ABC no longer disputes that ‘Lebanese, Middle Eastern or Arab races exist', unlawful termination suit hears
The ABC has amended its legal defence in the unlawful termination suit it is defending in federal court, after outcry about its claims that the onus was on the sacked journalist Antoinette Lattouf to prove the existence of a Lebanese, Arab or Middle Eastern race.
On Tuesday, the ABC's lead barrister, Ian Neil SC, began by amending the broadcaster's defence to say that the ABC accepted 'Lattouf is a person of Lebanese and Arab and Middle Eastern descent'.
'We are now instructed as follows: the ABC does not put in issue, that is, it does not dispute or contest that the Lebanese, Middle Eastern or Arab races exist, or that Ms Lattouf is one or more of those races,' said Neil.
'To be entirely clear about this, your honour will understand that the ABC continues to deny that Ms Lattouf's race or national extraction, together with any political opinion she may have had, were reasons for, or part of, the reasons for any the decision to take her off air in December 2023.'
The chief people officer, Deena Amorelli, emailed all ABC staff apologising for the distress caused by the legal tactic.
'Last Thursday I wrote to you regarding the ABC's defence of the current proceedings in the federal court brought by Ms Antoinette Lattouf,' Amorelli said in an email seen by Guardian Australia.
'As part of these proceedings, a proposition was made in the ABC's legal submission relating to race and matters that needed to be established by Ms Lattouf in her case against the ABC. This proposition was intended to state the legal elements that must be established, it was not to make a statement about any aspect of Ms Lattouf's race or national extraction.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
'The ABC recognises that, regrettably, this legal argument has caused distress in some sections of the community and our workforce. This was not the ABC's intention.
'Today, the ABC has made clear to the court that it does not dispute or contest Ms Lattouf's race or national extraction being Lebanese, Middle Eastern or Arab.
'The ABC does, however, deny that any action was taken against Ms Lattouf because of her political opinion, race or national extraction.
'The ABC's commitment to diversity remains an important part of the ABC's workplace culture and we will continue to work to foster inclusion for all staff.'
Lattouf was hired as a fill-in presenter on ABC Sydney radio for one week in December 2023. She was taken off air three days into a five-day contract after she posted on social media about the Israel-Gaza war.
The amendment comes following outcry from cultural groups after the ABC's legal arguments were made public last week.
'It follows that Ms Lattouf's case … insofar as it depends on 'race' as an attribute, must fail,' it said in a submission released by the court.
However, Neil said in court on Wednesday that 'the ABC does not deny the existence of any race' and the onus was on Lattouf to provide evidence in relation to any race claim she may make.
David Anderson, the ABC's managing director, was asked under cross-examination on Thursday whether he had any doubts that 'there exists a Lebanese race'.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'If somebody tells me they're Lebanese, I don't question whether they mean it's race or national identity,' he said.
When pushed by Lattouf's barrister, Oshie Fagir, as to whether there is 'a Lebanese race in your view or not', Anderson replied: 'I haven't formed a view as to whether there is or there isn't.'
The Arab Council Australia called the ABC's legal defence 'disturbing' while the president of the Australian Lebanese Association, Raymond Najar, said the ABC's position was 'surreal and blatantly racist'.
'Here we have the head of the national broadcaster accusing Ms Lattouf of being racist for stating facts on the one hand and then erasing her race all within a couple of hours of each other and seemingly blind to the irony of it all,' Najar said.
The court is due to hear evidence from the former head of ABC Sydney Steve Ahern, the former ABC chair Ita Buttrose and Lattouf's line manager, Elizabeth Green, on Tuesday, before concluding hearing evidence on Wednesday.
Proceedings on Tuesday opened with Justice Darryl Rangiah sternly reprimanding the ABC's legal team after they filed an unredacted version of witness Chris Oliver-Taylor's affidavit, despite a federal court order that the names of the people who complained to the ABC about Lattouf should remain private.
The document was taken down later on Monday.
'I am deeply unhappy about the error made by the ABC's legal representatives,' Rangiah said.
Neil apologised for what he said was 'human error'.
