Canadian shipyard slams B.C. Ferries' contract with Chinese shipbuilder
It's the latest criticism levelled at the ferry operator following its decision to purchase the vessels from Chinese-state owned CMI Weihai Shipyards. That criticism and China's punishing new tariffs on Canadian agriculture products have renewed calls for the contract to be cancelled.
"Unfortunately, the procurement criteria were heavily weighted toward the lowest price, effectively favouring Chinese shipyards," James Davies, CEO of Davie shipyard, wrote in a letter this month.
The letter was sent to Bloc Québécois MP Xavier Barsalou-Duval, the vice-chair of the House of Commons transport committee, which is scrutinizing the $1-billion loan B.C. Ferries received from the Canada Infrastructure Bank to finance the purchase of the new electric-diesel ships.
Davies said the company asked B.C. Ferries to "balance the procurement criteria by requesting recognition of Canadian content and innovation," a request that was rejected.
"Due to inherent price disadvantage caused by massive state subsidies for Chinese shipyards, coupled with low wages, weak environmental standards, and minimal labour protections, no Canadian or Western shipyard could reasonably compete, leaving us with no choice but to withdraw."
Transportation minister concerned over B.C. Ferries' construction deal with Chinese shipyard
2 months ago
Neither Davie nor any other Canadian company bid on the contract. B.C. Ferries says it would have cost $1.2 billion more to go with a European shipbuilder.
B.C. Ferries CEO Nicolas Jimenez was not available for an interview.
In a statement, Jeff Groot, B.C. Ferries' executive director of communications, disputes Davie shipyard's characterization of the bidding process.
"Contrary to Davie's claims that we 'summarily rejected' their proposals, we are not aware of any concrete requests or suggestions from Davie to amend our procurement criteria," Groot says.
"Price was only a secondary factor, representing less than one-third of the score, with shipyard technical considerations making up more than half of the evaluation. The RFP also showed that Canadian content was a scored consideration and set high safety and environmental standards that every proponent had to meet, regardless of shipyard location or nationality."
Calls to cancel B.C. Ferries contract with China misguided, say some mayors
1 month ago
B.C. Ferries' decision to award the contract to the Chinese state-owned shipyard has received national attention. Federal Transport Minister Chrystia Freeland said she was dismayed by the decision, especially in the face of China's "unjustified tariffs" on Canadian goods, including canola products, seafood and pork.
Freeland also raised concerns about potential threats to security, including cybersecurity, with B.C. Transportation Minister Mike Farnworth.
China has now imposed a new 75 per cent tariff on Canadian canola seed, which has renewed calls to cancel the ferry contract entirely.
The federal Conservative Party and B.C. Conservatives have repeated calls for the federal or provincial government to step in and force B.C. Ferries to cancel the contract.
Federal transportation minister slams B.C. Ferries deal with Chinese company
2 months ago
"When we're in a situation where a jurisdiction like China is intentionally damaging our agriculture sector, our aquaculture sector with these new tariffs … all these things that are very damaging to us here in British Columbia and to Canada, you don't turn around and reward them with a contract for a billion dollars plus to build ferries," said B.C. Conservative Leader John Rustad.
Dan Albas, a Conservative MP for Okanagan Lake West-South Kelowna who sits on the transport committee, says Canadians have a right to be concerned about the contract, especially in the face of new tariffs from China.
He's calling for the $1 billion loan to B.C. Ferries from the Canada Infrastructure Bank to be rescinded.
"The People's Republic of China, they subsidize their steel, they subsidize their shipbuilding practices. And yet here we have the Canadian infrastructure bank is further subsidizing with a billion-dollar loan those industries," Albas told CBC News.
Eric McNeely, president of the B.C. Ferry and Marine Workers' Union, says he's not surprised by the issues raised in Davies' letter.
"I think it really highlights that domestic shipbuilding wasn't factored in as a priority and there was a preference for the lowest sticker price," he said. "I think it is a real problem that a billion dollars of federal infrastructure bank money is earmarked to go to a hostile trading partner."
Premier demands lower rates for B.C. after Ottawa cuts ferry fares in Eastern Canada
16 days ago
Premier David Eby is calling on Ottawa to increase the federal subsidy for ferry users in B.C. after Prime Minister Mark Carney followed through on an election promise to lower ferry fares in Eastern Canada. But as CBC's Katie DeRosa reports, David Eby says it's yet another example of B.C getting a raw deal from Ottawa.
The union launched a campaign called Build Them Here, which urges people to contact their MP and MLA to demand ferries be built in Canada. McNeely said at a time when Canada is fighting trade wars with the United States and China, it can't afford to send nearly $1 billion in public money overseas.
