logo
‘The banks thought we were mad': coral castles and look-at-me loos reinvent New York housing

‘The banks thought we were mad': coral castles and look-at-me loos reinvent New York housing

The Guardian28-01-2025

For all its metropolitan dynamism and heady sense of possibility, New York is not a city that produces good housing. Its building codes are so strict, its land values so high, and its construction practises so intractable, that the results tend towards grim stacks of cells. New apartment blocks – even at the high end – do little to disguise the fact that they are simply physical spreadsheets of units, expressions of brutal economic efficiency, occasionally garnished with a thin architectural dressing.
'New York is supposedly the greatest, most competitive city on Earth,' says Sam Alison-Mayne, who grew up in Los Angeles, son of the prominent west coast architect Thom Mayne. 'Competition usually breeds the best solutions for things – but not when it comes to housing.' While he was working as a contractor, he met Sebastian Mendez, an Argentinian architect at Foster + Partners at the time, and the two realised there was scope to do things differently. They quit their jobs, founded a development company, Tankhouse, and, 10 years later, have built three of the city's most innovative housing projects in recent memory.
Their latest provocation stands on the corner of Vanderbilt and Myrtle avenues in Brooklyn's trendy Fort Greene neighbourhood, rising from the sidewalk like a jaunty pink castle. Its rose-tinted mass lurches in a staccato rhythm along the street, growing in blocky jolts from four-storey townhouses, up to eight storeys on the corner. The cubic volumes fold and twist as they rise, framing a world of shared terraces and open, breezy landings. The pink precast concrete walls are grooved like fine needlecord, their surfaces variously etched and bead-blasted, making the building shift and shimmer in the bright sunlight, casting sharp shadows across the facade. It recalls the enchanting work of Ricardo Bofill in Spain, whose La Muralla Roja stands like a vertical casbah on the Calpe coast, or the pastel-hued levels of the video game Monument Valley – as if this 3D jigsaw of apartments and courtyards might reconfigure itself at any moment.
The striking coral-coloured outcrop is the work of SO-IL, a Brooklyn-based architecture practice led by Florian Idenburg and Jing Liu, who hail from the Netherlands and China, and bring a healthy outsider's perspective to New York's real estate conventions. 'Everything here is driven by 'net-to-gross efficiency',' says Idenburg, with a Dutch sense of exasperation at North America's mercenary reality. 'The architect's task is just to maximise the sellable floor area within the smallest possible building envelope. The result is narrow, windowless corridors, with single-aspect apartments either side, stacked up into a dumb box. So we tried to do the exact opposite. And everyone thought we were insane.'
Since the earliest decades of the 20th century, the regulatory corset of the 'zoning envelope' has defined the architecture of New York. After the city's 1916 zoning resolution, the architectural draughtsman Hugh Ferriss created a prophetic series of illustrations, depicting how the set-back rules – which dictate how buildings must step back as they rise, to allow daylight to reach the streets – would lead to a particular architectural form. The zoning envelope, he wrote, is a 'shape which the law puts into the architect's hands,' and it has determined the city's form ever since.
In a new book about SO-IL's work, In Depth: Urban Domesticities Today, architect Karilyn Johanesen explains how the situation has since evolved into a complex cocktail of ever more constraining codes. 'Subsequent amendments to the zoning resolution such as height factor, floor-area ratio, open-space ratio, quality housing deductions, and affordability incentives,' she writes, 'have added more complexity to a matrix of ratios that pits zoning and code requirements against profit maximisation.' A building's boundaries are predefined before an architect can even make their first move.
SO-IL's impressive talent is to limbo beneath the bureaucracy, stretching loopholes and exploiting zoning quirks, to carve out space for architecture. Tankhouse began working with them in 2014, with an approach that, to their peers, looked like commercial suicide. They chose awkward corner plots that came with hosts of restrictions, but then turned those constraints, jiu-jitsu-like, to their advantage. On each project, the team decided to build out to the maximum volume that the zoning envelope would allow, in order to then carve out 'unsellable' space within it – in the form of terraces, balconies, stoops and shared outdoor circulation space, drawing on the developers' experiences of outdoor living in the sunnier climes of LA and Buenos Aires.
