How President Trump's Middle East tour signaled a bold reset in US foreign policy

Arab News

20-05-2025

LONDON: Standing ovations and scenes of jubilation are not normally witnessed at investment forums. But there was nothing normal about the speech President Donald Trump delivered at the US-Saudi Investment Forum in Riyadh last week.
Speaking at the beginning of a four-day tour of the region, Trump's geopolitical surprises came thick and fast.
'After discussing the situation in Syria with the (Saudi) crown prince,' he said, 'I will be ordering the cessation of sanctions against Syria in order to give them a chance at greatness.'
The last few words were almost drowned out by the wave of applause, which was followed by a standing ovation led by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.
Although the announcement came as a big surprise to most, including seasoned analysts and even some in Trump's inner circle, it was not entirely unexpected.
In December, for the first time in a decade, US officials had flown to Damascus, where they met with Ahmad Al-Sharaa, the commander of Hay'at Tahrir Al-Sham, which just two weeks earlier had led the dramatic overthrow of the Bashar Assad regime after 14 years of civil war.
As a result of that meeting, after which the US delegation said it had found Al-Sharaa to be wholly 'pragmatic,' the US removed the longstanding $10 million bounty on his head. A month later, Al-Sharaa was appointed president of Syria.
The day after last week's investment forum in Riyadh, Trump sat down for a face-to-face meeting with Al-Sharaa that produced what might well prove to be one of the most historic photographs in the region's recent history: the Saudi crown prince, flanked by Trump and Al-Sharaa, standing in front of the flags of the US, Saudi Arabia, and Syria.
The photograph sent a clear message: For the US, and for a region all too often subject to the whims of its largesse and military approbation, all bets were off.
The day before, Trump had more surprises for his delighted audience at the King Abdulaziz International Conference Center.
'I have never believed in having permanent enemies,' the president said, and 'I am willing to end past conflicts and forge new partnerships for a better and more stable world, even if our differences may be very profound, which obviously they are in the case of Iran.'
He praised local leadership for 'transcending the ancient conflicts and tired divisions of the past' and criticized 'Western interventionists … giving you lectures on how to live or how to govern your own affairs.'
In a message that will have echoed loudly in Kabul, Baghdad, and even Tehran, he added: 'In the end, the so-called 'nation-builders' wrecked far more nations than they built — and the interventionists were intervening in complex societies that they did not even understand themselves.'
Responding to Trump's announcements, Sir John Jenkins, a seasoned diplomat who served as British ambassador to Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and Syria, and as consul-general in Jerusalem, told Arab News: 'I think this could be a real turning point.
'Post-Arab Spring demographics — lots of young people wanting a better life and better governance but not wanting to get there through ideology or revolution — and Mohammed bin Salman, Trump, and Syria have all come together at a singular time.'
Trump's speech last week in Riyadh, he said, 'was extraordinary, an intellectually coherent argument, and he means it.
'If you can form a cohesive bloc of Sunni states — the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the rest of the GCC, Jordan, Syria and Egypt — which all aim in different ways to increase prosperity and stability instead of the opposite, then you potentially have a bloc that can manage regional stability and contain Iran in a way we haven't had for decades. And that gives the US the ability to pivot.'
But a lot could still go wrong. 'Iran, which is already trying hard to undermine Syria, will continue to play games,' said Jenkins.
'And then there's Israel itself: Does it want strong and stable Sunni neighbors or not? It should do, but I'm not sure Bezalel Smotrich (Israel's far-right finance minister, who this month vowed that Gaza would be 'entirely destroyed') and Itamar Ben-Gvir (the minister of national security who is pressing for Israel to seize and occupy Gaza) think so. That's a headache for Israel's Prime Minister (Benjamin) Netanyahu.
'But if you hook all this up to a possible US-Iran deal, which will give Iran incentives not to have sanctions come crashing back down, then there's something there.'
For Al-Sharaa, even six months ago, the dramatic turnaround in his personal circumstances would have seemed fantastic, and as such is symptomatic of the tectonic upheavals presaged by Trump's visit to the region.
Almost exactly 12 years ago, on May 16, 2013, the then-leader of the Al-Qaeda-affiliated Nusra Front, judged responsible for 'multiple suicide attacks throughout Syria' targeting the Assad regime, had been designated as a terrorist by the US Department of State.
Now, as the very public beneficiary of the praise and support of Trump and the Saudi crown prince, Al-Sharaa's metamorphosis into the symbol of hope for the Syrian people is emblematic of America's dramatic new approach to the region.
In Doha, the president chose the occasion of a visit to a US military base to make nice with Iran, a country whose negotiators have been quietly meeting in Oman with Steve Witkoff, Trump's special envoy, to discuss a nuclear deal.
