'You cannot take away choice from girls'- reactions to possible school skirt ban

Yahoo

21-06-2025

A GROWING number of schools across the UK are moving to ban skirts from their uniform policies — and the reaction from parents and residents has been anything but quiet.
The latest flashpoint is Honywood School in Coggeshall, Essex.
Earlier this month, the school announced that from September, students would only be permitted to wear trousers or knee-length tailored shorts — effectively banning skirts altogether.
The school said the decision was due to ongoing issues with students rolling up their skirts.
However, following a backlash from parents, the ban was postponed — though not entirely scrapped.
The Gazette took to the streets to ask residents what they thought of the controversial move, and the community offered a range of strongly held views.
Kerry Martin (Image: Newsquest Reporter) 'I think it's a little bit extreme that these schools are banning skirts,' said Kerry Martin, 36, an artist living in Blackheath.
'I understand that there are some concerns, and they are valid and they must have rules in place to ensure everyone is wearing the right length skirt.
"However, they shouldn't take it away from everybody. Girls should be allowed to wear skirts if they choose to. Especially in this hot weather.'
James Ferris (Image: Newsquest Reporter) James Ferris, 39, an engineer from Tollesbury, said he sees the issue from the perspective of a parent.
He said: 'I don't think it's fair at all. As a girl dad, I fully believe that the girls should be allowed to wear whatever they want to wear.
"They should have the right to choosing if they want to wear a skirt or trousers. You cannot take away choice from young women as they are growing up.'
Anna Gayle (Image: Newsquest Reporter) Anna Gayle, 42, who works in HR and lives in Manningtree, said: 'As a mum, I feel that it seems unnecessary to ban the skirt.
"If the length of the skirt is an issue, have stricter guidelines about what's the appropriate length.
"As a parent, I believe schools should have the right to policy making, but you cannot take away choice from young women.
"Have rules in place about what's the right length of the skirt permitted, and for kids who don't follow that rule, have a chat with their parents.'
Matt Gayle (Image: Newsquest Reporter) Her husband, Matt Gayle, 43, a CBT therapist also from Manningtree, agreed that banning skirts goes too far.
He said: 'I know girls tend to roll up their skirts, but a ban is over the top. If there is a certain uniform, have a guideline and make sure people abide by it.
"Discipline is important but we cannot simply dictate girls to not wear skirts.
"Skirt or trouser, the choice must be theirs and parents must also take full responsibility in making sure the girls wear the right length of skirt that is outlined in the school's uniform policy.'
Matt Coowes (Image: Newsquest Reporter) Matt Coowes, 34, a production engineer, living in Clacton said: "Well my organisation had banned shorts last year actually, which we all sided with because it was from a health and safety standpoint.
"So, this sort of uniform policy is only acceptable in my opinion if it's to safeguard the children from a health and safety perspective. But clearly that's not the case.
"It's a case of taking away choice from young women to decide if they want to wear a skirt or a trouser, it's about controlling how they chose to express themselves.
"Sure the girls roll up the skirts, then find a better way so they don't. Banning is not the solution."
Linda Lloyd (Image: Newsquest Reporter) Linda Llyod, 56, a screening officer for a learning disability organization living in St Osyth, said banning skirts fails to address the real issue.
She said: 'Well girls rolling up school skirts is very normal for their age. It's life, it's just girls for you.
"Now it's absolutely ridiculous they want to ban skirts. I think they shouldn't ban it. Girls wear skirts and they should be allowed to wear it if they choose to.
"The length is an issue, and that should be addressed in a better way. If your concern is girls' safety, make sure you outline it as a rule they wear knee-length skirts, but don't ban it entirely.
"I see both sides of this argument but a ban... that's still a bit unfair and I hope they don't implement it.'