Friend or Food: Why Are Iceland's Orcas Taking in Pilot Whales?
Scientists noticed orcas interacting with baby pilot whales off Iceland every year from 2021 to 2023. Each instance was short-lived and featured different individual pilot whales (dark-gray members of the dolphin family with a bulbous forehead) and different pods of orcas. Now, in a new study in Ecology and Evolution, Baumgartner and her colleagues describe the 2022 and 2023 incidents and posit three potential explanations: predation, play or parenting.
On supporting science journalism
If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.
In all the sightings, a weeks-old pilot whale swam by a female killer whale in what scientists call an echelon position, with the young whale located beside and slightly behind the adult orca. In the 2022 and 2023 instances, the killer whales occasionally nudged the calf along. In 2023 a calf was seen swimming ahead of the group, possibly as if to run away—and at one point it was lifted, belly-up, out of the water on the back of an orca.
With the first possible explanation, the killer whales could have been keeping the young pilot whales around like a living lunch box; some orcas in Iceland are known to eat harbor seals and porpoises. But Baumgartner notes that these Icelandic killer whales are predominantly fish eaters and that they didn't display overtly aggressive behavior toward the pilot whale calves. So predation is less likely, though not impossible, she and her colleagues say.
Alternatively, the killer whales could have been playing with the young whales or using them to practice hunting. Iceland's orcas often herd herring, and they could have been incorporating the pilot whale calves in their hunting games.
Finally, the killer whales could have been extending their parental instincts to the young calves. Whales and dolphins in the wild often care for the young of other members of their pod, and although it's rare, dolphins have adopted calves from different species. In the pilot whales' case, Baumgartner says, she wouldn't categorize the relationship as adoption because the interactions seemed to be short-lived. The young pilot whales would likely have died without milk, and none of the female orcas were lactating at the time.
These three possibilities also aren't mutually exclusive, she says. 'It could be [that the orcas] encountered the pilot whale opportunistically, and some individuals played with the whale, and others tried to nurture it,' Baumgartner adds.
The other conspicuously missing pieces of the puzzle are how, in each instance, the orcas came across a pilot whale calf in the first place and what happened to that calf afterward. 'Was it lost or abandoned?' asks study co-author Filipa Samarra, principal investigator at the Icelandic Orca Project and director of the University of Iceland's research center on the Westman Islands. 'Or did the killer whales actively approach to take the calf away?' The researchers also wonder if the calves escaped or died or were killed or eaten by the orcas.
Sarah Teman, a graduate student in ecology at the University of Washington, who was not involved with the new study, says her jaw dropped when she saw pictures of the pilot whales with the orca pods. Teman previously studied southern resident killer whales interacting with porpoises in the Salish Sea off British Columbia and Washington State. In that research, she observed interactions that may have been motivated by nurturing, hunting practice or 'play'—and often ended up killing the porpoises. 'It was fascinating to see such similar behaviors' in the Icelandic orcas, she says, adding that the animals' interactions with the pilot whales seemed to be largely driven by nurturing or play behavior, just as had been seen in the southern resident killer whales' interactions with porpoises.
