Unions blast Quebec, Montreal Economic Institute for false Quebec strike numbers
The Confédération des syndicats nationaux says that 'false data concerning labour disputes in Quebec' has been removed from Statistics Canada's site after the CSN questioned claims that strike and work stoppage numbers have skyrocketed in recent years.
MEI senior policy analyst Gabriel Giguère wrote a report in May showing work stoppages skyrocketing from under 100 from 2017 to 2020 and then jumping to 759 in 2024.
The MEI acknowledged that many organizations rely on StatsCan data as an authority.
'Statistics Canada remains Canada's source of reference and is relied upon by all research organizations across the nation,' said MEI communications vice-president Renaud Brossard. 'We acknowledge that the agency is now questioning and reviewing its own data following conversations with union officials.'
The government of Quebec's site shows that there were 208 work stoppages in 2024.
'We found that those numbers a little bit strange, so I asked my people working on my research services at the CSN to check with StatCan, and they called them last week and they said, 'Oh, we do have communication problems between Quebec and us,' and they said 'you're right, our numbers are no good,'' said CSN vice president François Énault.
Énault said the unions are frustrated because Labour Minister Jean Boulet has repeated the MEI numbers, even though the Quebec government's numbers are much lower.
'That's a bit strange because the number we have, these are the number from his ministery,' said Énault. 'I don't understand why he's using numbers from Stats Can when they have numbers from his own ministery.'
The CSN said that Stats Can's data comes from Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC), which obtains its information from the Quebec Labour Ministry.
How the numbers wound up so far from Quebec's numbers remains a mystery.
'We don't know,' said Énault. 'They just said they have a mistake and they do have a problem. They told us they have a communication problem.'
The CSN said ESDC representatives confirmed that the data will be recalculated.
'They even suggested that we use data from the Quebec Ministry of Labour instead, which they consider more reliable. A simple check would have prevented the MEI from relaying false information,' the CSN said.
Énault said that Quebec does have a higher unionized worker population than other Canadian provinces, at 40 per cent of the population. Also, the unions understand that strikes are, at times, unpopular.
'When we do strike, it's because we want to put some pressure on the government,' he said. 'You see, our goal it's to have a good collective agreement for our members, so they can spend money in Quebec and it's good for the economy. Don't forget, 95 per cent of all the collective agreements in Quebec. we have a deal with no strike or lock out, and it's a huge number.'
The CSN wanted to set the record straight so anti-union groups do not use the erroneous information in the MEI report.
'No, there has not been an explosion in the number of labour disputes,' said Énault. 'No, 91 per cent of strikes in Canada do not take place in Quebec. Now we must return to the fundamental question: who benefits from restricting the right to strike? Certainly not workers! We must ask ourselves why it is important for employer lobbies to attack the right to strike by any means necessary, even if it means putting their credibility on the line with false data!'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
42 minutes ago
- CTV News
Rents dropping but students still struggling to get by
Rents continue to come down in Lethbridge and across Alberta, but many students are still struggling to afford housing and school. Lethbridge is still one of the most affordable cities in Canada for renters. One-bedroom accommodations cost $1,336 per month compared to the national average of more than $1,800. 'We are continuing to see rents across Canada come down. Lethbridge is no exception there,' said Giacomo Ladas with But two-bedroom rents have risen 6.3 per cent year-over-year to $1,621. Many university students coming to Lethbridge this fall will be stuck paying those higher rents. 'Right now, we're seeing a lot of students working multiple jobs just to afford rent, and it's taking a real toll on their academic performance here. So, we're really taking it seriously,' said Bradley Pike, the University of Lethbridge Students' Union's vice-president external. Supports are available to students who need it. Emergency bursaries are available through the U of L Students' Union. But there's no specific rent supports or subsidies. 'Currently, there's nothing supported by the university in particular to subsidizing rent, but we do have the emergency grants for the times that students are facing significant financial challenges,' Pike said. Renters could be in for a bit of a break later this fall. After the summer rental peak, rents are expected to drop further. But most post-secondary students likely already have their apartments locked in. 'If we're developing a property, we don't want it ready for the middle of February,' Ladas said. 'As we know, Canada has sometimes too long of a winter. So, a lot of the supply comes in around June, July. … Your developers—their goal is to have them ready for that time. 'And then, of course, that matches really well with the demand of renters.' Alberta saw its average rent drop 4.4 per cent year-over-year to $1,738.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Air Canada flight attendants at the bargaining table
Vancouver Watch Flight attendants at Air Canada are advocating for better rights and could walk off the job next week if an agreement isn't reached.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Island Lake First Nations demand fire prevention overhaul
First Nations leaders are speaking out and calling for a comprehensive plan to address wildfires and evacuations. CTV's Harrison Shin reports. The Chiefs of the Island Lake First Nations are demanding solutions from the perspective of fire prevention, not reactiveness. On Friday, leadership members of the Island Lake First Nations held a press conference in Winnipeg, demanding five solutions. 'This is not an emergency system; this is a cycle of failure. Our Chiefs and Anisininew Nations are saying to Canada, 'The cycle ends now,'' Grand Chief Alex McDougall of Anisininew Okimawin said. 'Leaders called for a national Indigenous fire strategy because of chronic lack of firefighting, fire prevention and emergency services in First Nations was a recipe for disaster,' McDougall added. In a media release, the Anisininew Okimawin leadership is demanding five action items, addressing future-proof measures and the current wildfire situation. 'We don't need to fund more evacuations—we need fund on staying home,' Chief Raymond Flett of St. Theresa Point Anisininew Nation said. Six leaders of the First Nations drew their statements based on a 2022 Auditor General of Canada report. '$646 million in response, and $182 million on prevention. That's unacceptable—this should be the other way around,' Chief Willie Moore of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs said. The Canadian Red Cross said the organization is working extremely hard to provide support, in an email statement. 'As of August 6, the Red Cross has registered more than 31,000 people from more than 12,000 households evacuated due to wildfires in Manitoba. This includes people from more than 7,000 households on behalf of Indigenous Services Canada, and more than 5,000 households on behalf of the Province of Manitoba. 'This is a fast-moving and evolving response and the Red Cross is working with community leadership, the Government of Manitoba and Indigenous Services Canada to provide support to people impacted, as requested and directed by the community,' the statement said. Indigenous Services Canada (ISC) said the department operates multiple programs to support First Nations, in an email response. 'Since April 1st, 2025, ISC has also provided $58.9 million in advance payments to support immediate response to First Nations in Manitoba experiencing displacements due to wildland fires. 'We are actively engaging with First Nations and Manitoba to discuss improvements based on lessons learned from the current wildfire season, particularly through the development of multilateral emergency management service agreements that include First Nations as full and equal partners in governance, planning, and delivery.' The federal department said it's open to working closely on long-term plans with communities and provincial governments that wish to build all-season roads. 'While the building and maintaining of permanent off-reserve roads falls under provincial jurisdiction, ISC will continue to engage the provinces and impacted First Nations on longer-term transportation plans.' For the First Nations affected, they said their future is at stake. 'We can't live like this for another 60—maybe 50—years,' Chief Walter Harper of Wasagamack Anisininew Nation said.