'As leading counsel responsible for the presentation of the respondent's case, I stand before you this morning to tender my personal apology for what has happened.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
21 minutes ago
- Telegraph
US drops support for a Palestinian state
Supporting an independent Palestinian state is no longer official US policy, according to Mike Huckabee, America's ambassador to Israel. Mr Huckabee used an interview with Bloomberg to rule out a two-state solution in the Middle East, a policy first supported by George W Bush in 2002, ditched by Donald Trump at the start of his first term in 2017 and reinstated by Joe Biden. Asked whether Washington backed a two-state solution, Mr Huckabee replied, 'I don't think so'. He continued: 'Unless there are some significant things that happen that change the culture, there's no room for it.' Mr Huckabee, a former governor of Arkansas who ran for the White House in 2008 and 2016, is a long-standing supporter of Israel. Upon being nominated as Washington's ambassador to Israel, Mr Huckabee told Israeli Army Radio that he believed the annexation of Judea and Samaria – the biblical term used by Israel to describe the West Bank – was a possibility. In the Bloomberg interview, Mr Huckabee argued that three million Palestinians currently living under occupation in the West Bank could be re-accommodated in land carved out of another Muslim country in the Middle East, rather than expecting Israel to surrender territory. 'Does it have to be in Judea and Samaria?' he said. An Evangelical Christian and former Baptist minister, Mr Huckabee has led religious pilgrimages to Israel and visited the country dozens of times. He has long dismissed the idea of a Palestinian state. 'There's really no such thing as a Palestinian,' he said in a previous interview. Mr Huckabee's appointment by Mr Trump was seen as an endorsement of hard-liners in the Israeli government and the burgeoning settlements in the West Bank. On being appointed, he hailed Mr Trump's support for Israel, which, during his first term, included recognising Israeli control of the Golan Heights and moving the US embassy to Jerusalem. According to a Pew Research poll, 46 per cent of American Jews do support a two-state solution. The State Department has not responded to Mr Huckabee's remarks.
The Independent
39 minutes ago
- The Independent
Netanyahu's government could collapse over Israel's ultra-Orthodox military draft law
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces a vote to dissolve parliament Wednesday and key coalition partners have threatened to bring down his government. Still, few think it's the end of the road for Israel's longest-serving prime minister, who has been battling corruption charges for years, or his far-right government, still in power after presiding over the security failures surrounding the Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023, attack. The move to dissolve, called by the opposition, will only pass if Netanyahu's ultra-Orthodox coalition partners break with him over the failure to pass a law exempting their community from military service, an issue that has bitterly divided Israelis, especially during the ongoing war in the Gaza Strip. The threats coming from the ultra-Orthodox could be posturing, and many expect Netanyahu to pull off a last-minute deal. But Wednesday's vote is the most serious challenge to Netanyahu's government since the war began, and the coalition's collapse could have major implications for Israel and the ongoing war. Why the ultra-Orthodox reject military service Most Jewish men are required to serve nearly three years of military service followed by years of reserve duty. Jewish women serve two mandatory years. But the politically powerful ultra-Orthodox, who make up roughly 13% of Israeli society, have traditionally received exemptions if they are studying full-time in religious seminaries. The exemptions — and the government stipends many seminary students receive through age 26 — have infuriated the general public. After Hamas' 2023 attack, Israel activated 360,000 reservists, its largest mobilization since the 1973 Mideast war. Israel is engaged in the longest active war in the country's history, which has stretched its robust military to the breaking point. Many reserve soldiers have served multiple rounds of duty in Gaza totaling hundreds of days. Some reserve soldiers are rejecting new call-ups. The number of Israelis continuing to report for reserve duty has dropped so low that the military has taken to social media to try to recruit people to keep serving. The enlistment exemption for the ultra-Orthodox goes back to Israel's 1948 founding, when small numbers of gifted scholars were exempt from the draft in response to the decimation of Jewish scholarship during the Holocaust. But with a push from politically powerful religious parties, the numbers have swelled to tens of thousands today. Israel's Supreme Court said the exemptions were illegal in 2017, but repeated extensions and government delay tactics have prevented a replacement law from being passed. Among Israel's Jewish majority, mandatory military service is largely seen as a melting pot and rite of passage. That's exactly why some ultra-Orthodox don't want their children to serve. 'It mixes together people with very different backgrounds, very different ideas, some people with very immoral ideas,' said Rabbi Ephraim Luft, 66, from the ultra-Orthodox stronghold of Bnei Barak. Luft said the community's dedication to upholding Jewish commandments protects the country as much as military service. 