B.C. Ferries has given no indication it's going to reverse course.
"Nearly 80 per cent of our operating costs are funded directly by our customers, so every procurement decision must balance technical capability, quality, environmental standards, and cost to keep fares as affordable as possible," Groot said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
7 minutes ago
- CTV News
Voters head to the polls in Battle River—Crowfoot as Poilievre seeks return to House
A campaign sign for independent candidate Bonnie Critchley next to signs for Pierre Poilievre and Darcy Spady in the riding of Battle River-Crowfoot in Camrose, Alta., on Tuesday, July 22, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Amber Bracken CAMROSE — Voters head to the polls today in a rural Alberta byelection that's getting an unusual level of national attention. Battle River—Crowfoot was left vacant when Conservative Damien Kurek stepped down shortly after the spring election to make way for his party's leader, Pierre Poilievre, to run for a seat. Poilievre lost in the April election after being elected in the Ottawa-area riding of Carleton seven straight times. The byelection is in one of the safest Conservative seats in the country, and the Tory leader is widely expected to win by a large margin. More than 200 people are running against Poilievre, most of whom are part of a protest movement called the Longest Ballot Committee. As a result of the record number of people in the running, Elections Canada says voters will need to write in the name of their preferred candidate on a modified ballot. Polls will be open from 8:30 a.m. until 8:30 p.m. MT. Elections Canada says it expects the vote count will take longer than usual, given the unique blank ballot. More than 14,000 people already cast a vote in advance polls. There are more than 86,000 eligible voters in the riding. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 18, 2025. The Canadian Press
National Post
7 minutes ago
- National Post
Terry Newman: Keffiyeh-draped anti-Israel protesters target Jews at Saint John festival
Saint John's International Culturefest, according to the festival's website, is supposed to be 'a vibrant celebration of multiculturalism, community, and connection.' But it erupted into chaos on Aug. 2, when demonstrators gathered around an Israel booth, engaging in what some members of the Jewish community have described as threatening and intimidating behaviour culminating in an alleged assault and two arrests. No statement was made by the committee organizing the festival or the local police. The story was largely ignored by local media. Article content Article content According to an email forwarded to National Post, written by Lorie Cohen Hackett, president of the Saint John Jewish Historical Museum, a demonstration at the festival felt threatening to those volunteering at the Israel booth. Cohen tells members of the museum that both Shaarei Zedek synagogue and the museum 'hope for a peaceful and satisfactory resolution.' Article content Article content Below her message is one from Bruce Washburn, president of Shaarei Zedek synagogue, who describes to members of his congregation events leading up to an alleged altercation at the booth. According to Washburn, on Friday, Aug. 1, the evening before the International Culturefest, the Israeli flag at the event had been spray painted and had to be replaced with another from the synagogue on Saturday morning. Article content On Saturday Aug. 2, at the festival Washburn describes as 'an annual celebration of international cultures,' anti-Israel protesters with face coverings 'invaded the Israeli space and shot at those attending the booth with water guns filled with red water.' Article content Article content Washburn noted that when the volunteers 'attempted to protect their space, one was physically assaulted, breaking her glasses.' He told congregants, in his email, that the 'guarantees of security for the event from the Culturefest Committee were not fulfilled, and there was no apparent police presence at the time of the incident. The incident ended with the arrest of two of the protesters, based on the assault.' Article content Article content Washburn ended his email saying that the Board of the Congregation 'is actively seeking legal advice and remains committed to doing everything we can to restore safety and peace for the Jewish and Israeli community in Saint John and surrounding areas.' Article content According to Sgt. Shawna Fowler of the Saint John police department, at approximately 2:30 p.m. on the Saturday, police responded to a 'call about protesters making their way to the festival.' She pointed out that the caller described them as 'Palestinian demonstrators.' Fowler also said that 'calls were also received by attendees of the festival who described the protesters as wearing red bags over their heads, carrying signs, and one person was wearing a military uniform and carrying a gun later determined by police to be a water gun filled with red liquid. The protesters were at the Israel booth kneeling, chanting, and facing the crowd.'
