logo
Bra saleswoman wins €15,800 for constructive dismissal

Bra saleswoman wins €15,800 for constructive dismissal

RTÉ News​4 days ago
A lingerie saleswoman who said she was forced to quit her job of nearly 20 years over the health impact of workplace stress due to a "toxic" work environment at a Dublin department store has won €15,800 for constructive dismissal.
Karrin Breslin was awarded the sum on foot of a complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 against Chantelle Lingerie Ltd, the operator of a concession in the lingerie department of the unidentified store.
The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) awarded Ms Breslin her full losses after ruling that the international lingerie brand repudiated her contract of employment by failing to address grievances about under-staffing and rostering while her health deteriorated over the course of two years.
It was submitted on behalf of Ms Breslin – an employee of the brand since 2004 – that when the department store reopened in May 2021 following the Covid-19 lockdown, her section was down to 12 staff with just two full-time, compared with 10 full-timers out of 17 pre-pandemic.
The tribunal heard Ms Breslin had moved from north Co Dublin to Co Wexford during the pandemic closure. She asked at that stage to be given a set working day of 9am to 5.30pm, she said. Her employer's response was that "this was not a request that could be granted given the opening hours of the shop and the need for a fair departmental roster", the tribunal was told.
The tribunal was told that the department store, rather than the lingerie brand, was responsible for setting the roster governing Ms Breslin's working hours.
"I feel my mental and physical health has deteriorated… I don't have a good work/life balance and it's going to get worse due to the late closing times coming back again," she wrote.
Ms Breslin's case was that her job was made "overwhelming and physically hard" because of these issues and that she began to experience anxiety, low mood, high blood pressure and gastrointestinal problems "as a result of work-related stress".
Following a medical absence in June 2022, Ms Breslin again wrote to her employer and set out that because the department was so "understaffed" that sales were being lost because customers were walking out without being served.
Her employer's position was this was "a commercial point and not a personal grievance".
Ms Breslin had seven periods of certified medical leave between January 2022 and the summer of 2023, the tribunal heard.
In an exchange of emails with her employer during her fifth period of medical leave in June 2023, Ms Breslin said she believed her illness was "work-related".
"There are major obstacles stopping me from doing a good job and this has been going on for years.It's gotten far worse in the last 4 months and definitely having a negative impact on my working life due to a stressful and sometimes toxic work environment," she wrote.
In responding correspondence, she was told: "I am hoping you can get to the bottom of your sickness so you feel better," the WRC heard.
The tribunal heard that Ms Breslin worked her last shift on 25 June 2023 and ultimately did not return to work before she tendered her resignation on 31 October that year.
Chantelle's managing director, who gave evidence, said she had assumed Ms Breslin would return to her job when she got better and that her resignation "was pleasant and made no mention of issues or other employees' behaviour".
When it was put to her in cross-examination that Ms Breslin had told her she was "burned out", the managing director said she "understood there was an issue" of work-related stress but that she "did not relate this" to Ms Breslin's resignation.
Asked what she had done to respond to the staffing issues raised by Ms Breslin, the managing director said these were "a matter for the shop".
In her decision, adjudicator Patricia Owens wrote Ms Breslin had been raising "serious concerns for her physical and mental health" starting in October 2021.
While the managing director made efforts to resolve "minor issues" for Ms Breslin around medical certs and annual leave, "more complex matters" around roster problems and staff shortages "were never addressed", Ms Owens wrote.
"I consider that the respondent failed in its duty of care to the complainant to protect her health, safety and wellbeing while at work," Ms Owens wrote. She considered the firm's failure to respond adequately to amount to "repudiation of contract", upholding Ms Breslin's unfair dismissal claim.
Ms Owens awarded the claimant €15,800, her full losses for five months' unemployment.
A further complaint of disability discrimination under the Employment Equality Act was ruled out of time by the Commission.
Ms Breslin was represented by Aisling Irish of Parker Law Solicitors in the case, while human resources consultancy Tom Smyth and Associates appeared for the employer.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Demand for Wicklow barbers prompts roll out of three courses for trainees
Demand for Wicklow barbers prompts roll out of three courses for trainees

