's continued purchase of Russian oil, a key revenue source for Moscow's war in Ukraine. The tariff is set to take effect in three weeks and would be added on top of a separate 25% tariff entering into force on Thursday. Weak economic data on Tuesday raised concerns of an economic slowdown in the US. But Kathleen Brooks, research director at trading group XTB, said 'decent' corporate results in the US and Europe were overshadowing these concerns and the impact of Mr 'Trump's continuing obsession with tariffs'. In a Tuesday interview with CNBC, Mr Trump said he was looking at hitting pharmaceuticals with tolls that eventually reach 250%, while semiconductors were also in the firing line. The pound rose to 1.3343 dollars late on Wednesday afternoon in London, compared to 1.3301 dollars at the equities close on Tuesday. The euro traded at 1.1639 dollars, higher against 1.1579 dollars. Against the yen, the dollar was trading lower at 147.34 yen compared to 147.42 yen. The yield on the US 10-year treasury was at 4.22%, widened from 4.20%. The yield on the US 30-year treasury was 4.81%, stretched from 4.77%. On the FTSE 100, Hiscox rose 9.4% as it announced better-than-expected first-half profit and increased its share buyback by 100 million dollars. The Bermuda-based specialist insurer posted pretax profit of 276.6 million dollars for the six months that ended June 30, down 2.4% from 283.5 million dollars a year before, but 30% ahead of 212 million dollars Visible Alpha consensus. 'We have delivered a strong performance in the first half with profitable growth in each of our businesses,' said chief executive Aki Hussain. In addition, Hiscox increased the size of its share buyback to 275 million dollars from 175 million dollars. Meanwhile, Guinness owner Diageo, up 3.9%, and oil major BP, up 3.2%, extended gains after Tuesday's well received earnings. But Coca-Cola Europacific Partners slumped 9.2% as it cut annual revenue guidance despite a 'solid' first half for the soft drink bottler. The company, which operates in over 30 markets including Australia, Germany, Great Britain and Spain, now expects revenue growth between 3% and 4%, a downgrade from its prior expectation of 4% growth for 2025. Elsewhere, British Airways owner IAG fell 2.0% after UBS downgraded to 'sell' from 'neutral'. IAG has flown high in the last 12 months with shares more than doubling. But UBS suggested this could be as good as it gets, citing concerns over likely slowing momentum in profit growth, North Atlantic yield progression, the UK economic backdrop and changes in the Avios loyalty programme. On the FTSE 250, Telecom Plus climbed 2.9% as it reported the integration of TalkTalk customers was going well but TP ICAP fell 8.1% as profit fell short of City hopes. The interdealer broker said pre-tax profit in the first half of 2025 edged up 2.5% to £123 million from £120 million a year prior. Adjusted earnings before interest and tax advanced 8.2% to £184 million from £170 million, though Shore Capital Markets said the outcome fell short of consensus of £189 million. Brent oil was quoted higher at 68.31 dollars a barrel in London on Wednesday, up from 68.04 dollars late on Tuesday. Gold eased to 3,375.48 dollars an ounce against 3,385.82 dollars. The biggest risers on the FTSE 100 were Hiscox, up 119.0 pence at 1,379.0p, Fresnillo, up 135.0p at 1,655.0p, Diageo, up 79.5p at 1,983.5p, BP, up 12.90p at 430.35p and London Stock Exchange, up 296.0p at 10,100.0p. The biggest fallers on the FTSE 100 were Coca-Cola Europacific Partners, down 680.0p at 6,710.0p, Coca-Cola HBC, down 270.0p at 3,652.0p, Glencore, down 16.3p at 284.75p, Relx, down 168.00p at 3,646.0p and Pearson, down 43.5p at 1,083.5p. Thursday's local corporate calendar sees half year results from bookmaker Flutter Entertainment, hotel operator InterContinental Hotels Group and advertising group WPP. The global economic calendar on Thursday has the UK interest rate decision and weekly jobless claims data in the US.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Mining giant ditches plans for New York switch
Glencore has axed plans to move its main stock market listing away from London, in a boost for the London Stock Exchange. The FTSE 100-listed miner announced in February it was mulling shifting its main listing to New York, but said on Wednesday the move would not deliver better value to shareholders. The business is one of the biggest stocks on London's blue-chip index with a market capitalisation of around £35.9billion. It would have marked another major blow to London's capital markets, which has seen Paddy Power owner Flutter, building materials supplier CRH and equipment rental giant Ashtead among the large firm's shifting their primary listing to the US in the last two years. Glencore said the scale and depth of US capital markets was 'unrivalled'. But, it added: 'Having considered the costs and benefits, including in respect of indexation, we do not believe that becoming a US domestic issuer... would be value accretive for shareholders at this point in time." 