Unfinished business: Uncovering the buried crimes of apartheid regime
Lukhanyo Calata never had the chance to know his father. In 1985, when he was just three years old, his father, Fort Calata, was brutally murdered alongside Matthew Goniwe, Sparrow Mkonto, and Sicelo Mhlauli. Collectively, they became known as the Cradock Four.
Despite two inquests into their deaths, no one has ever been held accountable for their kidnapping, assault, or the gruesome act of setting their bodies alight following their arrest at a roadblock set up by the Security Branch near Port Elizabeth (now Gqeberha).
In 1999, six former police officers connected to the Cradock Four's arrests and murders appeared before the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), seeking amnesty. Their application was denied. Yet, even after this, no prosecutions followed.
For decades, Calata has sought answers, questioning why - more than 30 years after the democratic election of the ANC - justice remains elusive for the Cradock Four. This week, a third inquest got under way, seeking to uncover who was truly responsible for the death of the anti-apartheid activists.
This inquest comes shortly after the announcement that retired Constitutional Court justice Sisi Khampepe will lead a judicial inquiry into whether there were deliberate attempts to block the investigation and prosecution of apartheid-era crimes. Beyond the Cradock Four, there are an estimated 400 unsolved cases from South Africa's apartheid era.
In this week's Friday Briefing, News24's legal journalist, Karyn Maughan, delves into the law enforcement paralysis that followed the TRC and its devastating impact on the families of victims.
Lukhanyo Calata, in his contribution, writes poignantly about his family's anguish and the pain of asking questions when no one remains alive to provide answers.
Additionally, in this week's edition, in-depth writer Muhammad Hussain interviews ActionSA parliamentary leader Athol Trollip regarding the party's proposal to amend the Constitution.
Explore these insightful contributions below.
The apartheid government got away with murder... and SA needs to know why
There is compelling evidence that apartheid-era atrocity cases were not prosecuted because of alleged political interference from the ANC government. And, Karyn Maughan writes, it's crucial this toxic subversion of accountability is finally explained – and confronted.
Read the rest of the submission here.
An ANC failure: The long journey for justice for the Cradock Four
Lukhanyo Calata, son of Fort Calata - one of the Cradock Four who were brutally murdered - shares his reflections on a renewed inquest into apartheid-era atrocities. He argues that these proceedings, including an inquest into the Cradock Four's deaths, will expose the harm inflicted by the ANC and unravel the reasons behind the historical obfuscation.
Read the rest of the submission here.
Q&A with Athol Trollip | ActionSA constitutional change: 'If people want to call it xenophobic, so be it'
ActionSA parliamentary leader Athol Trollip speaks to in-depth writer Muhammad Hussain and defends his party's submission to modify the Constitution's 'South Africa belongs to all who live in it' principle.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Man sentenced after 'reprehensible' serious sexual assault of woman
A man who carried out a 'reprehensible' serious sexual assault of a woman in Greenock has been sentenced. Robert McGregor was jailed for seven years at the High Court in Edinburgh on Tuesday, August 5, 2025. The 44-year-old was also placed on the Sex Offenders Register and made subject to a non-harassment order in respect of his victim. McGregor was previously found guilty of the attack, which took place in August 2020 the High Court in Glasgow on Tuesday, July 8, 2025. READ NEXT: Detective Inspector David Tomlinson said: 'McGregor's reprehensible actions have caused lasting harm, and he will now face the consequences. 'We encourage anyone who has experienced any form of sexual or violent offence, regardless of when it happened, to report it. 'We will investigate all reports thoroughly and have specially trained officers and partner agencies who will support you throughout.'