CBC
8 minutes ago
- CBC
Cambridge mayor takes aim at councillor she says is spreading 'false information' over encampment motion
Cambridge Mayor Jan Liggett says any accusations she kept a notice of motion regarding the clearing of encampments off a recent city council agenda is "false" and a "misrepresentation of what happened." In a Facebook reel video posted last week to the page called Office of the Mayor — City of Cambridge, Liggett says she wanted to "correct the false information swirling around in social media as well as online and in print media." In the video, she also accused Coun. Scott Hamilton of making comments to the media that are "disingenuous at best, coming dangerously close to political opportunism." "We should always, in our roles as members of elected body, be striving to do what is best for the community, not about placating our echo chambers of supporters," Liggett said. The issue started on July 4, when federal housing advocate Marie-Josée Houle wrote a letter to council over concerns the city was allowing encampments of people experiencing homelessness to be cleared during the hottest days of the summer. This letter prompted Hamilton and Coun. Ross Earnshaw to put forward a motion to the city's clerk to ask the city to pause clearing encampments during heat events, and they asked for a notice of motion to be added to a city council meeting agenda on July 22. Initially, Hamilton says he and Earnshaw, who was going to second the motion, wanted a full pause on forced removals during extreme weather. They changed the motion after advice from staff and the amended motion asked for a staff report instead looking into the matter. The motion would have asked staff "to report back on prevention of forced removals of unhoused persons during extreme weather events upon the issuance of a warning, an alert, or during the occurrence of, an extreme weather event as determined by Environment and Climate Change Canada." Hamilton told CBC News he wanted to see the report from staff come back later this year. But Hamilton says the notice of motion never made it onto the July 22 city council meeting's agenda. Hamilton says he was told by city staff that the notice of motion was "delayed" from being put on a council agenda at the mayor's request so that staff could provide more information to councillors. Hamilton has told other media that is what happened, but Liggett charged in her video that his comments were "a total misrepresentation of what happened." Concerns about 'compromised legal position': Mayor A notice of motion usually means that a councillor wants to let other members of council know they want to discuss and vote on a certain issue at a later date. In some cases, councillors can vote to discuss the issue right away. "When I was informed of the potential, and I repeat the potential of a notice of motion, I directed our legal and clerks departments to provide information and advice to all council prior to the notice being placed on the floor," Liggett said. "It is not enough for councillors Hamilton and Earnshaw to have the advantage and the privilege of information or staff advice and not all of the rest of council. This would or could have put council in a compromised legal position." In her video, Liggett says if council had voted to discuss the issue right away, some members of council would have been at a disadvantage because they wouldn't be privy to the staff and legal advice Hamilton and Earnshaw had already sought out. Hamilton said he had already told the city clerk that he had no intention of going beyond providing a notice of motion at that meeting, knowing council was about to go on a summer break. He said it was his expectation that the motion would be on the Sept. 2 council agenda, more than 40 days later and with plenty of time for councillors and the public to learn about it and be able to attend the meeting if they wanted to speak to it. 'All I have said was what happened' Hamilton, who is on vacation and who said Friday evening he has watched the video once, rejects the mayor's comments that he's said anything inappropriate to media. "I have never thrown any shade or made any accusations," he said. He said he only spoke to the media when they contacted him. "I never tried to say anything that was accusatory or untrue. I told the truth and I stated what happened and I stated the order in which those events happened and what staff had said to me in emails about why the motion didn't come forward on [July] 22," he said. "It's my responsibility, I think, as a councillor to just be cool-headed and think critically about complex issues to move the city forward." Return to issue of encampments: Coun. Earnshaw Earnshaw, who is in Ottawa for the annual Association of Municipalities of Ontario conference, said in an email to CBC News that the debate over what happened to the motion is overshadowing the real issue he'd like to see addressed. "The controversy regarding procedural issues and the extent of authority of the mayor have distracted from the underlying concern about humane treatment of unhoused individuals during extreme weather events," he wrote. "I'd like to see the focus return to the issues that originally prompted Coun. Hamilton to put forward his motion and for me to propose to second it." In an interview Friday, Hamilton told CBC News he, too, just wants to get back to talking about how to best help people in encampments. "I think we have to remember the motion is just calling for a report on how we can help the city and how we can help some of our most vulnerable residents and we need to return to the issue," he said. Currently, Hamilton says there is still no specific date for his notice of motion to go before council. "I think it's an opportunity for Cambridge to become a real leader in this because it's my understanding that many municipalities don't actually have a lot of these bylaws in place because encampments are new, on the one hand, as is increased incidences of extreme weather. And right now, they're intersecting in this extremely challenging, complex situation," he said. "As the housing crisis increases and exacerbates, as we're seeing more extreme heat days, I think we're going to be seeing these issues more and more. So now I think it's time we have to come together as a council and as a city to learn more and to address it. Because the crisis isn't going away. We're going have to start tackling it bit by bit and the intention of this motion was just to have a start."