Samarra also speculates that the unusual interactions off Iceland could be a result of climate change because pilot whales increasingly follow schools of mackerel moving into warmer waters that overlap with the killer whales' range. She hopes that, next summer, her group will finally observe how the young pilot whales get entangled with the orcas and what happens to them next.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Gizmodo
17 hours ago
- Gizmodo
Here Are the Winners of the 2025 Wildlife Photos of the Year Contest
Nature can be equal parts majestic, heartwarming, and terrifying. The winning entries of the 2025 BMC Ecology and Evolution and BMC Zoology image competition illustrate that complexity in spades. Biologists, zoologists, and paleontologists from across the world sent in submissions to this year's contest. The photos were sorted into four categories: 'Collective Social Behavior,' 'Life in Motion,' 'Colorful Strategies,' and 'Research in Action.' But the overall winner (seen in the headline image above) was a snapshot taken by Andrey Giljov, showing two male saiga antelopes in a sparring match as part of their preparation for the mating season; this naturally involves butting heads with potential rivals. 'Saiga fights in spring, outside of the tournament season, are quieter and more about training than determining status. However, the males take every opportunity to practice,' said Giljov, a vertebrate zoologist and senior lecturer at Saint Petersburg State University in Russia, in an editorial detailing the contest winners. The annual photo competition, now in its second year, is a joint venture from the journals BMC Ecology and Evolution and BMC Zoology; it's the successor to contests that were separately run by the two journals. The photos are judged by the journals' editors and senior members of the editorial board. This year's winning entries and close seconds featured some of the biggest creatures on Earth as well as its smallest. Case in point, Alwin Hardenbol's incredible photo of a breaching humpback whale that he captured from a rigid inflatable boat in Varanger, Norway. 'Breaching is a fascinating behavior from a scientific perspective, as it is still inconclusive what purpose it serves,' said Hardenbol, a researcher at the Natural Resources Institute Finland whose photo was a runner-up in the Life in Motion category. 'It's unbelievable to imagine how such an animal can even jump out of the water like that.' Sritam Kumar Sethy, a student at Berhampur University in India, won the Collective Social Behavior category for his photograph of newly hatched Acanthocoris scaber (a species of leaf-footed bug) nymphs gathering together on the underside of a leaf—a survival strategy of having strength in numbers. 'By coming together, they enhance their protection against predators, reducing the chances of any individual becoming prey,' said Sethy. The entries also captured the never-ending struggle for resources between animals, such as Delip K. Das's photo of a Haliastur indus (a medium-sized bird of prey also called a Brahminy Kite) having to go the extra mile for its dinner. 'A Brahminy Kite had just caught an eel—a large and still-struggling fish. As the Kite wrestled to secure its catch in flight, another challenger appeared, attempting to hijack the meal,' said Das, whose entry didn't win but was singled out as highly commended. 'The dramatic moment unfolded above the mangrove-fringed waters, reflecting the intensity and agility of raptors in the wild.' Some images didn't highlight the present state of the natural world but its distant past. Digital artist Natalia Jagielsk won the Life in Motion category for her illustration of pterosaurs flying over the Jurassic Hebridean Basin, covering what's now called Scotland. Jagielsk, a postdoctoral fellow at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, based her work on the recent discovery of two pterosaur skeletons belonging to different species in the region. 'Despite their differing cranial anatomies, teeth morphology, and wing shapes, these pterosaurs could interact and compete for food during periods of environmental stress,' said Jagielsk, who was part of a team that described one of these species, Dearc sgiathanach. 'Set 170 million years ago in the Middle Jurassic, this image portrays these flying reptiles as they hunt along the shoreline.' My personal favorite selection is either endearing, gross, or both, depending on your tolerance for bugs and regurgitating. Nick Royle, a runner-up in the Collective and Social Behavior category, took a photo of a mother Nicrophorus vespilloides (a species of burying beetle) feeding her young—by which I mean, spitting back up the remnants of a buried mouse carcass. In addition to this unique feeding strategy, burying beetles are also one of the few insects that often share custody of their offspring, with both parents helping out with the rearing. 'This behavior normally occurs underground, so is not usually visible to us, but is here pictured in the lab, where these burying beetles are used as a model to understand the evolution of social behaviors such as parental care,' said Royle, a behavioral ecologist and conservation biologist at the University of Exeter in the UK. 'These beetles work together to bury carcasses to avoid competition from other users of carrion and, once safely underground, process the carcass, removing the fur, rolling it into a ball, and smearing it with antimicrobial secretions to combat the bacteria and fungi that would otherwise consume this precious resource.' Well, I'm certainly going to appreciate my parents' home-cooked meals more from now on. There are plenty more breathtaking images from this year's contest that can be seen here.
