Scale of planting to meet zero carbon goal ‘unachievable'
Dunedin City Council zero carbon manager Jinty MacTavish. File photo: Peter McIntosh
It is "unachievable" for Dunedin to plant a path to its zero carbon goals, city councillors have been told.
At a workshop yesterday, Dunedin City Council zero carbon manager Jinty MacTavish told councillors sequestration — capturing and storing atmospheric carbon dioxide, often with trees or vegetation — needed to be combined with a community-wide effort to reduce emissions.
Staff had carried out modelling to provide an idea of the trees required to meet the council's goal, although she warned councillors the results were "incredibly theoretical and incredibly indicative".
Speaking to the modelling, senior zero carbon policy analyst Rory MacLean said the scale of planting needed to meet the city's zero carbon goal was "unachievable".
The council had aimed for Dunedin to be a net zero-carbon city by 2030, excluding biogenic methane, but conceded in January this was unlikely, regardless of the level of investment.
Mr MacLean said more than 100,000ha of indigenous planting would have been required to meet the goal by 2030 — "and that's just imaginary numbers really".
If the goal was shifted to 2035, 27,000ha of indigenous plantings or 16,500ha of exotic plantings were needed for the city to become net zero as there was more time for the trees to grow.
"At present there's about 17,000ha of commercial exotic forests in Dunedin, so you're talking about a doubling or almost tripling of the land area covered by forests."
In an "accelerated ambition" scenario, 20,000ha of indigenous plantings or 10,000ha of exotic plantings would meet the 2035 goal.
Still, this was an "enormous" land area to be converted to forestry, Mr MacLean said.
"One of the assumptions in this is that all the plantings happen this year, which obviously would not happen.
"So if you're actually looking to do this, the land area would be even larger because you would need to space out the plantings over multiple years."
Ms MacTavish said decreasing emissions would reduce the amount of land required for planting.
"The intention of this was just to show that this needs to be a whole of community effort rather than something that the DCC alone would take on if it were to be achieved."
In 2021-22, the most recent year the council had full data for, Dunedin's forests absorbed 493,000tonnes of CO₂.
"It's not insignificant, and that sets us apart from other cities that don't have the large land area that Dunedin has. "
Forests were the only type of sequestration included in the Emissions Trading Scheme and emerging methods of absorbing carbon — such as blue carbon (wetlands) or increasing soil carbon — were not easily measurable and verifiable, she said.
A report on carbon renewals would go to council later this month.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Scale of planting to meet zero carbon goal ‘unachievable'
Dunedin City Council zero carbon manager Jinty MacTavish. File photo: Peter McIntosh It is "unachievable" for Dunedin to plant a path to its zero carbon goals, city councillors have been told. At a workshop yesterday, Dunedin City Council zero carbon manager Jinty MacTavish told councillors sequestration — capturing and storing atmospheric carbon dioxide, often with trees or vegetation — needed to be combined with a community-wide effort to reduce emissions. Staff had carried out modelling to provide an idea of the trees required to meet the council's goal, although she warned councillors the results were "incredibly theoretical and incredibly indicative". Speaking to the modelling, senior zero carbon policy analyst Rory MacLean said the scale of planting needed to meet the city's zero carbon goal was "unachievable". The council had aimed for Dunedin to be a net zero-carbon city by 2030, excluding biogenic methane, but conceded in January this was unlikely, regardless of the level of investment. Mr MacLean said more than 100,000ha of indigenous planting would have been required to meet the goal by 2030 — "and that's just imaginary numbers really". If the goal was shifted to 2035, 27,000ha of indigenous plantings or 16,500ha of exotic plantings were needed for the city to become net zero as there was more time for the trees to grow. "At present there's about 17,000ha of commercial exotic forests in Dunedin, so you're talking about a doubling or almost tripling of the land area covered by forests." In an "accelerated ambition" scenario, 20,000ha of indigenous plantings or 10,000ha of exotic plantings would meet the 2035 goal. Still, this was an "enormous" land area to be converted to forestry, Mr MacLean said. "One of the assumptions in this is that all the plantings happen this year, which obviously would not happen. "So if you're actually looking to do this, the land area would be even larger because you would need to space out the plantings over multiple years." Ms MacTavish said decreasing emissions would reduce the amount of land required for planting. "The intention of this was just to show that this needs to be a whole of community effort rather than something that the DCC alone would take on if it were to be achieved." In 2021-22, the most recent year the council had full data for, Dunedin's forests absorbed 493,000tonnes of CO₂. "It's not insignificant, and that sets us apart from other cities that don't have the large land area that Dunedin has. " Forests were the only type of sequestration included in the Emissions Trading Scheme and emerging methods of absorbing carbon — such as blue carbon (wetlands) or increasing soil carbon — were not easily measurable and verifiable, she said. A report on carbon renewals would go to council later this month.