'Over thousands of years, the Jewish people have stood very strongly against any kind of decrees to force them to give up their religion, they've given up their lives for this,' Luft said. 'People have to understand there's no difference between the Spanish Inquisition or the Israeli draft law.' Why ultra-Orthodox parties would want to bring down the government Two parties belonging to the Haredim, or 'God-fearing' in Hebrew, are essential to Netanyahu's coalition. Both would need to vote to dissolve the government to force new elections, including Shas, which has traditionally been more supportive of Netanyahu. On Monday, a Shas spokesperson told an ultra-Orthodox radio program the party plans to vote in favor of dissolution, unless there is a breakthrough in negotiations. The other party, Degel HaTorah, has been threatening to leave the government since last week. 'Basically, they don't really care about the war and the economic situation of the state and anything else but their communal interest. And the focus of this communal interest is getting the exemption from serving in the army," said Shuki Friedman, an expert on religion and state affairs and vice president of the Jewish People Policy Institute, a Jerusalem think tank. Friedman and other experts say the current system is unsustainable. With its high birthrate, the ultra-Orthodox are the fastest-growing segment of Israel's population, at about 4% annually. Each year, roughly 13,000 ultra-Orthodox men reach the conscription age of 18, but less than 10% enlist, according to parliament's State Control Committee, which held a hearing examining the issue. The shock of the Oct. 7 attack appeared to ignite some enthusiasm among the ultra-Orthodox to serve, but no large enlistment materialized. The army has repeatedly declined to comment on the ultra-Orthodox enlistment rate. What happens if parliament is dissolved If the dissolution vote passes, it still faces a series of bureaucratic steps, including additional votes, that the government would likely drag on for weeks or months, said Gayil Talshir, a political science professor at Hebrew University. 'It will be like a gun that's been put into position, but that doesn't mean the coalition is over,' she said. Elections in Israel are scheduled for the fall of 2026. Both Talshir and Friedman believe it's unlikely the dissolution vote will pass Wednesday. If one ultra-Orthodox party is absent, the vote will not pass and another cannot be brought for six months, Talshir said. However, there's also a 'valid possibility' the rabbis who advise the ultra-Orthodox parties will say they've waited long enough for a draft exemption law, because they are facing enormous pressure from their communities, Friedman said. On Tuesday, top Haredi rabbis issued a religious decree emphasizing their stand against military service, which complicates the Haredi politicians' ability to negotiate, Friedman added. The army has issued thousands of draft notices to the ultra-Orthodox community, and those who refuse to serve can face arrest. While only around a dozen have been arrested after being stopped for trying to leave the country or for traffic violations, the fear this has inspired is significant, he added. Impact on the war in Gaza and the hostage crisis Netanyahu frequently cites the ongoing war as a reason Israel needs to provide a united front against its enemies. While the ultra-Orthodox parties remain part of the coalition, they want the war to end as quickly as possible, Talshir said. 'The Haredim think once the war is over, the pressure will be off them and they will be able to get their (military) exemption law,' she said.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Labour's sanctions on Israel are disgraceful folly
It is one thing for the UK to impose sanctions on autocratic enemies like Russia. But to do the same to a democratic ally is reprehensible. The decision to pick out two members of the Israeli government for prohibition is extraordinary from a Government which refuses to proscribe Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps or the Muslim Brotherhood. David Lammy, the Foreign Secretary, has banned Itamar Ben-Gvir, the National Security Minister, and Bezalel Smotrich, the Finance Minister, from visiting the UK over comments they made on Gaza. Any assets in this country will be frozen. It is true that these individuals are on the extremes, even in Israel where their support for expanding West Bank settlements is controversial. Both politicians are ultra-nationalists whose continued presence in Benjamin Netanyahu's Cabinet is preventing the collapse of the coalition. But after initially declaring support for Israel after the October 7 2023 atrocities, Labour is in danger of being seen to side with Hamas. Backbench MPs are agitating for a far tougher line than the suspension of trade talks or curbs on arms sales. They want the UK to recognise a Palestinian state at a conference in New York later this month. That would be a serious mistake and perhaps Mr Lammy thinks he can head off party critics with limited action against individuals. But where does it stop? The two ministers are not being targeted for something they have done but for what they have said. It is unprecedented for Britain to treat politicians serving in the government of a friendly power in this way. How will Mr Lammy feel if Israel now bans him for the criticism he has voiced?