Gizmodo
2 days ago
- Gizmodo
‘Weird Looking' Otter Poo Reveals an Unexpected Role in Parasite Control
Receiving an unsolicited photo of worm-infested animal poop would make anyone cringe, unless you're a parasite expert like Katrina Lohan. When a colleague sent her a snapshot of a watery pile of feces with a fire-engine red worm inside, she was instantly intrigued. 'She sent this to me and was like, 'I think this is a parasite, are you interested in studying river otters?' And I was like, 'Ooh, I think that's a parasite too. And yes, I am,'' Lohan, a parasite ecologist who leads the Coastal Disease Ecology Laboratory at the Smithsonian Environmental Research Center (SERC), told Gizmodo. Her colleague discovered the otter scat on a dock at the SERC campus on the Chesapeake Bay. Scientists know surprisingly little about river otters that live in tidally influenced coastal areas, but these predators play a vital role in ecosystems. Studying the parasites in their poop would offer valuable insight into their dietary habits and the health of their habitat. So, Lohan teamed up with Calli Wise, a biological research technician at SERC and first author of the new study published in the journal Frontiers in Mammal Science on Thursday, August 14. Wise was particularly well-suited for this study, as she'd already conducted research on river otter latrines. Yes, you read that right, but wipe that image of a tiny, adorable outhouse from your mind. Otter latrines are essentially on-land congregation areas, Wise told Gizmodo. River otters don't just relieve themselves at these hubs but also eat, play, and lounge there. These animals are nocturnal and semi-aquatic, which makes it difficult to observe them in their natural habitat, but researchers can learn a lot from the stuff they leave behind at latrines. Wise and her colleagues hunted for latrines along roughly 7.5 miles (12 kilometers) of the shoreline of the Rhode River, a tidally influenced subestuary of the Chesapeake Bay. 'You're looking for areas of disturbance where it looks like an animal could have gone from the water to land,' Wise explained. 'Actually, beyond just looking, my best sense was my nose. You can kind of smell out a latrine,' she said. Go figure. The researchers collected scat from 18 active latrines and brought it back to the lab. In addition to observing samples under the microscope, they performed DNA analysis using metabarcoding. This DNA sequencing technique involves extracting small snippets of DNA, amplifying them, then comparing them to a database of snippets from known species. This allows researchers to identify species present in complex biological samples. 'This method has never been used on scat left at latrines in general, for diet or parasites,' Wise said. She and her colleagues found DNA from a wide variety of parasites spanning six taxonomic classes in the scat samples. Most of the species they identified infect river otters' prey, but there were also some that infect otters themselves. 'The fact that this method provided such a level of resolution that we could not only figure out what it was they were eating, but also see the parasites in their prey, was really cool,' Lohan said. What's more, the findings suggest that parasites play a key role in river otters' diets. When they infect prey species, their negative impact on the host's health may make it easier for river otters to hunt them, Lohan explained. Thus, these predators may be culling infected individuals from populations of their prey, but confirming this will require further research, she said.
Scientific American
2 days ago
- Scientific American
Why Glacial Lake Outbursts Like the One in Alaska May Happen More Often
Meltwater from a glacier outburst near Juneau, Alaska, is flooding nearby neighborhoods, with officials urging some residents of the city of 30,000 to evacuate. The meltwater is rushing downstream from Suicide Basin, a basin of water dammed in by the Mendenhall Glacier. As of 6:00 A.M. local time on Wednesday morning, the Mendenhall River was in a major flood stage. At 16.17 feet (4.93 meters) and rising, the water level had passed the record flood stage of 15.99 feet (4.87 m) that hit during a 2024 glacial outburst flood, according to the National Weather Service. Mendenhall Lake and River, both downstream from the glacier's tongue, are under a flood warning. The NWS predicts the river will crest at up to 16.75 feet (5.1 m) Wednesday around 8 A.M. local time. On supporting science journalism If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today. Glacial outburst floods happen when the ice dams holding back glacial lakes fail, allowing a sudden release of water. They're unpredictable and happen without warning. A 2023 study found that globally, 15 million people live in areas that could flood. More than half of people in at-risk areas are in India, Pakistan, China, and Peru. And with a warming climate, ice is becoming more unstable and glacial lakes are growing—a 2020 study based on satellite imagery found that between 1990 and 2018, the volume of water dammed in glacial lakes had grown 48 percent. Suicide Basin has flooded before. In fact, according to the NWS, the basin has released an outburst flood at least once a year since 2011. These floods have now set a record three years in a row: In 2023, the river crested at 14.97 feet (4.56 m) after an outburst, a record exceeded just a year later in the August 2024 flood. Residents had to evacuate by inflatable boat in the middle of the night during the 2024 outburst, according to the Red Cross. Now, only a year after that disaster, the river is setting a new record. It's a threat glaciologists in mountainous areas around the world are trying to better understand, Fabian Walter, a senior scientist at the Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research WSL told Scientific American in 2020. "These glaciated mountain faces were more or less stable,' Walter said. 'And now, with climate change, the whole stability is changing."