'The banks and the brokers thought we were mad,' says Mendez, who drummed up investment from friends and family in Argentina for their first project, after the usual lenders were reluctant to cough up. 'We weren't maximising the sellable floor area, so it simply didn't fit any formula they were used to dealing with.'
The gamble paid off. On the corner of Warren and Bond streets, in the formerly industrial Brooklyn neighbourhood of Gowanus, stands the group's first mini manifesto: a cluster of 18 homes, arranged around three lush courtyards, which sold out before construction was completed in 2023. A sculptural outdoor staircase curves its way between broad, convivial landings, where the homes enjoy views out in all directions on to planted gardens, crowned with a stunning roof terrace. In conventional real estate terms, the floor plan is as economically 'inefficient' as it gets; but the payoff is a liberating sense of connection to the outdoors, and a sociable, neighbourly, child-friendly place to live. Mendez liked it so much, he moved in with his family.
The design details are as pragmatic as they are ingenious. A drape of wire mesh netting, stretched tautly between the curving landings, is a cheap and cheerful substitute for balustrades (and has led to the space being hired for several photoshoots, a handy income stream). The walls are built with inexpensive concrete blocks, spiced up with a greenish aggregate, and laid at an angle to create an unusual serrated effect. 'It's also a way to overcome a bit of imperfection,' says Idenburg. 'Building here is not like the precision of Japan. In New York City, you have to create a lot of noise.'
He would know. Idenburg used to work for Sanaa, the Japanese masters of minimalism, leading their project for the New Museum in New York – acting as the translator between Japanese perfectionism and less-than-perfect US building practises. It left him with a dogged single-mindedness, and an uncompromising ability to push builders and suppliers beyond their usual standards (if sometimes alienating them in the process – Alison-Mayne jokes how many contractors refuse to work with them again).
Sign up to Art Weekly
Your weekly art world round-up, sketching out all the biggest stories, scandals and exhibitions
after newsletter promotion
While 450 Warren and 144 Vanderbilt both take mid-rise courtyard forms, a third project, between Dumbo and downtown Brooklyn, shows how the same approach can also work in a high-rise context. Standing as a shimmering pleated apparition, worthy of Issey Miyake, 9 Chapel St is another intelligent essay in interpreting zoning codes. It makes use of special allowances for features such as dormer windows, bulkheads and balconies, to play with the form – and create nicer apartments in the process.
As in the other projects, the elevator opens on to an outdoor hallway, leading to wide decks and generous porches in front of each home. All units have deep balconies, some of which wrap the entire way around, shielded by a perforated screen of metal mesh that ripples its way the full height of the building. Gentle vertical corrugations in the mesh create an irregular play of shadows across the building, while also serving a structural purpose – the pleats allow the panels to span floor-to-floor, without the need for additional support. Subtle rotations between bedrooms and living areas create varied views across the city, and capture sunlight at different times of day, while some bathrooms enjoy full-height glass doors to balconies from the showers – a moment of exhilarating exhibitionism, 15 storeys up.
It's impressive stuff, but none of these flats are cheap. Could the Tankhouse model be scalable, and, more importantly, affordable? 'Those are the two big questions,' says Alison-Mayne, who says the team is now working on their biggest project yet, a 20-storey tower of rental apartments in Gowanus with 'a deep affordability component'. It looks set to be a big, bulky thing, but one that has been elegantly chiselled into shape by SO-IL, with serrated sawtooth facades providing the apartments with views in two directions, as well as day-lit corridors, and a silhouette that recalls the muscular early days of Manhattan towers. Details like grey, iron-speckled brick, laid in a stacked bond with blue-green mortar, promise to give it a powerfully monolithic, mineral quality.
'I don't want to pretend like we're solving all the problems,' says Alison-Mayne. 'We've built a bunch of very expensive housing.' But there are lessons here, in terms of intelligent spatial thinking beyond the units-by-numbers approach, that developers of all tenures – as well as those in charge of codifying the city – could do well to learn from.
In Depth: Urban Domesticities Today by Florian Idenburg & Jing Liu is published by Lars Müller