Irish Independent

time5 hours ago

  • Irish Independent

Demand for Wicklow barbers prompts roll out of three courses for trainees

The shortage of barbers and hairdressers has become an increasingly pressing issue in recent years, with the country facing a significant skills gap in this sector, according to the marketing agency and talent hub, Back4good. It attributed the shortage to several factors, including the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and challenges in attracting young talent to the profession. There is also a growth in demand for barbering generally, driven by trends in men's grooming and a renewed appreciation for traditional grooming, beard-trimming and other services which require more skilled barbers. On the surface, Bray doesn't appear to suffer from a lack of barber shops (a rough count pointing to at least a dozen in the town) but it does suffer from a lack of barbers – as anyone who has had to wait in line while a customer is getting a 'skin fade' will know. Earlier this year, BNWAP – the community-focused organisation dedicated to supporting social inclusion and economic development in the Bray and North Wicklow area – launched an 'Introduction to Barbering' course for people in the community to provide them with a taster of a career in barbering. And after overwhelming interest, three Introduction to Barbering courses have already been delivered – with hugely positive feedback from participants. The hands-on training courses were designed to offer people a chance to explore barbering as a potential career in a supportive, skills-based environment. Participants learned practical techniques and gained insight into working in the industry, helping to build both their skills and confidence. As part of the course, participants also visited Bray Institute of Further Education (BIFE), which runs a one-year City & Guilds Level 5 Diploma in Barbering. They were given a tour of the facilities by BIFE Deputy Principal, Gabriel Allen, offering them a valuable insight into what further training in the field could look like. The success of the courses has now opened new doors, with a number of participants progressing to the full Level 5 year-long barbering course at BIFE. This marks an exciting step for those seeking to build a long-term career in the barbering industry. 'We were delighted to see such a strong demand for the courses,' said Jennifer Jones, the programmes activation and new communities team leader at BNWAP. 'The commitment and enthusiasm shown by participants was inspiring, and it's fantastic to see some now taking the next step in their training journey at BIFE.' The initiative reflects a wider effort by BNWAP to support local people in developing practical skills that lead to further education and employment opportunities. The courses were supported under the Social Inclusion and Community Activation Programme (SICAP), which is co-funded by the Irish Government, through the Department of Rural and Community Development, and the European Social Fund Plus under the Employment, Inclusion, Skills and Training (EIST) Programme 2021–2027. Information on accessing the courses can be found on

Government urged ‘not to delay solemn promise' of VAT cut for hospitality sector
Government urged ‘not to delay solemn promise' of VAT cut for hospitality sector

The Journal

time17 hours ago

  • The Journal

Government urged ‘not to delay solemn promise' of VAT cut for hospitality sector

THE GOVERNMENT HAS been urged 'not to delay its promise' of cutting the VAT rate for the hospitality sector to 9% in the upcoming budget. Despite election promises and ministerial pronouncements, government this week has been signalling that a cut to the VAT rate for the hospitality sector may not go ahead in Budget 2026. Tánaiste Simon Harris said the government had made a 'solemn' commitment in the election to reduce the VAT rate for the hospitality sector, but this week the government has been sending mixed signals on how it will proceed. Speaking to RTÉ Radio 1 yesterday, junior justice minister Niall Collins said the VAT cut was not a 'done deal'. VAT for the tourism and hospitality sectors was reduced to 9% during the Covid-19 pandemic at a cost of €1.2bn to the exchequer. The previous 13.5% rate was reinstated last August, despite the sector's opposition. Retail Excellence Ireland (REI), the largest representative body for the retail industry in Ireland, has called on the Government to follow through on its 'promise to permanently cut the rate of VAT for the hospitality industry to 9% in Budget 2026'. Jean McCabe, CEO of REI, said that 'after a tough few years, the Government's solemn promise to cut the VAT rate for the hospitality industry was welcome'. 'It would be regrettable for it to delay its promise now,' she added. 'There are too many livelihoods at stake not to introduce a measure as soon as possible that would have such a significant impact on the industry, and on related industries such as retail.' She said the government must do 'everything in its power to strengthen our domestic economy at a time when we need it most'. McCabe also called for the general rate of VAT be cut from 23% to 21% to assist the retail industry. Advertisement Meanwhile, the Irish Hotels Federation (IHF) has criticised the 'deeply misleading' figure of €1 billion per year that was quoted earlier this week regarding the cost to the Exchequer of reducing VAT for hospitality businesses. On Tuesday, during a press conference on the Summer Economic Statement, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe told reporters that the one-year cost for reducing the hospitality VAT rate to 9% for restaurants and hotels would be between €950mn and €1bn. However, later in the press conference, Donohoe said he would need to clarify if that figure did include hotels. A spokesperson for the minister told The Journal today that, based on CSO data, the total one-year cost for restaurants and hotels is actually €810mn. This is split €675mn for restaurants and cafes and €135mn for hotels. The cost for hairdressers would be an additional €40mn. IHF Chief Executive Paul Gallagher said it's time for an 'honest and balanced debate' that 'recognises the economic and social importance of hospitality food service businesses and gives them a fighting chance to survive'. He noted that the 'true cost involved is significantly lower than the widely quoted €1bn figure cited by the Government in recent days' Gallagher added: 'The Government's narrative has had the effect, intended or otherwise, of driving a wedge between the public and the hospitality industry, framing the VAT reduction as a giveaway to businesses. 'This is extremely divisive and simply not true.' He said the 9% VAT reduction sought would apply to prepared food services, such as meals in restaurants, takeaways, commercial kitchens and food served on transport. 'The real beneficiaries are small food businesses,' said Gallagher, 'many of which are operating on the brink of survival due to extreme food cost inflation and shrinking margins. 'Reducing VAT on food services is not a handout to hospitality businesses – it is a vital intervention for a sector that supports over 270,000 livelihoods and contributes significantly to the economy.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Major US flagship clothing store to open in Irish city in just weeks as fans say ‘can't wait'
Major US flagship clothing store to open in Irish city in just weeks as fans say ‘can't wait'