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Self-confessed murderer jailed for 18 years for killing ‘truly loved' man in town
A self-confessed murderer has been jailed for 18 years for killing a 'truly loved' man in an East Yorkshire town's marketplace. Timothy Tinson admitted murdering Matthew Phillips, 44, in Beverley after changing his plea on Monday (August 3). The 43-year-old, of Lairgate in Beverley, was today (Tuesday, August 5) sentenced to life in prison with a minimum term of 18 years for the murder in Saturday Market earlier this year. Mr Phillips' sister said he was 'truly loved' and 'meant everything to us'. She said the family's 'world has fallen apart' after Mr Phillips died in a 'violet and cruel' way which was 'impossible to make sense of'. Humberside Police said officers were called to Saturday Market at around 1am on Saturday, January 4, and found a man with a 'serious head injury lying unconscious in the road'. Tinson was subsequently arrested at the scene on suspicion of attempted murder. A police spokesperson said Tinson and Mr Phillips knew each other through a mutual acquaintance. They said Humberside Police has made a 'mandatory referral' to the police watchdog, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), due to prior police contact with Tinson and Mr Phillips. The IOPC's investigation 'remains active but paused pending the conclusion of the judicial process', the Humberside Police spokesperson said. On Friday, January 3, they said Tinson and Mr Phillips had been at a property in Lairgate when a 'verbal disagreement occurred and Tinson was asked to leave'. A final encounter happened between the pair later that night which involved a verbal exchange leading to a physical confrontation, which resulted in Mr Phillips falling into the road. The police spokesperson said Tinson 'continued his violent encounter, in which he repeatedly applied force' to Mr Phillips' head, 'leaving him unconscious with life-threatening injuries'. Mr Phillips was taken to hospital but died from his injuries shortly afterwards. Speaking after Tinson was jailed, Detective Chief Inspector Leanne Murphy, from Humberside Police, said: 'By receiving his sentence today, he is being held accountable for the devastation he caused, sparing Matthew's family the further anguish of a prolonged trial. 'I hope today's outcome provides his loved ones with a measure of comfort in knowing the person responsible is now facing the consequences of his actions.' 'His memory will always be with us,' says victim's family Mr Phillips' sister, in a tribute released by Humberside Police, said: 'We're shattered. We're hurting deeply and still trying to understand how this could have happened. 'What Tinson did didn't just take Matthew's life – it took away all his hopes, dreams, and the future we thought we'd have with him. That future is now gone. 'So many lives have been affected. And the pain will never go away. 'We miss Matthew every single day. But his memory will always be with us, in our hearts, and in everything we do.'
News24
2 hours ago
- News24
NCOP steps in as KZN police battle staff shortages and poor infrastructure amid rising crime levels
SAPS NCOP delegation meets with KwaZulu-Natal police amid allegations of infiltration by criminal syndicates. Only 23 000 officers serve a population of 12 million, raising alarm over SA Police Service capacity to fight crime. Umlazi Police Station still crippled after 2021 unrest, while rural communities remain underserved. KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi held a closed-door meeting this week with a delegation from the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) as Parliament intensifies efforts to strengthen its relationship with the SA Police Service (SAPS) across the country. The engagement, which formed part of NCOP's constituency work in the province, focused on the challenges facing law enforcement, including chronic under-resourcing, infrastructure shortages and rising crime levels. This comes after Mkhwanazi's explosive allegations last month. He claimed that criminal syndicates had infiltrated the highest levels of government and accused Police Minister Senzo Mchunu of interfering with police investigations. Mchunu has since been placed on special leave by President Cyril Ramaphosa, with Firoz Cachalia stepping in as interim minister. However, the NCOP delegation emphasised that these allegations were not on the agenda during their meeting with Mkhwanazi. DA provincial whip Mzamo Billy, who led the delegation, said that the oversight visit was part of their broader mandate to understand and address the challenges faced by the SAPS in the province. The engagement was purely about crime in the province and the operational challenges the SAPS is facing. We aim to help raise these issues in the national Parliament. Mzamo Billy According to Billy, during the meeting, the provincial police leadership painted a bleak picture of the reality on the ground. With a population of about 12 million, only 23 000 police officers service KwaZulu-Natal, a ratio that Billy described as 'shocking' and inadequate to meet the demands of communities. 'This tells you we are unable to deal with crime the way that we should or respond in time,' he added. Infrastructure concerns were also raised. The current SAPS provincial headquarters has been in rented premises for years and lacks basic amenities such as parking. Police here don't even have a proper headquarters. That's unacceptable. Mzamo Billy One of the pressing concerns was the state of the police stations, particularly those affected during the July 2021 unrest. The Umlazi Police Station, which was looted during the violence, is still not fully operational. Firearms were allegedly stolen and were now allegedly being used in crimes in the area. Billy said the oversight visit revealed deeper systemic issues, including an insufficient number of police stations, especially in the rural and poor communities. People in some areas still have to travel long distances to get to a police station. There are also mobile police stations in some areas that don't operate 24 hours, which is a serious concern for communities. Mzamo Billy Staff shortages also dominated the challenges. There are numerous vacancies within the SAPS, including in Crime Intelligence units, which further hamper the province's ability to effectively tackle crime. 'Even with committed officers, the police are severely under-capacitated,' Billy stressed. As part of the oversight week, the NCOP delegation was scheduled to meet with Premier Thami Ntuli and members of the provincial cabinet. These meetings are aimed at escalating the issues identified during engagements with the SAPS and exploring ways to address them through legislation or collaboration with other government departments. Billy said the delegation had agreed with the provincial police management to isolate specific challenges that require intervention at different levels, including those needing a legislative approach and others requiring engagement with departments such as public works. 'The matter of the police buildings, for example, falls under the public works department. It's our job to help facilitate that process so our officers can work in a safe and proper environment,' he said. He added that the MPs across the country should be doing similar oversight visits during the constituency weeks. 'It's what they get paid to do,' he said.