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Awards Recognise Training Company's Apprenticeship Stars
Awards Recognise Training Company's Apprenticeship Stars

Business News Wales

time6 hours ago

  • Business News Wales

Awards Recognise Training Company's Apprenticeship Stars

Winners of the Apprenticeship, Employment and Skills Awards organised by Cambrian Training Company. The achievements of apprentices, employers and work-based learning practitioners from across Wales were celebrated at an awards ceremony in Mid Wales. Twenty-seven finalists competed for the Apprenticeship, Employment and Skills Awards organised by work-based learning provider Cambrian Training Company. The awards, held at The Metropole Hotel & Spa, Llandrindod Wells, recognised employers, learners and practitioners who have excelled in apprenticeship programmes delivered by the Welshpool-based company and its sub-contractors. A popular winner was autistic apprentice Aaron Jones, a waiter at Penycae Inn, Penycae, near Swansea, who received a standing ovation after collecting the Apprentice Special Recognition 2025 Award. 'In receiving this very special award, I am enormously proud and owe it to every single person in the audience but above all to my fellow team of staff at Penycae Inn and to those that have autism and other profound learning needs,' he told the audience. 'As a person with autism who works in the hospitality industry, this award means so much to me. Anybody with a learning or physical disability who is considering doing an apprenticeship should absolutely go for it.' He praised Cambrian Training Company's hospitality training officers Andrew Addis-Fuller and Leah Williams for their support and encouragement to achieve his goals, which include completing his Hospitality Supervision and Leadership Apprenticeship early next year. Aaron Jones from Penycae Inn receives the Apprentice Special Recognition 2025 Award from Arwyn Watkins, OBE The Foundation Apprentice of the Year was awarded to Cameron Long, a cleaning support services attendant at Elite Clothing Solutions, Ebbw Vale, who has completed a Supported Shared Apprenticeship with support from Elite Supported Employment. Apprentice of the Year was Cai Watkins, head of business unit contract manager for Cambrian Training Company, Welshpool, while the Higher Apprentice of the Year award went to Mathew Verallo, operations manager for The Celtic Collection's Tŷ Milford Waterfront, Milford Haven. The awards for employers was keenly contested. The Small Employer of the Year was Silver Assist Homecare, Llangorse, Brecon, Filco Markets, Llantwit Major collected the Medium Employer of the Year Award and Achieve Together, Cardiff was named Large Employer of the Year. Outstanding Individual of the Year was Denise Hodson, a playworker at Little Disciples Childcare, Penymynydd, Flintshire and Welsh Ambassador of the Year was Phoebe Wilson, lead training officer at Clybiau Plant Cymru Kids' Clubs, Cardiff. Practitioner of the Year was Elfed Wood, from Portal Training, Cardiff, the Employer Special Recognition Award went to The Grove, Narbeth and Kepak, Merthyr Tydfil was recognised for Outstanding Contribution to Apprenticeships. 'Among our winners and finalists are inspiring stories of personal growth and professional development,' said Faith O'Brien, Cambrian Training Company's managing director. 'This year's awards ceremony was a testament to the dedication, passion and hard work of our apprentices, employers and supporters. From the Apprentice of the Year awards to the recognition of outstanding employers and individuals, each accolade reflects the transformative power of apprenticeships in shaping careers and communities. 'Let's continue supporting and championing vocational education. Together, we can create a future where every individual has the opportunity to thrive through learning and development.' The other finalists were: Foundation Apprentice of the Year Award: Josh Williams, a receptionist at Whitbread Premier Inn, Bangor and Leanne Barratt, a chef at Mitchell & Butlers' Miller & Carter, Killay. Apprentice of the Year Award: Deanne Rance, area manager for Lonetree-McDonalds, Newport and Jodie Bowater, hotel manager Whitbread Premier Inn, Bangor. Higher Apprentice of the Year: Ashley Richards, general manager at Peppermint Cardiff and Keri-Ann Evans, head chef at Bluestone, Narberth. Outstanding Individual of the Year: Rachael Bowles, blending room team leader for Hilltop Honey, Newtown and Aaron Jones, a waiter at Penycae Inn, Penycae, near Swansea. Small Employer of the Year: Nazareth House, Cardiff and Interplay, Penlan, Swansea. Medium Employer of the Year: Voco St David's Cardiff and The Grove, Narberth. Large Employer of the Year: Kepak, Merthyr Tydfil and Urdd Gobaith Cymru. Welsh Language Ambassador: Catherine Smith, training officer at Clybiau Plant Cymru Kids' Clubs and Samantha James, restaurant manager at Millie & Sid's, Tywyn. Work-based Learning Practitioner: Sean Williams from Sirius Skills Consulting, Mountain Ash and Sarah Bird from Clybiau Plant Cymru, Cardiff.