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Cavalcade host town raises record sum
Horses enjoy an early morning meal on the Goldfields Cavalcade Les Beattie Horse Trail to Twizel, at Ben Avon Station in the Ahuriri Valley, in February. PHOTO: SUPPLIED Cavalcade hosts will return a record sum to local groups at a ceremony in Twizel next week. Twizel was the host town for the Goldfields Cavalcade in February this year, and event organiser Terry Davis said the host committee was now ready to disburse proceeds from the event finale. Mr Davis said this year's event had been a double success as it not only marked the fulfilment of a promise from 2021, but also a record sum raised by the host town, of more than $70,000. "When I started in about 2010, the cavalcade would raise about $15,000 to $20,000. "That steadily rose until Waikaia made a record sum of $63,000 last year, which we were very excited about. "We had originally intended to come to Twizel in 2021, when Covid intervened, but we promised we'd be back, and back we came in February. "The Twizel committee pulled out all the stops and broke the fundraising record again, so we're delighted for everyone who's come together to make this another world-class event for the South," Mr Davis said. The cavalcade comprises a variety of guided horse, bicycle and tramping trails following traditional back-country gold-mining routes, ending at a different shared destination each year. Up to 600 people take part, alongside more than 400 horses, which gather for a fundraising celebration in the host town at the event's conclusion. This year's finale took place over February 28 and March 1. Previous economic impact reports had shown more than $1million injected into local businesses from the full cavalcade, Mr Davis said. In addition, this year's host committee disbursements would go to 10 local groups, and total more than $70,000. The celebration would take place at the town's Top Hut Sports Bar and Bistro on Monday at 6pm. Mr Davis said preparations were already under way for the next cavalcade, ending in Middlemarch on March 7 next year. "The bar has been set high, but I've no doubt Middlemarch will be ready to put on an amazing welcome this summer."
Scoop
2 days ago
- Scoop
Save Our Sheep Billboards Hit Wellington
Wednesday, 4 June 2025, 1:43 pm Press Release: Federated Farmers Federated Farmers have taken the fight for the future of New Zealand sheep farming to the streets of Wellington, with bold digital billboards visible directly from Ministers' Beehive offices. The message to politicians is clear and concise: sheep are not the problem - stop planting productive farmland in pine trees for carbon credits. Save our sheep billboard (Photo/Supplied) "We wanted this campaign to be bold and directly in politicians' faces. That's the only way we're going to get their attention," Federated Farmers meat & wool chair Toby Williams says. "Sheep farming is in crisis. We need the Government to urgently wake up to the impact poor policy is having on our farming families and rural communities. "Each year we're losing tens of thousands of hectares of productive farmland. "Where sheep and lambs once grazed there's now nothing but pine trees as far as the eye can see." Between 2017 and 2024, more than 260,000 hectares of productive sheep farming land were plastered in pine trees - never to return to pasture. In just one generation New Zealand has lost over two-thirds of our national flock, reducing from over 70 million sheep in 1982 to fewer than 25 million sheep today. "Our national flock is declining by almost a million sheep every year and the number one driver is carbon forestry," Williams says. "Farms are being converted to forestry because Government policy is screwing the scrum and making it more profitable to plant pine trees than to farm sheep. "The Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) is effectively subsidising pine trees to offset fossil fuel emissions, and that's pushing farming families off the land and destroying rural communities." New Zealand is the only country in the world that allows 100% carbon offsetting through forestry, with other countries recognising the risk and putting restrictions in place. Federated Farmers is now calling on the Government to urgently review the ETS and fix the rules to either limit or stop the offsetting of fossil fuel emissions with forestry. You can sign the petition at © Scoop Media