'We will continue to monitor market developments and keep this topic under review.' Job losses loom as losses soar But in a blow to staff, the Swiss-based miner warned over job cuts as part of efforts to cut costs by more than £753million by the end of next year. More than half of the cost savings are expected to be secured by the end of 2025. Glencore said savings would come from cutting its workforce as it streamlines its operations across 'energy, consumables, contractors, maintenance and administrative functions'. The cost-cutting drive came as Glencore posted a 14 per cent fall in underlying earnings to £4.09billion. Net losses nearly trebled to £493million from £175million a year ago, amid lower coal prices, copper production issues and uncertainty triggered by Donald Trump's stop-start tariffs, including on US mineral imports. Glencore said its first-half performance was an 'overall solid result, against a macroeconomic environment that was heavily influenced by US tariff policy uncertainty and tensions in the Middle East'. The company's primary listing is currently in London, but it is also listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange. It listed in London 14 years ago in a blockbuster flotation. Neil Wilson, UK investor strategist at Saxo, said: 'Glencore is sticking with its London listing and shares fell 4 per cent. 'That is probably less about staying in London and more about the fact it posted a deeper-than-expected net loss due to taking a big impairment on its Colombian coal assets. 'Weak thermal coal prices have weighed on the stock but there are potential signs of a turnaround in production, led by copper.' Paddy Power owner Flutter, Tui and Just Eat have all shifted their main listings away from the London Stock Exchange. In December, industrial equipment rental firm Ashtead Group, said it planned to move its primary listing to New York from London. Last month, Astrazeneca's boss said it was a 'very American company' as he refused to rule out moving its main stock market listing to the US. Speaking from the British pharma giant's offices in New York, Pascal Soriot said it was 'global', but it was 'very much rooted and present in the US'. He added that continuing to view it as a British company was 'old-fashioned'. The comments fuelled speculation that the FTSE 100 group could switch its main stock market listing from London to New York, and even move its headquarters to the US. Glencore shares were down 3.8 per cent or 11.45p to 289.60p on Wednesday, having slumped over a quarter in the past year.
Wales Online
6 hours ago
- Wales Online
Crooked finance manager who stole £140,000 from employers to pay back £72,000
Crooked finance manager who stole £140,000 from employers to pay back £72,000 Victoria King, 56, paid herself an extra £7,500 a month by fiddling the books Victoria King, as known as Vikki Phillips, pictured in 2011 A crooked finance manager who stole £140,000 from her employers years after being jailed for leaving another employer out of pocket has been ordered to pay back £72,000. She was already on a £45,000-a-year salary but paid herself an extra £7,500 a month by fiddling the books and creating payments to what looked to be a genuine supplier but was in fact herself. Victoria King, 56, who is also known as Vikki Phillips, was jailed in 2014 for stealing £130,000 from a charity she was working for and went on to forge "glowing" references from her victims which she used to apply for another job in finance. In 2021 King joined the Rhigos office of Eftech Ltd, a company which supplies adhesives and sealants to the automotive industry, as finance manager. For the latest court reports sign up to our crime newsletter. She said in that £45,000-a-year role the defendant was responsible for making payments to the firm's suppliers and had access to the company's Lloyds bank account. In April 2023 the defendant quit her job and the Belgium-based company decided not to replace her but to subsume the Welsh office's finance operations into the Belgian operations. As part of the transition process a financial review was carried out which involved checking invoices and payments at the Rhigos office. The audit highlighted discrepancies in the numbers and the boss of the Rhigos branch was asked to carry out an investigation. The internal probe ultimately uncovered 21 payments made between October 2021 and July 2023 to an account which had a name almost identical to that of a genuine supplier. In total £140,197 had been paid into the account, which was controlled by King, usually in monthly amounts of £7,500. The police were alerted and the defendant was interviewed but answered "no comment" to all questions asked. In a statement from the current boss of the Rhigos office he described King's behaviour as "despicable". He said the offending had led to a "breakdown of trust" which was a shame as the firm had always been a close-knit company where often generations of the same family had chosen to work. He said King had been happy to talk to people about her horses and the holidays she was taking and that the offending was done simply out of greed. King, of Highdale Crescent, Llantrisant, Pontyclun, had previously pleaded guilty to fraud by abuse of position when she appeared in the dock for sentencing. The court heard she has two previous convictions for two offences. She was sentenced to 32 months in prison at Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court in May. Article continues below A Proceeds of Crime Act (POCA) hearing at the same court on Wednesday heard King benefited to the tune of £145,197 as a result of her offending but only has assets worth £72,657. Judge Vanessa Francis ordered the defendant to pay that sum within three months or serve an additional two years imprisonment in default.