Major supermarket launches dupe of viral Matilda chocolate cake for £4 less
Major supermarket launches dupe of viral Matilda chocolate cake for £4 less

Scottish Sun

time8 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Major supermarket launches dupe of viral Matilda chocolate cake for £4 less

We reveal how you can save money on your next shop at the major supermarket CHOC FULL Major supermarket launches dupe of viral Matilda chocolate cake for £4 less Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MAJOR UK supermarket has launched a dupe version of the viral Matilda chocolate cake for £4 less. Tesco has unveiled its own version of Get Baked's famous "Bertha" chocolate slice for £16. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Tesco has launched a dupe version of Get Baked's viral Matilda cake for £16 Credit: TESCO 2 Get Baked's "Bertha" slice sells for £20 on its website Credit: get-baked And the dessert comes in £4 cheaper than the Leeds-based company's £20 original slice. The Bertha cake, formerly known as Bruce and now with a tweaked recipe, has taken social media by storm since its launch. Instagram and TikTok videos of people trying the cake have notched up millions of likes. Now, Tesco shoppers can't get enough of the supermarket's own version, which launched this week. Instagram account newfoodspotteruk posted about the new £16 cake, with shoppers quick to comment. Some can't wait to give the supermarket's dupe a try, with one posting: "Running to Tesco for these." Another added: "This is actually the most exciting new food post I've ever seen oh my god." A third chipped in: "Get in I can't wait to get it." But not everyone is convinced by the new arrival, with one posting: "Get Baked UK does it better. Bertha supremacy." Meanwhile, another posted: "Pass, I'll stick to the original Bertha thanks." SAVE HUNDREDS AT TESCO Tesco said the Bertha chocolate cake dupe comes with 10 servings each containing 375 calories. It is available across 480 stores in the UK while shoppers can order it online too. The cake is a permanent addition. The cake is made up of 24 layers and made by Studio Bakery. OTHER TESCO NEWS Tesco recently sparked shopper fury after axing a dinner staple from shelves. The supermarket has discontinued eight packs of own-brand beef sausages. Customers were left equally miffed after finding out Southern Fried chicken flavour noodles were axed. Confused eaters took to social media to find out where the popular snack had gone. Writing in a Reddit thread one shopper said: "These are my go to quick food and my local Tesco has none on the shelf and they've disappeared off of the website too. "I'll be gutted if they've discontinued them." Another fan replied: "Probably, if you liked them, these stores always stop what people like." Meanwhile, Tesco customers have been taking to social media to reveal how they're getting free items by checking receipts. How to save money at Tesco EVERY little helps when it comes to saving money at Tesco. The Sun's Head of Consumer Tara Evans explains how you can save money at the UK's biggest supermarket. Clubcard points Tesco first launched it's loyalty scheme back in 1995. You get one point for every £1 you spend in store. If you spend points in store then 100 points is worth £1. You can spend your points via its reward partners and get triple and even sometimes quadruple the value. Extend Clubcard points You can find lost Clubvcard points and find the last two years of unused vouchers by logging into the Tesco Clubcard site. Clubcard prices If you don't have a Clubcard then you will miss out on its cheaper Clubcard prices. However, don't forget to check prices before you shop because it might not be cheaper than elsewhere, especially on big value items like washing powder and loo roll. Yellow stickers Shops do vary the time they reduce groceries with yellow stickers but Tesco tends to be between 7pm and 9pm. Save money if you shop online If you get your Tesco food shop delivered then it might be worth buying a delivery saver pass to help cut the cost of delivery fees. If you live near a Tesco then you can get click and collect slots of as little as 25p, so it might be cheaper than getting your food delivered. Do you have a money problem that needs sorting? Get in touch by emailing money-sm@ Plus, you can join our Sun Money Chats and Tips Facebook group to share your tips and stories

