Survivors, families of victims mark 20 yrs since JR West derailment
OSAKA (Kyodo) -- Survivors and families of victims of a 2005 West Japan Railway Co. train derailment offered prayers at an event marking the accident's anniversary on Friday, with some pledging to pass on lessons learned from the tragedy which killed 107 people.
At a memorial ceremony at the site of the accident in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, JR West executives and other attendees paused for a moment of silence at 9:18 a.m., when the rush-hour commuter train crashed into a building 20 years ago and left 562 people injured.
JR West President Kazuaki Hasegawa vowed at the ceremony, hosted by the company, not to let memories of the accident fade as more than 70 percent of its roughly 25,000 current employees joined the company after the derailment.
"Had we not caused the accident that day, (victims) would have lived lives full of dreams and hopes," Hasegawa said before a cenotaph at the site. "I can only offer my sincere apologies for the frustration of having had lives suddenly taken away."
Kentaro Kosugi, a Tokyo resident, who lost both his parents in the accident, said he wished they would have lived to meet his two children.
"I think there are 107 different ways of (feeling) sadness among the bereaved families," the 41-year-old said, referring to the number of fatalities.
JR West is building a facility in neighboring Osaka Prefecture to preserve train cars involved in the accident and the belongings of those who died, with its completion expected sometime in December.
The facility will be closed to the public in consideration of bereaved family members opposed to the display. It is planned to be open to families of victims, officials of transportation operators in charge of safety and those who were involved in rescue efforts.
The accident occurred when the seven-car train on the JR Fukuchiyama Line derailed as it entered a curve on the track and crashed into a nearby condominium building.
The train was traveling at around 116 kilometers per hour, far exceeding the 70 kph speed limit.
All four former JR West presidents indicted on charges of professional negligence were acquitted.
The Penal Code has no mechanism for punishing organizations for such accidents, and the bereaved families have been calling for the enactment of a special law to penalize both corporations and individuals.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Times
14-05-2025
- Japan Times
34-year memorial held for victims of Shiga train collision
A 34-year memorial ceremony for a train collision killing 42 people in Shiga Prefecture was held near the site of the accident in the city of Koka on Wednesday. In front of a monument near the site, 21 participants, including bereaved family members and the heads of Shigaraki Kohgen Railway (SKR) and West Japan Railway, or JR West, observed a moment of silence and laid flowers. "We will do our best to advance our work to achieve train safety," SKR President Seijiro Masaki said in a memorial address. "We will engrave the tragedy of the accident and the preciousness of life in our hearts and continue to pass on the facts, remorse and lessons of the accident to future generations," JR West President Kazuaki Hasegawa pledged. "I would like to keep demanding that the nation and railroad operators take further safety measures," said Seiji Shimomura, 66, who co-headed a now-disbanded group for train safety set up mainly by bereaved family members in the 1991 accident. Shimomura lost his 2-year-old son in a July 2001 crowd crush on a pedestrian overpass in Akashi, Hyogo Prefecture. On May 14, 1991, an SKR train and a JR West train collided head-on in Shigaraki, now Koka, killing 42 people and injuring more than 600.