'I want them to succeed,' said Trump, who in 2018 unilaterally withdrew the US from the original deal, fashioned by President Barack Obama and European allies, and reimposed economic sanctions. Now, he said in Doha last week, 'I want them to end up being a great country.'
Iran, he added, 'cannot have a nuclear weapon.' But, in a snub to Israel, which has reportedly not only sought US permission to attack Iranian enrichment facilities, but has even asked America to take part, he added: 'We are not going to make any nuclear dust in Iran. I think we're getting close to maybe doing a deal without having to do this.'
In fact, Trump's entire trip appeared to be designed as a snub to Israel, which did not feature on the itinerary.
A week ahead of the trip, Trump had announced a unilateral ceasefire deal with the Houthis in Yemen, who had sided with Hamas after Israel mounted its retaliatory war in Gaza in October 2023.
Under the deal, brokered by Oman and with no Israeli involvement, the US said it would halt its strikes in Yemen in exchange for the Houthis agreeing to stop targeting vessels in the Red Sea.
On May 12, the day before Trump arrived in Saudi Arabia, Hamas released Edan Alexander, the last surviving US citizen held hostage in Gaza, in a deal that came out of direct talks with no Israeli involvement.
In a post on Truth Social, Trump celebrated 'a step taken in good faith towards the United States and the efforts of the mediators — Qatar and Egypt — to put an end to this very brutal war.'
Trump, said Ahron Bregman, a former Israeli soldier and a senior teaching fellow in King's College London's Institute of Middle Eastern Studies, 'threw Netanyahu, in fact Israel, under the bus.
'He totally surprised Netanyahu with a series of Middle Eastern diplomatic initiatives, which, at least from an Israeli perspective, hurt — indeed, humiliate — Israel,' he told Arab News.
'In the past, if one wished to get access to the White House, a good way to do so was to turn to Israel, asking them to open doors in Washington. Not any longer. Netanyahu, hurt and humiliated by Trump, seems to have lost his magic touch.
'Trump despises losers, and he probably regards Netanyahu as a loser, given the Gaza mess and Netanyahu's failure to achieve Israel's declared aims.'
It is, Bregman said, Trump's famously transactional approach to politics that is shifting the dial so dramatically in the Middle East.
'Trump looks at international relations and diplomacy through financial lenses, as business enterprises. For Trump, money talks and the money is not to be found in Israel, which sucks $3 billion dollars a year from the US, but in the Gulf states.
'Trump is serious about America First, and Israel doesn't serve this aim; the Gulf states do. For now, at least, the center of gravity has moved to the Gulf states, and the Israeli status in the Middle East has weakened dramatically.'
For Ibrahim Al-Marashi, associate professor at California State University, San Marcos, the events of the past week stand in sharp contrast to those during Trump's first presidency.
'During the first Trump administration, World War Three almost broke out, with aircraft carriers from my native San Diego deployed continuously to the Gulf to deter Iran, the (Houthi) strike on Saudi Aramco, and the assassination of Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani in Baghdad at the beginning of 2020,' he told Arab News.
'Five years later, the Trump administration seems to be repeating the Nixon-Kissinger realist doctrine: 'America has no permanent friends or enemies, only interests.' In that regard, his administration might forge relations with Iran as Nixon did with China.'
Kelly Petillo, program manager for the Middle East and North Africa at the European Council on Foreign Relations, likewise views last week's events as the beginning of 'a new phase of US-Gulf relations.'
Among the remarkable developments is 'Israel's relative sidelining and the fact that Israel does not have the privileged relationship with Trump it thought it had,' she told Arab News. 'The US agenda now is wider than unconditional support to Israel, and alignment with GCC partners is also key.
'Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the UAE have clearly become of key strategic importance to the US, with new deals on the horizon and the promise of expanding these relations. The announcements of more commercial ties have been accompanied with political declarations too, which overall represented positive developments for the region.'
Ultimately, said Caroline Rose, a director at the New Lines Institute, 'Trump's visit to the GCC highlighted two of his foreign policy priorities in the Middle East.
'Firstly, he sought to obtain a series of transactional, bilateral cooperation agreements in sectors such as defense, investment and trade,' she told Arab News.
'The second objective was to use the trip as a mechanism that could change conditions for ongoing diplomatic negotiations directly with Iran, between Hamas and Israel, and even Ukraine and Russia.'
It was, of course, no accident that Trump chose the Middle East as the destination for the first formal overseas trip of his second presidency.
'The Trump administration sought to court Gulf states closely to signal to other partners in the region, such as Israel, as well as the EU, that it can develop alternative partnerships to achieve what it wants in peace negotiations.'
Although a strategy to move forward with specific peace negotiations was 'notably absent during his trip,' it was clear that 'this trip was designed to lay the groundwork for potential momentum and to change some of the power dynamics with traditional US partners abroad, sowing the seeds of goodwill that could alter negotiations in the Trump administration's favor.'