Scottish Government calls in Flamingo Land plans for Loch Lomond
Scottish Government calls in Flamingo Land plans for Loch Lomond

Scotsman

time8 hours ago

  • Scotsman

Scottish Government calls in Flamingo Land plans for Loch Lomond

Controversial proposals included two hotels, more than 100 lodges, a waterpark and a monorail Sign up to our Scotsman Rural News - A weekly of the Hay's Way tour of Scotland emailed direct to you. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The Scottish Government has called in plans for a major development on the banks of Loch Lomond, reversing a previous decision. Through the firm Lomond Banks, the Yorkshire-based theme park operator Flamingo Land planned to build two hotels, more than 100 lodges, a waterpark and monorail on the site at Balloch, West Dunbartonshire. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad An illustration showing what Flamingo Land at Loch Lomond would look like | Contributed In a long-running saga, plans were initially scrapped in 2019 following substantial opposition from the local community and agencies such as the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (Sepa), the Woodland Trust and the National Trust for Scotland. Revised plans were later unanimously rejected by the Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park authority, but an appeal by Lomond Banks was granted by a Scottish Government reporter, who placed 49 conditions on the developer and forced them to reach an agreement with the authority before construction could start. Despite urging from MSPs, Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee had resisted calls for ministers to intervene in the decision to allow the plans to go forward, but it was announced on Tuesday evening that they would. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'I have decided to recall the Lomond Banks appeal as the proposed development raises issues of national significance in view of its potential impact on Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park,' the minister said. 'This means that the appeal should be determined at a national level.' Mr McKee had previously said there were 'technical planning issues' at play in the application, adding that it was appropriate for 'objective planning judgment' to be applied in the case and as a result, the Government would not call in the application. Following the minister's comments, a Scottish Green-led campaign claimed more than 50,000 people had written to him to urge a change of direction. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The decision comes the day before Scottish Labour was due to lead a debate calling for the Government to intervene in the application, with the party's deputy leader Jackie Baillie claiming on X ministers feared being defeated. 'The SNP face a motion tomorrow from Scottish Labour demanding that the application is recalled,' she said. 'Thanks to cross party support for our motion, the SNP has u-turned before it was defeated in the chamber.' Responding to the news, Scottish Green MSP Ross Greer said it was the 'right move'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'The evidence of the damage it would do to one of Scotland's most iconic locations is overwhelming,' he said. 'Once ministers consider the flood risk, loss of ancient woodland, hundreds of additional cars which would be brought onto notoriously congested roads and the litany of other devastating impacts it would have, I am sure they will reject the mega-resort application and finally end this decade-long saga. 'People across Scotland expect their Government to protect our natural heritage.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store