The Mainichi
27-04-2025
- The Mainichi
7 major Japan train operators do not discipline driver error, some adopt self-reporting
TOKYO -- Seven major railway operators in Japan do not impose disciplinary action for driver error under their internal systems, a survey by the Mainichi Shimbun has revealed as the country marks two decades since a derailment that killed over 100 people. Following the deadly crash of a JR Fukuchiyama Line train 20 years ago, West Japan Railway Co. (JR West)'s punitive guidance of crew members who made mistakes was viewed as a problem Some operators who say they do not have a no-punishment policy are also taking a flexible approach, meaning that railway companies are focusing on providing an environment where mistakes can be shared internally to enhance safety measures. The survey, conducted from March to April, targeted 31 major railway companies operating in urban areas, focusing on how they handle accidents, operational mishaps and other issues caused by human error. Out of the 29 companies that responded, seven reported having systems in place that do not treat such errors as grounds for disciplinary action. Tokyo-based Tokyu Railways stated, "We do not hold individuals accountable for human errors that are reported swiftly and accurately." Fukuoka City Transportation Bureau commented, "By creating an environment that facilitates voluntary reporting, safety guidance and education will be more effective, helping prevent recurrences." Conversely, among companies that do not have such systems, Tokyo-based Seibu Railway Co. assesses disciplinary actions on a case-by-case basis, depending on the nature and circumstances of the human error. Osaka-based Hanshin Electric Railway Co. stated they "collect small pieces of information daily to eliminate potential accidents," highlighting their commitment to risk management. Prior to the derailment accident, JR West conducted a "day shift training program" for crew members who made errors such as overrunning the train. It is said that the program was meant to "make an example" of the crew members by forcing them to write letters of remorse, among other such actions. The now-defunct Aircraft and Railway Accidents Investigation Commission under the transport ministry identified excessive speed by the driver as a cause of the 2005 accident, and noted that "strict management of drivers may have been a contributing factor." Post-accident, JR West removed minor errors from disciplinary measures, and in 2016 introduced a system that excludes punishment even in the event of an accident. However, even among companies that do not impose disciplinary measures, exceptions are made for cases involving malice or intentional misconduct.
The Mainichi
25-04-2025
- The Mainichi
Editorial: 20 yrs after west Japan derailment disaster, safety efforts remain paramount
April 25 marks 20 years since a morning rush hour train derailed on the JR Fukuchiyama Line in western Japan, killing 106 passengers and the driver and injuring 562 others. The accident was attributed to the driver's delay in applying the brakes, causing the train to hurtle around a steep curve far over the speed limit. Forming the backdrop to the deadly derailment was a reeducation program punishing train crew who made errors on duty. Dubbed "day-shift education," employees subject to the program were tasked with writing letters of remorse and continuing other work while being rebuked by superiors. The driver of the derailed train had been through this program three times in the past. As his train had overrun a station shortly before the derailment in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, it is likely he was worried about facing the program again and lacked concentration. In the wake of the disaster, West Japan Railway Co. (JR West) scrapped the controversial program. The railway operator also stopped imposing disciplinary measures on crew members for their errors, including when those errors led to accidents. We urge the railway company to revisit the lessons learned from the 2005 accident while striving to keep the memory of the disaster alive. To prevent serious accidents, it is essential to maintain an environment where mistakes are not covered up. Sharing and analyzing on-site information will help reduce risks. As a result of prioritizing greater speed, investment in safety had been delayed and there was no automatic train stop system (ATS) at the derailment site. Measures need to be adopted on the assumption that anyone can make mistakes. The bereaved families of the victims of the derailment played a significant role in propelling JR West's endeavors to prevent a recurrence. They took part in the review of the accident and were given an opportunity to discuss countermeasures. These unprecedented attempts became a driving force helping officials to dig deep into the railway operator's organizational problems. Efforts to pass down the memory of the disaster are also important. More than 70% of JR West members employed today joined the firm after the accident. The company plans to establish a facility to preserve the derailed train at the end of the year. It is hoped that the facility will be utilized to raise safety awareness among employees. However, other trouble that could have led to major accidents has occurred in recent years. In 2017, a crack emerged in the undercarriage of a Nozomi superexpress bullet train on the Tokaido-Sanyo Shinkansen line, but despite the crew having noticed abnormalities, the train continued to operate. In East Japan Railway Co. (JR East)'s service area, meanwhile, two cars of the Hayabusa-Komachi superexpress decoupled in 2024 and then again in 2025 while running on the Tohoku Shinkansen line. For public transport operators that are responsible for passengers' lives, ensuring safety is paramount. They should constantly inspect the status of their operations and promote both physical and procedural countermeasures. Such efforts have no end point.