The Irish Sun

timea day ago

  • The Irish Sun

Major US flagship clothing store to open in Irish city in just weeks as fans say ‘can't wait'

A MAJOR US flagship clothing store is set to open in an Irish city in just weeks - and fans say they "can't wait." Urban Outfitters is officially opening a new shop on Patrick Street in 2 It will be located among a range of other retailers on Patrick Street Credit: Savills 2 Urban outfitters is coming to Cork City Credit: Getty Images The trendy American fashion and lifestyle chain is moving into 101 Patrick Street, the former home of Dorothy Perkins. This will be Urban Outfitters' second store in Ireland, following its long-running location in Dublin's Temple Bar. The new Cork shop comes after a full high-end refurbishment of the four-storey building since it was closed in 2019 - making the move hugely anticipated. Only two of the floors will be open to customers, with retail space expected on the ground and first levels. READ MORE IN MONEY Earlier this year, planning permission for shop front changes and internal upgrades was submitted to Cork City Council ahead of the new store announcement. Drawings show plans for new signage, fitting rooms, stair balustrades and merchandising units. Now operating over 177 stores in the US and 33 in the UK, it first launched in 1970 and originally targeted students with a mix of clothing, music and homeware. MOST READ IN MONEY Its first Irish store opened in Dublin in 2000, and Cork will mark its return to retail expansion in Ireland. Cork's new location will sell a mix of men's and women's Wendy's hilarious dig And shoppers can expect to find brands like Nike, Fila, Adidas and Champion sitting alongside their own-label designs. Urban Outfitters joins a wave of new arrivals on Patrick Street in the past two years - including Mango, Flannels, Dune, Sea Salt Cornwall and The North Face. And the retailer has already started hiring staff for the Cork branch - which you can apply to here. People have taken to One person wrote: 'That is wonderful news. It's great to see the city centre coming back to life after it was badly hit by Covid.' Another said: 'Can't wait, we're gonna have to queue.' FAST FOOD CHAIN Meanwhile, American fast food chain Taco Bell is a hugely popular Mexican style fast-food chain, featuring items like tacos, burritos and the Crunchwrap Supreme. This launch is part of a new partnership between Applegreen and Taco Bell, marking a major move in the chains expansion in Applegreen's Managing Director for the Republic of Ireland, Seamus Stapleton, said the company is delighted to introduce Taco Bell to Irish consumers. He said: 'We are really excited to announce this partnership to launch the iconic Taco Bell brand in Ireland. "This partnership underscores our commitment to bringing world-class roadside hospitality to our customers, offering them greater choice and quality while they travel. "We are constantly investing in our locations, and I'm sure Irish consumers will be very excited at the arrival of Taco Bell.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store